16. Why Did The Sahaba Fight, Abuse & Hate Imam Ali? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

3 المشاهدات· 26/03/05

Sayed Ammar Nakshawani Official
مشتركين

في محاضرات

Truth. Dialogue. Courage. After two compelling and impactful seasons, The Divide & Dialogue returns for Season 3—at a moment when silence is no longer an option, but a risk. As sectarian narratives intensify and misinformation deepens divides, this series fearlessly challenges accusations, unpacks misunderstandings, and confronts the uncomfortable truths shaping today’s Muslim world. This Holy Month of Ramadan, join Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshawani on Imam Hussein TV 3 for bold conversations, sharp historical insight, and a dialogue that refuses to be silenced. ——————————— Subscribe to Sayed Ammar’s official online platform, consisting of bespoke courses, exclusive content, brand new podcasts & more! https://www.sayedammar.com

أظهر المزيد

Transcript

[0:00]Just a short while ago, we came to you with a dream.

[0:04]Imm Hussein TV finally has a new home thanks to your generosity.

[0:07]This chapter is something special.

[0:12]We're finally bringing everything to life.

[0:16]Phase one of the Zenibia complex starts here on the ground floor.

[0:22]The studios are being developed.

[0:23]Shortly, you'll hear the voices you love to hear and the stories

[0:26]about the a bait.

[0:28]Also on this floor is something special.

[0:32]Ab Hussein dedicated to Imam Sad Alam.

[0:35]Phase two brings this floor to life.

[0:39]All the background work be editing development for all of your favorite

[0:41]shows happens on this floor.

[0:44]The stuff you don't get to see, the magic behind the camera

[0:47]is all here.

[0:48]Phase three is all about sustainability with offices being created to allow

[0:56]the channel to generate rental income.

[0:58]This phase is all about the long-term vision of the channel.

[1:01]Have the opportunity to rent an office in our new home.

[1:06]You helped us secure a foundation.

[1:11]This Ramadan helped us build it.

[1:12]Every single donation leaves a legacy.

[1:14]This is a place for community, family, and most importantly, every single

[1:21]one of you.

[1:20]Donate this month.

[1:23]Build with us.

[1:43]Hey, hey, hey.

[1:52]Hey, away.

[2:18]In the name of God, the most beneficent, the most merciful.

[2:22]All praise is due to Allah, master of all the worlds.

[2:27]And peace and blessings be on all his prophets and especially the

[2:32]final prophet, the holy prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi.

[2:35]My respected brothers and sisters, why did the Sahabah hate, fight, and

[2:43]abuse Im Ali?

[2:46]When one examines Islamic history, it's unbelievable how all this literature that

[2:51]surrounds me involves narrations concerning Sahaba who fought Im Ali.

[2:58]Those who had hate for Im Ali Alisam.

[3:03]Those who as well abused Im Ali.

[3:07]Remember one thing that throughout the world, especially in the Sunni world,

[3:11]there's always this image that's given that either the Sahabah were all

[3:17]best friends and they're all going to Jenna or that we're not

[3:19]allowed to discuss any of the differences that exist between them at

[3:23]all.

[3:23]But then when we look at the narrations in Sunni literature, we'll

[3:28]find that there are so many disputes that occur between the Sahab

[3:33]that leads them to fighting Imam Ali, hating Imam Ali, no abusing

[3:39]Im Ali.

[3:41]Now, the problem here is if you're all going to go into

[3:43]Jenna, Jenna sounds like quite a rowdy place.

[3:45]Because if I'm going to go to Jenna and there's someone in

[3:48]Jenna who I've abused, who who I've hurt or who I've for

[3:54]example fought in a battle and raised an army against, I'm not

[3:58]looking forward to seeing that guy in Jenna.

[4:00]And so when you look within Sunni history and Sunni theology, Im

[4:05]Alivisam is a very problematic figure.

[4:09]Yes, when you look at the Sunni community today, all of them

[4:14]love Imm Ali Alisam.

[4:14]But this of course was not the case in the early days

[4:18]of the religion of Islam.

[4:19]This is something that has evolved and has crystallized into later theology

[4:24]that concepts such as Imm Ali being the forthrightly guided Khalifa was

[4:30]not something that was there in early Islam.

[4:33]Any Sunni scholar of reputation or of good note or of good

[4:37]standing will be someone who will tell you blatantly that Imam Ali

[4:43]Alisam amongst the groups that despised him in early Islam were groups

[4:47]such as the now before you even got to the was a

[4:52]group that despised Im Ali Alisam and they would not acknowledge Im

[4:58]Ali Alisam as a righteous individual.

[4:59]Many times people try and portray that it's the Kawar who really

[5:03]hated Imam Ali Alisam.

[5:03]The first real group one may argue and when I say group

[5:09]that is known with a particular title.

[5:11]Yes, Abu Bakr and Omar we know very well you served the

[5:13]right of Imam Ali Alaiam with the Sham election that was the

[5:20]Satifa election.

[5:18]But the Omani sect was really the group who despised Im Ali.

[5:26]the group who felt that man was unjustly treated and oppressed and

[5:32]that I im Ali Alisam had to be held account and they

[5:34]did not raise Im Ali's status at all and then you had

[5:39]another group at that time the who decided not to give judgments

[5:43]they could see that Imam Ali Alisam has too many for them

[5:48]to give a judgment on and so they suspend their judgment and

[5:52]then you have the and then later on coming in the time

[5:56]of Ahmed bin H.

[5:57]There's this book right in front of me over here.

[5:59]One may argue that this book over here by Ahmed Hel if

[6:05]you zoom into this book you'll see that this book this book

[6:09]of im Ahmed bin hal as you could see over here I

[6:18]imbdued bin hal this book written by Ahmed bin hal in my

[6:23]opinion is a major turning point in the respect of to Im

[6:30]Ali as the forthrightly guided Khalifa because Ahmed H what he does

[6:36]in this text is living 150 years or so after the prophet

[6:39]peace be upon him and his family has passed away he decides

[6:43]to collect all the of the Sahabah half of it is the

[6:46]of im Ali so in the Sunni world when you're looking at

[6:50]the merits of Im Ali Alisam this is one of the best

[6:54]another of the great works on the merits of Imam Ali in

[6:55]the Sunni world is of the of one of the six authors

[7:08]you know we have Muslim Iba Abu Daw and so has Ahmed

[7:16]within has unbelievable merits of Im Ali in reality therefore in the

[7:22]Sunni world you could not say that everybody has the same opinion

[7:25]on Im Ali Alisam I have for example here the famous work

[7:35]of Ibia in coherence of the Shia okay by Ibia.

[7:38]Now when you look in Minhajnah you'll see that the whole book

[7:43]is dedicated to nullifying the merits quite literally nullifying the merits of

[7:47]Imam Ali Alisam.

[7:47]So if you come to the chapters of the book, look at

[7:51]each chapter of Ib Tamia's book and you'll see that each chapter

[7:54]it's about nullifying one way or the other Imm Ali's merit.

[7:59]So you'll see over here nullifying the claim of the Rafi that

[8:02]the verse those are sincere proves the leadership of Ali.

[8:07]Nullifying the claim of the that the verse of those who spent

[8:10]their wealth proves leadership of Ali.

[8:12]Nullifying the claims of the rafi that the verse of asking for

[8:14]blessings proves the leadership of Ali.

[8:17]Nullifying the bonite existence of the Quran on the verse of the

[8:22]two seas as advanced by the about Ali and others.

[8:24]Nullifying the claim of the rafi that the verse of those who

[8:28]have knowledge of the scripture proves leadership of Ali.

[8:30]Nullifying the claims of the Rafi that the verse on the day

[8:33]in which Allah will not disgrace the prophet proves the leadership of

[8:36]Ali.

[8:37]Nullifying the claim of the Rafi that the verse of the best

[8:39]of creatures proves the leadership of Ali.

[8:41]Nullifying the claim of the Rafi that the verse of mankind of

[8:46]making kindred and in-laws proves leadership of Ali.

[8:47]Nullifying the claims of the that the verse be with those who

[8:53]are truthful proves the leadership of Ali.

[8:56]Another chapter nullifying the claim of the that the verse of bowing

[8:59]down to Allah proves the leadership of Ali.

[9:02]Nullifying the claim of the verse of appointing a helper proves the

[9:05]leadership of Ali.

[9:06]Nullifying the claim of the the verse of testifying proves the leadership

[9:10]of Ali.

[9:09]Nullifying the claim of the that the vers of Allah is his

[9:14]protector proves the leadership of Ali.

[9:15]Nullifying the claim of the that the hadith of declaring the message

[9:18]of Allah proves the leadership of Ali.

[9:21]Explaining the falsity of the arguments of the with the ofad.

[9:23]Now which is referring to he's referring to of course live in

[9:33]the same time.

[9:35]One has been Haj and the other has been Hajnah.

[9:36]And of course the famous Syrian who is without a doubt one

[9:43]may argue the most influential scholar at the moment in Jama or

[9:48]the most agreed upon.

[9:51]Let's make that clear.

[9:50]The most influential scholar is Ibia today.

[9:54]Now you see Syria the books of Ibia are being distributed to

[9:59]people so that they may learn about the religion of Islam.

[10:03]So you have when people talk about Imam you either have Ahmed's

[10:11]book full of praise with all the merits of Im Ali that

[10:14]sometimes makes you look at and say wow that's virtually sh in

[10:19]terms of proving the merits and the position of Im Ali Alisam

[10:23]and then you have trying to nullify every single merit of Almanis

[10:29]and that's why it wasn't surprising when you had ISIS is stopping

[10:33]people and literally because they were called Ali they were beheaded before

[10:37]them there were people of the extreme of especially those influenced by

[10:44]Ibia now of course don't get me wrong Ahmed there is a

[10:47]connection there without a doubt many times people would look at Ibamy

[10:49]as a strand of halism and then look at the more extreme

[10:56]Muhammad Abdahab later on but when you come to one undeniable fact

[11:00]that Ibia and Ahmed Hal can never ever go against and that

[11:04]is that the Sahabah had amongst them Sahabah who hated Ali or

[11:11]who fought Ali or who abused Ali.

[11:15]Now I'm not going to show that from Shia books because if

[11:17]I show it from Shia books everyone will turn around to me

[11:20]and say ah this is typical Shia bringing up from their own

[11:24]literature.

[11:24]No, I will show you tonight and I want to make something

[11:26]clear.

[11:27]Not all Sahabah because this whole idea that Shia I don't like

[11:29]any Sahabah I've already discussed a number of times in this series

[11:33]and other series is the great number of Sahabah that we revere

[11:36]and of course we put Sahabah on the different levels the same

[11:40]way the Quran says there are those who ran away in battle

[11:42]and those who didn't those who turned up for battle those who

[11:45]didn't those who were hypocrites those who weren't.

[11:46]The Quran has put them in levels and I go with the

[11:50]levels of the Quran.

[11:49]For me, when I'm trying to see the hate of Im Ali

[11:55]Alisam, there's something that baffles me.

[11:57]Ali on many occasions made it clear that the hate of Ali

[12:03]or fighting Ali is the same as fighting the holy prophet peace

[12:05]be upon him and his family.

[12:09]Now, someone may ask me why does he make this clear?

[12:10]Why would the prophet randomly say that whoever loves Ali loves me

[12:15]and whoever hates Ali hates me?

[12:16]It's as if the prophet is giving a huge warning for the

[12:18]future after he passes away.

[12:22]As you know, the prophet would guide mankind not just in relation

[12:25]to his life.

[12:26]He would tell us what's going to happen after him, the trials,

[12:30]THE TRIBULATIONS ALL THE WAY UNTIL THE signs of Allah would bestow

[12:34]on him knowledge of the unseen and sallallahu alaihi would even tell

[12:37]us all the of the day of judgment and the stories of

[12:41]the end of times.

[12:43]Why would the prophet keep repeating whoever hates Ali hates me, whoever

[12:47]fights Ali fights me?

[12:47]And if you want to recognize whether you live in 2026 or

[12:53]whether you live in 36 after Hijra, look at their behavior with

[12:55]Ali son of Abu Talib.

[12:58]Come with me over here, my dear brothers and sisters.

[12:59]Let's begin over here.

[13:03]You'll see these hadiths one after another.

[13:04]Immedi all of you can see here translated by Muhamad Mahi Sharif

[13:12]English Arabic text volume 4 of Nasi if we come over here

[13:16]we'll see my dear brothers and sisters of course it's printed where

[13:22]in Lebanon in the year 2008 come with me to this hadith

[13:24]on page 178 or so okay so if we just keep going

[13:32]down you'll see over here 78.

[13:33]This chapter is called the sign of a hypocrite.

[13:38]Okay, look over here.

[13:39]The sign of a hypocrite.

[13:42]Hadith number 5030.

[13:44]Okay, all of you can see here that the prophet begins to

[13:47]talk about what the signs of the hypocrites are.

[13:49]Come with me on the sign of a hypocrite.

[13:52]Hadith number 5032.

[13:52]It's narrated on the authority of Ali that he said the messenger

[13:59]of Allah sallallahu alaihi wasall confirmed to me that none but a

[14:03]believer should love me and none but a hypocrite should hate me.

[14:06]Look at the Arabic all of you can see over here.

[14:20]Okay.

[14:20]So none but a believer loves me and none but a hypocrite

[14:26]doesn't matter male female related to the prophet not related to the

[14:30]prophet if you show hatred for Ali that is a sign that

[14:36]you are afra where is this this is now this again is

[14:40]seen in the bin my dear brothers and sisters come with me

[14:43]over here you could see the English translation of the mus of

[14:49]Im Ahmed bin Hel hadith number 1 to 138 80 as you

[14:52]could see over here volume one translated by edited by Hudal all

[14:58]of you come with me over here where is the head office

[15:01]of Dam the publishers prince Abdiz bin jalaw street riad kingdom of

[15:06]Saudi Arabia if we all go over here let's go to this

[15:13]hadith page 375 it is of course in the mid of Ahmed

[15:19]bin Hel and in the musnet of Im Ali Come to the

[15:22]bottom here.

[15:24]It was narrated that Ali said page 7 hadith number 731.

[15:26]It's narrated if we zoom in that Ali said the prophet assured

[15:35]me no one will love you but a believer and no one

[15:38]will hate you except what?

[15:43]Except that that person is a hypocrite.

[15:45]So we have two clear traditions here in Sunni literature.

[15:47]When you say to me, why am I Shia?

[15:50]Because I have a criteria.

[15:55]My criteria is anyone who loves Ali is a believer.

[15:57]Anyone who hates him, anyone who raises an army against him.

[16:03]Anyone who fights him, anyone who abuses him, my prophet said to

[16:08]me, is a hypocrite.

[16:07]that person is a or a and I will never follow the

[16:13]path of a I will follow the path of those who showed

[16:17]love of Ali and not those who hated him.

[16:20]Now the hate of Imam Ali normally when people talk about the

[16:26]hate of Imam Ali in the Sahabah they try and portray it

[16:28]that this hate happened many years after the prophet there's clashes between

[16:32]people 20 years after the prophet died and you know even even

[16:37]a few days after the prophet died there's clashes and that's where

[16:41]the hate begins on the contrary the hate of Ali began in

[16:43]the time of the prophet peace be upon him and his family

[16:48]not afterwards it's crazy to think that the Sahaba already hated one

[16:52]another and had envy of one another in the time of the

[16:55]prophet peace be upon because this glorious image that's portrayed that we

[17:00]have to be like the Sahabah but the Sahaba in the time

[17:04]of the prophet clearly there were disputes we all know about how

[17:11]Khaled abused and the prophet said do not abuse my companions you

[17:14]have amongst the Sahabah those who ran from battle which Abdman b

[17:18]reminds of man bin A and his caliphate that you were the

[17:22]one who ran away on the day of you have those who

[17:25]ran those who stayed amongst them hypocrites and so on and so

[17:28]forth but in the time of the prophet there is already a

[17:32]group who hate Ali now one may ask why the hate I

[17:33]would summize to say that number one Ali marrying fatheram is bound

[17:38]to bring some envy I think number two the prophet when he

[17:41]enters Medina all the Ansar and Muhamon are made brothers of one

[17:46]another and he makes Ali his brother I think that that brings

[17:48]a lot envy.

[17:50]The fact that the prophet doesn't enter Medina until Ali arrives from

[17:54]Mecca with the fawatam, I think that brings a lot of envy.

[17:56]And I think also Ali kills the fathers of some of these

[18:03]companions or their uncles at Badr and so on.

[18:05]And I think you know as much as a person tries to

[18:07]say that the of the of is going to leave somebody you

[18:13]and me both know that that remained.

[18:15]And there's another part of the equation.

[18:18]The who were freed on the opening of Mecca, the couple of

[18:22]thousand of them or so who were freed on the opening of

[18:25]Mecca, these are excons being freed.

[18:27]If we're going to be frank, even in Sunni literature, you'll see

[18:30]there is a difference between the muajarun and the ansar and the

[18:36]that some sunni theologians even said that the those who were freed

[18:40]on the day of Mecca, they could not even become they certainly

[18:43]did but they cannot become now the who are freed on the

[18:49]day of Mecca all expected to die.

[18:50]They had too much blood of Muslims on their hands from and

[18:53]so on and then the prophet says today the day of mercy.

[18:58]Now those they're going to want vengeance for a man who's killed

[19:01]their dad and their uncles and so on.

[19:03]So that's going to bring as well.

[19:05]So amongst others they all admit that listen amongst the Sahabah there

[19:09]were certainly people who had hatred for Ali.

[19:12]If we play clip number one and you'll see that this hatred

[19:15]of Ali normally this is the theory that's given in relation to

[19:20]the hatred of Ali um in Islamic history.

[19:21]Let's play clip number one.

[19:55]Allah.

[20:11]Now he pretty much there just admits that literally said to the

[20:18]prophet you are the one who claims to be the messenger of

[20:20]Allah and most people normally say that the hatred of Ali began

[20:26]with but the hatred of Ali doesn't begin at JL it begins

[20:29]in the lifetime of the companions of the prophet peace be upon

[20:34]him and his family.

[20:33]That's where really that hatred begins that we see in the lifetime

[20:39]of the prophet peace be upon him and his family.

[20:40]And I want to come to this hadith over here in Sah

[20:43]Bkari to prove to you that the first to really show hate

[20:45]to Ali were the Sahaba in the life of the prophet and

[20:49]the prophet has to actually calm them down because the envy is

[20:51]now over boiling.

[20:52]This is the towards the end of the life of prophet.

[20:55]Come with me over here.

[20:56]The translation of the meanings of Sah Bkari Arabic English volume 5

[20:59]hadith 3849 to 4473.

[21:02]My dear brothers and sisters, translated by Dr.

[21:05]Muhammad Muin Khan.

[21:07]All of you can see over here printed in July 1997 print

[21:10]supervised by Abd Malik Mujah.

[21:16]I want us to go to page 387 and you'll see that

[21:21]very early on just over here that in hadith 1350 Bates the

[21:24]prophet sent Ali to Khalid to bring the and I hated Ali.

[21:30]Read this again.

[21:40]The prophet sent Ali to get the from Khaled and Boreda says,

[21:47]"I hated Ali." Is this after Allah died?

[21:48]No.

[21:49]No.

[21:50]But wait, the prophet has already told us about the fact that

[21:56]a believer loves Ali and only hates Ali.

[21:58]But can I call Bored the Sahabaf?

[22:03]My criteria for who af is is their hate of Ali.

[22:07]It's simple.

[22:08]The prophet has given it is Sunni books.

[22:10]You don't need to be a rocket scientist to understand it.

[22:12]Come back to me again.

[22:16]The prophet sent Ali to Khalid to bring the and I hated

[22:18]Ali and Ali had taken a bath after anexual act with a

[22:22]slave girl from the hums.

[22:23]I said to Khal, "Don't you see this Ali?" When we reached

[22:27]the prophet, I mentioned that to him.

[22:30]He said, "Oh, do you hate Ali?" And then he replied, I

[22:37]said, "Yes." He said, "Don't hate him for he deserves more than

[22:40]that from the look over him." So you could see already in

[22:51]this story, and we don't have to agree with all the parts

[22:53]of the story, but one part we certainly agree with.

[22:56]You've certainly got an issue with Ali.

[22:58]That hate is already there.

[23:01]The hate I can see even again in Jammed.

[23:04]Come with me over here.

[23:05]The English translation my dear brothers and sisters of compiled by Muhammadi

[23:10]volume 6 from hadith number 3291 to 3956 translated by Abu Khal.

[23:17]A hadith edited and referenced by Abu Zub Aliz.

[23:21]Final review by Islamic Research Section Dar Salam first edition November 2007

[23:29]supervised by who?

[23:29]Supervised by Abdul Malik Mujah.

[23:30]Come with me to hadith number 3726.

[23:34]Let's see my dear brothers and sisters what's going on over here.

[23:40]Come with me.

[23:39]Let's see the Sahaba's hate stroke envy of Ali son of Abu

[23:46]Tal in the time of the prophet not after.

[23:47]in the time just in case you thought all these sahab around

[23:50]the prophet were all very kind very nice to each other weren't

[23:55]envious of each other Allah revealed just to wake people up but

[23:58]anyway come back look over here hadith number 3726 jabar said the

[24:03]messenger of Allah called Ali on the day of the battle of

[24:07]and spoke privately with him so the people said his private conversation

[24:10]with his cousin has grown lengthy so the messenger of Allah said

[24:15]I did not speak privately with him rather Allah spoke privately ly

[24:19]with him.

[24:20]And the commentator here says then he says this hadith is and

[24:27]so on the envy they already got problems with him either because

[24:33]of his marriage to Fatama or because the prophet has made him

[24:37]his brother his exploits at war and killing a lot of their

[24:40]parents and that's why you see after the prophet dies suddenly the

[24:44]fangs are out suddenly they want to finish Ali his wife shortly

[24:50]after the prophet gone has died angry with the first Khalifa but

[24:55]they still want Ali and none wants Ali more than is but

[24:58]there's always an excuse given to Isa for why she hated Ali

[25:04]let's look at this academic in the states discussing when someone asks

[25:08]and Ali what's the issue between them that made wage war against

[25:12]Ali please play clip number two >> how much um influence did

[25:23]Aisha's hatred of Ali have to do with all of this?

[25:25]>> Well, very hard to tell.

[25:30]Um there there was clearly some tension between Ali and Aisha even

[25:34]when Muhammad was alive, right?

[25:34]Uh the story I told last time about the the the accusations

[25:37]of adultery, you know, Muhammad comes to Ali and he says he

[25:42]says, you know, what do you think I should do about this?

[25:45]And Ali says, well, you know, you really can't trust her.

[25:46]So, you really can't trust.

[25:47]Who knows?

[25:48]I mean, maybe she did.

[25:48]Maybe she didn't.

[25:49]You ought to just divorce her to be safe.

[25:53]Aisha never forgot that.

[25:53]She didn't like that very much.

[25:55]And of course, Aisha is the daughter of Abu Bak, right?

[26:00]And and Ali was so close to Muhammad, but Aisha was also

[26:02]so close to Muhammad in a sense.

[26:04]They had kind of a rivalry, you might say, or at least

[26:07]it's represented that way in the sources for Muhammad's affection, even though

[26:11]it was obviously very different kinds of affection.

[26:14]So, it's hard to say, it's very hard to sort out in

[26:16]the sources.

[26:18]Uh was there initially some kind of personal tension between Aisha and

[26:22]Ali?

[26:23]Uh or is this uh are these sort of stories and tensions

[26:26]kind of read back once you have the development of the Shiite

[26:32]perspective?

[26:33]A very hard thing to um to recognize.

[26:35]>> Professor Maria, I expected you to go deeper with that answer.

[26:41]You're a professor.

[26:41]I expected you to be able to open up on that answer.

[26:46]You say that Aisha hated Ali, which of course everybody agrees on.

[26:50]But you say that Aisha hated Ali, which of course everyone knows

[26:54]that she fought Ali.

[26:57]Now you say that Aisha hated Ali because Ali was the one

[26:59]who was telling the prophet when the prophet was uncertain about the

[27:02]incident of the if and the accusations of adultery.

[27:06]That yeah, it could be the case.

[27:07]Number one, as a do I believe in the incident of the

[27:12]if?

[27:13]That's open for question.

[27:12]Is it who's being accused?

[27:15]The Quran doesn't mention her name.

[27:17]Some wife of the prophet has been accused.

[27:19]Is it Aisha being accused by Medina or is it Aisha accusing

[27:22]Mary the Coptic?

[27:22]That's one for another night.

[27:26]Number two, why does the prophet need to ask Ali what he

[27:29]thinks if the prophet is receiving Wi-Fi emails from heaven?

[27:33]Number three is fought Ali later on.

[27:39]And of course the prophet had said very clearly that if you

[27:44]want to see the believer none will be a believer except they

[27:51]love Ali and those who have hate are.

[27:52]Okay.

[27:51]So we can't escape from that.

[27:54]But let me ask you when you turn around and say that

[28:00]Aisha hated Ali because Ali was willing to tell the prophet that

[28:03]yeah maybe she did commit adultery.

[28:05]What did Khadijah do to Aayisha for Aisha to resent Khadijah so

[28:10]much?

[28:11]Uh what did Fath do for Aisha to resent Fatima so much?

[28:14]You don't need to make a story of adultery for Aisha to

[28:18]hate you.

[28:18]Aisha can hate you when you're not even alive if she has

[28:23]an issue with you.

[28:26]Ask Maria or ask Zab in the story of or ask other

[28:27]wives.

[28:28]Each of them has felt the brunt of butisha is amongst those

[28:33]who we label hater of Ali and we've already seen what the

[28:37]hadith says about the haters of Ali led the most bloody of

[28:44]civil wars over here come with me my dear brothers and sisters

[28:48]the history of volume 16 the battle of jeal will be discussed

[28:53]the community divided today we always hear people say that you know

[28:58]what when you give lectures you shouldn't divide the community we're taking

[29:02]from the sunnah of about division of community is the one who

[29:07]was part like her dad in the division of the Muslim community

[29:10]yeah her dad and his friend at the election and their punchup

[29:16]with the ansar and then she in the battle of jl come

[29:19]back the history of not a shia book volume 16 the community

[29:25]divided translated by adrian brockett let's see over Here my dear brothers

[29:30]and sisters as you can see translated and annotated by Adrien Brockett

[29:35]State University of New York press all of us can see over

[29:38]here that 1997 State University of New York let's go here to

[29:46]page 52 I'm sure the title is clear for everybody who says

[29:49]did the Sahaba hate each other did the Sahaba fight each other

[29:54]come with me over here the caliphate of Ali Aisha's remark by

[29:59]Allah I will seek vengeance for the blood of man and her

[30:02]departure for Albas and Zuber and their followers.

[30:08]So here's the beautiful first 30 years of Islamic history dear brothers

[30:12]and sisters where we have over here the wife of the prophet

[30:15]and two of those promised Jenna about to go and fight another

[30:20]of those who is promised Jenna.

[30:21]Okay.

[30:22]Okay.

[30:23]So this is the beautiful early history that we have that we've

[30:25]been told this is the most glorious history that we've ever had.

[30:28]Now come back over here by Allah I will seek vengeance for

[30:32]the blood of and her departure for and their followers.

[30:34]And we cannot forget of course my dear brothers and sisters that

[30:38]was one of the most outspoken against like as we've seen earlier

[30:42]was outspoken but this is how history plays games.

[30:46]Let's come back.

[30:46]Okay.

[30:48]Now according to Ahmed Hussein his father also and Abdah a scholarly

[31:01]commentary scholar contemporary with the events as arrived at on her way

[31:07]back from visiting Mecca bin met her.

[31:07]He was bin Abbam but named after his mother.

[31:12]What is the matter?

[31:12]Aisha asked him.

[31:15]They killed Oman and then did nothing for eight nights.

[31:17]What did they do then?

[31:20]She asked.

[31:20]The people of Medina handled the affair by consensus and matters proceeded

[31:25]very well for them.

[31:29]They agreed upon Alib and Abi Alib by Allah.

[31:30]Shia replied, "Would that the sky were overturned if the command is

[31:36]decided in favor of your leader?

[31:38]Take me back.

[31:40]Take me back." So she departed for Mecca saying by Allah man

[31:45]has been killed unjustly and I will seek revenge for his bloodb

[31:53]said to her how is that by Allah you were the first

[31:56]to incline the blade against and were saying kill footnote 362 an

[32:05]insulting go down nickname it means hyena used to call Hyena Tabari

[32:11]page 52 volume 16 Amarak Shawani 2026 at exactly 7:40 p.m.

[32:22]and 31 seconds.

[32:25]Come back.

[32:28]By Allah, you were the first to incline the blade against and

[32:34]was saying kill for he has become a disbeliever.

[32:36]Aisha according to calledman hyena and she said kill the disbeliever.

[32:49]It's right in front of you.

[32:53]Volume 16 of the Shia Sahaba.

[32:53]It was who taught us.

[33:05]They asked him to repent.

[33:09]She replied and then they killed him.

[33:11]Aisha herself was the one who was the cause of the biggest

[33:16]fitnner in early Islamic history.

[33:18]a fitna that had Sahaba fighting each other and the poor Sunni

[33:24]world is taught that they all loved each other and then you

[33:28]make up a Yemeni Jew in the equation you add a bit

[33:30]of spice over here you throw the idea of well it happens

[33:37]20,000 people die it happens you know things happen what a mess

[33:41]what a mess mess Yes.

[33:48]If you ask any sunni in the world, what do you think

[33:55]of binasar?

[33:53]They'll sayar binas.

[34:02]No one will doubt the position of do they?

[34:05]Everyone says is amazing.

[34:08]No one's like come with me here.

[34:10]Bkari.

[34:10]If we go to Bkari, I want to go volume five again

[34:12]of Bkari.

[34:13]Look at what says the translation of the meanings of Sah Bkari

[34:17]Arabic English volume 5 hadith number 3849 to 4473 translated by Dr.

[34:26]Muhammad Khan, come with me to 3772.

[34:27]Amar bin Yaser is asked, "What's going on?

[34:30]Ali is I thought all of you guys are like best mates

[34:33]and you're going to heaven.

[34:34]You're going to all sit by rivers of milk and chill with

[34:38]each other.

[34:37]Why are like thousands of us here killing each other like what's

[34:42]going on, bro?" And someone has a good right to ask that

[34:44]question.

[34:45]So when you come to hadith 3,772, Amar says something amazing.

[34:48]Look at the page 75 alkari volume 5 the virtues of the

[34:53]companions of the prophet come down over here hadith 3772 narrated Abu

[34:58]when Ali sent and Hassan to the people of Kufa to urge

[35:01]them to fight Ali sent and to urge people to fight you

[35:09]have to choose whose side you're on the side of Ali or

[35:13]the side of there is the difference between and I've summarized it

[35:17]in 15 seconds come Back when Ali sent Hassan, Hassan by the

[35:25]way is who?

[35:24]Imm Hassan is the grandson of the prophet.

[35:27]So his wife, the prophet's wife was ready to take on who

[35:34]was ready to take on his grandson.

[35:35]Come back.

[35:36]When Ali sent Hamar and Hassan to the people of Kufa to

[35:39]urge them to fight, Hammar addressed them saying, "I know that she

[35:42]is the wife of the prophet in this world and in the

[35:46]hereafter, but Allah has put you to test whether you will follow

[35:52]him, i.e.

[35:50]Allah or her." Look at the footnote.

[35:56]Allah's orders to obey the imam and for the ladies to stay

[36:02]at home.

[36:07]What a shambles.

[36:10]Absolute shambles.

[36:10]Wallah leads an army to fight Ali.

[36:16]But they're both in Jenna.

[36:16]One sidear is another.

[36:17]Amar is just like listen she's a test whether you follow Allah's

[36:22]command and follow Im Ali or whether you follow her.

[36:23]you're either obsessed with her or you're gonna follow who is truly

[36:30]Allah's guide on earth.

[36:30]It was a very difficult time for Imam Ali that period we

[36:35]underestimate it and we're a few nights away from his shahad and

[36:37]inshallah I'll see all of you Sunday, Monday and Tuesday at Zah

[36:44]where we'll honor three nights the shahada of the Amir here in

[36:51]London.

[36:49]It was a very difficult difficult period for Imam Ali Alisam.

[36:56]Tabari narrates how Im Ali died.

[36:59]But he says something interesting.

[37:00]Aisha was happy on the day that he died.

[37:05]Aisha was happy on the day that Im Ali died.

[37:10]Four years after the battle of J, Imam Ali was assassinated.

[37:16]Come with me over here.

[37:17]The history of volume 17.

[37:23]The first civil war translated by GR Hing.

[37:24]All of you come with me over here.

[37:29]As you can see, State University of New York press.

[37:30]I want all of you to come to page 224.

[37:36]Look over here.

[37:41]They try and always say to us that Muawi and A were

[37:45]also to be assassinated that night.

[37:47]and Imam Ali.

[37:49]This is all nonsense.

[37:48]Muawi and Amaz firmly behind the whole plot, but they tried to

[37:54]make it out.

[37:53]Someone tried to attack Muawi and someone tried to attack.

[37:57]Someone tried to attack Imm Ali.

[37:59]They're behind the whole plot.

[37:59]Anyway, over here we see my dear brothers and sisters, look over

[38:02]here, the first civil war, page 224, Tabari, volume 17.

[38:09]When news of Ali's death reached Aisha, footnote 898, she said, "And

[38:15]she threw down her staff and settled upon her place of abode

[38:23]like the traveler, happy to return home." Let's go to footnote 899.

[38:33]If you see that over here, hing comments says that the verse

[38:40]is proverbial and is cited to indicate pleasure at something.

[38:45]Come back again.

[38:47]When news of Ali's death reached Aisha, she said, "And she threw

[38:51]down her staff and settled upon her place of abode, like the

[38:57]traveler happy to return home." 899 says that the verse is proverbial

[39:00]and is cited to indicate pleasure at something.

[39:10]She asked, "Come back.

[39:13]Who had killed him?" And when told that it was a man

[39:17]of Murad, she said, "Even though he was far away, there has

[39:19]announced his death.

[39:21]A young man in whose mouth there was no dust." Zanab, the

[39:32]daughter of Abuam said, "Are you saying this about Ali?" And Aisha

[39:35]replied, "I'm forgetful and if I forget, remind me.

[39:42]Abi Mori said about the killing of Ali.

[39:44]You upon whom be blessings.

[39:48]We have struck Abul Hassan with a blow to the head and

[39:50]he was split apart.

[39:52]We have removed kingship from his concerns with the blow of a

[39:56]sword since he waxed high and mighty.

[39:57]We are noble and powerful at dawn when death puts on and

[40:02]wraps itself in death.

[40:03]He also said, "I never saw a dowy provided by any generous

[40:08]man, whether Arab or other like that of Kotami, 3,000 dirhams, a

[40:11]slave and a singing girl, and the stabbing of Ali with the

[40:17]piercing blade.

[40:15]There is no dowy, however costly, more costly than Ali, and no

[40:23]killing above that performed by Ib Muljim." Abu Dali said, "Indeed say

[40:26]to Mu, "And may those who gloat not rejoice.

[40:30]Do you afflict us in the month of fasting with the loss

[40:32]of the best of all men?

[40:35]You have killed the best of those who ride mounts and put

[40:37]the saddle upon them, the best of those who sail the seas,

[40:41]the best of those who wear sandals and make them, the best

[40:42]of those who recite the math and the mubin.

[40:45]If you looked at the face of Abul Hussein, you saw the

[40:51]full moon that he delighted those who looked.

[40:57]There's certain times where you have to hold back, you know, when

[41:02]you're giving lectures and speeches because of the against and those who

[41:13]found pleasure.

[41:14]But the prophet summarized it.

[41:16]Only a mafik hates Ali.

[41:18]And that's why you'll see clip number three clear as day.

[41:23]The hatred and the cursing of Ali.

[41:26]Please play clip number three.

[41:39]Fore!

[41:40]Foreign!

[41:41]Foreign!

[42:01]this sheh he highlights that he has a problem with the senate

[42:05]of Muslim and Bkari and I'm sure they were the best things

[42:07]after the Quran so but there are people who can doubt it

[42:12]but anyway you come over here sah Muslim you'll see that Muawi

[42:15]of course was the king of the institution of cursing Ali can

[42:21]you curse Sahabi will say disgusting.

[42:24]Go and teach Muawi that before you teach me.

[42:28]English translation of Sah Muslim compiled by Abul Muslim Abdul Hussein Muslim

[42:33]and Haj volume 6 from hadith number 5646-6722.

[42:35]I want us to all come over here.

[42:40]Chapter 4.

[42:38]You can all see the virtues of Abi Talib on page 200

[42:43]and at the top 261.

[42:44]The virtues of the companions the virtues of Alibab hadith 2404.

[42:49]It was narrated from that.

[42:51]His father said the messenger of Allah said to Ali, you are

[42:56]to me like Harun was to Mus.

[42:57]We all know that hadith.

[42:58]Everybody knows it.

[43:01]Now come over here.

[43:01]In hadith 622032 was narrated from the son of his father said

[43:07]ordered saying what kept you from cursing Abu Tab now cursing Ali

[43:15]fighting Ali being at pleasure with hating Ali.

[43:16]It's unbelievable what these Sahaba left as a legacy.

[43:21]Wall.

[43:22]No one has been whitewashed and given the best rep like these

[43:25]guys.

[43:26]Look at the hadith, man.

[43:27]Look at it.

[43:30]Abu Sufyan's kids all back in power.

[43:33]Come back.

[43:35]It was narrated from that his father said ordered saying, "What kept

[43:39]you from cursing Abu Tur?" He said it's because of three things

[43:42]that I remember that the messenger of Allah said that I will

[43:43]never curse him because if even one of them were for me

[43:48]that would be darer to me than red camels is one of

[43:52]the 10 going to heaven.

[43:54]He says look you're asking me why don't I curse Abu?

[43:56]There's three merits three he has I wish that I had.

[44:01]What are they?

[44:02]I heard the messenger of Allah say to him when he appointed

[44:04]him in charge during his absence when he went on one of

[44:07]his campaigns and Ali said to him oh messenger of Allah are

[44:08]you leaving me behind with the woman and the children?

[44:09]The messenger of Allah said to him, "Does it not please you

[44:13]to be to me as Harun was to Musa except that there

[44:16]will be no prophet after me, a prophethood after me?" And I

[44:18]heard him say on the day of, "I shall give the flag

[44:21]to a man who loves Allah and his messenger." And Allah and

[44:23]his messenger love him.

[44:25]We were all hoping for it, but he said, "Call Ali for

[44:28]me." And of course, the third one when this verse was revealed

[44:30]about let us call our sons and your sons.

[44:36]The messenger of Allah called Ali Fat Mass Hussein said, "Oh Allah,

[44:39]these are my family." So we see over here, my dear brothers

[44:42]and sisters, Muawia instituting the abuse on Im Ali.

[44:47]A few hadiths later, you'll see again Muawia asks another Sahabi, what's

[44:52]stopping him from cursing Imm Ali.

[44:55]If you see over here, hadith number 2409, it was narrated that

[45:01]Sahb said a man from the family of Maruan was appointed as

[45:06]governor of in Medina.

[45:06]Look at how a sunnah continued appointed as governor of Medina and

[45:12]he called bin and ordered him to insult Ali but refused.

[45:15]He said if you refuse to do it then at least say

[45:20]may Allah curse Abu Tab.

[45:20]Sah said no name is dearer to Ali than Abu Tab.

[45:25]And he used to feel happy when he was called by it.

[45:29]Sahabi asked Sahabi, "Why don't you curse?" Sahabi asked, "Sahabi, why don't

[45:33]you curse?" Muawia instituted the cursing of Ali.

[45:35]And then you'll get this sheh in clip number five, not four.

[45:40]The last clip, clip number five, you'll get this Sheh with Muawia

[45:44]ordering the cursing of Ali.

[45:48]With Muawia FIGHTING ALI WITH ALLAH SAYS, "Whoever hates Ali is a

[45:51]hypocrite." You'll get a sheh like this sitting I don't know where

[45:53]in America or somewhere there talking in like a Sufi style, mystical

[45:57]style, spiritual style.

[46:01]Listen to the nonsense.

[46:00]Please play clip number five had a huge effect on his generation.

[46:12]He is the sheh of Salahadin Aubi.

[46:13]He is the sheh of Nuredin Zeni.

[46:15]He is the liberator of Palestine.

[46:17]He is the liberator of Syria.

[46:19]He's the one who liberates Jerusalem.

[46:21]He's a huge figure in history.

[46:24]And once this um rafidi rafid are people who reject the sahaba

[46:29]this rafidi came to him he said oh abd you're from mashallah

[46:35]you're huseni and you're so great and you've had such an effect

[46:39]on our time.

[46:41]What do you say about morawya?

[46:43]Ah that's what you want to ask right?

[46:46]What do you say about Morawi?

[46:51]Abdul Kadalani said Abdul Kadani he said I am not worth the

[46:54]dust under the feet of the camel of Muawia when he made

[46:59]jihad with the prophet sallall alaihi wasallam.

[47:00]That's true.

[47:02]He's not exaggerating.

[47:04]He said I'm not worth the dust under the feet of the

[47:07]camel of Muawia when he made jihad with the prophet.

[47:10]Case closed.

[47:13]Wes and fellow Wesnella he doesn't make claims right beware of the

[47:18]maker of claims yeah says I'm not worth the dust under Muawi

[47:33]on the day of are you not worth the dust under which

[47:37]one this overall I even forgot the sheh's name sitting there I'm

[47:41]not worth the dust But you can't generalize.

[47:47]I suppose clip number four will show us that we admitted that

[47:51]was asking people to curse Ali.

[47:53]Sahaba were cursing each other.

[47:55]Play clip number four.

[48:10]That's what we should do.

[48:22]Let's see.

[49:16]summarized it well very very well.

[49:22]None loves Ali but a believer and none hates him but that

[49:25]they're a hypocrite.

[49:24]Couldn't be more clearer than that.

[49:37]Hey, away.

[50:09]Salamore.

[50:39]That's hot.

[51:03]Keep follow

0 تعليقات

التالي

16. Why Did The Sahaba Fight, Abuse & Hate Imam Ali? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

Transcript

التالي

استكشاف المزيد

يرجى ملاحظة أنه إذا كان عمرك أقل من 18 عامًا ، فلن تتمكن من الوصول إلى هذا الموقع.

التالي

16. Why Did The Sahaba Fight, Abuse & Hate Imam Ali? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

Transcript

التالي

استكشاف المزيد

اختيار طريقة الدفع

لغة