Up next

Autoplay

متشيعة من بريطانيا🇬🇧: فتنة مقتل عثمان بن عفان | #ايزدشناس #اكسبلور #shia #shiaislam #shiavssuni

0

0

2 Views· 25/07/23

ايزدشناس
Subscribers

In Lectures

Show more

Transcript

[0:00]leader.

[0:01]Another issue that is often said by the scholars from other schools

[0:09]of thought, the Sunni schools of thought, not all of them because

[0:15]opinion is different uh between different Sunni schools of thought, but there

[0:19]are some that say that although Imam Ali in the battle of

[0:24]Safhine and in the whole issue of contention between Imam Ali and

[0:30]Maawya, Imam Ali was in the right?

[0:33]They accept that Imm Ali was in the right, but that the

[0:38]issue with Maawi was that it was a mistake in Ishihad.

[0:43]That Mahawia attacking Imam Ali was a mistake he had done in

[0:49]Ishtiad.

[0:49]First of all, again looking at this historically at that time ishiad

[0:56]had not yet been developed as a science in Islam.

[1:04]And secondly, when we study closely the sources of Tabari and Baladori

[1:11]who were both Sunni historians, we can see that Mahawi was very

[1:19]determined to have Imam Ali Alisam assassinated because Imam Ali Alisam was

[1:26]not going to accept Maawi as the governor of Syria.

[1:31]Maawya had been made governor of Syria under Uman.

[1:35]And when he saw that Imam Ali was about to come to

[1:40]power, he found some pretexts for entering into this battle with Imam

[1:46]Ali.

[1:46]We can see it was not an error of Ishtihad.

[1:51]It was a matter of deliberate planning according to the sources including

[1:58]the Sunni sources.

[2:00]It was Aisha, Talha and Zuber who were among those who had

[2:07]called for the assassination of man.

[2:11]There are historical records that say how Aisha sent out letters to

[2:19]those who are already disgruntled with the rule of man.

[2:23]And they were headed in the name of the the mother of

[2:28]the believers or the mothers of the believers.

[2:31]And it was understood that it is Aisha sending out the letters

[2:36]calling for the overthrow of man because he had cut her yearly

[2:42]stipend.

[2:42]He had cut her yearly allowance and she was insulted by this.

[2:48]So she was among those who had called for his assassination.

[2:53]There was also unrest in Egypt uh where people felt

0 Comments

Up next

Autoplay

Home

Explore more

Help