Night 4 - Abu Bakr and Umar anger Fatima (as) - Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshawani

35 المشاهدات· 24/03/24

Sayed Ammar Nakshawani Official
مشتركين

في محاضرات

أظهر المزيد

Transcript

[0:03]brothers and sisters and dear viewers of imam hussain tv we are

[0:08]here in karbala to give you another update the latest update that

[0:11]we have we are here at the top floor studio here in

[0:15]kerbela you can see that there's been a bit of a change

[0:17]here there's four ac units that cover the entire building there's a

[0:25]stage here for us inshallah this will all be built with your

[0:28]donations and inshallah you will find it in your heart to help

[0:32]build this place for you for your children for your grandchildren and

[0:36]everyone to hear the message of imam al-hussein these ac units have

[0:44]cost us 130 thousand dollars we need this money to be able

[0:48]to accommodate for everyone for the shows for the guests that we

[0:51]have here in karbala you can see that from this studio we

[1:00]overlook the beautiful shrines of abel and right there the construction that's

[1:06]happening that will be there where say it stood and saw the

[1:14]calamities of kerbela now my dear brothers and sisters if we just

[1:16]go behind me here you can see that there's still a lot

[1:21]of work to be done the flooring needs to be covered with

[1:24]tiles now the walls need to be done and a lot of

[1:28]stuff in the background that hasn't been decorated or painted it's literally

[1:31]just bricks so my dear brothers and sisters this is the latest

[1:35]update that we have on this studio and inshallah we will receive

[1:40]your donations to help complete this building for you for your children

[1:44]and for your grandchildren [Music] we all have a duty towards the

[1:56]preservation and the propagation of the message of imam hussein indeed one

[2:02]of the best ways to work towards the reappearance of imam al-mahdi

[2:06]allah is through promoting the values of carmella imam hussain media group

[2:14]is the only shia television network that broadcasts globally in five different

[2:18]languages arabic farsi turkish or do in english we are appealing to

[2:25]the lovers of worldwide to support the channel such that it may

[2:31]continue its global operations the hussein media group is seeking 1 000

[2:35]partners to pledge to a 14 pound contribution per month this will

[2:39]allow the channel to sustain its operating costs as we continue to

[2:46]spread the message of imam alaihissalam in multiple languages across the globe

[2:52]you be a part of this great legacy and donate today you

[2:56]can pledge in two ways www dot along the same three dot

[3:02]tv slash donate we'll take you down to our donation page where

[3:05]you can play it monthly or you can call or what's up

[3:11]us on double zero double four seven nine three double nine one

[3:15]seven one six three i'm on for saint tv your gateway to

[3:19]karbala [Music] [Music] [Music] am [Music] [Music] [Music] muhammad [Music] foreign foreign

[5:40]refused to give her any of the property so fatimah became angry

[5:48]with abu bakr kept away from him and did not talk to

[5:55]him until she died she remained alive for six months after the

[6:00]death of the holy prophet peace be upon him and his family

[6:04]when she passed away she was buried by imam ali alaihissalam and

[6:12]he did not inform abu bakr of the burial i wouldn't blame

[6:18]you if you thought that this was a passage from a shiite

[6:22]text from a shia author from a shia piece of literature indeed

[6:27]it's a passage from sahih al-bukhari of all texts you find that

[6:32]this passage is found in one of the most famous non-shia texts

[6:37]in islamic history if ever there was a problem a difficulty a

[6:41]nemesis for abu bakr after it was indeed who would have thought

[6:50]that a female would be his major problem there were enough personalities

[6:54]who were around in medina at the time who had already objected

[6:58]to what took place at satifa their objection could be seen and

[7:03]the fact that they were not ready to pledge allegiance to abu

[7:07]bakr many assume that everybody had pledged allegiance to him and that

[7:12]everything had moved smoothly this couldn't be further from the truth there

[7:15]were already a number of personalities who we discussed last night who

[7:20]clearly were not ready to pledge allegiance to abu bakr for one

[7:24]reason or another either there were those who were busy with the

[7:27]burial of the holy prophet peace be upon him and his family

[7:31]or there were those who blatantly had disagreed with either his appointment

[7:37]the method of his appointment or him taking this leadership you therefore

[7:45]found that the most outspoken of them in many cases were the

[7:47]males of medinian society but if ever there was one who was

[7:53]more outspoken than all the males put together against abu bakr and

[7:57]omar and what in the muslim world today is the most revered

[8:07]lady one may argue if you go to shia and non-shia that

[8:11]will say to you how much they love as in wherever you

[8:16]travel in the muslim world you'll see people who admire people who

[8:20]will name their children after this when the cases of many out

[8:27]there they do not know about the differences and the war of

[8:31]words between if they did then they have to ask themselves a

[8:36]major question does not agree with that particular government and believed that

[8:44]there was power that was usurped then what does it say about

[8:49]the government of that time if you claim to love fatima your

[8:52]love for fatima cannot be simply based on the fact that she's

[8:56]the daughter of the prophet here we have a lady who when

[8:59]we examine what took place after sarifa is the most vehemently outspoken

[9:03]of all personalities in that society nobody spoke out against abu bakr

[9:10]and omar and nobody proved to be a thorn in the lives

[9:16]of abu bakr and omar at the beginning of their authority like

[9:22]father allah yet if you want to ask many muslims do you

[9:25]understand this do you believe in this you'll find that there are

[9:29]many out there who don't even know about this when you see

[9:32]the tradition that i quoted the tradition from sahih al-bukhari is a

[9:36]tradition which in reality is self-explanatory as in says that she is

[9:45]angry with somebody her anger is an anger which is the anger

[10:02]whoever angers her whoever hurts her has hurt me hurting her hurting

[10:08]the prophet is hurting allah subhanahu wa ta'ala therefore if left this

[10:17]world angry with somebody what does that tell you about that person

[10:21]because every year you ask me as a shiai that why is

[10:24]it that i do not revere abu bakr or i do not

[10:27]revere omar or i do not reveal uthman why it's because i

[10:32]see that there is a clear instance in my history where the

[10:37]holiest household in this religion are clearly angry with personalities because of

[10:44]their behaviors when i see that how can i love the one

[10:46]and good and the one they're angry with logically speaking i see

[10:52]two people one who's angered another who's angry with somebody who's the

[10:57]cause of anger how can i love both of them as in

[11:00]do i believe in a jannah and in this heaven i believe

[11:05]that the one who has died angry with somebody are going to

[11:07]end up in the same heaven as one another as in surely

[11:11]when the quran keeps telling us why do you not reflect why

[11:14]do not ponder further than that how does she die so young

[11:18]as in this is a lady who's still according to some narrations

[11:22]in her teens in her late teens how does she die so

[11:28]young when you look at what's taken place in the last few

[11:30]lectures that we've delivered in muharram we're not talking more than 10

[11:34]days of history many might assume that when i've discussed the pen

[11:38]and paper and i've discussed osama's army and yesterday when we discussed

[11:43]sativa and today when we discuss you might assume that this is

[11:49]over three months seven months nine months you might assume that this

[11:52]might be over 10 years 20 years i'm literally discussing 10 days

[11:56]worth of history in literally 10 days we have personalities who have

[12:01]not only attacked the prophet emotionally with their words after the prophets

[12:08]died they've gone ahead and formed their own election after that they

[12:13]begin to take out their venom on the household of rasulullah let

[12:20]us tonight examine how taking out your venom on fatama means there's

[12:26]no issue one day in taking out your venom on the sons

[12:30]of fatama and i'd like to do this in the following stages

[12:32]number one when sarifa took place which house did the dissenters gather

[12:39]in the ones who were against what took place at sarifa number

[12:42]two if they gathered and they dissented in this house does that

[12:49]mean that they are now faisakin are they kuffar are they out

[12:53]of the fold of the religion of islam number three what do

[12:58]non-shia texts show about the reaction of omar when he heard there

[13:02]were a group of people gathering in the house of fatima what

[13:07]was his opinion number four did that group have to pledge allegiance

[13:13]to abu bakr if you didn't have to pledge allegiance to the

[13:16]prophet of islam when he said he was a prophet why should

[13:19]you be forced to pledge to ah khalifa number five when father

[13:24]realized what the plan was what did they do to the peace

[13:30]of land given to her by rasulullah number six in sahih al-bukhari

[13:35]what is the whole hadith in the chapter of the magazine in

[13:40]the chapter discussion discussing the aftermath of what does the hadith say

[13:45]exactly and when we break down the hadith how does the hadith

[13:48]highlight not only fatama dying angry but not only nobody knowing where

[13:52]her grave is not only that she died in the middle of

[13:56]the night but also imam ali's clear disapproval of umar abner's behavior

[14:01]and was buried what was the reaction of imam amir al-mumin salam

[14:13]to the stand of his wife fatima and in the muslim community

[14:19]did that result in them showing respect to imam ali when fatima

[14:22]died or did they distance themselves even more from imam ali and

[14:26]to conclude when we look at islamic history what were the reactions

[14:33]to fathamataz in islam in the umayyad period who were the ones

[14:37]who loved her who were the ones who cursed her and on

[14:39]the 10th of muharram does she deserve a mention of course she

[14:44]does but who exactly mentioned her let's examine this and dissect the

[14:48]topic in depth sacrifice taken place when sativa is taking place naturally

[14:51]we could not say a hundred percent of the people agreed with

[14:56]what took place at sacrefa because already we said amongst the ansar

[15:01]sadhana and his son said we will never pledge allegiance to abu

[15:05]bakr we said that imam ali alayhi salaam was burying the prophet

[15:09]and was finishing everything that was taking place wasn't the only one

[15:15]who was doing this nor was he the only one who had

[15:19]heard about what had happened at sacrifice and was unhappy with it

[15:24]who were the others amongst the others was for example as zubair

[15:29]cousin of imam he was amongst those who had blatantly spoken out

[15:34]against what was taking place amongst them was amongst them was amongst

[15:46]them for example was the likes of khadifah al-iman amongst them you

[15:53]find for example some mentioned the names of abdullah have been masood

[15:57]others some mentioned bilal as being amongst those who had an issue

[16:02]with what was taking place because there's always an interesting question why

[16:07]bilal of rasulallah why have you stopped and why are you dying

[16:16]in syria far away from the islamic land the reality is that

[16:22]all of these realized what had taken place then the space of

[16:27]one week um not only had raised this voice against the prophet

[16:30]not only had abu bakr blatantly not joined osama's army not only

[16:36]had the two of them gone to sarifa but now they were

[16:38]walking around and ordering for people to pledge allegiance why are you

[16:46]forcing people to pledge allegiance my prophet when he came to mecca

[16:51]did he put a sword on people's heads and say you must

[16:54]believe in me as a prophet i ask all of you the

[16:57]prophet did he go to people when he became a prophet and

[17:00]said if you don't believe in me as a prophet i'm going

[17:04]to behead you do we have any evidence of that if you

[17:06]were christian or you were jewish and you didn't believe in the

[17:10]religion of islam which ayah do all of us use from surah

[17:12]al-baqarah to prove that i cannot compel you to be a muslim

[17:26]whoever wants to believe they can believe who wants to just believe

[17:31]they can disbelieve to use your religion towards mine the prophet may

[17:48]be a bashir he may be a nazir he may be a

[17:52]munder a warner a reminder one thing he's not muslim cannot compel

[17:56]a person wants to join my religion they can join and if

[18:00]they don't want to join they don't have to join what i

[18:05]have never understood in islamic history is how is it that with

[18:10]nobu you cannot force someone to pledge to rasulullah but suddenly with

[18:15]satifa you're going round forcing people to pledge what islam is that

[18:20]if he announced his prophethood went round to every house and be

[18:25]like if you guys don't come towards us and accept us i'm

[18:30]gonna burn your house down i'll be like you know what i

[18:33]don't want to follow this guy this guy's crazy this is lunatic

[18:36]this is blatant ignorance would you agree as then any non-muslim out

[18:42]there if you told him the prophet muhammad peace be upon his

[18:45]family if you never agreed with him he used to pick up

[18:46]a sword and he comes to your house and beheads you he'll

[18:50]be like you guys prophet's mad so what's he doing either i

[18:53]can agree to follow him or i agree to disagree the reality

[18:58]is that a non-muslim will look at this and say this is

[19:03]ridiculous after sarifa happened do you know what began to take place

[19:06]they had a problem how do we get ali to pledge why

[19:09]is ali a problem a because he's the closest to muhammad nobody

[19:15]is as close to rasulallah [Applause] there's too much of a wording

[19:23]there to indicate that he's bigger than everybody else see he's not

[19:29]present so what did they want they wanted him to pledge hold

[19:31]on a minute if you people are already in power why are

[19:34]you so adamant that imam ali has to pledge to you you

[19:38]know what's your problem so imam ali for example said no i

[19:40]don't want to pledge to you why do you have to force

[19:43]a pledge we know in islam which is coerced is not abaya

[19:48]that can be accepted has to come from the heart it cannot

[19:51]come from if i now get somebody to come to the khalifa

[19:55]and i'm like give bay and i've pointed an ak on his

[20:00]head that person even if he gives bayer at the end of

[20:02]the day of judgment will say they forced me into giving a

[20:05]but what happened was if you read literature you'll find these companions

[20:10]where did they gather the house of fatima and ali all of

[20:15]them were gathering in that house your amir al-mu'min your zubairs your

[20:21]salmans they were gathering in that house what is that house by

[20:25]the way who's in that house in that house there's a young

[20:30]boy he's eight years old he's called imam al-hasan alaihissalam and in

[20:34]that house there's a young boy called imam al-hussein seven years of

[20:39]age and in that house there's a young girl by the name

[20:45]of zainab salam five years of age and there is another young

[20:49]girl who possibly might be called zainab as well but as smaller

[20:53]zayna we may call her for example um and there is a

[20:59]lady by the name of fatama daughter of who's pregnant as well

[21:04]at that time so this we will call it in our language

[21:09]a young family do you agree yeah because imam ali is in

[21:13]his thirties in her late teens and they have kids again go

[21:16]to the non-muslim out there say to a non-muslim if there's a

[21:21]house where there are children there even the non-muslim will say listen

[21:24]if i've got a problem with the elders of the house put

[21:25]the kids aside don't touch any of the kids there's a non-muslim

[21:29]who would say this when all of these were gathering in the

[21:32]house they were telling him what do we do i said look

[21:38]what they've done they've gone to sarifa and they've had this skirmish

[21:42]in sacrifice they've had this election take place when they were gathering

[21:46]in this house discussing with imam salam there are two texts i

[21:50]want you all to read at home and they're not sheery texts

[21:53]one of them is the musa of ibn abi shaiba these two

[22:00]texts are available in arabic i don't know if they're available in

[22:02]english but they're certainly available in arabic if you look at them

[22:09]there's something which is interesting which occurs in both these texts what

[22:13]is it omar's threat to burn the house of fatima in both

[22:20]these texts because of what not because of fatima zara but um

[22:30]has a problem that why are these people not pledging allegiance to

[22:37]abu bakr why do they have to if abu bakr is chosen

[22:39]by allah and they don't pledge allegiance even then you shouldn't attack

[22:44]them because the man greater than all of them chosen by allah

[22:49]has his final prophet if you never pledge the leaders to him

[22:52]you were not attacked did anyone ever go to the house of

[22:55]the moon and say that there's a family in the house i'm

[22:58]going to burn the house down when rasulullah was alive ever do

[23:03]you find because we find eyes in the quran that says if

[23:09]you or prophet of god were hard hearted or you were severe

[23:14]people would have run away from you in the first of these

[23:18]texts the musa of ibn abi shaiba this is narration from obama

[23:24]omar from zaidbin islam from his father islam what is the narration

[23:28]the narration tells us how um has a discussion with fatima zahra

[23:33]while these are all in the house he says we respect you

[23:38]nobody is more beloved to the prophet to us than you but

[23:42]if these people think that they can gather in this house and

[23:46]dissent against the government we will burn the house down who's in

[23:51]the house see when you say i'm going to burn a house

[23:53]down who's in the house if you want to look at sunni

[23:58]political theory some of the people in that house are going gender

[24:01]they promise gender so i'm going to burn a house of people

[24:04]who are going to heaven me and them are going to couch

[24:05]we're going to link we're going to relax in heaven it's absolutely

[24:11]crazy it is absolutely crazy of course we could look later on

[24:15]people started to write names of hadiths people they're all going jannah

[24:18]but at that moment if you think logically if um burns the

[24:22]house of fatima remember this is not a shia book just in

[24:27]case someone says ah this is your literature musa of ibn abi

[24:29]shaiba it says that he says to her listen we respect you

[24:34]father i'll make it clear to you they continue to gather in

[24:36]this house why because they are descending against the islamic government and

[24:41]if you descend against the islamic government then you're going to have

[24:45]to be burnt if that's islam then assalamu alaikum peace be upon

[24:50]islam if that's islam even i wouldn't want to be part of

[24:54]that islam he says this therefore the threat has already begun that

[24:59]i'm ready um i am ready to burn a house which the

[25:04]prophet used to say assalamu alaikum outside that house where the prophet

[25:11]used to recite innama you read allah you found the discussion there

[25:29]as well where fatima tells him but you know what this house

[25:31]is he says well if we're going to have to burn it

[25:34]it's going to have to be burnt when this therefore takes place

[25:38]we see clearly that the government that's been established is a government

[25:43]that is ready to get rid of any of its enemies including

[25:48]the very flesh of rasulullah when someone tells me why did karabella

[25:54]happen i say hold on if you're willing to burn fatima what

[25:59]are the tents of zainab if you're willing to burn the house

[26:09]of fatima what are the tents of them i've already burnt before

[26:13]and those were meant to be more religious than me so what's

[26:17]the problem if i do this if those more religious than me

[26:20]were ready to do it he already knew that if ali and

[26:27]zubair and the rest of them think and that's why you'll find

[26:30]medieval scholars like him in tamiya when they say that there is

[26:33]if if an attack happened on the door of fatima then it's

[26:37]justified because you're breaking the fitna of the dissenters against the government

[26:41]yeah hold on who's behind the door if an attack happens who's

[26:45]behind the door you say to me that there's four ladies of

[26:48]paradise this is their hadith they say four ladies of paradise fatima

[26:53]and khadija and maryam and asiya you say to me fatam as

[26:58]a part of me whoever angers her angers me you have now

[27:02]reached the level and that's why every listener out there i don't

[27:04]care if you're she whatever you are you admit that there's a

[27:12]problem there's a war of words between umar you have to decide

[27:17]for yourself what your position is before you get to your grave

[27:20]because you're gonna have to face your lord and your prophet one

[27:26]day either saying i loved the one who was angered or i

[27:29]love the cause of the anger someone says yes but these texts

[27:34]how do they prove what do they prove they prove to us

[27:38]that um felt that it doesn't matter what needs to be done

[27:44]even if the house where revelation used to take place because we

[27:47]know jabra it came in that house how then in where was

[27:52]the house where the verse of purification took place jibra il came

[27:56]to that house omar did not mind even if i have to

[28:01]burn the house not kill you fatima burn the house well if

[28:03]you're going to burn the house that means anyone who's in that

[28:07]house even the two masters of paradise even there they can get

[28:11]burnt as well when they did that they kept on saying ali

[28:14]must pledge ali baba if you've become khalifa why does ali have

[28:19]to pledge to you why unless you're chosen by allah even if

[28:23]you're chosen by allah why should he pledge to you get on

[28:26]with your khilafah unless you know that you know what we need

[28:29]to get past this hurdle one way or the other that's why

[28:33]if you look at nowaway or even hajjar they always are trying

[28:37]to justify fatima versus abu bakr umar versus fatima they're trying to

[28:41]find a way to reconcile why because of that one hadith in

[28:46]bukhari that hadith in bukhari highlighted that when they wanted to finish

[28:52]imam ali and fatima zahra knowing how outspoken they were against sakaifa

[28:56]what was the way to do it confiscate their property confiscate which

[29:03]property confiscate the property known as fedex why confiscate fedex for what

[29:10]reason did they want to confiscate fedex on the one hand economically

[29:13]speaking you virtually kill any opportunity for them to rise economically the

[29:18]date palms of fedex fedex which is about 160 km from medina

[29:21]the date palms of fedex are to the date palms of kufa

[29:28]people used to swear by the departments of iraq isn't that true

[29:30]until today the land of iraq has the most beautiful palm trees

[29:34]on earth and the arabs used to swear by their palm trees

[29:39]and that land of fedex that was a piece of land that

[29:42]belonged to the jews of fetak when imam ali salam achieved victory

[29:48]in the battle of by defeating marhaba and his soldiers when you

[29:53]achieve victory in war in islamic law the booty can either be

[29:57]achieved through warfare or no warfare not either i've achieved victory by

[30:03]riding horses and i've fought with swords i bought shields i bought

[30:08]my camels if i achieve victory through warfare then there is a

[30:14]certain amount of hums distribution that has to take place quran says

[30:17]on surah 8 verse 41 of what i acquire has to be

[30:30]given towards god the prophet and then the rest could be shared

[30:35]amongst the soldiers that's if i fought in a battle when imam

[30:38]ali defeated the jews of khaibar the jews of fedex were their

[30:41]neighbors the jews of fedex said listen we ain't gonna get involved

[30:45]with abu torah nor his sword you can have our land the

[30:51]prophet said half of the land will still be yours and half

[30:54]will come to us if a piece of land in islam has

[31:01]been acquired without war it doesn't fall under the category of homs

[31:04]it falls under the category of fate okay faith is that piece

[31:08]of land which is acquired without any horses fighting cavalry and the

[31:14]word derivative of faith can be found in the quran you found

[31:26]here that this ayah mentions very clearly what that that which you

[31:31]acquire without fighting without horses without cavalry falls under the category of

[31:36]fae in islamic economics faye unlike homs can be distributed as the

[31:43]prophet wants to withholms them is the fifth towards a certain criteria

[31:49]of people with faith acquires that piece of land then the holy

[31:55]prophet can distribute it as he likes took place four years before

[32:00]he died remember this point fedex is not inheritance they made it

[32:05]a case of inheritance fedex possession indicates ownership if now i'm living

[32:13]in my house okay and you claim that it's yours is it

[32:16]me who has to bring witnesses or you have to bring witnesses

[32:19]i'm living in the house you say it's yours who has to

[32:23]bring the witnesses me or you possession indicates ownership unless you go

[32:28]and bring yours that property how did it come to her the

[32:31]prophet because he acquired that property what did the prophet say quran

[32:35]revealed the ayah according to narrators give your near ones the haqq

[32:41]he said in honor of khadijah and what she gave to islam

[32:47]from her wealth i'm going to give it to father this piece

[32:51]of land because her mother gave so much wealth to the religion

[32:56]the least we could do is give this to her when it

[32:57]was given to her it was given to her when seventh year

[33:02]after hijrah the prophet and what we're talking about right now is

[33:06]four years later therefore fedex on the first level for us it's

[33:12]not inheritance fedex is that which already belongs to fatima it belongs

[33:18]to her all of a sudden as soon as sakifa happens feather

[33:23]confiscated oh a fedex being confiscated it's not a surprise if i've

[33:29]got a man who wants to burn a house what's a piece

[33:31]of land as soon and what i'm going to narrate to you

[33:37]right now is purely bukhari i won't go anywhere else i'll narrate

[33:41]not because on me it's not but for the non-shia out there

[33:50]who are like huge guys just make up issues between abu bakr

[33:53]and fatah they all loved each other no i'm reading the chapter

[34:00]of the expeditions or the wars on the section of khaibar i

[34:05]read that fatham sent for someone to ensure that her fate was

[34:12]given to her and that when that person was sent to abu

[34:19]bakr this is exactly what's written in sahih al-bukhari you can all

[34:22]go and search it online and non-shia go and search it online

[34:27]and let your conscience speak to you she sent somebody to make

[34:31]sure that that which is hers the faye of fedex is with

[34:37]her abu bakr had confiscated it abu bakr said the prophet says

[34:41]that our property is not inherited the prophet peace be upon him

[34:46]his family says our property is not inherited rather what we leave

[34:49]behind the sadaqa and that is at the disposal of our family

[34:52]so abu bakr refused to give fedex of atama you're the sole

[35:01]narrator of this hadith which works wonderfully for him the prophets they

[35:07]say that the prophet does what the property is not inherited i

[35:11]ask all of you a question very basic question everybody listening to

[35:16]me wherever you are in islam a lady can inherit or no

[35:21]you all agree and you all have cases where your march passed

[35:26]away and there's a sister in the family and that is distributed

[35:30]why would there be a law for the prophet and a law

[35:34]for everybody else on this issue why his daughter no and my

[35:39]daughter yes does it make any sense that everybody's son or daughter

[35:47]inherits except rasulallah does that make any sense why not no because

[35:56]prophets we do not live behind property as inheritance yeah you know

[36:00]what you just leave your family just to rot on the earth

[36:03]you don't leave anything behind of that's what you acquired that's what

[36:08]islam became he said that the prophets do not leave behind property

[36:13]as inheritance okay rather what we leave behind the sadaqa and then

[36:18]maybe a disposal of so abu bakr refused to give fedex her

[36:25]reaction is fundamental why in one reaction she will highlight whether she

[36:29]believes the government of the time is legitimate or illegitimate do we

[36:35]agree fatima became angry with abu bakr that's all we need to

[36:40]know even if i finished my major list here that's enough because

[36:44]on the day of judgement her father is going to have to

[36:48]meet him and meet her and she's going to say i died

[36:49]angry with him father became angry with abu bakr kept away from

[36:56]him and did not talk to him until she died when she

[37:01]became angry with him if we just sidestep from bukhari for a

[37:06]moment when she became angry with him was it just a tantrum

[37:08]there's a lady emotional you know some people will say these things

[37:12]orientalists say fatham is always in a bad mood and emotional and

[37:17]so on when she became angry with him you're saying that prophets

[37:21]don't leave behind inheritance let's look at the quran because fatima is

[37:26]the walking quran because abu bakr versus fatima if you were to

[37:33]look at it from the sunni angle it's non-muslim versus non-mason for

[37:40]us it's non-muslim versus masuma you agree in sunny angle even if

[37:45]there's a war of words between they're both not muslim you have

[37:50]arguments for us no there's a difference between when a fallible speaks

[37:53]against an infallible a lady who was in the eye of kisa

[37:58]in namayor that for us is enough she has been purified where

[38:04]no impurities come near her she looked at him and she said

[38:08]to him that you say that prophets don't leave behind inheritance sulaiman

[38:16]inherited from darwood i thought prophets don't leave anything behind how about

[38:22]the ayah about yahya and zakaria ali yakub sorry in the story

[38:36]even you find others in the quran where they're saying provide for

[38:41]me an heir someone who inherits from me inherits from the family

[38:47]of jacob then she says another eye look what's she showing us

[38:51]don't respect me just as a daughter who you imagine is like

[38:54]this young girl i'm a quran walking on earth and my husband

[38:58]is greater than me she said have you not read the eye

[39:05]in the quran quran is the power of islam if the muslims

[39:20]have memorized it they're powerful if the muslims neglect it know that

[39:25]they're miles away it has been prescribed upon you that when death

[39:32]approaches you if there is a certain amount of property or wealth

[39:35]left you write a wasa to your near ones am i not

[39:40]the near one of muhammad am i not the nearest one all

[39:49]these ayahs of the quran so sulaiman can inherit david yahya can

[39:55]inherit zakaria the quran stole the whole of the muslim world that

[39:59]they could inherit from their fathers or have you taken us back

[40:06]to jaahiliyah because in jayalia the ladies could not inherit they were

[40:10]being inherited are we going back to jaahiliya now bukhari's hadith what

[40:15]does it say fatima was angry with abu bakr clay in the

[40:18]hadith she refused and then she stayed away and then after that

[40:26]what happened and then after that the narration mentioned she did not

[40:31]talk to him until she died bukhari continues interestingly who narrates this

[40:37]narration continues interestingly she remained alive for six months after the prophet

[40:44]died this is in bukhari when she died her husband imam salaam

[40:52]this is in bukhari buried her alone and did not inform abu

[41:02]bakr of the funeral how many things can you pick out just

[41:04]from those two lines in bukhari how many things firstly that this

[41:10]lady the daughter of the prophet dies months after her father secondly

[41:15]that imam ali al-islam does not want to inform abu bakr of

[41:20]what's taken place if imam ali felt abu bakr is this pious

[41:24]spiritual individual then why not inform invite him to a jainism i've

[41:30]seen people who are not the most religious in the world but

[41:31]you'll still tell them listen tomorrow we're doing my father's jannah may

[41:34]allah 10 30 at this cemetery please join us why fatima doesn't

[41:39]want them to be at the funeral isn't that enough that's when

[41:45]saying i don't want these to be at the funeral and bukhari

[41:49]himself admits imam ali did not inform abu bakr of the funeral

[41:55]of father what was it being mentioned here imam was making it

[42:00]very clear that for us this situation indicates our rejection of the

[42:06]government our rejection of these people if now imam ali has rejected

[42:10]them i ask in sunni thought a question imam wife and him

[42:16]have blatantly not pledged allegiance do they remain muslim or of course

[42:20]what's the argument that comes back later he pledged after she died

[42:26]he pledged six months later he pledged why why why would he

[42:29]wait to pledge if this man is the most pious man and

[42:32]the leader of the muslims why would he wait until he pledges

[42:35]what's interesting is when the hadith continues the hadith continues that imam

[42:39]ali says while fatima was alive people used to come towards me

[42:42]when she died they all left me very interesting in bukhari this

[42:48]is not outside so that someone says this isn't she literature in

[42:52]bukhari he says that while fatima was alive people would come towards

[42:56]me when fatima died they began to distance themselves more and more

[43:00]from me until imam ali says the hadith says he said call

[43:06]for abu bakr but let him come alone he didn't want umar

[43:10]to come why not why if you want to call fabul back

[43:17]because we believe that's when father died that period there was a

[43:21]sort of coming together of the caliphate with imam ali but in

[43:25]ali says only abu bakr comes to see me nobody else omar

[43:29]doesn't come isn't that enough of an indication that imam salam has

[43:34]a major problem with umar abner and a major problem with the

[43:37]actions of omar and interestingly later on omar does what he wants

[43:44]to do with fedex and later on even you find the umayyads

[43:48]themselves finding them with fedex at their disposal everybody minting fedex and

[44:03]even that they took away from us therefore when we come and

[44:09]see the conclusion of all of this what is it the conclusion

[44:11]of all of this is that became the nemesis for that government

[44:16]a clear nemesis she is the one who stood up against that

[44:20]government the one who blatantly wouldn't talk to them if they say

[44:27]salam she wouldn't reply to the salam and i'll tell you something

[44:29]that's amazing go and see the ulama of the sunni world in

[44:31]their explanation of this hadith in bukhari because this hadith i kept

[44:39]away from abu bakr i refuse to talk to him till i

[44:42]die i get buried without him being in the funeral how do

[44:44]we explain it the explanations are unbelievable i've seen some contradictions in

[44:50]my time in the explanation but explanations like you know abu bakr

[44:54]well he was right because she doesn't deserve inheritance but at the

[44:58]same time she's the daughter of rasulullah at the same time you

[45:01]got to understand that you know these things and it got a

[45:04]bit emotional but imam ali at the end was okay with everyone

[45:07]okay i'm not understanding what's going on here because this lady's ended

[45:11]up dying from all of this she's received death threats her house

[45:14]has been threatened to be burnt first issue that emerges from this

[45:18]in the muslim world today whenever you see us talk about these

[45:23]sensitive topics as i've done in the last few nights you'll always

[45:26]hear people saying imam ali wouldn't have wanted us to talk about

[45:29]these things tell you what his wife did you say he wouldn't

[45:37]have wanted the muslims to talk about these things his wife certainly

[45:42]caused the clamor she wouldn't stop even while injured she continued to

[45:51]speak out she would be the one going from house to house

[45:57]in medina going from house to house have you forgotten you've allowed

[46:04]these two the ones who go around forcing people to pledge and

[46:07]i haven't even finished with how they force people inshallah tomorrow we

[46:13]go towards one of their foot soldiers who if he wants to

[46:17]force somebody no he doesn't just force him maybe heads him you

[46:20]go towards these two and my imam my husband abel hassan all

[46:25]of you neglect him now i ask all of you those of

[46:29]you who say imam ali would not want us to talk about

[46:31]these topics talking about these topics talking about these topics but the

[46:40]second issue that emerges from this is what what's the second issue

[46:45]if we are able to burn the house of hussein while his

[46:52]mom's alive what stops us from killing hussein after his mom has

[46:57]died because you know what principle was set by the attack on

[47:00]fatima what was the principle the principle was that yazid could turn

[47:03]around and say hold on a minute you guys have a problem

[47:07]with me for threatening to kill babies at karbala we took her

[47:12]baby out and if you guys are telling me that i'm wrong

[47:16]for burning tents well masters before me who appointed my father they

[47:21]burned ten they burnt a house in medina what happened was that

[47:27]the precedent was set that if um are able to anger then

[47:34]don't be scared if you anger hussein that principle that had been

[47:39]said became a dangerous principle because a person could turn around and

[47:43]use that principle and that's why what surprises me on the third

[47:46]level is the shia who doubt this incident you know you meet

[47:52]shia in the muslim community and you'll see some of them saying

[47:59]yeah but you know what i don't really believe it's a non-shia

[48:02]books number one and non shia books they're saying omar is saying

[48:05]to her listen if these guys are going to continue to gather

[48:09]in the house we're going to burn the house you tell me

[48:11]if someone tells you i'm going to burn your house is it

[48:12]far-fetched to think that he may actually eventually do it that's number

[48:18]one number two what's the second issue they say well imam salah

[48:22]would never allow such a thing to happen you know how could

[48:25]he watch his wife being attacked you never said that about the

[48:30]prophet when somaya was being executed ammar's mom ammar's on earth go

[48:44]and defend her no some things are matters which the prophet takes

[48:47]into his own hands imam ali in our opinion stop those who

[48:53]came towards his house those who had said already that we're going

[48:56]to burn the house but he made it clear that the will

[48:59]of the prophet stops me from taking this bloodshed even further yes

[49:02]third they say well the arabs would never do that which arabs

[49:07]the sarifa arabs the reef and hawazin and others many of these

[49:14]already had a hate and a vengeance that they wanted to take

[49:16]out on the holy household number four when you see a man

[49:22]saying i'm gonna threaten to burn the house isn't that enough for

[49:24]you to realize that that person will actually go at what they

[49:28]do number five why a secret burial if you died naturally just

[49:31]have a public burial number six why do none of us know

[49:34]where she's buried simple reality if she died the natural death imam

[49:41]all of us know where why her in particular nobody knows why

[49:45]as a symbol against the oppression of that time just in case

[49:50]there are some of you who think that i was not oppressed

[49:53]show me where's my grave can any of us see her grave

[49:56]can any of us find her grave we search in bahrain wherever

[50:02]we walk and for all we know we may be walking on

[50:04]her grave one day imagine that feeling that all of us have

[50:08]that we don't know if we are on the grave of fatima

[50:12]or not so therefore she was the nemesis against that government and

[50:16]she and this is a vital point if imam al-hussein showed in

[50:23]his stand that yazid's government was illegitimate then his mom done exactly

[50:28]the same thing 50 years before him why is this he's government

[50:34]illegitimate because hussein bin ali stood up do you agree the fact

[50:38]that says the government that's enough if his mom does it 50

[50:41]years earlier what's the difference if his mom agrees with that government

[50:45]it's a legitimate government if his mom says no it's illegitimate and

[50:51]therefore you found am i surprised that hussain bin ali emerges the

[50:55]way he emerges no at the end of the day if you

[50:59]have a mother like fatama standing up against the oppression of her

[51:02]time then you'll do the same question how did the umayyads find

[51:08]her because she eventually dies becomes a martyr if we fast forward

[51:14]the years later how did the umayyads find fatima did they see

[51:17]her as glorious did the muslims all see her as glorious how

[51:22]did the kuffin see uh the umayyads reached the stage by the

[51:24]way where they were cursing fatima in their pulpits the abbasids is

[51:29]a different story and alkavi and with people are warned don't praise

[51:33]ali and for there are many haters of ali and fatima the

[51:38]umaids had christian poets who would curse father one may argue that

[51:44]zayd in his revolution stood up against these poets and stood up

[51:49]against the umayyads had those who hated fatima who disrespected fatima the

[51:54]kuffins had those who loved fatima and had those who may have

[52:00]not respected fatima but on the 10th of muharram what do you

[52:04]find you find that sometimes subhanallah you may not be ashi but

[52:08]if you have that love for al-muhammad a seed of that love

[52:14]for al-muhammad a seed of love for zahara it could come to

[52:17]help you one day in guidance towards allah subhana wa ta'ala someone

[52:22]says how you look on the tenth of muharram when's her name

[52:28]mentioned one of the times her name is mentioned is by her

[52:32]lovers that young man whose mother is there on the tenth of

[52:36]muharram and she is there and she sees all the other mothers

[52:40]have given sons and you see this young boy next to his

[52:42]mom and she is like it's your turn now you go out

[52:47]and make me proud he turned around to his mom he said

[52:50]watch me i'll make you proud he goes to abba abdullah and

[52:53]he says to him it's my turn is that a young man

[52:57]go and look after your mother go and protect your mother went

[53:00]back to his mom his mom said why have you come back

[53:02]said he said to me he doesn't want me to go out

[53:04]he said you have to protect you said no on the country

[53:06]you will make me proud today go out and tell them who

[53:11]you are his lines of poetry until today they cause us to

[53:19]cry to break down our heart becomes softened softer because of this

[53:24]young man's poetry amir hussain allah all of you know it all

[53:28]of you know these lines but i want you to focus in

[53:34]particular at his description when he gets to fataman okay my prince

[53:40]my master is hussein and this is all of us in this

[53:45]hall all of you watching at home can relate to these lines

[53:47]well i think all of us wish we could have said these

[53:51]nines is my prince and the most blessed prince the one who

[54:16]brought happiness to the one who guided and reminded ali and fatima

[54:21]are his parents have you found an equal to come near him

[54:25]allah young man but that he gave every shia on earth lives

[54:34]by it that we all wish we were in karbala tonight and

[54:36]if we were holding that man that young man highlighted his love

[54:57]for fathamatazhara then there was another one this other one believe you

[55:06]me this other one his love for fatima saved him all of

[55:13]us ya allah we love fatima but his love for fatima at

[55:19]which moment when he encounters imam al-hussein even at salah time he

[55:37]says abba abdullah you have to lead us even though he's the

[55:39]leader of the opposition he says you are here how can i

[55:43]lead salah so when does his love of fatima show he blocks

[55:48]imam al-hussein from going to kufa he says i will not let

[55:56]you go imam al-hussein says something to him is like when someone

[56:04]has literally attacked your mom may your mom have never given birth

[56:09]to you the reply of horubini highlights to all of you wallah

[56:16]if you have a love for allah you will be saved on

[56:20]the day of judgment and wallah if you show hate to fatima

[56:23]then on that day may allah save you he looked at her

[56:28]he said to him may your mother have never given birth to

[56:33]you what does her reply if you were the son of any

[56:37]other lady if you were the son of any other lady then

[56:44]i would attack you but your mother is fatima how can i

[56:50]say anything to you you can imagine i i've never seen this

[56:58]narrated in traditions i'm saying this from myself you can imagine because

[57:03]of the politeness of harambe he had that moment where anybody else

[57:08]had you attacked his mom he would have attacked your mom because

[57:11]par said i cannot your mom is father i believe maybe abba

[57:19]abdullah prayed and said guide him guide him because he has a

[57:26]respect for my mother and how close was imam hussain to his

[57:30]mother and that's why the morning of the 10th of muharram came

[57:38]and but one of the soldiers said i looked at her and

[57:46]you know people were counting that you know what if harmony is

[57:50]at the front no one loses war it doesn't matter who's in

[57:53]front of him he said i looked at her and when i

[57:57]looked at him i thought to myself that if they told me

[58:02]who's the bravest soldier in the whole of kufa i'd say but

[58:05]i look at him and he looks confused so i came towards

[58:10]myself what's wrong with you if they ask me who's the bravest

[58:13]of the warriors then i'd say it's what's wrong you seem confused

[58:24]and he mentioned what he mentioned the two things affected him at

[58:30]that moment what were they i give this to all of you

[58:36]now the first of them was that last night i heard the

[58:39]children of fatha calling out last night i heard that was the

[59:04]first one what was the second thing that affected him shimmer bundle

[59:08]joshua that day had said put water on the hooves of the

[59:14]horses the horses are feeling the heat of carabella get them some

[59:20]water you care about the horses how about the family of rasulullah

[59:24]at that moment he thought to himself i have to make a

[59:40]between heaven and hell at that moment he walked towards abba abdullah

[59:49]with his head about down knowing that he had blocked the water

[59:56]from the children when he got to imam hussain he came out

[60:01]to him because he thought maybe an attack could come imam and

[60:05]they said no no wait abbas maybe he has something to say

[60:08]to us remember a few days earlier he had known very well

[60:12]that this horror had already said to him i respect your mother

[60:17]father so he knew there was the seeds of change so he

[60:20]came to him with his head bowed down when he came to

[60:24]him and his head was bowed down what did he say to

[60:28]him he said to him abba abdullah forgive me forgive me for

[60:33]blocking allow me to come back imam hussain look at the softness

[60:36]of his heart he said to him don't worry i forgive you

[60:41]the next thing that said why because it's as if he knew

[60:51]what would happen to say that maybe because of his decision he

[60:55]walked [Music] [Applause] of course we forgive you do not worry he

[61:10]turned around his son was with him he went towards imam al-hussein

[61:15]he said to him considering i'm the one who blocked you then

[61:19]i should be the first to be demarted alongside you allow me

[61:24]to be the first imam hussain said no no leave it he

[61:29]said no i will be the first let me go about abdullah

[61:33]imagine him walking towards the battlefield until he fell on the ground

[62:01]and he called out baby for the first time in his [Applause]

[62:18]imam looked at him he forgot that the man blocked the water

[62:24]from his children he forgot that the man could be the reason

[62:31]for his death look at the humbleness i'll leave you all with

[63:03]this line now i don't know if my grandmother fatam is in

[63:04]the crowd with us tonight she maybe be careful if you move

[63:12]your hand you might touch a broken rib she may be next

[63:14]to you it could be next to any one of you i

[63:16]don't know if she's here in the crowd she might be she

[63:20]might not be here but one thing i want to speak to

[63:24]her is her grandson i want to say one thing to her

[63:28]when you lost your ribbon medina did you expect more ribs to

[63:34]break in kermit when you lost your ribbon medina did you expect

[63:40]more ribs to break in kerbala behind the door did you expect

[63:57]to see that already on the floor when you were slapped behind

[64:04]that door did you expect to see zainab slept on the floor

[64:11]when you were slapped behind that door did you expect to see

[64:17]zayn of honor the floor one more thing i want to ask

[64:22]you grandmother when you saw the fires around the house did you

[64:31]see the running from the fires around her in caramela all of

[64:39]you are wherever you may be the loudest of yours [Music] [Music]

[66:18][Music] [Music] foreign

0 تعليقات

التالي

Night 4 - Abu Bakr and Umar anger Fatima (as) - Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshawani

Transcript

التالي

استكشاف المزيد

يرجى ملاحظة أنه إذا كان عمرك أقل من 18 عامًا ، فلن تتمكن من الوصول إلى هذا الموقع.

التالي

Night 4 - Abu Bakr and Umar anger Fatima (as) - Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshawani

Transcript

التالي

استكشاف المزيد

اختيار طريقة الدفع

لغة