The Final Cut: The Companions of the Prophet in Shi'a Thought || Br. Hassan al-Qadri

21 Views· 23/04/14

The Purified Truth الحق المبين
Subscribers

In dogmas

In the name of Allah,

Two very important questions regarding the companions of the Prophet in Shi'a thought:

1) Do the Shi'a do takfir on all the companions of the Prophet except three?

2) What is the belief of the Shi'as regarding the companions of the Prophet?

Brother Hassan al-Qadri answers these crucial questions in this video.

#Sahaba #Takfir #speakerscorner

Transcript

[0:00][Music] foreign [Music] [Music] the second is that and the third is

[4:14]in the honor of imam abdullah al hussein the companions of rasulullah

[4:41]without a shadow of a doubt are from the most crucial generation

[4:47]of muslims for they are the first generation they are the generation

[4:53]that saw the prophet sat down with the prophet went into battle

[4:58]with the prophet they are the people that struggled in the way

[5:03]of allah subhanahu wa ta'ala for the sake of the nabil and

[5:07]for the sake of religion for it's a vital discussion as in

[5:15]is the first generation immune from committing major sins are they immune

[5:21]from lying are they immune from apostating are they immune from leaving

[5:28]the religion of islam it's a major discussion and without a shadow

[5:34]of a doubt it's been a controversial one especially between the school

[5:39]of the sahaba what is called and the shias for many of

[5:49]the scholars of sunnah throughout the centuries have don't take fear on

[5:53]the shia as because apparently the shia has only believe in a

[5:58]certain number of companions and have done take fear on the shias

[6:01]because they are against some of the companions so it's a crucial

[6:07]discussion today in sha allah we want to discuss the companions of

[6:15]rasulullah our discussion tonight inshaallah is regarding the companions of rasulullah in

[6:23]shia thought what is the shia position for many years i've heard

[6:31]as a youngster only three stayed loyal to imam ali only three

[6:35]stayed muslim and the rest of them all left islam they all

[6:41]became apostates it's a discussion that needs to be discussed as in

[6:46]do the shia i really believe this is this something that the

[6:51]shias believe in and it's something that's been solidified within their books

[6:54]within the hadith corpus or not so our discussion will be specifically

[7:04]only about the companions of rasulullah in shia thought but let us

[7:10]go to what some of the scholars of allah say even kathir

[7:16]in his tafsir he says when discussing the verse that i just

[7:20]mentioned so surah 9 verse 100 he says after he mentions the

[7:30]verse he says therefore woe to those who dislike or curse them

[7:36]or dislike or curse any of them especially their master after the

[7:43]messenger of allah the best and the most righteous among them and

[7:52]the grand caliph the first historical caliph the failure group so the

[8:06]failing group the rafa are the enemies of the best companions they

[8:12]hate and curse them we seek refuge with allah from such evil

[8:15]this indicates that the minds of these people are twisted and their

[8:26]hearts have turned upside down for where are they in relation in

[8:37]believing in the quran they curse those whom allah stated he is

[8:42]pleased with important point very important point another crucial and this is

[8:55]a very very crucial book it's called usual it's written by an

[9:03]individual by the name of nas bin abdullah bin ali this book

[9:10]is probably the best book written as a refutation to the shias

[9:16]why because he actually for once he goes to shia hadith shia

[9:25]principles and tries to use them against the shia he mentions the

[9:28]the books of the shia are filled with lana take fear to

[9:36]those who allah is pleased with and they are pleased with him

[9:40]from the muhajiroun will answer the people of badr the allegiance of

[9:46]and the rest of the companions now this is the crucial point

[9:52]listen very carefully and they have excluded only a very small minority

[9:57]of the companions that do not even reach the number of fingers

[10:04]on a hand so he's saying the shias he's looked at the

[10:09]shia hadith corpus and the shia as do you take fear on

[10:14]all of the sahaba except you can't even count them in you

[10:17]can only it doesn't go for more than more than the fingers

[10:20]of one hand it's an important discussion i remember one of my

[10:29]teachers long his life he says when he converted to shiasm from

[10:33]the lectures in the english language from the shia lecturers and from

[10:38]the books that were translated alhamdulillah of course now he's mastered the

[10:42]arabic language and the different sciences but he says it seemed that

[10:48]yeah the shia i believed that all of the companions apostated except

[10:54]a few three four maybe five so let's discuss it today inshaallah

[11:03]we want to look at these narrations bring them all together to

[11:07]come to an understanding look at it from various different angles and

[11:13]one history what was occurring in that time what is truly meant

[11:18]by these narrations how many do the shias believe in to be

[11:28]good from the companions of rasulullah [Music] of zurara bin ayan this

[11:48]family ali ayan they were all sunnis they were from the time

[11:53]of imam al-bakr do you know how they converted they converted because

[11:59]of their sister see the power of what a woman can do

[12:04]she found truth she converted all of them or majority of them

[12:08]and they became from the most loyal companions and for over three

[12:15]generations they served the imams a woman did this said i said

[12:23]to abhija for allah how few we are the shias if we

[12:29]were together to eat a sheep we would not be able to

[12:34]finish it now of course depending on how big you are i

[12:42]don't know if i was with them what would happen but only

[12:46]a few number from what you can understand literally only there's a

[12:53]few numbers so the imam replies he says should i not inform

[12:57]you of something even more bewildering something more surprising he says yes

[13:09]so the imam says all perished i mentioned the arabic because we're

[13:19]coming to it slowly all perished except for and ingested with his

[13:31]hand free allahu akbar we're going to come to these discussions we're

[13:53]going to come to these slowly we're coming back to them another

[13:57]narration from imam abi jaffar al-baqar is one of the titles one

[14:07]of the names of imam al-bakr he says the people were the

[14:11]people of now most have translated this as the people that uh

[14:20]became apostates the people were the people were the people of rudder

[14:27]after the prophet sorry the people of the after the prophet except

[14:36]free so except three from the people of stayed loyal i said

[14:42]who are the three he said al-mukd may allah's mercy be upon

[14:54]them and then the people came to know after a short while

[14:58]crucial line now let me repeat it then the people came to

[15:04]know after a short while we're going to now understand slowly we're

[15:08]coming from every angle to understand what was happening these three uh

[15:14]are those around whom the banner of truth revolved and they refused

[15:20]to give baya to who abu bakr ibn until when they fought

[15:26]the command of the faithful allah on the force sorry until when

[15:33]they brought the command of the faithful allah on the force and

[15:38]he gave the pledge of allegiance let's just discuss this this land

[15:44]that i just mentioned it means [Music] did not want to give

[15:55]bay to abu bakr ibn abi in sunday books they say there's

[16:00]a bit of a confusion some of them try to connect it

[16:04]but it doesn't really connect one says oh no one narration general

[16:07]says he even forgot he was basically half naked running to give

[16:10]bayer another narration says in bukhari if i'm not mistaken where it

[16:20]says it was after six months but they say no he was

[16:23]busy with fatima that's why he didn't yeah so he couldn't leave

[16:26]for 10 minutes and it wasn't medina wasn't even that big so

[16:30]what we what we see is they're saying oh he was busy

[16:33]with father and son she was very upset with the death of

[16:39]her father okay so you're telling me he couldn't just said um

[16:46]zainab or imam al-hasan saying look after your mother five minutes salaam

[16:52]or he could have said send a messenger i'm going to give

[16:56]you better in front of the people at this time he comes

[16:59]ten minutes and goes back but no fatah zahara was a bit

[17:06]ill right so it shows that amir al-munu did not want to

[17:11]give allegiance jade another hadith from imam al-bakr again the people turned

[17:19]back that's the word used in arabic except three individuals so the

[17:30]narrator says what about amar the imam replied he swerved a bit

[17:36]then returned to the truth we're going to understand what you mean

[17:45]what happened then the people returned after that so the first ones

[17:49]to return were abu says they became seven none recognize the rights

[18:02]of the commander of the faithful except these seven there's an understanding

[18:10]to this also now we have the word [Music] i mean okay

[18:22]if we're going to look at it from a literal standpoint i

[18:26]mean their scholars are correct the shia as are saying everyone became

[18:32]apostates except three let's discuss now inshallah let's let's slowly slowly start

[18:38]to break down these narrations a very crucial point to be discussed

[18:47]and that we need to put forward linguistically in the arabic language

[18:58]actually mean yes true it could mean they became apostate someone of

[19:06]course they left religion but there's a scholar by the name of

[19:11]ibn he has a book called hadith it's a book that discusses

[19:15]he brings different hadith from the sunnah and he discusses them from

[19:20]the controversial hadith that's found in bukhari and other books is that

[19:28]it says there and i'm just paraphrasing that basically if you read

[19:33]it literally that all the companions by sunnistan this is the sunni

[19:38]books in the day of judgment they were all going one way

[19:40]or thirtu they became apostates after you that's what it says he

[19:43]says no murtadin it means contradiction disagreement of their duty and it

[19:53]is not understood as apostasy or belief thank you abina thank you

[19:59]very much we're going to use that in a second i appreciate

[20:04]that thank you okay now this hadith that i'm about to bring

[20:10]brings us a bit closer starts to tighten it up with all

[20:14]these narrations and others came after so after to ali and said

[20:27]you are by allah the commander of the faithful and you are

[20:32]by allah the most rightful person and closest to the prophet put

[20:36]forth your hand so that we can pledge allegiance to you that

[20:41]means they had many of the muhajiroun and ansar and the others

[20:47]had they very crucial this is very crucial and the other ones

[21:04]it seems like oh no everyone left no one was left except

[21:10]three for by allah we are going to die in front of

[21:16]you in your defense jade imam ali said if you are truthful

[21:25]then come to me tomorrow having shade your heads this is to

[21:32]identify that they will rebel they want to go to war against

[21:38]never wanted to stay silent never ever believe that it wasn't a

[21:43]thing where he died and abu bakr took the khilafah and then

[21:47]amir ramon just sat back and that's it cried a bit uh

[21:52]compiled a few books or he looked off the father to zara

[21:55]right now amir and mummy wanted to revolt amir al-manin wanted to

[22:03]go to war certain narrations and it breaks my heart when i

[22:10]mention it you know what it says after this the chad of

[22:18]rasulillah amir al-mukhmuneen he puts a zara on the donkey and he

[22:22]would walk her in madina knocking on the door of the muhajireen

[22:26]and ansar and he'll tell them remember do you remember that i

[22:34]am the caliph do you remember what rasulullah said in termini to

[22:52]you picture it my brothers at sahara on the donkey knocking on

[23:01]the doors telling people who's whoever's there just imagine that so it

[23:14]says the wire says but no one else did so they didn't

[23:25]come and meet him then they came a second time after the

[23:30]first and said so they came another time the next day probably

[23:34]he said you are by allah the most rightful person and closest

[23:39]to the prophet put forth your hand so that we can pledge

[23:42]allegiance to you and they swore an oath he said come to

[23:48]me tomorrow having shaved your head if you are truthful but no

[23:54]one shaved except three what does this show us that the companions

[24:05]many of the muharram and ansar and others believed in the but

[24:13]there were things that were stopping them some were scared but that

[24:19]doesn't make him a kafir yes he's he committed the sin for

[24:24]not aiding the imam of his time no doubt no doubt but

[24:26]it doesn't make him a coffer how many how many of us

[24:35]here break the oath that we have to imam sharif how many

[24:38]of us every day every sin that we commit we're breaking that

[24:44]oath or breaking that dua that we always recite so this shows

[24:53]us that no they had belief that it wasn't just three that

[25:00]only believed in emira mummy no no there was many now i

[25:04]want to just just so we can you can understand historically what

[25:07]occurred now of course we're talking from [Music] shia standard shia books

[25:15]today i'm not concerned with sunny books because we're talking about companions

[25:22]and shia thought one there the way that what occurred when rasulullah

[25:34]died you remember yesterday i mentioned the words of the sunni scholar

[25:42]that said imam is so important that they the companions wanted to

[25:48]choose the imam before bearing rasulillah this is what they they did

[25:58]so that's their importance for them so it shows us when this

[26:03]happened and abu bakr became the caliph there is indication reports historical

[26:10]reports that indicate a tribe that were basically rejected by rasulullah came

[26:24]in and took over medina you remember how daesh took over mosul

[26:30]a bit similar to that and a bit similar to when you

[26:37]know the daughter of abu bakr took over basra and murdered many

[26:40]muslims in basra but not many people want to talk about that

[26:43]so we see that this happened okay so this shows us that

[26:51]it it was a matter where people were in fear companions were

[26:56]unfair it even mentioned some reports and this is the second point

[26:59]many of the companions of rasulullah were beaten the third point and

[27:14]very important point historically is that many of the great companions where

[27:20]with the army of osama bin zayed remember when rasool allah said

[27:25]you have to go with the army of osama the young man

[27:29]many of the companions were with osama osama didn't even know that

[27:34]abu bakr became the caliph so it shows us these ahadith historically

[27:43]cannot be understood how some of even our scholars fortunately have understood

[27:50]it in that way but i believe that they didn't do good

[27:55]enough research it was something just oh the imam said they will

[27:58]take it on you need to look at things holistically bring all

[28:01]the hadith together so this shows us now historically what was occurring

[28:06]so they believed in imam ali we've agreed right all of us

[28:11]have agreed they believed in imam ali but some were scared some

[28:14]were not there some didn't make it and someone like ammar he

[28:19]came a bit late he swerved a bit didn't know what was

[28:24]going on because honestly when you look at the reports the historical

[28:30]reports when abu bakr took the khilafah it was it was like

[28:35]a shock just and it happened so many people didn't didn't know

[28:41]what was happening do we run do we stay do we what

[28:46]what's happening there's a narration in in kitab al hisal kitab one

[28:59]of our classical scholars what happens is first chapter for example talks

[29:06]about one he brings all the narrations that mention the word one

[29:10]second chapter two anything that talks about two readers it's been translated

[29:16]very nice book but when you get to chapter 12 when he's

[29:19]talking about the number 12 he discusses that there were 12.

[29:26]from the mahadarin and ansar that rejected the caliphate of abu bakr

[29:36]stood up and said i bear witness i have heard god's prophet

[29:43]say the following from the pulpit your divine leader after me [Music]

[30:07]your divine leader after me will be alibi talib he is the

[30:16]one person who is the most caring of the nation you see

[30:24]here this is very important so what's happening now with the other

[30:27]narrations that talk about three very important no this gathers this this

[30:35]how we need to start to look at history look at different

[30:44]topics recently and every every asian it happens what pops up what

[30:50]discussion discussion about fasting on day of ashura and i see many

[30:55]oh the sunnis how can you accept it because rasulullah legislated it

[30:59]in the day of in hararam and he legislated it when he

[31:05]got to medina because of the jews no that's not true what

[31:09]am i trying to say i'm saying even with our brothers and

[31:12]sisters from atlas sunnah we need to be fair there has been

[31:16]research done by scholars like even that have discussed this what is

[31:26]our problem with these narrations our problem is one of the philosophies

[31:29]of fasting on the day of for them is that it's a

[31:33]day of victory a day where you are happy because musa was

[31:35]victorious i say no no we're not we're not happy we're not

[31:42]happy at all the day of our is the day of tragedies

[31:48]the day abi abdullah was slaughtered in the lands of karbala ashora

[31:54]is the day where the tents of the daughters of rasulullah was

[32:00]burnt where the daughter of imam hussain would run from one tent

[32:10]to another asura is that day where the daughter of imam al-hussein

[32:15]no not yet brother imam hussain she would tell him i'm thirsty

[32:21]and the different children are thirsty the day of our is not

[32:30]a day of happiness in any shape or form we go to

[32:37]a passage in kitab tahara for sayyid khomeini he says it is

[32:43]also possible to say the fundamental belief of imam was in the

[32:47]first generation among the riyadh from the most important matters of islam

[32:54]and the first first generation who rejected the imam of imam of

[33:01]the maula the command of the faithful and the nas the designation

[33:09]of imam ali of the messenger of allah concerning his khilafah and

[33:14]leadership were rejecting a important matter without there being credible excuse from

[33:21]their like especially the people of al halliwell the elites the decision

[33:28]makers that we discussed yesterday this is a very important point why

[33:33]because we are saying yes those who openly showed that they are

[33:44]rejecting the khilafah of amir al-mu'min will be either two things they

[33:52]left the religion of islam or they are munafiqueen that's what he's

[33:57]basically saying because now we cannot say for example that all that

[34:05]the our brothers and sisters from sunnah why because throughout time so

[34:13]much of the truth was hidden now you bring them a hadith

[34:17]ali is the khalifa after me you have to look at the

[34:20]chain how many of the people have studied these different sciences or

[34:22]understand these things you bring them hadith no albeit doesn't just mean

[34:28]that doesn't mean follow it means be good to them you know

[34:33]there's a lot of playing around he was looking after fatima right

[34:39]so we see that yes are very important why because he's saying

[34:47]that the first generation saw it was clear to them rasulullah in

[34:51]many occasions ali is the khalifa after ali is the successor after

[34:55]ali is the leader of him all of these things it's clear

[35:02]but now this narration that i'm about to bring you pizza all

[35:09]together muhammad when the people did what they did giving allegiance to

[35:27]abu bakr when they gave allegiance to abu bakr nothing prevented the

[35:32]commander of the faithful from calling to himself except his concern this

[35:41]is very important now i'm going to it's very very important accept

[35:45]his concern and fear for the people that they would apostate from

[35:53]islam so that means we agree with with even athir in the

[36:00]meaning here for these narrations these companions many of the companions did

[36:06]not leave islam rather they broke their oath as as i have

[36:11]shown are we all understanding how we're going with this he says

[36:19]accept his concern and fear for the people that they would apostate

[36:25]from islam why did amir how did emir menin want to rebel

[36:29]we have narrations that say rasulullah says do not rebel if they

[36:32]take the khilafah from you except if you have 30 or 40

[36:41]supporters this is very important why why do i say 30 or

[36:44]40 because the narrations some of them differ um some say 30

[36:48]some say 40.

[36:50]either way a specific amount of supporters he didn't have these supporters

[36:55]to rebel that doesn't make them go far because if you're going

[36:59]to make them go far then many brothers and sisters will be

[37:05]kuffar because we're breaking offs every day so he says and begin

[37:10]to worship the idols they would go back to worshiping the idols

[37:16]and seize witnessing that there is no god but allah and are

[37:29]you seeing how we're tying everything together we're putting it all together

[37:33]so this shows the author of us did not look at the

[37:45]narrations holistically he was unfair and the shia scholars that came to

[37:49]the conclusion that everyone left islam except a few have not looked

[37:53]into our traditions well and i'm very sorry to say this it

[38:01]was more beloved to him imam is continuing it is more beloved

[38:06]to him to accept to what they had done rather than them

[38:14]becoming apostates and leaving the whole of islam that means they didn't

[38:19]leave islam see how when you look at things holistically what happens

[38:26]now you see ex-muslims what they what do they do they bring

[38:32]a verse from the quran kill the polytheist people wherever you find

[38:36]them okay sir can you look at like the other verses look

[38:43]at the hadith that are explaining it are you seeing muslims left

[38:48]right center all of the muslims just any one that is a

[38:52]non-muslim or is a mushrik you know god forbid that just slaughtering

[38:55]killing people left right center no verily it is only those who

[39:04]embarked on what they embarked so the people that did the crime

[39:09]who are destroyed wow this now has put it all together so

[39:18]those who wholeheartedly without force gave allegiance to abu bakr ibn abby

[39:26]are destroyed as for the one who did not do that and

[39:32]entered in what the people entered without knowledge nor enmity towards the

[39:40]commander of the faithful then this act of his does not make

[39:45]him a car fair i don't even need to continue anymore but

[39:54]i will and it does not remove him from islam and that

[40:00]is why ali kept quiet about this matter and gave allegiance wiles

[40:10]compelled happy with roses and daisies giving it to him never when

[40:27]he could not find support he could not find supporters he was

[40:35]compelled some narrations it's found in the book kitab sulaim now of

[40:39]course our scholars are in dispute whether this book is um accepted

[40:44]or not but it gives a certain detail that doesn't contradict what

[40:49]we are seeing is that it says amir al-mu'manin they took him

[40:57]they put they tied his neck dragged him dragged him and by

[41:04]the way he wasn't he just stood there and they somewhat arrested

[41:07]them no no there was it states that reports state that maybe

[41:13]a few hundred jumped on him put him down and did this

[41:16]to him that's what the report says now we have finished the

[41:26]discussion any sunday scholar that comes from now on and that's why

[41:29]i called i titled this lecture the final cut i don't hear

[41:34]it anymore whenever you hear it just send them the lecture because

[41:38]it's finished for too long you're far why you believe that the

[41:47]the companions of kuffar no we believe that certain companions are munafikin

[41:58]hypocrites and some of them are our masters we follow their footsteps

[42:09]as mentioned in the verse earlier and those who follow them in

[42:15]goodness yes this gives us a premise that these companions we follow

[42:19]have to be upon goodness we have to define goodness we're not

[42:25]going to follow the goodness of someone that attacked the daughter of

[42:30]rasulullah we're not going to follow the goodness of those who took

[42:40]the khilafah from amir al-mu'manin let's look at the traditions that discuss

[42:46]the shia now we've we agreed that discussion is finished the final

[42:54]cut i'm not going back to it no more anishia scholar sunni

[42:57]scholar that says it please look at the hadith so that we

[43:03]can understand things we don't just take one narration or two and

[43:07]throw out the rest again in kitab al hisala and the chain

[43:17]of narrators are all trustworthy to god trustworthy narrators ah there were

[43:26]twelve thousand companions of god's prophets a thousand of them were from

[43:36]medina two thousand of them were from mecca and another two thousand

[43:38]were from those who the prophet pardoned when the who had become

[43:52]muslim 12 000 8 000 from medina two thousand from mecca and

[44:00]two thousand from who had become muslim they were no there were

[44:08]no kadriya these are sets that came up in the time of

[44:12]the imams mohammed who act according to their opinion they cried day

[44:37]and night and said oh god oh god please take away our

[44:41]souls before we eat barley bread the imam is praising twelve thousand

[44:47]just a bit of a important point to um for us to

[44:57]put forward these twelve thousand did they all die before rasulullah surely

[45:01]many of them stayed alive after rasulullah but here the imam is

[45:07]praising them the imam came about 140 years after rasulullah something like

[45:12]that crucial point so the shias do not say only three unfortunately

[45:22]many of our lecturers only mention these three but we have so

[45:26]much about the other companions of rasulullah and a very crucial point

[45:34]and this is one of the commentaries of my someone that i

[45:39]i see as my teacher salman he says these are of the

[45:44]greatest companions so they was on the highest level there are more

[45:48]who were upon goodness so these 12 000 were the best of

[45:53]them the elites the you know there's no discussion about them righteous

[45:58]pious muttering imam sajah says oh allah asks for the companions of

[46:19]muhammad especially those who did well in companionship so he's not saying

[46:24]just anyone that saw the prophet believed in him and died upon

[46:29]that belief that's their definition of companion no he did well in

[46:33]his companionship who stood the good test in helping him when he

[46:39]made them hear his messages and children manifesting his words fought against

[46:45]the for their fathers and sons and strengthening his prophecy and it's

[46:50]a lengthy but it shows us what that we praise those who

[47:00]are good with the prophet it wasn't just three that were good

[47:05]with the prophet there were many there were many again one of

[47:13]our grand scholars sheikh al-mufid one of our classical scholars in his

[47:19]book kitab he says on the death of the prophet may allah

[47:24]bless him and his pure family the community differed over his imam

[47:27]so over who the imam is going to be after him all

[47:33]from benihashim shah the man who is known as the the one

[47:45]who um basically professed to the two testimonies and people like them

[47:55]among the important and ansar all these maintained that he was the

[48:06]successor after the prophet so from our classical scholars he's saying it

[48:15]our classical scholars are stating that many of the muharram and ansar

[48:24]stayed loyal and believed in the khilaf of amir al-mu'min and another

[48:32]very now these last two points of is very important i'm sure

[48:37]many of you have heard of the book the author is sayid

[48:43]abdul hussain al-musa he's one of our grand scholars he was from

[48:52]lebanon one of the lions of tasheon one of the only few

[48:56]to lead salah i think it was in mecca medina one of

[49:00]the my memory is not serving me leading the prayer he said

[49:12]he mentions 171 companions that are praised in the school of athletes

[49:20]now of course some of the brothers and sisters from sunnah are

[49:26]probably like no only 170 71 i'm coming to a quick explanation

[49:32]don't worry he was a specialist in the study of the narrators

[49:43]of hadith he has a book called which is like an encyclopedia

[49:53]of the narrators of hadith he mentions 533 companions that are praised

[49:59]and revered in the school of achievement how important is that so

[50:07]he's done a very crucial study about the companions and he found

[50:18]533 companions to be praised and revered in the school of atlas

[50:23]this is very crucial and i will end it in sha allah

[50:29]by saying in conclusion one not three companions many more they just

[50:36]broke that oath when you ask them to shave their hair to

[50:41]shave and come so that they can rebel they broke that oath

[50:47]and of course there will be a punishment for that but it

[50:52]doesn't make them allah another point to be understood the shias revere

[50:59]and love most of the companions it's not all of the companions

[51:06]that were hypocrites we are lovers of the companions that stayed loyal

[51:13]to rasulullah and the household of muhammad lastly to gather it all

[51:22]together one we believe some of the companions of rasulullah are hypocrites

[51:32]we believe also a big group of them who are righteous pious

[51:42]loyal companions and the third one which is crucial some of them

[51:47]are unknown some of them are unknown so we don't know their

[51:51]name we don't know anything about their history we can't judge and

[51:55]we can't just give just one solid principle for all of them

[51:59]sunnah they believe in a dialect of sahaba the justice of the

[52:03]all of the companions that the companion will never lie against rasulullah

[52:09]never lie against rasulullah today we spoke about the companions of the

[52:20]messenger of allah but there were no companions like the companions you

[52:39]know what he says to them he says it's dark he says

[52:46]to them it is dark why don't you go i'll allow you

[52:53]to leave they never left him they stood firm with him there's

[53:01]a scene just before i hand it over to the sayyid that

[53:09]truly is remarkable ahmad bin sad throws the first arrow and he

[53:15]says tell the emir i am the first that i am the

[53:20]first one to shoot i arrow against the camp of hussein and

[53:24]then they start to shoot the arrows do you know what hussain

[53:32]says to his companions he says may allah have mercy upon you

[53:40]rise rise all servants of allah or slaves of allah for these

[53:50]arrows are your messengers to death and you know what they did

[54:00]they rose and it says that the first reign of arrows the

[54:05]first reign of arrows killed many of the most of the companions

[54:10]of imam hussein meaning they were standing like shields for abba abdullah

[54:21]may allah make us like the companions of hussein for the imam

[54:30]of our time and i'll leave you just with this question all

[54:37]of you if you are someone that doesn't have the knowledge to

[54:43]you know put it out there you can help out in different

[54:49]ways i have my good friend here sami he's got he's been

[54:52]driving me around my car broke down if you're someone that has

[54:58]your alhamdulillah allah has given you help out financially mother sayyid hussain

[55:03]he gave us his house to make a medjlist so inshaallah i'll

[55:10]leave you with this question what are you doing for the imam

[55:17]of your time are you going to be like the companions of

[55:23]hussein or are you going to be of those who just loves

[55:32]hussein but his love means nothing because he's not doing anything for

[55:35]the imam of his time saying that for the lord you

0 Comments

Up next

The Final Cut: The Companions of the Prophet in Shi'a Thought || Br. Hassan al-Qadri

Transcript

Up next

Explore more

Please note that if you are under 18, you won't be able to access this site.

Up next

The Final Cut: The Companions of the Prophet in Shi'a Thought || Br. Hassan al-Qadri

Transcript

Up next

Explore more

Choose a payment method

Language