The Basis of Discussion

18 Bekeken· 24/08/10

Shaykh Dr. Usama Al-Atar
abonnees

Lecture by Dr. Usama Al-Atar
ISIA - Edmonton
www.jammat.org

Laat meer zien

Transcript

[0:00]hahaha man over him well hamdu lillahi rabbil alameen Bobby ill holla

[0:07]at the edge marine barthel ambia evil Marceline the masala to assalaam

[0:13]o Allah ashraful ambia was a Adele mousseline habibi illa illa Allah

[0:20]mean al-mustafa a bell qazi muhammad ali eid natok avenal masoomeen Almonte

[0:30]jovina ladina and hvala and homology surah Taha home total hero am

[0:42]a bad fall allahu wa ta'ala chiquita bill majeed walk or any

[0:49]Hill honeydew ol haha I all believe in a shape on rajim

[0:53]bismillah yo mano mahim alum no loss of all abou Murphy summer

[1:07]what you wanna feel all of us bajale come yamaha yama ballina

[1:13]warming a messy my you judge you know feel him behind me

[1:19]wallah who da Wallach it up boonie shut up alone on Halloween

[1:35]so Allah Muhammad Ali Muhammad when there is a discussion that's taking

[1:43]place there has to be a basis for this discussion in order

[1:48]for it to continue in order for it to go forth for

[1:52]example when Sam allama of med hub of the rice the different

[2:03]Islamic rights or sects discuss they say you know what we have

[2:06]to have some basis for our discussion to start from for example

[2:09]let's turn to the toughest event or partitions and a hadith the

[2:19]hadith that are accepted by both schools of thought right so when

[2:24]the hadith is accepted by both schools of thought then we'll accept

[2:28]that and we'll use that as the basis for our discussion and

[2:33]then we'll move forward build on it so if one school of

[2:36]thought brings one Heidi that is not accepted ok we'll leave that

[2:38]aside and the same thing with the other school of thought will

[2:42]be better side and we'll take what is accepted what is established

[2:44]and both schools of thoughts and we build on them so many

[2:51]writers and authors who are writing in this field the field of

[2:55]the Maga head for example the will I of an evil minion

[3:00]sallallahu alehiwassallaam ola the authenticity of Ahlul Bayt and their rights sallallahu

[3:04]alehiwassallaam an image marine this is the basis that they used is

[3:09]they you know what will take the quotes and the hadith and

[3:11]that fic the interpretations that are cepted and authenticated by both schools

[3:19]of thoughts and we'll build on that so that to be some

[3:25]basis that's one when it comes to the basis the second is

[3:29]when engaging in the discussion I mean what should be the point

[3:32]of the discussion when you want to discuss with somebody the ultimate

[3:35]goal should be to learn to be educated this is the goal

[3:42]the goal is not to establish my view on the end on

[3:45]the opponent for example that you know what this is the way

[3:50]I believe and I don't care even if you show me I

[3:53]will not believe this is not really there's no point in the

[3:57]such discussion that's why sometimes Imam Ali him assalaam our Imams they

[4:00]used to be asked questions so that what so the Imam before

[4:07]he answers the question he puts a criteria he says SL so

[4:10]I LaMotta a lemon I will miss teff him in LA so

[4:15]I LaMotta an it ask a question of one who's seeking guidance

[4:18]seek acknowledge not a question of one who's coming from arrogance you

[4:25]know what this is what i believe so what do you think

[4:27]about this ok well i'll show you what i think and i'll

[4:31]bring you the proof now will you submit afterwards if you will

[4:33]let's to sit down and discuss but if you're not then why

[4:37]do you want to discuss to me so the whole point of

[4:39]the discussion should be to learn to learn about the reality of

[4:46]things the truth of things and once you learn about the truth

[4:48]of things the nature of things how things should work then one

[4:56]should accept it and adopt it and apply it so when I

[4:58]discuss with somebody I want to learn what the truth is and

[5:02]then once I learned the truth I want I have to apply

[5:03]the truth in my in my life for example or in my

[5:07]work for example it is what we call in the circles of

[5:11]academia this is something established in the world of academia this is

[5:15]what and of course this kind of discussion this kind of discussion

[5:20]it is what a lil bae telling him with Salam introduced because

[5:24]they're the Masters of academia if you want to talk about academia

[5:28]they're the Masters vaca ammamma sladek alehissalaam one day was as hell

[5:33]minji dahlin 15 is there really debate in the religion can you

[5:39]discuss he said yes Allah says wah ha dil home but what

[5:42]Belleci here assen acid yes there is G doll in religion there

[5:49]is discussion and debate but Bella teehee assen you know we have

[5:53]to use manners you got to use your logic you got to

[5:57]use your proofs I don't start insulting the other you know the

[6:00]opponent or for example degrading him or for example using words against

[6:04]him this is not the manners of discussion this is not the

[6:08]etiquette of discussion and these days if you hear the news just

[6:15]today and yesterday there's a whole basically discussion and debate about one

[6:19]political party using an ad against another political party for example you

[6:25]know where they attack attacking ads and they say you know what

[6:29]this is not ethical for example this is not right and that's

[6:31]where the debate you know is it right to do this or

[6:34]is it not right and see the whole now listen to the

[6:37]news and you hear about it if you haven't heard yet but

[6:40]in the world of academia know people discuss to learn the truth

[6:43]you know in 2005 and 2005 the Nobel Prize for chemistry was

[6:52]awarded for three chemists okay for one particular reaction and chemistry is

[6:57]known the metathesis reaction olefin metathesis which is something used in polymerization

[7:01]in polymer chemistry polymerization three people 12 of them developed a compound

[7:10]that they call catalysts which basically helps this process help this reaction

[7:18]to proceed the third one what did he win it for he

[7:20]proposed the mechanism for this reaction he said that you know what

[7:25]this is how I think this reaction works one of the people

[7:28]who won he shared the same price of one of the three

[7:33]when this person the third person proposed the mechanism he proposed another

[7:36]mechanism he said no I think this is the way the mechanism

[7:39]the reaction works I don't think it's that way but few years

[7:43]later when he started doing his experiments his research he realized know

[7:46]the other guys is right the other person is right his mechanism

[7:49]is true so he said he wrote the paper and he said

[7:53]you know what I agree with his mechanism that mechanism although it's

[7:56]different from what I proposed but nonetheless that is the truth that's

[8:01]where it is so so people discuss it's open this is the

[8:08]criteria and you know who knew 30 years later all three of

[8:11]them won the Nobel Prize so this should be the criteria for

[8:17]the discussion when you discuss this ayah which is ayah number 20

[8:20]of surat locum and kind of gives us some criteria when people

[8:27]are discussing and it also tries to pay our attention that don't

[8:30]be fooled by some arguments of individuals that you know on the

[8:35]outside on the exterior these arguments may seem sound may seem valid

[8:38]but once you dig deep into them you find there is nothing

[8:43]in here it's like for example a hologram you know a hologram

[8:45]which on the outside it looks real looks as if something appears

[8:49]but once you dig deep you see no there's nothing in here

[8:51]you know there's no it's just an image for example a loss

[8:57]of Hannah whatta Alistair's starts this ayah by said LM yow ana

[9:02]ana la la mia alum Telo and Nala sad saga lacombe don't

[9:10]you see now who's you who's you if I Stiliyan have two

[9:13]opinions on who is you don't you see some of us singing

[9:18]say it is the mushrikun watch v kino McKay the Prophet is

[9:21]talking LM taro the Prophet is talking and he is saying to

[9:28]the mushrikun of Mecca don't you see other guava psidium say no

[9:32]it is Allah Subhan Allah Ta'ala talking here and of course we

[9:35]know the Puranas all the words of Allah but sometimes Allah subhana

[9:39]Allah says something on that tongue of his prophets allah or other

[9:42]prophets when Musa says something for example when asus has something for

[9:45]example so this is asa same but allah staying in the quran

[9:48]so nonetheless he some other mufa serene say no it is allah

[9:53]who saying he so there for Allah is not just talking to

[9:57]the mushrikun but rather to every human all human beings so what

[9:59]does this to them was lucky in all weather it is to

[10:03]all humans you know there's two days to interpretation see what okay

[10:08]what do we see and Allah that Allah indeed Allah and neda

[10:13]to toukiden which means you affirm something haven't you see that surely

[10:18]Allah is done what's a saga lacombe Mathis timati waffle ro he

[10:28]has made everything in this skies and on the earth under your

[10:32]service under your service everything Allah subhana Allah created Allah says about

[10:38]the human being that he is honored well about karramna bani adam

[10:42]we have honored the human being the children of Adam Allah has

[10:47]honored the human being with the mind with the Apple with that

[10:52]occurred so Allah has given him the hakan and with this achal

[10:55]he basically takes control of everything allah says in others i answered

[11:00]yasin that you just recited here Liam Allah says olm yellow and

[11:05]novel upon Allah home Emma a meal at edina and I'm and

[11:10]formula homily Coon was ll na hala home from in haiku boho

[11:13]woman higher coolin wallah on phenomena voi Michelle give a fella yes

[11:19]cool haven't they seen that we created for them I'm paraphrasing the

[11:23]ayah that we created for them cattle and on you know for

[11:26]example the scows the sheep that Allah sooo Hanukkah well now holla

[11:31]home which means that we enabled them to take control of them

[11:34]over them imagine if the Sheep had a mind similar to the

[11:39]human being or never mind the Sheep imagine the Lions the Lions

[11:42]for example in Africa those of you who come from Africa imagine

[11:44]of the Lions I mean as is back in the old days

[11:48]now we don't have that problem but I was told by some

[11:51]people from Africa back into all the Lions used to come in

[11:53]the city in the village itself and used to kill people and

[11:58]they used to hunt people in the village you know imagine if

[12:00]the Lions can have to have intelligence like humans where they meet

[12:02]you know and they say let us plan to how to eradicate

[12:06]human beings you know you know so as is we get disaster

[12:12]so the name of Allah Subhan Allah Ta'ala he created everything for

[12:17]you that allah subhana wa'ta'ala has enabled you to take care and

[12:23]control of everything Allah subhana allah says sad saga lacombe lacroix means

[12:28]for you which means it is for you use for your use

[12:33]oh he for you means for your ownership that you and get

[12:39]in charge you yourself can make these things serviceable for you by

[12:44]my permission by a las permission so Allah Subhan Allah Ta'ala has

[12:48]given the human being disciplined dis mind which if he uses it

[12:52]of course if he uses it he can take control of everything

[12:59]although sometimes you know being chooses to turn off his mind turn

[13:03]off his up in you know so this this this Apple this

[13:09]the human being his mind becomes according to Surat enamel you know

[13:14]enamel and nam there was a nebula an aunt that when it's

[13:18]a süleyman alayhis salaam recognized fillet mark and stewart enamel that one

[13:23]aunt when it's a sulaiman al ASR the Prophet recognized him and

[13:27]you have human beings when Allah they don't recognize a loss of

[13:31]Hannah wa'ta'ala honey so you can imagine you know then to look

[13:35]the level of knowledge nonetheless a loss of hannover to Allah says

[13:39]Allah Hisashi Iwakuma phys Samaha teamo fill up so everything that allah

[13:45]subhan allah ta'ala and this earth in the skies is under your

[13:50]service and indeed you see the human these days they're sending spaceships

[13:55]to Mars sending spaceships to the moon just the other day was

[13:59]hearing that they hadn't expedition on the moon to look for water

[14:01]you know they suspect there's water on the moon because they thinking

[14:07]down the road if the human being goes to live on the

[14:09]moon you know much imagine and the human being goes to live

[14:13]on the moon then instead of shipping water all the way from

[14:15]the earth to the moon you know and the funny thing is

[14:19]they had actually a figure they say would cost I don't know

[14:21]how many hundreds of thousands of dollars to ship one liter of

[14:26]water to the moon whereas if we find it there it's great

[14:28]you know great all of the sudden you know and pretty soon

[14:32]you'll have for example drawing Maps you know the draw maps of

[14:33]the moon as well you know this is the region that's country

[14:35]this country salasa don't don't cross territories and not only on earth

[14:41]that they're fighting over territories and over resources imagine now in the

[14:44]moon that oh you stepped off of my resource okay so let's

[14:46]go to Orion I imagine this is not an E we don't

[14:48]have enough things on earth to keep us busy that we're going

[14:50]to the moon but yani the whole exploration of course is great

[14:56]the whole science or knowledge it's great so all this allah subhana

[15:01]allah has kept under the human being control the service of the

[15:04]human beings so haven't they seen that allah subhana wa'ta'ala has made

[15:09]everything on this earth and in the skies under your service ok

[15:17]what else what's better alaikum near a mahoba he returned whopping them

[15:22]asperger if we want to use kind of a modern term you

[15:24]know a term of the english language would say he showered you

[15:29]he showered you with his blessings espada alaikum niama union is the

[15:33]name of Allah the blessings of allah so allah has showered you

[15:36]with his blessings well here at ten wobble inna llaha what does

[15:43]not have a mean why he remains visible clear you could see

[15:48]it and what else bought Lina boppin amines hidden hidden unseen you

[15:52]can't see much so what are the blessings that are clear and

[15:59]visible and what are the hidden ones here where again interpreters have

[16:06]different interpretations those who say the Prophet is talking to the mushrikun

[16:14]the mushrikun so he's telling them that look a las given you

[16:16]blessings what are the blessings that actually it is your senses you

[16:20]have your hands your eyes your tongue you knows these senses are

[16:25]the blessings of Allah that you can see and both Lina the

[16:30]ones you can't see are basically your heart your mind your Apple

[16:35]for example as something you cannot see those who say Allah is

[16:40]talking to everybody to everybody they say yes that's true but in

[16:44]addition to that you may have also mahira these senses but in

[16:53]addition to that also it is the religion Allah has given you

[16:58]the religion this is also the name of Allah Subhan Allah Ta'ala

[17:04]and but Lina in addition to giving you a mind giving you

[17:06]a heart that Allah has given you the ability to perceive this

[17:09]religion and utilize this religion to ascend in the path of spirituality

[17:17]you have a person who becomes like a mule minion sallallahu alehiwassallaam

[17:21]who are they no to human being yet not an ordinary human

[17:24]being he ascends in the path of taqwa and piety or you

[17:29]have then the next generations people after that for example people who

[17:32]follow the path of a mugen what minion sallallahu alehiwassallaam are they

[17:35]people who walk on his path the path of rasulullah sallallahu like

[17:41]Salman a Buddha people who go in this path and i sent

[17:48]they become like Salman and a Buddha as well so Allah has

[17:50]given you the snap man this is a blessing that's one interpretation

[17:53]another interpretation people go with a hadith of rasulullah sallallahu alaihe eyelid

[17:59]to open a bus he says you have not a bus I'm

[18:04]mama haga fell Islam the name of Allah that's you can see

[18:11]it one is Islam what else wama sawalha home in celtic and

[18:14]everything the organs that Allah has given you and the hell that

[18:17]Allah has given you your health all this is you can see

[18:22]that's too what else three wama a father alaikum in a risk

[18:25]and the blessings because of the sustenance that Allah gives you that

[18:30]sustenance comes from Allah so this is the three things that are

[18:35]visible but clear and what is the hidden part he says what

[18:38]a mama boppin facet to oma sowwy amelie Kuala me habla la

[18:44]mia vaca be the hidden part is that he did not expose

[18:47]your bad deeds indeed one of the names of Allah is what

[18:56]satara are you satara you walk em mens sana and Jamie Lee

[18:59]less to a la la una Carta and how many of these

[19:04]merits that I don't really qualify for but you spread them is

[19:09]Fred them and on the contrary how many of my bad actions

[19:17]you hit ya allah you had if people were to know or

[19:23]see our bad deeds they would not even want to talk to

[19:26]us anymore but allah subhanahu wa'ta'ala hides our sins covers them up

[19:32]on the day of judgment however these will be exposed that will

[19:37]be exposed except for certain individuals who are mean that's why we

[19:42]read in the door our webinar are Tina Martin o Allah Allah

[19:49]koala tosh zena yo Mel key on o Allah do not expose

[19:53]us on the day of judgment on the day of judgment don't

[19:56]expose us he Allah so this is one of the door that

[20:02]allah subhan allah ta'ala and dunya he keeps our sins all under

[20:05]cover but in a fair I know however a person who works

[20:11]feasible Allah for the sake of allah subhanahu wa'ta'ala when a person

[20:14]works for the sake of Allah and purely for the sake of

[20:16]Allah Allah will show their work to the people in dunya and

[20:23]in the hawk that work will come will come out I'm evil

[20:26]minion alayhis salaam and a lil betta mama sajjad and other imams

[20:31]they used to go in the middle of the night giving food

[20:34]to people without the people recognizing them in the middle of the

[20:38]night they would cover their faces and with the goat give food

[20:42]to people imam is sajjad he used to go get food to

[20:43]somebody and that someone would tell him he was a relative of

[20:49]the imam and he would tell him you know what of they

[20:52]mom said he doesn't know him he said may allah bless you

[20:54]you remember me and you recognize that i'm in need and my

[20:57]relative Ali Hussein doesn't even know that and he doesn't come and

[21:02]he doesn't help me any mom would not anything i would go

[21:05]comes back the next day and give him the same thing and

[21:09]the person will say the same thing again mom would not say

[21:11]anything and this continued continued continued until the imam dies when that

[21:17]person doesn't get anything one day two days he realizes who was

[21:22]the person who was giving him he realises he regrets it he

[21:27]regrets it and Imams work becomes exposed he comes and he tells

[21:34]him am will bother alehissalaam this is what your father used to

[21:39]do for me and so the word gets spread out the action

[21:40]was done feasible in LA for the sake of Allah not for

[21:45]the sake of reward of a thank you no visible Allah but

[21:47]Allah made it show in dunya and of course in the affero

[21:53]and in the so that's the second meaning a third meaning is

[21:58]the hadith of a mammal ba-cock sallallahu alehiwassallaam Holly he says that

[22:05]the blessings of Allah that are visible that are cleaved is our

[22:13]holy prophet sallallahu alayhi what the knowledge that he brought forth and

[22:18]the bobland is our will I will I a tuna a lil

[22:20]bait this is the name of Allah subhana Allah we have ensure

[22:27]that attack Ottawa lattice alone Naomi Eden Annan am one day Imam

[22:30]eternal back over Asad Ali him as salaam was sitting with his

[22:33]companion he told him he asked him what is the meaning of

[22:39]this I I mom is asking the person the companion sometimes Imam

[22:42]when they teach when they want to teach they asked the student

[22:47]a question and what do you think about this and they see

[22:49]what the person says if they say correct great if not they

[22:55]correct him and this is so that then the teachings of the

[22:58]Quran come to you and me brothers and sisters that's why when

[23:02]we learn about on we learn about the headless turn to a

[23:05]lil betta alaikum assalaam he sells him what do you think what

[23:10]is the meaning of name this companion thinks for a second he

[23:13]says maybe the the food that Allah has given us these blessings

[23:16]that Allah has given us you know the clothes we wear so

[23:20]Allah is gonna ask us your money what do you bring he

[23:22]mom told him if if someone generous invites you to his house

[23:31]and you have a good meal would he tell you that look

[23:33]I've given you a good meal now look I'm giving you a

[23:37]good meal here and here's that you know every time he sees

[23:38]you says that this was a good meal so remember this huh

[23:42]what he started naga mind in here with me if a generous

[23:47]man never mind he said no a generous person would never even

[23:49]mention it policy gives it he says so how do you think

[23:53]Allah Subhan Allah Ta'ala on the day of judgment is going to

[23:55]ask you about the result of the blessings he has given you

[23:57]in this dunya so the man's pondered reflected he said then what

[24:04]does it mean yet nervous will I said well it was Naomi

[24:06]and will I atina ll bait our way liar what did he

[24:11]do with the will I of a debate did you follow a

[24:14]lil bit did you not follow her hip why don't you follow

[24:16]a little bit and then the ayah continues here Allah subhana Allah

[24:23]says women an ass and a monk people may you ja de

[24:29]la fila para el manejo de oaxaca tava Mooney and among people

[24:32]is one who does judaa you judged the same word you Jaden

[24:35]Jaden phila about Allah subhana wa'ta'ala Barea elman without knowledge voila hodan

[24:47]without guidance while al-kitab omunye and no illuminating book what does that

[24:53]mean you have some individuals will come and debate with you discuss

[24:57]with you and this is one problem that some people are going

[25:00]through even this day and age from the time of imam asada

[25:06]until now people come and they propose they say where is allah

[25:10]subhan allah ta'ala we can't see him so Allah doesn't exist you

[25:15]know this and they start giving some proof you know where science

[25:19]explains everything you know people nowadays they say science if we science

[25:24]cannot explain it then then that's it it doesn't exist then it's

[25:27]abstract you tell them hold on a second how many things have

[25:32]science failed to explain second talk to scientists they tell you the

[25:39]more I know this one famous scientist he said the more I

[25:42]know the more I learn that I don't know the more I

[25:46]know the more I realize that I don't know how things work

[25:50]out so science doesn't always have the answer science cannot describe the

[25:55]soul for me they try they attempt psychologists do their best to

[26:01]try to analyze and characterize the self the psychiatry the psychology of

[26:08]the individual but they can't they can how is it that one

[26:12]word can change the state of the human being one word can

[26:17]make him happy extremely happy or can make him depressed one word

[26:23]one statement how still theories are out there but science doesn't explain

[26:29]everything how is it that stress causes illness you know they come

[26:35]and they say well there's our hormones that are released and everything

[26:39]but how is that one word affecting the individual how does it

[26:43]affect him to the extent where he becomes stressful and these hormones

[26:48]are really how is that possible that one word how does it

[26:51]do that again science cannot explain everything yet where you know if

[26:55]science has all the answers there would not be all this research

[26:58]that's been doing you know billions of dollars on research so you

[27:03]have people who come one day a man came to me Mom

[27:04]asada alehissalaam he told him you know prove to me that this

[27:11]this universe has a creator he says just like when you take

[27:13]a look at the building and this building your mind tells you

[27:18]this building could not have been built without a builder so when

[27:22]you take a look at this whole universe how could your mind

[27:25]tell you that you know what this whole universe was built without

[27:31]a builder without a creator so that's obvious but you have individual

[27:36]so Allah says what Mina nos and among people may you giardino

[27:39]falahi be right here al so what does m in this ayah

[27:43]and refers to that prove the knowledge that comes from logic when

[27:50]you use the proof use the logic and you have the knowledge

[27:52]you presented you say this is my proof going back to the

[27:57]beginning of my discussion when I said about the metathesis and the

[28:00]reaction we had two scientists each one proposing a theory but one

[28:04]proposed a mechanism that he brought proof for once the proofs was

[28:08]shown the other scientists and the scientific community accepted it hallows so

[28:13]it's based on proof based on evidence based on logic so they

[28:19]accepted that that's hell so I am which stems from proof and

[28:21]logic that knowledge not the helm that based on nothing you know

[28:24]sometimes people call themselves island but you take a look at and

[28:31]there's nothing what has he learned nothing so that's one hell wallah

[28:34]hodan oh that is the guidance that comes from allah subhanahu wa'ta'ala

[28:39]through the Prophet sallallahu alehiwassallaam our the prophets all the prophet alayhi

[28:45]Mesilla the prophets when they come they bring some guidance that comes

[28:49]from allah subhan allah ta'ala bad guidance or kitab and mooney kitab

[28:53]and munir is the holy book the Quran for example and this

[28:57]time the Quran without using for example evidence from the Quran the

[29:03]words of Allah now this is something interesting so this means anybody

[29:06]can pick up the pot on and say well let me bring

[29:09]you the proof from the Quran this is what the Quran says

[29:11]that's what the Quran says and the answers obviously no and this

[29:16]is what again some people try to proposed this theory or this

[29:20]notion was proposed at the time of rasulullah sallallahu alaihi wasallam atala

[29:26]we don't need anything other than the book of allah subhana Allah

[29:31]hollis we have the hold on we don't need anything else you

[29:35]come to this individual and then till today until today by the

[29:38]day after my lecture you know the university those of you who

[29:40]are there after my lecture a person comes to me and that

[29:45]says you know these are hadith you say a hadith a hadith

[29:48]we have the Quran why do we need the happy I thought

[29:50]hold on a second you know without the how do you prayed

[29:56]you pray said yes how do you pray how do you know

[29:57]says what we pray this Formica I don't know show me in

[30:04]the Quran where does it say to like Africa what does it

[30:07]say that he looked at me didn't have an answer I thought

[30:12]it's the hadees that teaches you that's one second one says after

[30:19]your Allah who are clear over soon obey Allah and obey the

[30:23]messenger so what the Prophet says sallallahu alayhi wale is with the

[30:28]guidance of Allah when he says whatever he speaks is a guidance

[30:33]from Allah for my aunt the coronal Hawaiian hula wahio new attack

[30:37]evaluation by revelation alati it tells the Prophet guys the Prophet as

[30:40]to what to say so the words of the Prophet are also

[30:42]valuable they're very important I cannot put them aside and then you

[30:49]have individuals these days who say well how do we know this

[30:52]hadith authentic well my question back to you how do you know

[30:57]it is not authentic you know have you done the studies can

[31:00]you for like certainty say put your hand on the Quran and

[31:05]swear this hadith is not authentic if you can't then don't question

[31:10]its authenticity don't question it we have scholars we have a lama

[31:15]who invest their lives studying especially in the Jaffa a school of

[31:18]thought in the Jaffa emami a school of thought we have scholars

[31:24]who invest their times until today constant research about something called el

[31:28]Mago agile the knowledge of the men which basically the narrator's they

[31:32]study the chain of narrators and they can tell this hadith is

[31:35]authentic this hadith is not authentic or lesser antic than the others

[31:38]we have people who study this one of my scholars it's not

[31:43]up to person anybody to come and say I don't really like

[31:45]this hadith or this hottie doesn't make sense to me you know

[31:49]just because it doesn't make sense to you doesn't mean that's not

[31:52]true I can talk for example to you know the other day

[31:55]yesterday yesterday why go too far yesterday there was a reporter I

[32:01]was listening to the radio ok porter our journalists was mentioning something

[32:05]about physics you know about and neutrons and protons and things the

[32:11]funny thing is there was another journalist sitting next to this one

[32:15]and they were talking they say you know what I read the

[32:17]script but I don't understand anything of it you know the journalist

[32:20]says you know all these physics that's in here I don't have

[32:23]a clue what am I reading in the script it doesn't make

[32:25]any sense to me so we tell them okay just because it

[32:29]doesn't make any sense to you it means it's not it's not

[32:33]true it doesn't exist call us auntie sha it's false so that's

[32:36]that doesn't make sense and there is nobody who is a scholar

[32:42]and everything yeah of course for except a little bit any Muslim

[32:45]but nobody is a scholar now we have a medical doctor we

[32:47]have a scholar of physics a scholar of chemistry you talk to

[32:51]them in other language they may not understand it I don't understand

[32:54]anything from this language for example it doesn't mean it's not true

[32:58]sorry authentic so just because your mind doesn't accept that hadith it

[33:02]doesn't mean it's not true it is not authentic imam assad allah

[33:08]salam tells us any happy if you hear from us take it

[33:10]to the Quran if it matches what the program says accept it

[33:14]if it doesn't then put it aside but who is really qualified

[33:16]if it's the scholars to do that it's their job not our

[33:20]job so you have these individuals who say this hadith I don't

[33:23]you know the hadith is very important very important we cannot underestimate

[33:26]the importance of hadith but you have these individuals who come discuss

[33:32]with you with no evidence no basics no rights so when we

[33:37]go to the Quran we can't just come to the Quran and

[33:40]do it ourselves third the Quran itself says there are verses which

[33:48]are mutashabihat with the shabba means you don't really know its meaning

[33:52]you have to dig deeper who is there to teach us for

[33:54]answers across gonna fill n that's a new and let Vic those

[34:00]who are well versed and knowledge the people of the book who

[34:03]are they a lil betta la mesera so the Quran alone does

[34:07]not have all of our answers we have to turn to a

[34:11]little bait alayhi wassalam and therefore brothers and sisters when you hear

[34:15]these claims somebody's saying for example this hadith do we need hadith

[34:19]we have the poll on you know don't make this claim and

[34:22]sometimes they bring arguments sometimes arguments and you might say no no

[34:25]no we have the hold on and a lil betta Alima we

[34:28]need both of them and there's not up to anybody to come

[34:32]and start deciphering the Quran the way he likes interpreting the whole

[34:35]on he likes we go to a lil betta limassol aah and

[34:37]that's what the ayah is trying to bring our attention that Oh

[34:43]manin or people when you discuss discuss based on knowledge knowledge I'll

[34:50]and some knowledge that is kind that's logical that is based with

[34:56]evidence and with words of a lil betta alayhim with Salam the

[34:59]Hooda the guidance and based on the Quran as taught by a

[35:04]little bait sallallahu alehiwassallaam on image my when you have this you

[35:10]discuss with somebody and when you engage in discussion engage with the

[35:17]intent of learning the truth not with arrogance know what learning in

[35:23]doing so insha'Allah Allah subhana Allah will bless us to be among

[35:28]the sincere followers of a lil betta allium salam we pray to

[35:30]Allah subhana Allah to increase in our guidance and we pray to

[35:36]Allah subhana Allah to make us among the sincere followers of a

[35:39]lil betta sallallahu wasallam holly him ajma'in raise your hands for the

[35:44]door on this eve lailatul Joe we have some mini and somewhat

[35:47]minute who requested a specifically for Dora let us raise our hands

[35:50]may allah subhan allah accept Deltron inshallah grant them their hodgett bismillah

[36:00]al-rahman al-rahim mi ug ball moga da da way aksha for soo

[36:11]mi you Jimbo almost para y da da boi AXA for su

[36:25]mi you Jimbo Elmo da da da boi AXA for su mi

[36:29]ng ball milagre da da da why aksha for so am i

[36:39]evil moga da da da boi AXA food along my Nana's Aluko

[36:47]when I don't miss me que la famille la famille Ozil agile

[36:51]a crummy o Allah you're a la mia alarm or your along

[37:01]your mommy amor your law we all know ya ilahi before tlie

[37:07]mettawa abhi na baba ali hawa Benina was surreal mas todavia exif

[37:18]Anasuya Allah Allah Danube anna catherine i sent you artina ottawa phenomena

[37:26]Bob along the shower gel mater Genia alarm I love for sossaman

[37:30]also now buckle the Hawaii Jehovah FEMA Guam and hum hum a

[37:37]TKO come on I mean along my Sharpie wifey Jamie I mac

[37:39]mini no one minute you're a la a la minute mini now

[37:45]Elmo may not be out Barney him ya allah allah allah i

[37:52]dont him ya allah and humber motika yamaha i mean a bit

[37:55]fiddly when you only day in Yokohama come on a ban you

[38:03]something it's a marvelous on your son will be singing out your

[38:07]honor rabbit your name a famous solid only achieve a banner what

[38:11]a bubble da a la are genuinely you can forget watch on

[38:18]demand she asking you on slugging you honey when was the shoddy

[38:21]never in a day alone McCully wanaka haja technol hassan salameh toca

[38:39]la la la vie hadiza wafi Calissa hualien happy for wider what

[38:50]the leela why hotter to skena who auto baka dawa were to

[39:05]meet yahoo fijo bharat mata KO yamaha alam ii not a dog

[39:09]machine well over at Alameda walk hold on Lauren IV not watching

[39:17]me na la alarma Noxzema a link at the Sahara infant Lima

[39:21]a llama gossip Tanisha for Tessa haha yah yah la me alone

[39:25]baba wawa it well shefa Almagro le cash we had the Elven

[39:30]ha de la moto g 4g Mawlana Sahib a las dos semana

[39:35]el agua minerale momina lossy muhammad in jealousy novel hovering rahim allah

[39:41]huma atras ova till mubarak al fatiha hottie my solo

0 Comments

Volgende

The Basis of Discussion

Transcript

Volgende

Ontdek meer

Houd er rekening mee dat als u jonger bent dan 18 jaar, u geen toegang kunt krijgen tot deze site.

Volgende

The Basis of Discussion

Transcript

Volgende

Ontdek meer

Kies een betaal methode

Taal