Can God Place the World in a Small Egg? - Sayed Saleh Qazwini

0 Views· 22/02/05

MECCA Media
Subscribers

In Lectures

Transcript

[0:00]there was a man during the time of imam sadiq by the

[0:04]name of abu shakira desani this man at desani he was one

[0:10]of the zanadika he was one of the atheists of the time

[0:14]and he goes to one of the students of imam sadaq by

[0:17]the name of hisham ibn al-haqam he goes to hashem and he

[0:23]tells him o hashem you believe in god hashem tells him yes

[0:28]i believe in god he tells him do you believe that your

[0:30]lord is powerful he's capable of doing anything he says yes i

[0:36]believe my lord is capable my lord can do anything he tells

[0:39]him can your lord take this dunya this dunya that we have

[0:45]take it and place it in an egg without making the egg

[0:52]bigger and without making the dunya smaller now of course this is

[0:57]something that's impossible this goes against the laws of creation this goes

[1:01]against the laws of reason allah created this world and he created

[1:06]laws a white wall cannot be black wall at the same time

[1:09]there is there are different things that are binaries things that are

[1:12]different from one another and there are laws of existence but this

[1:19]man he didn't have an answer even though hashem al-haqam was a

[1:22]mutman he was a believer and he was one of the mutha

[1:24]kelly he was one of those people who were very strong in

[1:29]the science of theology and debates with other people but he tells

[1:36]him i don't have an answer for you but i will go

[1:39]and i will bring you an answer abu shakur desani he tells

[1:44]him go and come back in a year i'm going to give

[1:46]you a whole year he's ridiculing him he's mocking him he tells

[1:50]him go and come back in a year then we'll see if

[1:54]you have an answer right away he gets up and he goes

[1:58]to imam he goes to the imam and he tells him oh

[2:01]my dear master there's a zindiak there's a an atheist out there

[2:06]who came and he told me this how can you place this

[2:10]whole dunya in an egg without making the egg bigger and without

[2:13]making the dunya smaller so the imam salaam he tells him oh

[2:16]hashem how many senses do you have how many senses do you

[2:22]have he tells him i have five senses he tells him what

[2:27]is your smallest of the senses he says the smallest is my

[2:31]eyes the smallest of the senses it's my eyes it's a small

[2:34]eyeball with the pupils that are very small the imam tells him

[2:38]o hashem what do you see with your eyes he tells him

[2:42]i see the mountains i see the deserts i see the sun

[2:48]i see the valleys i see the rivers i see all of

[2:52]this in front of me the imam tells him o hasham the

[2:57]one who is capable of placing this whole dunya and these small

[3:02]eyes is also capable of placing the dunya in an egg however

[3:07]allah has laws allah has laws of creation hashem al-haqam he took

[3:14]the answer from the imam and right away he goes desani he

[3:16]goes to desani and he tells him i have brought you the

[3:21]answer and he tells him what the imam alaihissalam says and that

[3:26]desani is shocked this is the first time he's seen someone who

[3:30]is able to answer his misconception in a very beautiful way in

[3:35]a very beautiful way very precise way he's able to answer him

[3:41]so at desani he gets up and he says i'm going to

[3:43]go and see imam he doesn't believe in him but he says

[3:46]i'm going to go and see this man imam assad so he

[3:54]goes and he sees imam sadaqa salaam and of course he still

[3:58]wants to debate the imam but the imam alayhi salaam is very

[4:01]respectful the imam is following the verse in the quran the imam

[4:13]is not resorting to intolerance and violence the imam says let's see

[4:17]what this man has to say because perhaps there's a chance that

[4:22]this person is going to be guided i'm not going to shut

[4:24]the door in front of this person's face perhaps there's a chance

[4:29]he's going to be guided so he tells him he tells him

[4:35]he tells him he tells him what's the dalil what's the proof

[4:42]that you have been created that you have someone a power that

[4:48]has created you so the imam alaihissalam he tells him i see

[4:54]myself in two scenarios either i am the creator or i am

[5:01]the created either i am the khalak i am the or i

[5:05]have been created if we go to the first scenario if i

[5:12]am the creator either i created something from things that were already

[5:16]there something that already existed i created something which already existed then

[5:21]i am not the real creator whoever created it first is the

[5:27]original creator if i created something that already existed that doesn't mean

[5:32]that i'm the creator someone else came before me and created or

[5:36]i created something out of nothing and you know that you can't

[5:42]create anything out of nothing so therefore we go to the third

[5:47]option and that is i have been created and there has been

[5:53]a creator that has created me

0 Comments

Up next

Can God Place the World in a Small Egg? - Sayed Saleh Qazwini

Transcript

Up next

Explore more

Please note that if you are under 18, you won't be able to access this site.

Up next

Can God Place the World in a Small Egg? - Sayed Saleh Qazwini

Transcript

Up next

Explore more

Choose a payment method

Language