Evolution - Hajj Hassanain Rajabali

31 المشاهدات· 23/12/14

brainiaction
مشتركين

في محاضرات

Hajj Hassanain Rajabali talks about the theory of Evolution in Islam

أظهر المزيد

Transcript

[0:00]can you please discuss evolution versus creation evolution is a created system

[0:06]that's the answer mind-numbing ly simple isn't it what I thought you

[0:15]gonna go into a debate I'm telling you evolution is a created

[0:18]system it's absurd for something to self create a that's created or

[0:26]it doesn't exist from nothing comes nothing it is something must be

[0:31]created if you want to embark on that go ahead you'll have

[0:34]infinite regression you can't argue evolution is a created system got no

[0:38]problems with Islam doesn't reject evolution slum there's no Allah say so

[0:42]many creatures we brought from single ones here mankind we made you

[0:47]from a single creature now come on up after come in like

[0:50]an obscene wada where there is none forbid that now you said

[0:54]but with me because based on scientific law you have a cause

[0:57]and effect and when you do deductive reasoning in science you have

[1:00]to reverse the engines which takes me back to a single-cell creature

[1:05]that's the only way I said true because the science is limited

[1:08]to those scopes science has no philosophical arguments hence it must be

[1:12]physical and physical means I have to reverse the Domino and the

[1:15]reversal of Domino in the reverse of time is to take a

[1:18]multicellular creature to take it back to a single cellular if the

[1:20]assumption is that a single cellular creature is less complicated than a

[1:24]multicellular creature but who's to say that that's an argument in itself

[1:31]how do you know that a single-cell creature is more primitive than

[1:35]a multicellular whoever said in the scope of time that a primitive

[1:38]thing has to predate in advance thing this also it's flawed today

[1:42]we have we have older fossils of humans than Apes but if

[1:49]I came from apes I should have all the fossils of Apes

[1:54]we call this missing link speciation how come a species is stuck

[1:59]the genetic numbering is so fixed that you cannot mate a horse

[2:01]with a cat where they all came from the same family so

[2:05]I should be able to use them how about when I when

[2:08]I do you know in combination recombinations of DNA why can't this

[2:11]Papa ape and mama ape the game birth to my ancestors do

[2:17]it again I can do it in in in the lab with

[2:21]PCR why can I do it now you can't do it so

[2:24]why not who's we ciated this who decided there was a distinct

[2:27]line that is differentiated unless is I create the way I do

[2:30]you will find out maybe 100 years from now maybe ten years

[2:34]from now but it would still beg the question if you argue

[2:35]that it came up from a single cell where did the single

[2:39]cell come from it's too structured forget the single cell what's the

[2:42]single cell made up of it's made up of atoms who really

[2:46]and the lowest atom that we know of at least from the

[2:49]atomic principles is hydrogen hydrogen is a very complicated entity use you

[2:55]pull the electron out of there you get a hydrogen bomb Wow

[3:00]the amount of energy in an electron this circles around a proton

[3:04]is so intense you split that you get a hydrogen bomb this

[3:10]is accidental absolute nonsense going to quantum physics the particles that make

[3:13]the atom and see that the particle physics talks to the other

[3:19]side of the universe that the spin of one side of the

[3:21]atom on this side of the universe is directly correlated the subpoena

[3:24]of the atom on the other side of the universe this is

[3:26]well known quantum physics all came by accident you have to be

[3:31]out of your mind to call yourself a scientist and to dare

[3:34]stipulate the idea this is all pure coincidence nonsense even mathematicians like

[3:39]Roger Penrose says the probability of pure chance being the cause of

[3:43]all existence is zero is a mathematician you can argue with the

[3:46]mathematician I'm always baffled by this abject disregard so okay okay but

[3:55]if I go back in science and say listen science is limited

[3:58]it's limited on a trajectory of cause and effect where the effect

[4:01]we want to know the cause which means a cause which is

[4:04]the cause okay please go back it begs the question even people

[4:06]like Stephen Hawking says that bang Big Bang at Planck's moment one

[4:12]times 10 to minus 43 seconds we don't know what caused it

[4:14]if I go before that moment this is philosophy is not science

[4:17]because my tools break apart at Planck's moment my tools start before

[4:22]that I have no tool so I cannot talk science anymore this

[4:24]is my hats off to the philosopher who can talk this existence

[4:27]but how do you say it for nothing comes nothing how could

[4:31]this happen if you're going to stipulate the idea that the universe

[4:35]was always existent this is a contradiction because time is finite and

[4:38]therefore it had a beginning so there's no such thing as forever

[4:41]innocent time in the negative it had a beginning it chasm it

[4:46]has a vector moment in in infinity towards the forward movement but

[4:50]never backward it has a moment of start well the basic premise

[4:53]is from nothing comes nothing time was nothing it can never exist

[4:57]and that's something above time made it otherwise it's impossible so I

[5:01]can go on and on and on so they are you okay

[5:04]but if that is the case Quran says we place to Adam

[5:06]isn't this a bit fantastic story maybe Adam came from an ape

[5:13]I said possible I'm gonna train them Iacullo khun chayakorn you ever

[5:18]see the sperm of a male it looks like a tadpole very

[5:20]similar when you see a baby it looks like a creature of

[5:25]the sea you know the same baby looks very similar yeah we

[5:28]share a lot he says you see there you go we share

[5:31]so much commonality isn't this that we evolved from each other I

[5:36]said that's one stipulation how about since we all look alike it's

[5:42]because there's only one maker if I go into Rowan I see

[5:44]20 photographs pictures painted one is a mountain one is a dog

[5:48]one is a cat one is a monkey one is a human

[5:51]and I say what a fantastic artist hey but these are all

[5:53]different creatures I cannot say well this it came from that mountain

[5:56]or this mountain can I say oh this chair came no so

[5:58]why not this is because they have so many similar features I

[6:02]see yeah the artist is got his signature everywhere the artist has

[6:06]got his signature when I go the DNA the artist is that's

[6:09]my signature alice's had a helpful law for our own II mean

[6:13]I mean Dhoni but it's ala moana feudal Alamo mean this is

[6:18]what God created a must show us show me Allah says our

[6:24]Oni mashallah Dean I mean don't show me who else has created

[6:26]anything show me please show me another universe I'd like to see

[6:30]another universe that allows you this not mine show me so when

[6:34]I speak to scientists say the DNA do you agree that we

[6:36]all share the same atomic particles are we not all Stardust isn't

[6:39]that what the Nobel Prize got the Nobel for concluding that we

[6:44]all made of Stardust he said yeah I said there you go

[6:46]one universe one honor one signature isn't that beautiful no so look

[6:50]I can go back and forth he said but how did the

[6:54]atom join it I said do you agree that the initial premise

[6:56]had to have a higher order because if he doesn't it's absurd

[7:01]this is okay assuming God started the lightning bolt and made this

[7:05]single cell I said where does the rules say that once you

[7:10]start you cannot interject in between so for Adam to come in

[7:13]between is just as good as coming from the beginning because Allah

[7:16]could have started three cells could have cited 500 cells why not

[7:19]another cell in between why not a cell at the end Allah

[7:22]who eylem as far as we're concerned anything is possible is it

[7:26]out of scientific jurisdiction absolutely not in fact within science we're limited

[7:32]but the probability is just as good I can say as much

[7:34]as that initial cell started from a higher order so can more

[7:38]cells be added or subtracted don't we agree that some creatures become

[7:43]extinct extinction means that DNA is wiped out forever well if it

[7:46]can be wiped out forever then the logic of reversal comes in

[7:52]that something can be introduced also other words how does it continue

[7:55]so I can go on and on on these arguments and this

[7:56]basic answer this is what Islam has to say and I love

[8:01]it Quran is so elegant about this is no problem what color

[8:05]do you want now there are creatures when I went do you

[8:10]know when I went diving in the Great Barrier Reef in Australia

[8:13]in Cairns you know I went diving I was about 70 feet

[8:19]down in the Barrier Reef I tell you I was looking down

[8:22]there so sea cucumber vacuuming the floor of the sea literally purple

[8:27]beautiful velvety creature elegantly moving unless did you see my creature look

[8:31]at him he's 60 feet on the floor look he's vacuuming my

[8:36]floor so I picked this creature up it's got thousands of legs

[8:38]I'm touching it and he's massaging me so did you feel me

[8:42]I came by chance I felt him I said what about a

[8:47]colossal Halloween blessed be you for creating such a creature I squeezed

[8:51]him I feel like a sponge he curled up I open him

[8:55]up left him he kept walking then I went to the corrals

[8:59]I said Wow look at this rock suddenly the rock moved he

[9:03]looked at me with eyes that's so hollow what is this just

[9:05]I'm not a rock I'm a fish I look like a rock

[9:10]oh but you know what I accidentally engineered myself to look like

[9:13]a rock you know there are so many atoms and somehow are

[9:19]the fluke I decided to pluck me and look like a rock

[9:21]you know because I needed to survive otherwise the fish would eat

[9:26]me you know I said you have to be a nutcase to

[9:30]say that if you ask this creature how do you look I

[9:33]don't know so what I was made to look feel it you

[9:36]see a plant I went next to it I did this in

[9:40]the prime Rendon then two seconds ago they came out looking at

[9:45]me Wow are you a plant or an animal then looks having

[9:47]with different colors did you see my colors you'll be mesmerized I

[9:51]went snorkeling at the island and I'm crystal-clear water so I got

[9:59]my garb I'm snorkeling I see Christopher floor I put my snorkel

[10:02]I go in the water it's 100 fish looking at me transparent

[10:08]I can see their their bones and their swimming colorful crystal clear

[10:16]see-through they're looking at me said accidental all I could say is

[10:22]for Tabar a colossal colleague I went said the water I'm sitting

[10:24]in there cuz my my trainer went up to get the other

[10:28]people from the from the yacht so I'm here all along with

[10:29]this tank and I'm breathing I felt I was in the grave

[10:34]it's dark you don't know the shark is coming from behind you

[10:39]of the fraud you know unbelievable universe silent Allah says look at

[10:43]my universe you haven't even seen this this is your earth Jacques

[10:46]Cousteau said we've only uncovered 10% of the ocean our ignorance of

[10:51]the ocean is so much we don't even know how the ocean

[10:55]works and yet we think about the universe unless you spend a

[10:58]million years in my ocean you'll be stunned by what is down

[11:03]there so when I'm sitting there waiting breathing for a moment worried

[11:08]or maybe a shark will come from the back huge what'd he

[11:12]call what's the name stingray it was like from here to where

[11:19]this table is this massive was like 10 12 feet wide and

[11:21]he was just gliding like this he was just moving and his

[11:25]big black eyes looked at me you know kept moving and he

[11:28]just kept going it was just absolute silence the universe Alessa fat

[11:33]ybarra callosum oh sorry I tell you I was trembling down there

[11:39]65 hours trembling so subhanAllah what a creation Allah says look all

[11:42]you have to do is look you think this can come by

[11:44]chance no doesn't come by chance

0 تعليقات

التالي

Evolution - Hajj Hassanain Rajabali

Transcript

التالي

استكشاف المزيد

يرجى ملاحظة أنه إذا كان عمرك أقل من 18 عامًا ، فلن تتمكن من الوصول إلى هذا الموقع.

التالي

Evolution - Hajj Hassanain Rajabali

Transcript

التالي

استكشاف المزيد

اختيار طريقة الدفع

لغة