17. Khalid Ibn Waleed Or Imam Ali: Sword Of Allah? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

11 Views· 26/03/07

Sayed Ammar Nakshawani Official
Subscribers

In Lectures

Truth. Dialogue. Courage. After two compelling and impactful seasons, The Divide & Dialogue returns for Season 3—at a moment when silence is no longer an option, but a risk. As sectarian narratives intensify and misinformation deepens divides, this series fearlessly challenges accusations, unpacks misunderstandings, and confronts the uncomfortable truths shaping today’s Muslim world. This Holy Month of Ramadan, join Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshawani on Imam Hussein TV 3 for bold conversations, sharp historical insight, and a dialogue that refuses to be silenced. ——————————— Subscribe to Sayed Ammar’s official online platform, consisting of bespoke courses, exclusive content, brand new podcasts & more! https://www.sayedammar.com

Transcript

[0:00]amlaykum.

[0:02]We are in the blessed holy month of Ramadan and there's no

[0:05]better time than now to give to the needy in Iraq.

[0:08]Imam Hussein charities is giving you the chance to provide food baskets

[0:12]for destitute and impoverished families.

[0:13]Each basket contains enough food to feed a family of four.

[0:22]We're one of the areas where we distribute food baskets.

[0:25]Going to go drop off this food basket to one of the

[0:28]Haj who's registered with Imam Hussein charity.

[0:40]These orphans need your help and require your assistance.

[0:45]Don't let any of these orphans go hungry this Ramadan.

[0:50]Please donate.

[0:52]Your donation can provide a source of nourishment for those who do

[0:58]not have access to food.

[1:09]Hey, away.

[1:33]In the name of God, the most beneficent, the most merciful.

[1:37]All praise is due to Allah, master of all the worlds.

[1:41]And peace and blessings be on all his prophets and especially the

[1:46]final prophet, the prophet Muhammad, my respected brothers and sisters.

[1:54]Im who is truly the sword of Allah.

[2:01]As we know occupies one of the most important positions in Sunni

[2:07]Islam and it's quite the contrary in Shia Islam in Shia Islam

[2:10]there isn't that respect that is afforded to Khalid as there is

[2:16]in Sunni Islam and in reality if you want to see a

[2:18]clear difference between the two sects of Islam look at somebody like

[2:26]W in the Sunni world admired adored in the Shia world not

[2:31]respected and in some cases detested.

[2:32]Now it shows you how when we look back at 1,400 years

[2:38]of Islamic history, we may have different opinions on a number of

[2:41]areas.

[2:42]But why do we reach such conclusions?

[2:43]As in why is it that the Shia rever someone like Salman

[2:46]or someone like Abdah or someone liked but not choose to revere

[2:56]someone like or someone like don't forget and both convert to Islam

[3:01]at around the same time.

[3:02]Now, Khadin Wal is more known for his exploits after the prophet

[3:08]peace be upon him's family died than he is known for during

[3:11]the life of the holy prophet peace be upon him and his

[3:15]family.

[3:16]But he still has a very interesting biography and it led many

[3:19]in the Sunni world that when you talk about bravery while there

[3:22]is that reverence of course that exists for a number of Sahabah

[3:27]but the first man that comes to mind is the sword of

[3:28]Allah.

[3:30]Many times you'll hear That is without a doubt the title that

[3:34]is always associated with and that title is one which in Sunni

[3:40]Islam is conferred upon him by the holy prophet peace be upon

[3:45]him and his family.

[3:45]But wal at the same time as being a brave warrior and

[3:51]we all will see his journey from shik towards Islam but at

[3:55]the same time can be quite a reckless warrior can also have

[4:01]certain issues with his decision-m now someone might turn around and say

[4:04]well at the end of the day is not mas he's not

[4:06]infallible for us to say that he has to be perfect at

[4:10]all times.

[4:12]It's one thing not being infallible.

[4:14]It's another when you can recklessly kill another Muslim who disagrees with

[4:20]you or recklessly make decisions on behalf of the religion of Islam

[4:25]that are quite destructive or have a dua read against you by

[4:30]the holy prophet peace be upon him and his family because it's

[4:33]very interesting that when you look at Im Ali and you look

[4:40]at Im Ali Alisam there is not a single battle Was a

[4:43]mushik that he managed to defeat Imam at the very least oneonone.

[4:53]We know that at the minimum let's say that he converted to

[4:57]the religion of Islam.

[4:59]I'm going to give him the ultimate benefit of the doubt about

[5:01]how the books have been written and how history has reached us.

[5:04]Let's say that converts with the religion of Islam after the battle

[5:10]of I'm not going to go to a conclusion that he converts

[5:12]with no I'm going to give him a nice piece of history

[5:18]that they convert after the battle of that means that the same

[5:23]who of course is the famous son and the last of the

[5:25]sons of by the way the most vicious enemy of the most

[5:34]arrogant man in Arabia alongside Abu Sufyan and of course's tribal friend

[5:41]Abu Jahal was one of the main soldiers for the Mushri community.

[5:46]If you were to look at the list of the soldiers of

[5:50]the mushiks, you'll always see that the main soldiers were who the

[5:53]main soldiers were always the likes of at the battle of bad

[6:02]wed faced Imam and was not able to overcome imam.

[6:05]Most famously wed is known for his exploits at the battle of

[6:12]all of you know the story that at the battle of we

[6:14]have all read very clearly my dear brothers and sisters that in

[6:19]that battle the holy prophet peace be upon his family was on

[6:22]the mountain of and the rest of the sahaba were fighting in

[6:26]the middle of the battle.

[6:26]The holy prophet peace be upon him's family had said to the

[6:29]sahaba he had said to them that whatever happens make sure that

[6:35]you guys do not leave this mountain because you see that we're

[6:38]winning cuz what would be in the mind of the sahaba if

[6:41]we're winning and we're just stuck on a mountain here we're not

[6:43]going to get the spoils and the booty of the war so

[6:46]we've got to le it and the prophet said whatever you do

[6:49]don't leave this mountain I don't want to see any of you

[6:51]leaving this mountain and so what happened was the moment some of

[6:59]Sahaba saw that Hamza had been killed.

[7:01]The holy prophet peace be upon him's family had a lookalike with

[7:04]Abbar and he got killed.

[7:06]Some of these Sahaba left the mountain and when they left the

[7:11]mountain came from around the mountain to attack the holy prophet peace

[7:14]be upon him and his family.

[7:14]Was he able to kill the holy prophet peace be upon his

[7:20]family?

[7:17]There's no way Khalid could kill.

[7:21]In Sunni literature, you'll always find this tradition that's there that the

[7:26]prophet was injured in the battle of and you'll hear that amongst

[7:33]the main people who injured him was for us of course the

[7:38]sh we don't believe in this idea that the holy prophet peace

[7:40]be upon his family had his broken teeth on that day and

[7:43]so on and so forth.

[7:46]But in Sunni literature, you have a man who they say attacked

[7:48]and sought to injure the holy prophet peace be upon his family.

[7:51]For me as a sh I know that Allah guides the worst

[7:55]of the worst.

[7:58]But I'm hardpressed to find Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala guide somebody who

[8:05]has struck a struck a member of the Ballam.

[8:15]I have not found anybody who has with his sword struck a

[8:19]member of the Bam or has been such a fervent enemy and

[8:23]somehow Allah subhanana wa ta'ala made him move from attacking Allah or

[8:28]attacking Fat Zah or attacking Im Ali or attacking Im Hassan or

[8:34]attacking Im Hussein and then come towards religiosity.

[8:37]Someone might say to me, well, how about say Yazidi was the

[8:44]commander of the opposition against Im never ever raised his sword against

[8:49]Imam Hussein.

[8:50]He never struck Im Hussein.

[8:52]In Sunni Islam, you could eat the liver of the uncle of

[8:58]the prophet and you can still be guided.

[9:00]You can eat from someone's skull and you can still be guided.

[9:04]You can attack and you can still be guided for us as

[9:08]while there is no limit to Allah's haya somebody who has that

[9:14]venom against it is very rare for that person to have a

[9:16]180 there's no way if anything they have a 360 where they

[9:20]just come back to the same circle of the same type of

[9:22]leaning over and over again at Bedrid couldn't defeat Im Ali Imam

[9:31]killed his tribesmen from Ben ated could not defeat Imam.

[9:36]Famously on the day of we hear the cry.

[9:41]There is no youth but Ali and there is no sword but

[9:45]at the minimum IM Ali killed 22 of the opposition at Im

[9:52]Ali was only 24 couldn't defeat him at we see that Im

[9:58]Ali was of the few that remained and didn't run away from

[10:03]the battle of Khalid could have easily finished Im Ali or the

[10:05]prophet peace be upon him because there was only a handful of

[10:09]people left on that mountain couldn't overcome Im Ali Alam at Khalid

[10:13]was still a mushri and he still couldn't overcome Im Ali.

[10:18]You all know who was the bravest warrior on the day of

[10:23]if is the bravest and the sword of Allah and no one

[10:28]is like him.

[10:30]I WANT TO ASK ONE QUESTION.

[10:31]If I im Ali has given us all victories at Badr and

[10:36]at Kandak and where what comes after Kandak which battle the battle

[10:43]of look in with me over here at Sah Muslim.

[10:44]Everybody please look Sah Muslim over here.

[10:47]Volume number five of Sah Muslim.

[10:49]Hadith number 4519 to 5645.

[10:53]All of you could see over there.

[10:59]Hadith edited and referenced by Abu Zuber Ali, translated by final review

[11:04]by Abu Khalil.

[11:08]First edition, August 2007, supervised by Abd Malik Mujah.

[11:10]All of you can see over here publishers.

[11:13]Look at the battle of Khalid Wal could easily be as the

[11:20]mushri of Mecca had joined the Jews of Medina to fight in

[11:23]the battle of on that day could easily if he is the

[11:26]greatest warrior in Islamic history should be able to overcome he has

[11:32]the Jewish support and he has the mushri support if you come

[11:34]with me over here my dear brothers and sisters you'll see that

[11:38]on that day at when you look at this hadith what do

[11:44]we see we see that and his companions were in a very

[11:49]very precarious situation on the day of why the Jews were strong

[11:53]the mushiks were aiding them.

[11:54]Therefore, they were a strong strong force.

[11:57]But again, we see one man comes to the four who nobody

[12:00]else is able to come near him.

[12:04]If you will look over here and you'll see what the hadith

[12:06]says.

[12:07]Come with me over here.

[12:08]Page number 130, the book of jihad and expeditions.

[12:11]The messenger of Allah said, who is this?

[12:14]He said, I am.

[12:16]He said, may your Lord forgive you.

[12:17]Whenever the messenger of Allah prayed for forgiveness for a certain person,

[12:22]he would be martyed.

[12:22]who was riding a camel of his called out, "Oh prophet of

[12:27]Allah, would that you had let us benefit from when we reached

[12:30]their king came out." Who came out of Marab came out brandishing

[12:42]his sword and saying knows that I am what?

[12:43]That I am All of us know the famous lines of as

[12:58]can be seen here knows that I am a fully armed warrior,

[13:06]a tried and tested hero.

[13:08]When war comes, spreading its flames.

[13:11]Okay.

[13:12]When Marhab came forward, of course, he exchanged blows.

[13:14]The sword of Mhab struck the shield of my uncle Amar.

[13:18]And went to attack from below, but his sword recoiled and struck

[13:20]the artery in his forearm and that led to his death.

[13:25]Then the holy prophet, look at the next page.

[13:28]The holy prophet sallallah.aii said to me, then he sent me to

[13:38]Ali who had sore eyes and he said, I will give the

[13:40]banner to a man who loves Allah and his messenger, who is

[13:44]loved by Allah and his messenger.

[13:46]I brought Ali leading him because he had sore eyes.

[13:51]He had an eye infection.

[13:55]Yes, I im Ali on the day of I brought him to

[13:55]the messenger of Allah.

[13:57]This is in Sah Muslim.

[13:58]I brought him to the messenger of Allah who put spit in

[14:03]his eyes and they were healed.

[14:04]Then he gave him the banner.

[14:06]Marab came out as we all know and he said his lines.

[14:13]Then Im Ali said his lines.

[14:13]All of you can see over here.

[14:23]Look over here.

[14:24]I am the one whose mother called him.

[14:27]Where is this?

[14:29]No, this is in Muslim.

[14:33]I am the one whose mother called him Haidar.

[14:34]Like a lion in the forest with a fearsome countenance.

[14:39]I returned their attack with one more fierce.

[14:42]He struck the head of Marab and killed him.

[14:47]Then victory came at his hands.

[14:51]Now Ali Ali two points emerge over here.

[14:57]If is this glorious soldier which I don't doubt that is a

[15:02]powerful soldier.

[15:03]There is no doubt about that.

[15:05]But to say that he's the foremost soldier.

[15:09]There's nowhere you will find that the foremost soldier in early Islam

[15:16]is Imam.

[15:16]That is number one.

[15:19]Number two, Im Alibab never in his life will you ever find

[15:24]that he was reckless on the battlefield or that he oppressed on

[15:30]the battlefield or that he hurt on the battlefield.

[15:33]Im notice what the prophet said.

[15:34]The man who's going out, Allah and me love him and he

[15:37]loves me and Allah.

[15:39]That is the best description you can ever have.

[15:41]Why?

[15:40]Because it means Allah subhana wa ta'ala is fully pleased with every

[15:46]action.

[15:44]Number three, never would mark my line over here.

[15:49]Never would make a dua that I dissociate from Ali's behavior at

[15:53]better.

[15:54]I dissociate from Ali at I don't like what Ali has done.

[15:59]Some of you may be wondering what why would he read a

[16:00]because we're going to come to the dua that read against number

[16:10]four if converts the same time as both of them mashallah join

[16:21]the religion of Islam great baraka for the religion and joined at

[16:26]the same time the religion of Islam Let's play clip number one.

[16:30]Shehikh Omar Sleman explaining to us that these two joined the religion

[16:35]of Islam a few years before the prophet died.

[16:37]Please play clip number one.

[16:41]He said, "Subhan Allah, I found remember the woman that wanted to

[16:49]drink out of the the skull of that's her son.

[16:50]And I bumped into and I'm not afraid of anybody.

[16:56]I told him exactly what I was going to do.

[16:58]And he responded and he said, "You know what?

[17:01]I'm going to do the same thing.

[17:02]I'm actually on my way to Medina to embrace Islam." So Khaled

[17:06]says, so I said, "Alhamdulillah, I got I've got a companion now."

[17:11]So said, you know, we we made our way to Al Medina

[17:13]and he said, "Once we got to the outskirts of Mecca," he

[17:18]said, "we bump into" and says, "Welcome to the to to my

[17:24]brothers.

[17:25]Welcome to these people." They said, "And you as well?" He said,

[17:31]"Where are you all going?" And they said, "We're going.

[17:34]We're going because we want to meet the messenger of Allah sallallahu

[17:39]alaihi wasallam." Says, "You know what?

[17:42]I'm going to do the same thing." Now, therefore, joined Islam with

[17:50]a few years left.

[17:50]Who does that remind you of?

[17:54]Who else?

[17:55]Who else?

[17:57]Abu.

[17:58]Are you all with me?

[17:59]I al was born into Islam.

[18:05]At the very least, if I go with the Sunni narration, he

[18:08]converts to Islam as a child.

[18:13]Okay, we agree.

[18:11]The first young Muslim.

[18:17]Okay.

[18:14]Joins Islam with a couple of years left.

[18:18]I'm going to say three and a half years left of the

[18:21]religion.

[18:21]Is that fair of me to say?

[18:23]How do you raise someone as the sword of Allah?

[18:27]Someone says, "Where does it say he's the sword of Allah?" I'll

[18:32]come to it in a second.

[18:33]But I ask, a man who's been fighting for the cause of

[18:38]Islam from Mecca.

[18:38]Some people think fighting is only on the battlefield.

[18:41]Sometimes in Mecca that was a proper war because there's 100 Muslims

[18:45]against all these Quraysh in early Islam.

[18:47]100 Muslims against all these Quraysh.

[18:49]The of Abu Talib threeear sanctions.

[18:52]There was no to help the Muslims.

[18:54]There was no there was no none of these people were around

[19:00]in those early days of Islam.

[19:01]None of them helped the religion.

[19:02]They were fighting the religion.

[19:03]Even in Sunni literature, you'll always hear that when the prophet asks

[19:07]Khalid, "What took you so long to convert?" Imagine Allah with all

[19:17]his and with all his miracles, all his all his words, it

[19:21]takes you 20 years to accept him as a prophet.

[19:25]Just think about this mama.

[19:29]Think about it for a moment.

[19:30]You yourself in your theology say the higher than the and the

[19:34]higher than and of course to squeeze and in they said they

[19:41]made the cut off line of being a muhaj.

[19:46]They were the last couple to become wallah when when become government

[19:50]you could do anything with hadith.

[19:52]Yeah.

[19:53]Now these guys takes them 20 years to join the religion.

[19:59]Abu Darfi Mdad Salman all these others nice Sahabah but never described

[20:07]the swords of Allah even though witnessed all these battles never you'll

[20:12]hear he's the sword of Allah why because he has a leaning

[20:17]to Ali if you have a leaning to Ali you are demoted

[20:20]if you have a leaning to the government you're promoted when a

[20:28]person has taken 20 years to become a Muslim.

[20:32]He faced aliat nothing couldn't finish it off couldn't finish it off

[20:40]couldn't finish it off.

[20:40]Eventually we hear the story that he went towards Medina.

[20:44]He said now it's time for me to convert.

[20:46]Why now?

[20:45]Why?

[20:47]We've been in Medina now for well over seven years.

[20:50]What was left for you to realize?

[20:52]Someone says Allah guides who he wants to guide.

[20:55]You are not to question.

[20:56]Okay, no problem.

[20:58]I won't question.

[20:57]But I'm baffled how it takes someone 20 years to realize this

[21:02]man's a prophet of God and I don't trust Beni Makum.

[21:04]I have my major problems with Beni Makum and Muira and his

[21:09]children.

[21:08]Although and then they Allah can guide whoever he wants.

[21:12]Now where does he attain the title the sword of Allah?

[21:14]Come with me over here.

[21:18]You'll see alkari as you can all see volume 5 a hadith

[21:20]3849 to 4473 translated by Dr.

[21:24]Muhammad Minhan which edition print in July 1997 printing supervised by Abd

[21:32]Malik Mujah come with me over here the virtues of the companions

[21:36]of su what's interesting is you will always find a section on

[21:42]and abu okay where you'll have the same number of merits as

[21:48]been with Islam from day one his neck for Islam his arm

[21:54]for Islam and joins at the end.

[21:56]But has merits has merits as if they've both been Muslims since

[22:00]day.

[22:01]True.

[22:02]Now come with me over here.

[22:03]Chapter 25, the merits of 3757 narrated.

[22:08]The prophet announced about the death of Zaff and Abdah to the

[22:13]people before the news of their death reached them.

[22:17]The battle of M was in reality his first major battle.

[22:20]the leader in the battle of M.

[22:23]Mut was the battle in the eighth year after Hijra after the

[22:29]battle of the battle of M against the Romans.

[22:35]You had was led by Zab he was killed Im Ali's brother

[22:38]his arms were chopped off and then you had Abdah when they

[22:43]all got killed.

[22:44]You hear the story and you have to with retrospect make sure

[22:49]you protect that strategically managed to take the Muslims back in a

[22:54]moment of a predicament.

[22:54]That could be worded it another way.

[22:57]It depends whether your Shia or how you word take the Muslims

[22:59]back.

[23:00]Anyway, so here what do we have?

[23:02]Look what it says.

[23:04]He said with his eyes overflowing with tears they took the flag

[23:06]and was martyed.

[23:08]Then Jaffar took the flag and was martyed.

[23:11]And then Ibin Raah took the flag and was martyed.

[23:12]Finally, the flag was taken by a sword from Allah's swords.

[23:19]One second.

[23:19]Finally, the flag was taken by a sword from Allah's swords.

[23:24]Is not a sword from Allah's swords.

[23:28]It is not a sword from receives the title say Allah.

[23:35]Look over here.

[23:34]What does it say?

[23:48]Finally, the flag was taken by a sword from Allah's swords.

[23:52]How do we know he's a sword from Allah's swords?

[23:57]He was mushik at kak.

[23:57]He's mushri at he is mushik at bad.

[24:00]He's mushik.

[24:02]His cv is all shik and fighting the prophet in his first

[24:05]battle in Islam.

[24:07]He is a sword from Allah's swords.

[24:09]Now some might say but this is Allah predicting the future that

[24:14]is saying this man who's bought us victory he is a sword

[24:18]from Allah's in one way he is if he's got a sword

[24:21]in his hand he's a sword from Allah's swords correct but all

[24:23]of a sudden there is a glorious 20 years someone's been an

[24:29]enemy of your mosque all of a sudden in his first day

[24:30]you've given him presidentship of the mosque okay 20 years he's been

[24:36]fighting you on the first day all of a sudden he's promot

[24:39]promoted as if Islam had no warrior wed came in.

[24:43]Now comes into the relig of Islam as I said a couple

[24:47]of years before the prophet dies I said earlier I'm giving him

[24:49]benefit of the doubt that he came in three and a half

[24:51]years before su died would you all agree with me that if

[24:58]you've killed his dad or his uncles at battle he's going to

[25:02]have severe issues with you true so imagine you you become a

[25:04]Muslim but that guy he stabbed my dad that one stabbed my

[25:09]uncle that one stabbed my cousin and believe you me the sahaba

[25:12]still had tension s even when they became Muslim with people who

[25:18]had killed their dads earlier.

[25:19]Someone says, "Nah, bro.

[25:19]When you convert, you forgive everyone.

[25:21]You don't forgive someone who stabbed up your dad.

[25:25]Let's be real.

[25:24]Let's be real." And what happens is that one of the people

[25:30]he clearly has a hate for, there's no doubt, is I imam.

[25:33]Remember, these are two people who've been at war with each other.

[25:38]One of them Allah and his messenger love him and he loves

[25:41]Allah and his messenger.

[25:44]One of them he is known as the bravest and the most

[25:47]knowledgeable and and another one has just joined the religion.

[25:51]Now do they have issues with each other or they don't have

[25:54]issues with each other?

[25:56]This is interesting.

[25:55]If we look at Sah Bkari 4349, come with me over here

[26:00]my dear brothers and sisters.

[26:02]Sah Bkari Arabic English volume 5 of Sah Bkari.

[26:06]Okay.

[26:07]go to hadith 4,349, we'll see that there's tension already has joined

[26:14]Islam.

[26:14]But if there's one person he has an issue with, and that's

[26:16]Imam because there is a context behind this incident that I'm about

[26:27]to narrate.

[26:29]Look over here, the sending of and to Yemen before.

[26:32]Now look over here.

[26:35]It has been narrated as you could all see by Allah's messenger

[26:39]sent us to Yemen along with later on he sent in his

[26:47]place.

[26:46]The prophet said to Ali give Khalid's companions the choice of either

[26:51]staying with you in Yemen or returning to Medina.

[26:54]Okay.

[26:54]Khaled was in Yemen.

[26:58]The prophet sent Imam Ali said replace Khalid Khalid.

[27:00]Clearly there is something that he's done.

[27:03]There's something that's caused tension where the prophets like you know that

[27:08]sword of Allah go replace him.

[27:12]What's the issue?

[27:15]One of the worst moments of you'll ever come across my dear

[27:19]brothers and sisters.

[27:20]Okay, please everybody play clip number two is that the prophet sent

[27:32]to and when he went there was quick.

[27:39]He invited them to Islam.

[27:40]They didn't say they said which means we changed their religion which

[27:46]can mean that they apostated or that they became Muslim.

[27:48]They had their weapons.

[27:50]He said, "Why do you have your weapons?" They said, "This is

[27:53]for the other Arab tribes." He ordered them to put them down.

[27:55]They refused to put them down.

[27:56]Why?

[27:56]Because one of the things that plays into this in a very

[28:00]unique way is that had a previous rivalry with that tribe in

[28:04]particular.

[28:04]Remember, he used to duel with everybody, right?

[28:08]Also what complicates is that this was the tribe that killed an

[28:12]uncle of and they killed the father of right which becomes relevant

[28:20]in the story.

[28:20]So in any case was quick to attack that tribe not realizing

[28:26]that indeed some of them had become Muslim right or all of

[28:30]them part of them or some of them had become Muslim.

[28:31]And when this came back to the prophet sallallaihi wasallam abdom came

[28:36]to the prophet sallall alaihi wasallam and he complained to the prophet

[28:39]sallallaihi wasallam about what khalid had done because this is a huge

[28:42]mistake in the early days of Islam in the early days of

[28:46]his being Muslim.

[28:47]The prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam looked towards the he said oh Allah

[28:55]I disavow myself of what has done.

[28:57]This is not what I taught him.

[29:01]Oh Allah, I disavow myself of what Khalid has done.

[29:03]So it's a significant mistake and the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam sends

[29:08]to make up for to compensate in whatever ways that he possibly

[29:16]can for the mistake that made.

[29:18]And some of the say this is not a part of history

[29:21]you should rush over.

[29:27]as I said reckless and it's a recklessness that later on Omar

[29:33]comes back to really haunt him with because clearly as we'll see

[29:41]over here and as she Omar has just described Bkari volume 9

[29:45]hadith 6561 to 7563 come with me over here chapter 35 chapter

[29:52]if a judge passes an unjust judgment or a judgment which differs

[29:56]from that of the learned religious men.

[29:59]Such a judgment is to be rejected.

[30:01]Okay.

[30:02]Now, Ib Omar narrates, "The prophet sent an army unit under the

[30:06]command of Wid to fight against the tribe of Benu Beni." Okay,

[30:14]all of you can see over here.

[30:15]They had to go there and fight against Benjima.

[30:19]And those people could not express themselves by saying Islam.

[30:22]So you've gone up to a group of people and you're wondering

[30:27]are they Muslim or not?

[30:28]If they're not Muslim, I'm going to butcher them.

[30:33]About 10 years ago, I said that when ISIS butchers or when

[30:38]ISIS beheads or when ISIS cooks people, cooks food on people's heads

[30:42]or when ISIS burdens or when ISIS um rapes and when ISIS

[30:47]does everything.

[30:46]I said you can go back to early Islamic history and find

[30:51]that there's examples and there was a backlash.

[30:52]How could you say that this is sectarian and so on and

[30:56]so on.

[30:57]What ISIS does is not out of a vacuum.

[30:59]Even with Shia, what we do is not out of a vacuum.

[31:00]We must have literature where we get what we get.

[31:03]And what ISIS does doesn't come out of a vacuum.

[31:07]If can set a precedence for killing people he wants to kill,

[31:12]for beheading people, for sitting and having a meal while putting a

[31:16]pot on their head, for sleeping with their wives, you're going to

[31:21]say to me all these things.

[31:22]Yes, all these things I will show you one by one in

[31:25]the next 15 minutes.

[31:24]If you can show all of these things, there's nothing no issue

[31:29]with dash dash.

[31:28]Whether they did this to Yazidis or they did this to Christians

[31:31]or they did this to Shia or they did this in Syria

[31:35]and Iraq, they have Wed's precedent.

[31:37]Come back with me.

[31:39]The prophet sent an army unit under the command of Wal to

[31:44]fight against the tribe of Benujadima.

[31:46]And those people could not express express themselves saying but they said

[31:52]what did they say my dear brothers and sisters all of you

[31:58]could see very clearly over here kept on killing some of them

[32:03]and taking some others as captives and he gave a captive to

[32:06]every one of us and ordered every one of us to kill

[32:11]his captive.

[32:10]Have you all understood what's happened?

[32:12]I've come to a tribe.

[32:14]I want to know if you're Muslim or not.

[32:16]If you say Islam, you're Muslim.

[32:18]If you say Sabatna, I'm going to kill you.

[32:21]I want to ask somebody.

[32:21]Why would you say Sabatna?

[32:24]Why would you say Sabatna?

[32:26]Everyone knows the religion is called Islam.

[32:28]It's 21 years old.

[32:30]By the time you get to them, if a religion is called

[32:32]Islam, the derivative I'm not going to say Sabah.

[32:35]I'm going to say Islam.

[32:37]No, but I heard them say Sabata, not Islam.

[32:40]So what does he do?

[32:42]What do you do if you're wearing orange?

[32:44]What do you do if you're wearing a turban?

[32:46]If you've got a long beard, what do you do if you

[32:50]have a gun in your hand and you're not sure if someone

[32:54]is a morted whatever titles they want to give?

[33:00]What do you do?

[32:59]Look what he says.

[33:01]Khaled kept on killing some of them and taking some others as

[33:03]captives.

[33:03]And he gave a captive to every one of us and ordered

[33:05]every one of us to kill his captive.

[33:08]All of you saw the spiker attack that happened in Iraq, I

[33:10]think about 10 years ago.

[33:11]Do you remember the beheadings of the Shia by the river?

[33:14]Come on.

[33:16]We're not far, are we?

[33:20]We're not far.

[33:19]Here's Bkari is opening a a beautiful thing for us.

[33:22]Now, someone might say to me, "Yeah, yeah, yeah, but that's your

[33:25]Shia interpretation." It's not because the end of this hadith gives a

[33:27]way that the prophet was really angry.

[33:28]Come back.

[33:30]I said, "By Allah, I shall not kill my captive and none

[33:35]of my companions shall kill their captives." Then we mentioned that to

[33:39]the prophet and he said, "Oh Allah, I am free from what

[33:41]has done and repeated it twice." What did he say?

[33:46]Allah, he read a dua.

[33:47]When he heard that had massacred innocent people, oh Allah, I dissociate.

[33:59]I am free from what Khaled has done.

[34:02]I go to a group of people.

[34:05]If they join Islam, they join.

[34:05]If they don't join Islam, what am I going to do?

[34:09]Behead them?

[34:11]Play that clip number two.

[34:14]Repeat it again of just repeat it one more time please.

[34:18]Clip number two is that the prophet sent to when he went

[34:31]there was quick.

[34:31]He invited them to Islam.

[34:33]They didn't say, they said, which means we changed our religion, which

[34:39]can mean that they apostated or that they became Muslim.

[34:41]They had their weapons.

[34:43]He said, "Why do you have your weapons?" They said, "This is

[34:45]for the other Arab tribes." He ordered them to put them down.

[34:47]They refused to put them down.

[34:48]Why?

[34:49]Because one of the things that plays into this in a very

[34:52]unique way is that had a previous rivalry with that tribe in

[34:56]particular.

[34:57]Remember, he used to duel with everybody, right?

[35:00]Also what complicates is that this was the tribe that killed an

[35:05]uncle of and they killed the father of right which becomes relevant

[35:13]in the story.

[35:12]So in any case was quick to attack that tribe.

[35:16]>> He killed them >> not realizing that indeed some of them

[35:20]had become Muslim right or all of them part of them or

[35:24]some of them had become Muslim.

[35:24]And when this came back to the prophet sallallaihi wasallam abdom came

[35:29]to the prophet sallall alaihi wasallam and he complained to the prophet

[35:32]sallallaihi wasallam about what khalid had done because this is a huge

[35:35]mistake in the early days of Islam in the early days of

[35:39]his being Muslim.

[35:40]The prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam looked towards the he said oh Allah

[35:48]I disavow myself of what has done.

[35:50]This is not what I taught him.

[35:53]Oh Allah, I disavow myself of what Khaled has done.

[35:55]So it's a significant mistake and the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam sends

[36:00]to make up for to compensate in whatever ways that he possibly

[36:08]can for the mistake that made.

[36:11]And some of the say this is not a part of history

[36:14]you should brush over.

[36:15]Of course it's not a part of history that we should brush

[36:18]over.

[36:19]Of course it's not a part of history that we should brush

[36:22]over.

[36:23]Yan, you're smiling and saying that this was a mistake.

[36:26]You've gone to a group of people.

[36:28]You've wonder this is who's been reckless for the last 20 years

[36:34]of his life, brandishing his sword, killing Muslim after Muslim, torturing Muslim

[36:38]after Muslim.

[36:41]You think that guy has been rehabilitated in one year?

[36:54]You know what they say?

[36:57]They say, "But he thought they were apostates." The prophet, peace be

[37:00]upon his family, said, "I disavow." I'm looking at the Kaa.

[37:02]I disavow from what this guy's done.

[37:05]One act can ruin the image of Islam when done by someone

[37:11]representing Islam.

[37:13]One act can ruin the image of the religion of Islam by

[37:19]someone who claims to be representing the religion.

[37:21]This guy has come up to them.

[37:26]He's killed them.

[37:25]Other Sahab are looking to what's this guy doing?

[37:28]I'm surprised that you're baffled with what he's doing.

[37:30]He's been reckless for 20 years.

[37:32]Just because he converted, what do you think?

[37:34]You can suddenly rehabilitate him because he said there are many who

[37:39]convert in this UK.

[37:39]You can't rehabilitate them for 20 years from their excon life.

[37:46]And that's why in clip number three, Shehikh Omaran admits the Sahabah

[37:52]had too much in their heart.

[37:54]That would always mean they'll make reckless decisions and his friends who

[37:59]converted.

[37:58]There was always tension that remain in there.

[38:00]Please play clip number three.

[38:04]And by the way, the reason why I mentioned subhan allah his

[38:09]father having been killed by this tribe that you know actually came

[38:17]to because he suspected that one of the reasons you're still human.

[38:20]One of the reasons why you were quick to attack them was

[38:22]because you remember them killing your uncle.

[38:25]Right?

[38:26]So he's suspecting that maybe there's someah that's still within you that

[38:30]you need to purify this.

[38:30]We don't do this anymore.

[38:31]Keep in mind what did the Arabs used to do repeats repeats

[38:35]repeat years later my son will come and attack your entire tribe

[38:38]that actually the reason why I mentioned subhan allah his father having

[38:45]been killed by this tribe that you know actually came to because

[38:50]he suspected that one of the reasons you're still human one of

[38:54]the reasons why you were quick to attack them was because you

[38:57]remember them killing your uncle right so he's suspecting that maybe there's

[39:02]someah that's still within you that you need to purify this.

[39:04]We don't do this anymore.

[39:05]Keep in mind what did the Arabs used to do?

[39:07]If you killed my camel 40 years later, my son will come

[39:12]and attack your entire tribe.

[39:12]That actually happens.

[39:16]So is saying you still have some inside of you.

[39:18]And who argues back and Khaled says and they killed your father

[39:24]too.

[39:25]Right?

[39:24]And this is actually where the prophet sallall alaihi wasallam has the

[39:31]very famous hadith.

[39:29]It's it's interesting.

[39:39]Prophet sallall alaihi wasallam said, "Do not curse my companions because if

[39:43]one of you were to spend a mountain of in gold, you

[39:47]would not be able to reach their rank, not even a handful."

[39:53]The prophet said, "Don't curse my companions cuz Khalid cursed Abdah and

[39:57]Oh, that's an interesting one.

[40:00]So Sahabi was cursing Sahabi and they say why do you sahab

[40:03]but they're cursing each other number one.

[40:06]Number two they're also admitting what's being admitted over here.

[40:10]We still have jahi tendencies.

[40:13]Why do the sh insist that the success of the prophet has

[40:17]to be a you cannot have the remnants of jah and the

[40:22]evil of jah still in you.

[40:24]You'll be reckless.

[40:26]We saw over here that the prophets read a dua.

[40:27]Now, someone asked me a question once.

[40:30]If Khaled had done something so bad, why didn't the prophet punish

[40:34]him?

[40:35]Good question.

[40:34]It's a solid one.

[40:38]Solid question.

[40:37]If the prophet had to punish his companions for every bad they've

[40:41]done, wah, he would have to wait till the courtroom wouldn't close.

[40:49]At everyone who ran away, did he hold each one and said,

[40:51]"You put the Muslims life in danger.

[40:52]I'm going to punish each one of you.

[40:54]The ones who ran away ran and ran and ran and did

[40:59]the prophet peace be upon him's family punishman.

[41:04]No.

[41:03]How many of the Muslims made mistakes at they ran away?

[41:07]Did the prophet catch each one say you ran away at how

[41:10]many times we read aysman.

[41:20]Why didn't the prophet punish them for their running or their turning

[41:26]or their revoling in the story of why didn't the prophet punish

[41:30]them?

[41:30]That's why even in Sah Muslim when someone says to you if

[41:33]Khalid done such a bad thing why didn't the prophet punish Khalid

[41:38]if he done such a bad thing look in sah Muslim the

[41:39]prophet me makes it quite clear why he hasn't punished because this

[41:45]question is asked a lot that why didn't the prophet peace be

[41:47]upon him and his family do that if you come with me

[41:50]over here let's go to sah Muslim let's go sah Muslim volume

[41:54]number three come with me over here why did the prophet not

[41:56]punish his companions sah Muslim compus Muslim volume 3 from hadith number

[42:02]2263 to 3397.

[42:04]A hadith edited and referenced by Abu Tah.

[42:06]I want us to go to 1063.

[42:11]For those who say, "Why did the prophet not punish his companion

[42:15]if it was such a bad thing?" You'll always hear these lines.

[42:18]You come with me over here.

[42:23]1063.

[42:21]My dear brothers and sisters, okay, where are we?

[42:27]1063.

[42:26]Come over here.

[42:28]Chapter 47.

[42:30]the Kawar and their attributes.

[42:32]24491421063 it was narrated that Jabb Abdal said a man came to

[42:35]the message of Allah.

[42:38]Okay.

[42:36]In the area in the area which was known as when he

[42:42]was on his way back from Hunain in the cloak of Bilal

[42:45]there was some silver and the messenger of Allah was giving handfuls

[42:47]of it to the people.

[42:50]He said oh messenger be fair.

[42:52]Oh Muhammad be fair.

[42:51]He said, "Wo to you who will I who will be fair

[42:55]if I'm not fair.

[42:57]I will be doomed and lost if I'm not fair." Omar said,

[43:00]"Oh messenger of Allah, let me kill this hypocrite." He said, "Allah

[43:03]forbids that the people should say that I kill my companions." Allah

[43:11]wouldn't kill his companion.

[43:12]People will say, "Look, he kills his own companions." Otherwise these people

[43:19]who have caused the butchering he receives the revelation he receives the

[43:24]after the prophet dies peace be upon him his family khalid is

[43:29]part of the group that attacks the house of fatam and that's

[43:34]clear within shia literature if you look within shia literature khalid even

[43:38]tried to kill Imam Ali so when we say who is greater

[43:42]khalid or Im Ali many shia don't know the tradition ition about

[43:45]trying to kill Im Ali in Salah after the prophet died.

[43:51]Come with me over here.

[43:52]The book al as you can all see by Abu Mansour Ahmed

[44:00]Ali translated by say Amir Hussein Saresh Kan.

[44:02]All of you can see over here my dear brothers and sisters

[44:08]first edition 2017.

[44:07]If we go to page 120 this a reference someone says I

[44:13]want Sunni habibi.

[44:13]You can look for Sunni yourself and I have my Shia books.

[44:16]When I want to use them I'll use them as freely as

[44:18]I want.

[44:17]You're not a barometer by which I live my life.

[44:20]Come back over here.

[44:22]My dear brothers and sisters, you come over here.

[44:24]Hadith number 45.

[44:26]It is narrated that Abu Bakr and Omar asked Wal to murder

[44:32]Im Ali.

[44:33]After they held talks with him and he accepted.

[44:35]At a corner of the house, Abu Bakr's wife Asma noticed it

[44:40]and abruptly sent someone to Imam Ali's house to say some were

[44:43]going to make an attempt on his life.

[44:45]Upon hearing the news, Imam Ali told the messenger peace be upon

[44:48]your lady as who would kill the faithless deviators and apostates then

[44:52]if they achieve their goal they want to kill Imam Ali.

[44:55]Imam saying who's going to kill the worst of the people if

[44:59]I'm not around was to use the opportunity to conceal himself at

[45:02]the time of dawn prayers when it was dark.

[45:06]Okay.

[45:06]However, Allah has the knowing.

[45:08]Abu Bakr told him to hit Imam Ali on the neck whenever

[45:12]he finishes saying his prayers.

[45:13]It was why he sat besides Imam Ali in the line of

[45:18]prayers.

[45:18]While saying prayers, Abu Bakr suddenly thought about the consequences of that

[45:22]act and felt afraid of the disturbance.

[45:24]After that, it might put his own life in danger.

[45:28]Abu Bakr got scared.

[45:28]Allow this plan.

[45:29]Let's not do this.

[45:29]There's no need for us to go down this route.

[45:32]Let's go back.

[45:33]Thus, before finishing his prayers, he said three times, "Oh Khalid, do

[45:36]not do what you were assigned to do." In another narration, it

[45:38]is mentioned that he told him, "Do not do what I ordered

[45:42]you." Then I imam turned to Khaled and saw him standing beside

[45:44]him with a sword naked in his hand.

[45:46]Imam Ali told him Khalid what had he assigned to you?

[45:51]Imagine Imam Ali looks at you and says what's been assigned to

[45:53]you oh Khalid tell me I've caught you come back.

[45:58]He said killing you.

[45:58]Imam Ali asked him did you really want to do it?

[46:00]He replied by Allah if he had not stopped me I would

[46:01]have struck you on the head with my sword.

[46:03]Imam Ali said you told a lie.

[46:06]I swear by him who developed the seed and created the human

[46:08]being that if Allah had ordained differently, you would have realized which

[46:12]of these two group is more wicked and feeble.

[46:15]Okay.

[46:17]Now in another narration from Abu Dar it's quoted saying following the

[46:22]above measan Imam Ali took with his first and middle fingers and

[46:25]pushed him so much that he cried out in pain.

[46:29]People were overcome with fear and became analid says here wet his

[46:35]pants hitting his feet to the ground and saying nothing.

[46:37]In the meantime, Abu Bakr told Omar, "It is the result of

[46:40]your wrong advice.

[46:41]It seemed as if I had been I had seen its consequences.

[46:46]I'm thankful to Allah that I did not pollute myself with that

[46:49]act.

[46:49]However, anyone who took a step to release Khaled from Ali's hands

[46:52]moved away out of fear." Here upon Abu Bakr sent Omar to

[46:58]his uncle Abbas.

[46:57]He came and interceded with him on behalf of Khalid and by

[47:02]the owner of this tomb and him who was buried in it

[47:05]and by and Fatma leave him.

[47:06]That's all he had to say to him in the name of

[47:10]Allah and the and Fatma leave release don't keep him in this

[47:17]chain.

[47:17]Then he did as such and Abbas kissed him between his eyebrows.

[47:22]Okay.

[47:24]So 20 years not a Muslim joins Islam has already recklessly killed

[47:28]a group of people has already been part of the gang with

[47:33]and others threatening the house of Fatham and you'd think that was

[47:38]the last of the crimes and then you're introduced to another world

[47:44]of crime when is employed as a general by Abu Bakr to

[47:49]collect taxes anyone who doesn't pay zakat is to be killed.

[47:53]Be they sahabi or not sahhabi.

[47:54]Please play clip number four.

[48:36]for forch.

[49:34]for a thousand.

[50:14]for and foreign.

[51:43]Islam.

[52:04]forch.

[52:45]Islam.

[52:50]They go to Malikb No.

[52:52]Malikb Noer doesn't want to pay zakat.

[52:55]Of course, later they all accuse him that this guy is with

[52:58]Musam al- Kadab and he's with the false prophet and you have

[53:00]to work so hard to look after the character of a man

[53:05]who had literally joined Islam for 3 years had been an enemy

[53:07]of Islam for 20 years of the prophethhood of the holy prophet

[53:11]peace be upon him's family but you have to rebuild his character

[53:14]he's been reckless in Yemen you still have to rebuild his character

[53:16]he's now reckless again that Omarilab is super angry with him in

[53:22]relation to what he's done Katab has known that this guy has

[53:28]been savage with what he's done.

[53:29]If you come to Tabari over here, my dear sisters, the history

[53:31]of Tabari volume 16, the challenge to the empires, translated by blankansship.

[53:37]All of you come over here, page 64.

[53:40]It's very brief, this reference, but you can see over here, my

[53:42]dear, the caliphate of Abu Bakr Sadik, he also appointed guardians to

[53:49]look after their children.

[53:50]Omar held their slaying against Khalid in addition to his killing of

[53:56]Malik that is Ib no footnote 359.

[53:59]He was a chief of the Tam who was killed by the

[54:04]Malik Aar during the Ridda wars.

[54:06]Omar held his killing against Khaled.

[54:08]Why would Omar have a problem with you killing an apostate?

[54:11]What's Omar's issue with you killing?

[54:14]If someone is an apostate, why would Omar have a problem with

[54:16]it?

[54:16]He'll say, "Well done.

[54:16]You killed all the apostates.

[54:18]We have to kill the mort.

[54:19]This is the rid the wars.

[54:20]Omar knew Malik wasn't apostate.

[54:22]And Omar knew what Khaled had done.

[54:25]Khaled had savagely killed Malik.

[54:27]Malik said, "Listen, pray.

[54:29]I pray zakat.

[54:29]I'm not giving to you guys.

[54:31]I used to give to the prophet.

[54:32]I'm not giving to you guys.

[54:33]I don't believe in no.

[54:34]This is your sham election." He beheads him.

[54:40]If you play clip number I think the last two clips.

[54:45]So, let's play the penultimate clip and then the last one.

[54:47]play the penultimate one first which I think is uh clip number

[54:54]seven.

[54:51]Clip number seven.

[55:10]Foreign Incarnate.

[56:09]What?

[56:10]Wasam.

[56:23]So it's the menhaj of the prophet that he'll kill your husband

[56:27]and then he'll take you as his misses.

[56:29]Okay?

[56:30]So that's the way that they follow.

[56:32]You take captives whoever you like.

[56:34]Okay?

[56:34]This all ISIS.

[56:35]ISIS.

[56:36]And there's one more ISIS part.

[56:38]Imagine you killed Malik, the husband.

[56:41]You've taken his misses and then you're about to have a meal.

[56:44]What's the best form of um what's it called?

[56:51]Table wear, they'll call it.

[56:51]Uh what's the best form of uh furniture to use for you

[56:56]to eat on?

[56:56]Which which which furniture is the best?

[56:58]Oh, I know.

[57:00]Uh play the last clip.

[57:03]Let's use someone's head as the furniture, as the stool.

[57:21]Yeah.

[57:22]You kill someone then behead them and then use the head as

[57:27]the stool for the pot.

[57:27]Okay.

[57:27]And that's the person who's called the sword of Allah.

[57:32]And that's why Omar Kab always had major problems with him.

[57:35]You'll see again you come back to the history of Tabari volume

[57:38]16, the challenge of the empires.

[57:41]As much as there is a cover up, there is still a

[57:44]reality about it over here.

[57:45]You'll see over here the caliphate of Omari page 162 volume 16.

[57:53]Come with me.

[57:55]Uh volume number 11.

[57:55]Sorry.

[57:56]Come with me.

[57:56]Omar dismissed Khalid only owing to words that Khaled has spoken according

[58:00]to what they claim.

[58:02]Okay.

[58:03]Omar did not cease being wroth with him and disliking his behavior

[58:06]during the whole time of Abu Bakr owing to his battle with

[58:11]Ib no and what he had done in fighting against him.

[58:13]When Omar succeeded to the caliphate, the first words he spoke were

[58:17]those of Khal's dismissal.

[58:20]He said he will never govern any province for me.

[58:22]Omar wrote to Abu Khal admits that he is a liar then

[58:27]he remains commander over what he has charge of but if he

[58:30]does not admit that he is a liar then you are command

[58:31]of what he had charge of then pull his turban off his

[58:36]head and confiscate half of his property could be clearer that Omar

[58:40]his son and others were never happy with Khaled's recklessness there's no

[58:44]doubt that was brave on a battlefield but recklessness killing innocent people

[58:49]taking the wife and using their heads as stalls that's not the

[58:52]Islam that we want.

[58:57]Hey, hey, hey.

[59:19]Stay away.

[59:33]Choosing meaningful content to watch has never been easy.

[59:38]But with the Imam Hussein Media Group smart TV app, you don't

[59:43]have to choose.

[59:45]Watch inspiring programs, lectures, and live from Karbala.

[59:51]Search Imam Hussein Media Group on your TV app store and download

[59:57]our app now.

0 Comments

Up next

17. Khalid Ibn Waleed Or Imam Ali: Sword Of Allah? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

Transcript

Up next

Explore more

Please note that if you are under 18, you won't be able to access this site.

Up next

17. Khalid Ibn Waleed Or Imam Ali: Sword Of Allah? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

Transcript

Up next

Explore more

Choose a payment method

Language