He Had The Audacity To Come To The House of Al Zahra (S)! || Br Hassan Al Qadri

22 Bekeken· 23/04/14

In the name of Allah,

is the report in Musanaf Ibn Abi Shaybah that discusses Umar bin Al Khattab coming to the house of Sayeda Al Zahra (S) an actual virtue for Umar? Does this report really paint a good image of Umar bin Al Khattab?

Watch as Br Hassan Al Qadri dissects this report to understand its true image that it was trying to portray.

#HassanAlQadri #Fatimiyyah #IslamicHistory

Laat meer zien

Transcript

[0:00][Music] Villa Lama salli ala muhammadin wa ali muhammad magic for John

[0:27]Mullen a down assalamu alayka ya say editable marathi say ye that

[0:34]nazar al al-amin you are only a be ha your fatima az-zahra

[0:39]alayhis-salam agree to all with the islamic greeting assalamu alaykum warahmatullahi wabarakatu

[0:49]today I want to discuss a specific hadith specific report that is

[0:59]mentioned in the book and Masson F emotionally even Abby shaver in

[1:07]this report it discusses that omar bin al-khattab came to the house

[1:16]of fatima and that he threatened to burn the house on imam

[1:25]ali alayhis-salam and as well and those who are with them now

[1:33]there is a discussion regarding the chain because they say that Aslam

[1:42]mullah omar the one who usually narrates from tomorrow didn't say that

[1:48]he narrates this from a Sahabi and he was not present when

[1:53]this occurred once a thief had been inside occurred he was not

[1:57]present he wasn't in medina what i say is is are they

[2:04]trying to say this feta mr.

[2:07]pattabhi this Jalil this individual is somehow just coming up with something

[2:13]that didn't occur I mean when it comes to history what would

[2:16]the historian usually does is he goes back to the earliest source

[2:20]possible the person that was nearest to the event why would someone

[2:29]like Aslam narrate such a thing is he just bringing it up

[2:33]from his mind or did he hear someone saying it or is

[2:39]it something that was famous among the people of madinah and that's

[2:43]why he's saying it for example because it's important because when you

[2:48]come around and you say no we don't accept it it's Morrison

[2:52]okay let's say it is more said who says we cannot accept

[2:54]a more sane report when it comes to a historical event Aslam

[2:59]has no reason to come up with such thing he cannot just

[3:04]come and bring it out of his bag his keys just like

[3:09]that it doesn't work like that he must have heard someone or

[3:16]something was being said and he's narrating it otherwise you're saying oh

[3:20]he's not 15 or more or that he narrates things that are

[3:23]not trustworthy and well are not reliable you imagine someone that is

[3:27]thicker that you know as reliable he's saying I wasn't the present

[3:32]but this is what happened and he tells you what occurred and

[3:35]then you say now I don't believe me because he wasn't there

[3:41]even your rationality wasn't accepted so that's one two they have some

[3:46]objection regarding the content of the report so he says when abu

[3:50]bakkar received the pledges of Allegiance after the messenger of allah ali

[3:54]and as zubayr so other reports even in Bihari and other historical

[3:59]books other books of history sorry they stay that it wasn't just

[4:05]Ali alehissalaam and a super robber there were others many from Benny

[4:09]Hashem and even some say al ha and others who are close

[4:13]to Amir al-mumineen like Sandman of adharmic Dada and so forth aliens

[4:19]away used to enter the presence of a farmer the daughter of

[4:24]The Messenger of Allah and consult her consult with her and hesitate

[4:29]in their allegiance when the news of this reached omar bin al-khattab

[4:32]he came out until he entered father's presence so he came to

[4:36]the house of fatima and he said all due to the message

[4:44]of allah none and all creation has more is more day daily

[4:48]beloved to me than your father and none is more beloved to

[4:55]us after him than you however by Allah they shall not prevent

[4:59]me if that group gathers in your house to order that house

[5:08]to be burnt over them when Omar went out they came and

[5:13]she said do you know that Omar came to me and swore

[5:18]by Allah that if you were to come back he shall surely

[5:24]burn the house over you by Allah he shall certainly fulfill what

[5:28]he swore so go away in peace so basically he said go

[5:31]away as Raja Deen flee from your opinion and do not come

[5:38]back to me they left her and did not return till they

[5:42]gave their pledge of allegiance to abu bakkar so what do they

[5:47]say is they say this hadith shows the virtues of Omar because

[5:50]a place on my place is the love of photos and straight

[5:55]after the Prophet I say this doesn't show the virtues of Oman

[5:59]actually if you look at it just just try to come out

[6:05]of that bubble and try to think someone has just come to

[6:07]the house a woman is behind the house behind the door and

[6:13]then he says I will burn this house down on them so

[6:18]your husband and who is with him and it seems like from

[6:23]other reports that they'll has Irwin Hussein was present in the house

[6:27]I will burn them but I love you as I loved your

[6:29]father for me that's not a virtue that shows that he has

[6:35]psychological issues he's mentally ill that shows illness my brothers and sisters

[6:38]yeah and it'd be months if you come to a house I

[6:42]love you and you are the most beloved to me after your

[6:47]father but I will burn the house down on your husband and

[6:50]those who are with him Rajiv that's not virtue no I am

[6:56]for you to come to the I've done are you guys drinking

[6:59]smoking something drinking a bit of maybe something and he being most

[7:05]of when you're doing these things I remembered a discussion with someone

[7:13]who is well versed in Sunni Shia polemics and he's our Salafi

[7:16]himself I don't want to name his name so because I don't

[7:19]know if he gives me permission he even says he says if

[7:21]we accept this hadith is problematic he says it's more said I

[7:23]don't accept it tell you that's bad but don't try to say

[7:28]or even for to accept it this is how it goes it's

[7:32]not a virtue this is shows mental illness you come to a

[7:34]house a woman come what do you want oh I'm going to

[7:39]burn the house down on your husband and the people that are

[7:44]with him and probably your children are there but um I love

[7:49]you you're ill that's mental illness they say the hadith doesn't say

[7:54]on you it says on them okay so were you trying to

[8:00]go what's fathometers aha and he had said I'm not in the

[8:02]house so if he was to burn the house was she just

[8:06]gonna walk out very happy knee and you say okay my Salama

[8:08]and he better be a palliative my salaamed zubayr and then she'll

[8:12]go outside is that what you're trying to say because that's not

[8:18]how things work he said them on them or on you or

[8:23]on all of you it doesn't matter same because I'll tell you

[8:28]why him is the same meaning yes look Hawaiian it is a

[8:30]difference but the end of the day when you say I'm going

[8:35]to burn them or burn the house over then what does it

[8:40]what's that saying to you she's in the house or was she

[8:42]gonna just walk on bilac yellow my Salama haben do you guys

[8:47]not think and then they're going to say Farkle my never felt

[8:51]threatened well what did she say what did she say to them

[8:59]that go and give allegiance to him for us where he will

[9:01]do it yeah of course the narrations not telling us any facial

[9:07]expressions or body language so even you can't say that a chilean

[9:09]feel threatened would you not feel threatened would your wife not feel

[9:14]threatened you or your daughter or your sister who's married and then

[9:16]you have someone come to your house say I'm gonna burn the

[9:18]house over your husband and those who are with him but you're

[9:24]not gonna feel threatened no are you guys lying to yourself or

[9:27]you are you just trying to make herself feel better then they

[9:32]go to say father my agreed with her mother that they should

[9:35]go and give back well he's gonna he's gonna burn her husband

[9:38]and those were with him would you want her to do would

[9:42]your daughter or your husband I'm sorry your daughter or your wife

[9:46]or your sister or your mother if someone came to do came

[9:50]to their house saying you must pledge allegiance to full on would

[9:54]you not just tell them just go and get better and don't

[9:59]forget this is this reporters in your books so it's a Hodja

[10:03]upon you I don't need when I try to prove the event

[10:05]of the door or the least I can say is that he

[10:09]came to the house and he had the audacity audacity to toe

[10:14]phantom it is our annalisa I'll burn the house on yours husband

[10:17]and those who are with him when he knows it's the house

[10:22]of the household of prophethood it's the house where the Angels used

[10:26]to come it's the household it's that house where divine why he

[10:30]was coming from and then you want to tell me that all

[10:35]of a sudden she didn't she agreed with him just like that

[10:39]no no don't tell me that she agrees you have no other

[10:44]option that's what you should be saying that's the more correct way

[10:47]of saying it and at the end of the day I agreed

[10:51]that the she has that tried to use this report to prove

[10:55]that there was an attack on the house or that they burnt

[10:57]the house down is wrong because it doesn't say that in the

[11:01]report there was a threat he threatened her and you imagine who

[11:05]he threatened the woman leader of heaven say it as a hawk

[11:14]Elena so now say ye the Zara he had audacity to come

[11:17]to the house oh limited Sahara and threatened her that's good enough

[11:22]for me to know what type of individual he is but don't

[11:25]try and sit there and like yourself and hide and play propaganda

[11:29]when it comes to these things hey at least you could say

[11:35]it's more subtle I don't accept a black coupe for that standard

[11:37]I I could see where you're coming from but don't come and

[11:41]lie to me and say to me I know she agreed with

[11:43]her mother she only agreed with my mother what he's threatened to

[11:46]burn a house down with her husband in it would you want

[11:49]her to do then they're going to say it's Claire accepted the

[11:52]caliphate of Abu Bakr now you now the definitely smoking something you

[11:57]are definitely smoking something to say that definitely smoking something where does

[12:05]it say she agreed he threatened they told him go and get

[12:11]bail go it doesn't say she she accepted it what we know

[12:13]was historically accepted is that she died angry with him you imagine

[12:16]she'd had anger that kind of if that's the case no be

[12:21]Munsif and be like the best she could say is that it's

[12:26]more sell but our standard by the standard over now away and

[12:30]so forth we don't accept this hadith come up with something better

[12:33]than trying to say that oh it works in your favor because

[12:40]it doesn't he threatened Azhar ah young master alone he threatened far

[12:46]limited Zahara what she's in the house now they'll say do you

[12:49]know nobody never said on you on them would you not feel

[12:53]threatened yourself if someone comes to your house and he says I

[13:00]am going to burn the house down on your husband I don't

[13:02]know you won't feel threatened well you know it's just the threat

[13:04]on his and her husband and a threat that our house will

[13:07]be burned down no and in logical human being would be luck

[13:13]she was there and he saints Gandhi she's going through threatened for

[13:19]her husband that's the least you could say but don't say she

[13:22]didn't feel threatened and and she agreed with Ahmad well she had

[13:25]no other she had she couldn't disagree with him he's going to

[13:31]burn the house down so the threat wasn't less a university yeah

[13:34]and he said Lemna Jaden young if we was to compromise and

[13:39]say okay the threat wasn't direct to her indirectly was to her

[13:41]who's going to accept for her for their house what woman will

[13:47]accept her kingdom her castle to be burnt down her house to

[13:49]be burnt down a husband to be in it and the people

[13:52]that are with him and maybe his our children but she's not

[13:57]gonna feel threatened indirectly somehow now there was an indirect threat that's

[14:03]the least we can go looking reopened but don't play that game

[14:06]the propaganda game be must've be a man when you're researching history

[14:10]because it's not just about all refused and not be most of

[14:14]of your with your research so hope insha Allah to Allah I

[14:21]have answered this hadith and never want to hear from our opponents

[14:24]this type of stupidity in sha-la-la-la-la-la allah sayidina muhammad why elevated by

[14:32]envy nebari you

0 Comments

Volgende

He Had The Audacity To Come To The House of Al Zahra (S)! || Br Hassan Al Qadri

Transcript

Volgende

Ontdek meer

Houd er rekening mee dat als u jonger bent dan 18 jaar, u geen toegang kunt krijgen tot deze site.

Volgende

He Had The Audacity To Come To The House of Al Zahra (S)! || Br Hassan Al Qadri

Transcript

Volgende

Ontdek meer

Kies een betaal methode

Taal