Their Hatred Toward Ahlulbayt - Kitab Sulaym & Sahih Bukhari (Fatemiyah 2024)

6 Views· 24/12/11

Sayed Mahdi Modarresi
Subscribers

In Lectures

Delivered in Manchester. Organized by @mancomuk

Transcript

[0:06][Music] m [Applause] [Music] [Music] yeah May [Music] [Music] f [Music] s

[1:53][Music] [Music] Al [Music] Allah [Music] [Music] raise your voices [Music] for

[3:52]the hastening of the reappearance of the master the Savior the Avenger

[3:57]the one who will restore Justice for the oppression of his beloved

[4:07]mother f z recite the loudest salaat muham so that we may

[4:18]receive the privilege and the honor of supporting him in his cause

[4:23]and his campaign to Second louder salaat muhamad so that we may

[4:35]receive the intercession of lady on the day of judgment the day

[4:42]we have no avail the day we are disconnected from everyone and

[4:45]everything the third and the loudest of salawat my dear brothers and

[5:00]sisters we are and have been fighting two parallel Wars ever since

[5:19]that Dreadful Monday the day when rasool was accused of being Delirious

[5:28]of not knowing what he says and the subsequent events that included

[5:37]a Calamity and the ultimate known as s we have been victims

[5:47]of these two Wars happening simultaneously in parallel to one another one

[5:55]is a hot War a war that has led to the shedding

[6:01]of rivers of blood the crime leveled against us is that we

[6:13]have expressed allegiance to the holy messenger and his beloved and blessed

[6:17]family so many have lost their lives and the only thing they

[6:27]have against them is a semblance of Fellowship to the I wish

[6:33]that I and people like me were actual true followers of the

[6:40]but the mere semblance of it the mere hint of being associated

[6:48]to the family of the holy prophet has been a grave enough

[6:53]cardinal sin for which we have been massacred and slaughtered and subjected

[6:59]to to attempted genocide for centuries that's been the hot war and

[7:06]it's ongoing and it will continue to shed even more innocent blood

[7:14]for God knows how long perhaps until the return of our savior

[7:20]parallel to that there's been a soft War raging against us as

[7:28]well that's soft war is in the form of mass deception in

[7:36]the form of the manipulation of facts it's taken the form of

[7:47]twisting reality so that the truth is obfuscated let me give you

[7:52]an example of that to illustrate how this war functions on October

[7:58]17th 20 2023 a bomb exploded in the courtyard of a hospital

[8:11]in Gaza City the hospital's name was Al Arab hospital it's also

[8:17]known as the Baptist hospital because it's run by the Anglican Church

[8:23]when the bomb exploded in the immediate aftermath there were reports of

[8:30]Mass casualties the numbers are of dispute some have put the number

[8:41]and this is the most conservative estimate at just over a 100

[8:47]people killed instantly hundreds more injured however the Gaza Health Ministry put

[8:53]the number at around 400 people killed with that bombing and another

[9:01]500 or so who were non-fatally injured God knows how many of

[9:07]those survived God knows how many of them were later killed either

[9:12]due to their injuries or in the endless Onslaught that that region

[9:20]has seen but we're talking about hundreds of people getting killed mostly

[9:25]women and children why because even though the hospital itself is rather

[9:32]small many people had taken shelter at the hospital now you would

[9:37]think that when a region is being attacked by land air and

[9:41]sea when the bombing campaign has been one of the worst ever

[9:50]witnessed throughout human history that it's pretty obvious who did it we

[9:54]know who the victims are the perpetrators aren't too difficult to identify

[10:00]and yet the truth is anything but simple when you have state

[10:09]sponsored systematic campaigns of misinformation happening the truth will be obfuscated the

[10:16]fact will be twisted and manipulated and so rert Murdoch and his

[10:26]media Empire March in with their cavalries Elon mus and his $44

[10:31]billion social media platform comes to the rescue and so many media

[10:40]Outlets based in the west they began to push this narrative that

[10:45]the bombing occurred as a result of a misfired missile from within

[10:50]Gaza now investigations were conducted later on Forensic Labs got involved media

[11:01]Outlets that were impartial and unbiased they all came together conducted their

[11:09]own investigations and the results were clear the one responsible for the

[11:13]bombing was the Israeli side it wasn't a misfired small rocket that

[11:22]killed four 500 people and injured hundreds more rather this came from

[11:29]the Israeli side now you think that when you are watching the

[11:34]very first televised genocide in history where you have cameras that are

[11:42]reporting live from the site of this massacre youd think that it

[11:49]wouldn't be too difficult to find out who did this and who's

[11:51]responsible for this but you'd be mistaken because try as they would

[12:00]to manipulate ulate public perception they will attempt and exert every effort

[12:06]to muddy the waters and to make the matter too complicated for

[12:14]the average individual watching from their sofa at home in London and

[12:21]Paris and New York and elsewhere to at least at least abandon

[12:26]what we call uh reasonable doubt right to not be so sure

[12:35]and when you can poke even small holes in the facts of

[12:39]the matter you create a narrative that isn't so certain and all

[12:46]they aim for is to remove certainty because once you remove the

[12:51]element of certainty it becomes a case of he said versus she

[12:55]said and while you might sympathize with the victims but you won't

[13:01]experience the same level of Rage as when you actually know who

[13:07]the perpetrator is and so when a massacre of this scale and

[13:14]in the 21st century and before world media coverage and live cameras

[13:23]can be manipulated and distorted in this manner how easy do you

[13:29]think it was for them to obfuscate the facts about the murder

[13:35]of fatat when a small Hut probably 40 50 square meters in

[13:46]size maybe less is surrounded at Night by a hundred Savage men

[13:51]armed to the teeth brought in from outside Medina a tribe known

[13:56]for their barbarity called Beni Aslam they were brought in to police

[14:04]the streets of Medina as the coup leaders established their Authority and

[14:09]struck fear into the hearts of the inhabitants of the city so

[14:13]that no one dares ask who are you why are you doing

[14:18]this we've already pledged our allegiance to Al only a few months

[14:22]before how easy do you think it is to manipulate the facts

[14:28]and to cast doubt and to remove Reasonable Doubt much easier much

[14:36]easier and yet we have people that when you speak to them

[14:43]and I'm not even talking about followers of other sects I'm speaking

[14:47]about self-proclaimed Shia when you talk to them about these facts when

[14:53]you present them with the most glaring reality they respond to you

[15:01]by saying but how can we prove this from bukari how can

[15:06]we prove this from The Works of Muslim and Ahmed Bal andari

[15:13]and I Kath and others a says but how can we prove

[15:19]it almost as though there is a burden of proof that rests

[15:23]on your shoulder and that until you can definitively prove this to

[15:29]people who follow other faiths and denominations it remains a questionable fact

[15:36]at best it's questionable it's riddled with holes well we don't quite

[15:41]know what happened let's leave out the details do these details even

[15:47]matter we've been at War for 14 centuries brothers and sisters this

[15:54]soft war is in fact more damaging because it affects our mindsets

[15:59]it affects our perceptions it affects our beliefs if the hard bloody

[16:09]wars kill us as they have this war is now making I

[16:17]wouldn't say a large number of people but at least a certain

[16:24]segment from within our own communities question reality especially when it comes

[16:29]to Fat Z so you'll have people who say isab really authentic

[16:41]and I'll just mention a couple of examples here even though this

[16:46]isn't my topic about and its authenticity but I just want to

[16:51]mention a couple of points right they'll say things like this in

[17:02]his book he says that and for those of you who don't

[17:09]know about this book it is the very first book to be

[17:15]authored in Islam in Islam No One wrote a book prior to

[17:19]that and even after that for many generations books were not written

[17:25]why weren't they written because they were banned was an official state

[17:33]policy Hadith is not to be transcribed it's not to be collected

[17:37]it's not to be put together in a book form this was

[17:43]a state policy and it was set by the first Khalifa and

[17:50]enforced even more heavily by the second Khalifa to the extent that

[17:55]Abu Hur the famous narrator of Hadith who is a superhero to

[17:59]so many Muslims today he says that there are so many a

[18:05]Hadith that I did not mention because had I done so Omar

[18:10]would have hit me over the head with his Rod he says

[18:13]I had to hide so many ath and clearly he's not talking

[18:18]about the Hadith about the merits of eating onions and whatnot he's

[18:21]talking about more consequential matters he's talking about the things that might

[18:30]jeopardize and undermine the legitimacy of the regime he says I did

[18:36]not speak out in another location he says I did not mention

[18:40]many of the hadiths that I heard from because my throat would

[18:47]be slit so there was an official state policy that hadiths are

[18:52]not to be written Omar once he sent a governor to kufa

[18:56]I think it was Abu musar he sent him to kufa to

[19:00]become the governor and he accompanied him all the way to the

[19:03]gates of Medina as they were leaving he kept giving him some

[19:09]last minute critical instructions as to how to rule over the city

[19:12]of kufa one of the things he said to him was he

[19:16]said listen the people of kufa are uh the kind that enjoy

[19:24]reciting the Holy Quran so don't occupy them with a Hadith right

[19:27]just let them be focused on the Quran the Quran my words

[19:32]not his the Quran is easily misinterpreted right anyone can take any

[19:37]verse of the Quran and kind of twist it and somehow make

[19:41]it work in their favor and so just have them focus on

[19:44]the Quran the Hadith is just going to distract them and so

[19:51]don't go there as for Medina it was banned outright alali who

[19:57]was a companion ofir from Lebanon he was and he came to

[20:06]Medina in the immediate aftermath of the passing of the holy prophet

[20:11]when he came he realized something's not right as in there is

[20:16]a government and there is resistance against the government there is talk

[20:20]about an ambush that's taken place against the house of's name is

[20:27]being floated around something happened to her she's just died she was

[20:31]only 18 years old she was a healthy young woman what's going

[20:36]on too many questions to dismiss and so he started asking questions

[20:40]some of those events he was a witness to the fact that

[20:44]had refused to give his Pledge of Allegiance for the next 6

[20:51]months no less he was witness to all of this others he

[20:53]did what any reporter would do right any journalist he went to

[21:00]the I Witnesses people like Salman people like himself people like Amar

[21:03]Abu and he spoke to them he interviewed them he said to

[21:08]them tell me what happened and so he compiled the book he

[21:14]kept it secret he kept it with him he did not publish

[21:19]it because you could imagine what would happen to him until many

[21:23]years and towards the end of his life uh uh he had

[21:32]a friend named Aban and he went to him he stayed with

[21:38]him and he told him I wish to give you this book

[21:40]of mine the book's actual title is but it's known asab because

[21:47]that was the practice back in the day where the book would

[21:50]be attributed to its author so he told Aban that I wish

[21:58]to tell you of what I learned throughout my investigations and my

[22:02]own uh testimony about the events that transpired in the aftermath of

[22:08]the passing of the holy prophet and so he told him verbally

[22:14]then he gave him a copy of the book just in case

[22:16]here's the written version here's the verbal version i w i want

[22:22]you to keep it and to give it only to those that

[22:25]you trust so this is the story of the book essentially the

[22:31]book contains intricate details about sakif about the events that occurred after

[22:39]the death of the holy prophet about the Ambush on the house

[22:47]of f z and he really expands on this particular incident so

[22:52]then somebody comes along and says in his book he says that

[22:59]the copy of the book that we have now right this is

[23:06]muid about 200 years after the book was authored he says uh

[23:16]thatb is a real individual he is a real companion of there's

[23:23]no question about it he had a book that he compiled and

[23:27]there's no question about it either the only issue I have is

[23:33]is this the actual book of or has the book been tampered

[23:42]with was the book when scribes were trying to copy it uh

[23:46]were changes introduced into the book were mistakes made right for example

[23:51]they often cite two mistakes in the book one about the number

[23:57]of imams being 13 rather than 12 where the the prophet says

[24:00]to Amir you and your 12 IM and the 12 imams after

[24:07]you right which you can imagine can be an easy mistake to

[24:10]make when a scribe is copying the book right and the other

[24:14]one is about Muhammad abib Bakr telling his father who was on

[24:19]his deathbed certain things and so historians say that Muhammad AB Bakr

[24:22]was too young at the time he must have been one or

[24:26]two years old and so this doesn't add up so two you

[24:30]can call them mistakes blunders whatever you want but you can understand

[24:34]how such a mistake can conceivably be made in unintentionally inadvertently right

[24:42]what does he say he says that this book's chain of transmission

[24:50]back to Su is questionable in other words those people that took

[24:56]the book from Aban and then handed it over one person to

[25:03]another reaching a muid says that we can't really rely on every

[25:10]single one of those individuals some of them are not known well

[25:16]enough some of them um there might be some question marks so

[25:19]he casts doubt about the chain of transmission so far so good

[25:26]and if you took this statement by she Al muid then you

[25:29]would be excused for thinking that she muid does not consider the

[25:35]book reliable and therefore at least according to his methodology the book

[25:37]should be placed on a shelf and not quoted or cited correct

[25:44]however and I've noticed this being done by charlatans all over the

[25:49]place all over the place they actually show you a picture of

[25:56]the book by Al muid and they quote him acting as though

[26:02]they're being super objective right and careful this is what said look

[26:07]the book is not reliable one line before that one line Al

[26:12]mu says while the majority of the contents of the book are

[26:17]accurate however the chain of transmission of the book itself is unreliable

[26:23]so what's mu saying he's saying the contents of the book are

[26:28]consistent with everything else that we know is verifying the themes of

[26:37]the book the contents of the book The Facts of the book

[26:40]he's saying they the majority are accurate and you are able to

[26:47]believe in them and accept them although he has a technical problem

[26:51]with the chain of transmission and that's a critical point which is

[26:59]what that the tradition mentioned inab are consistent with other sources and

[27:07]also they are Corr corroborated by other reports and also the of

[27:15]the but the charlatans try as they may they don't quote mu

[27:24]correctly number one number two they present as being the only source

[27:30]that the Shia must rely on in order to prove the attack

[27:37]and the Ambush on the house of fat zah when in fact

[27:39]that's not true either we have so many other sources some Scholars

[27:45]have put the number of other sources that definitively prove the Ambush

[27:50]on the house of fatat zah and the martyrdom and the killing

[27:57]of FAA and her unborn fetus at over 70 sour being one

[28:04]of them even though itself is reliable is the one who says

[28:10]I don't deem the chain to be TR to be reliable but

[28:12]others have different methodologies for the verification of the chains of transmission

[28:17]and so many scholars consider this book to be reliable on the

[28:24]whole again there might be minor mistakes and minute issues here and

[28:27]there but but on the whole Ali reports from kab the eminent

[28:36]scholar a quote from in fact is considered one of the 400

[28:47]fundamental sources of Hadith which were verified either through the authentication of

[28:54]the imams themselves in other words these books were presented to IM

[28:58]am to Imad and the scholars the companions they would say to

[29:04]the imams do you approve of the contents of these books and

[29:06]the Imam would go through them and say yes I do 400

[29:11]fundamental sources were either authenticated by the IM imams or they were

[29:16]authenticated by a consensus among the earliest of our Scholars and kab

[29:21]is one of them why am I saying all of this I'm

[29:27]saying it because they will try to the waters through different means

[29:32]one of them is to poke holes in the sources that we

[29:41]have available and try and exploit people's ignorance because when you show

[29:48]a statement from mu but not show the cont context what happens

[29:51]someone who's not going to bother to go back to the original

[29:54]book of muid is going to say oh hang on a second

[29:58]muid said this but many people don't even know they don't know

[30:04]relied on this book but most people are too ignorant to understand

[30:08]these things but they're being exploited they're being manipulated that's number one

[30:15]number two one of the techniques used in this soft war of

[30:18]manipulation and deception is called information overload when you give people too

[30:26]much information and you say said this say said that said that

[30:29]and this and that and that and then you've got 50 browser

[30:31]tabs open in front of you suddenly you're like okay so you

[30:35]know there's two sides to this discussion and when there is two

[30:41]sides to the discussion you cannot issue a verdict it has to

[30:45]be Beyond a reasonable doubt you won't have certainty and we need

[30:51]certainty that's one technique another technique I want to share with you

[30:59]is in a nutshell redaction alari mentions a Hadith under a heading

[31:09]in volume one ofi listen carefully to this he has a uh

[31:18]chapter heading called by the way this is one of his techniques

[31:27]right bukari would omit certain facts certain words certain uh truths about

[31:34]an incident present you with the bare bones right to make it

[31:40]really obscure and weird and that would be his uh resorting to

[31:47]redaction and Omission another thing he used was he would put a

[31:55]Hadith somewhere and give it a completely irrelevant chapter heading so you'd

[31:59]read the chapter heading and you might even because you now have

[32:02]created a a a preconceived notion of what the Hadith is going

[32:09]to be about right when it says the chapter on getting angry

[32:13]while advising someone and then you go on to read the Hadith

[32:19]you're constantly thinking to yourself This Hadith is about getting angry while

[32:22]giving advice or that you shouldn't get angry when you give advice

[32:27]to someone right but you'll miss the Crux of the Hadith the

[32:30]main point is going to be opusc so here's what he does

[32:35]bukari as I said is a master redactor someone should write a

[32:41]PhD thesis about the deceptions of bukari in particular when it comes

[32:44]to redacting a Hadith and taking them completely out of context and

[32:47]reducing them to the Bare Bones minimum so the chapter title is

[32:51]what getting angry while giving advice okay bukari what's this about out

[33:02]he starts off by saying that was asked a series of questions

[33:06]the prophet didn't like those questions okay hang on a second don't

[33:11]don't ask any questions just bear with me the prophet didn't like

[33:18]the questions then he says he was asked more questions so he

[33:24]became angry then rasool Allah said ask me anything you want then

[33:31]someone got up and said to the prophet who is my father

[33:36]so the prophet told him you're an illegitimate child the one who

[33:40]you think is your father is not your actual father then another

[33:43]person got up and said who is my father and Allah said

[33:47]well your father is you know the mailman and it's not the

[33:50]person that you think he is then L listen to this then

[33:57]Omar came toool and he said to him yahool Allah I seek

[34:01]forgiveness from Allah so the prophet stopped okay I have so many

[34:09]questions number one the prophet was asked questions so uh he became

[34:16]annoyed by them what questions why would the prophet be annoyed with

[34:21]people's questions this is this is the one about whom Allah says

[34:29]why would he be annoyed why would he hate those questions what

[34:34]were the questions number one number two he was asked more questions

[34:38]he became angry all of a sudden well why is he getting

[34:42]angry am I missing something then after getting annoyed and angry then

[34:48]says ask me anything you want something is not right something's doesn't

[34:52]add up he's getting angry and annoyed but then he says keep

[34:56]asking me questions then why does go on this campaign of exposing

[35:04]people about being illegitimate children in public why would he do something

[35:12]like that does that make any sense to you suddenly he's exposing

[35:15]people he's saying you you you you you your fathers aren't who

[35:19]you think you are don't bother with the D DNA test come

[35:25]on are you taking us as fools What's Happening Here then the

[35:30]biggest question of all when the prophet starts exposing individuals of being

[35:36]illegitimate children Omar suddenly comes to the prophet and says to him

[35:40]I seek forgiveness from Allah from what from what what what was

[35:49]this sin that he committed that now he's subtly jumping and begging

[35:54]the prophet to forgive him so that the prophet doesn't keep going

[36:00]on on and doesn't expose him perhaps what's going on here man

[36:06]all right bear with me so this is the version in bukari

[36:12]as I said he's a master redactor the guy was the most

[36:15]dishonest person I've come across in my entire professional life W if

[36:22]you want to know the context of this story and fill in

[36:26]the 6,000 blanks that you're kind of confused about in your brain

[36:30]right now you have to go and look at other secondary sources

[36:36]and so you go to by for example the entire purpose of

[36:42]the book of was to fill in the blanks left by bukari

[36:47]and Muslim just putting out all the fires that's what Alim andri

[36:50]did and even though isn't the most honest and reliable narrator of

[36:59]Hadith himself but he did a much better job of filling on

[37:03]filling those blanks and so his book as well as plenty of

[37:07]others in fact if you do a quick search online and look

[37:12]for the words you'll understand the context of this Hadith so you'll

[37:22]come across different variations of this expression that I just told you

[37:38]um another version says right basically the story goes like this on

[37:55]multiple occasions those Within the closed circle of rasool the so-called companions

[38:02]they would address family members of the holy prophet by telling them

[38:10]do you think that just because you're related to him he's going

[38:14]to benefit you look at the Envy look at the hatred look

[38:20]at the jealousy the hatred brothers and sisters was such that we

[38:26]don't even need to know what these people were capable of doing

[38:30]after had left this world the hatred they exhibited to the very

[38:36]daughter of is so obvious in these Hadith which are reported in

[38:44]their own books so on multiple occasions they would say to different

[38:48]members of the Holy prophet's household on one of those occasions IB

[38:52]Abbas says that we were excuse mear Abdullah Omar he says that

[38:57]we were sitting close to the house of a woman walked past

[39:02]us so a man said this is the daughter of so another

[39:12]man addressed her and said this expression what does this actually mean

[39:26]it means that the example of Muhammad they don't even address him

[39:34]as the messenger of God the example of Muhammad among his family

[39:37]is like a palm tree in a dumpster or a flower in

[39:47]a swamp a palm tree in a garbage yard meaning that yeah

[39:52]Muhammad is exempt or for now at least until he's still alive

[39:55]we won't say anything about him but for his family nothing but

[40:00]garbage this was said to F this was said to safia the

[40:10]prophet's Aunt this was said to different members of the on multiple

[40:16]occasions using different expressions in fact this became such a consistent theme

[40:22]thatn Zu who was an avowed enemy of the ah bit I

[40:28]Zu makes two statements which are Earth shattering one of them remember

[40:36]the story ofn Zu he took control of Mecca and Medina he

[40:40]declared himself the Khalifa and eventually he was killed uh in Mecca

[40:45]while seeking refuge in the sanctuary IBN Zu when he took over

[40:49]Medina he Unleashed his unbelievable vitreal against the family of rasol Allah

[40:58]and he made two statements or more actually but two that I

[41:03]want to site tonight which are Earth shattering one of them is

[41:06]that he said to them the tribe of himself used to say

[41:16]which means they would say this over and over again the example

[41:28]of Muhammad Within Hashim is like a tree that bears fruit but

[41:33]is unfortunately inside a garbage dump that's one statement that he makes

[41:39]and proves that this was something that that was said over and

[41:44]over again the second statement is he comes to Muhammed the son

[41:49]of Al who was the most senior figure in Ben Hashim and

[41:52]he said to him either you come and give me your Pledge

[41:57]of Allegiance or I will burn down your home the way your

[42:00]the the your father's house the house of was burnt down I

[42:08]will burn your door the way the door of FAA was burnt

[42:13]which tells you again that this was quite well known Subhan Allah

[42:22]Subhan Allah the example of rol Allah and his family is that

[42:27]of a palm tree in a garbage yard now another way bukari

[42:36]has tried to obscure and op escate this incident and not say

[42:41]what happened is that he's included it in other chapters essentially the

[42:46]link between the Hadith that I mentioned earlier and this one is

[42:49]this when the statement was uttered to safia or to fa or

[42:55]to other members of the whichever it might be she started crying

[43:02]safia and she went back toool Allah crying the prophet said to

[43:07]her why are you crying my aunt she said I'm crying because

[43:10]so and so told me that we the family of R Allah

[43:17]are like garbage we're nothing we deserve no respect for being related

[43:24]to you Soo got so angry that he got up and and

[43:27]he told B tell everyone to come to prayer to the Masjid

[43:33]even though it wasn't prayer time when they heard the prophet calling

[43:39]for prayer they assumed that the prophet was going to war they

[43:44]said we looked at the anger in the face of and we

[43:47]assumed that he was going to war so we got all of

[43:51]our weapons all of our swords and Spears and we came to

[43:55]the Masid ready to fight we came to the Masid got upon

[43:59]the member and he said who's going to excuse the fact that

[44:05]you are hurting me like this why would you make a statement

[44:09]like that do you know who I am they said the prophet

[44:15]said then I will introduce myself to you anyway I am Muhammad

[44:19]the son of Abdullah the son of Abdul mutalib the son of

[44:25]Hashim the son of Adnan and he began to list his holy

[44:29]ancestors that the Quran speaks about when it when Allah subhah wa

[44:33]ta'ala says and your movement from one prostrates every single one of

[44:47]the prophet's ancestors were prophets and Messengers The Prophet introduced himself he

[44:51]says this is who I am meaning you want to know who

[44:56]my family is this is my family now who wants to know

[44:59]about his family this is what happened the prophet was asked a

[45:05]question it annoyed him that it angered him that makes no sense

[45:10]and now it does the prophet said who wants me to tell

[45:14]him who his ancestors are so anyone who dared to ask would

[45:19]tell him that you're an illegitimate child you're an illegitimate child then

[45:29]the head of the one of the biggest tribes at the time

[45:35]Al who was he got up he pulled out his sword he

[45:39]said y just give me a name just tell me who said

[45:45]this and I will have his head whether he's from My Tribe

[45:51]Al I will have his head or if he's from the I

[45:56]will have his head just give me the name and so so

[45:59]suddenly again this is in the head of the who was he

[46:04]was a hypocrite he was one of the people who participated in

[46:07]s he wanted the for himself but they ended up killing him

[46:10]and they blamed the Jin by the way they said the Jin

[46:23]killed him Subhan Allah eliminated this threat anyway so who was a

[46:28]good companion a righteous loyal companion of rol Allah he said just

[46:31]give me the name and I will have his head Yol Allah

[46:35]the head of the got up and he said you wouldn't dare

[46:39]touch any one of us you only say that because you have

[46:41]a vendetta against my tribe because they were at War prior to

[46:45]theith says in Sunni sources it says in the presence of they

[46:58]began pelting each other with stones and slippers they started punching each

[47:02]other so somebody got up and said have you no shame is

[47:08]right there on the mimar what is wrong with you what kind

[47:14]of animals get into fist fights in the presence of rol sit

[47:18]down you Shameless animals and so and by the way that wasn't

[47:22]the first or the last time they had actual physical brawls in

[47:27]the presence of we know what happened in when they deserted their

[47:31]posts looking after the booties of War we know the fights they

[47:35]had amongst themselves over The Spoils of War my point is this

[47:44]this is the context of the story and it tells you how

[47:52]intense this war was I'll give you a couple more examples and

[47:57]wrap up the uh um again in bukari it says that uh

[48:05]the same story is mentioned under another heading this time it's even

[48:09]more deceptive The Heading is uh translated it means the chapter on

[48:22]kneeling down in the presence of the Imam as he teaches you

[48:29]so you'd think this is about the rewards of kneeling down or

[48:34]about the etiquettes of kneeling down or how to sit or what

[48:38]direction right it's got nothing to do with that the heading is

[48:42]misleading you read the Hadith and it says that one day was

[48:48]sitting down and he said who wants me to tell him who

[48:51]his father is again out of the blue so a couple of

[48:55]people dared to ask the prophet shut them down and then Omar

[49:03]suddenly sat on his two knees he kneel down and he said

[49:08]y please stop whoa whoa whoa whoa let's not go there let's

[49:11]not talk about fathers and mothers and aunts and grandmothers and the

[49:14]family tree let's not go there again you read this and it

[49:24]makes no sense until you go and dig up a little deeper

[49:26]and you find out what is actually happening and why would Omar

[49:32]be the one to apologize and beg the prophet to stop why

[49:37]him had he not had something to do with that accusation that

[49:45]comment that disrespects the holy prophet himself let alone his family it's

[49:54]a war it's a war of ideas it's a war of facts

[49:56]it's a war of Truth Versus Falsehood and as I said last

[50:03]night f z set the record straight you don't need any of

[50:10]that I don't need kab to know what these people were capable

[50:18]of I don't need that book or other sources to explain to

[50:25]me the level of hatred they harbored towards fa and Ali and

[50:32]Hassan and Hussein it's glaringly obvious it's so clear and so ultimately

[50:38]it comes down to the basic facts Abdullah Hassan was asked the

[50:43]question they told him what is your position VAV the two he

[50:50]didn't even need to violate the rules of he said our mother

[51:00]was called sik meaning that she is overly truthful excessively truthful and

[51:11]she was she was the daughter of the Prophet number two number

[51:18]three she became angry with them and we are angry for her

[51:32]anger end of discussion someone says to you next time that oh

[51:35]you have a problem with companions just say no no no absolutely

[51:38]not we have no problem with anyone but I have a principle

[51:44]in my life that where the Prophet says fa is the barometer

[51:58]of God's pleasure and God's anger I will synchronize my pleasure and

[52:05]my anger with that of fa that's it FAA was angry with

[52:07]someone I will be angry at that person come with me come

[52:13]with me I'm I'm simply angry with them why are you angry

[52:20]with me f was angry with them I'm angry along side fa

[52:23]there's a poem in which the uh the author auth of the

[52:32]poem says F dies while she's angry at someone and we become

[52:37]pleased with them that is not the work of a good righteous

[52:42]child of this mother my mother was angry with them I'm angry

[52:50]with them f z set the record straight fat zah spoke to

[52:55]them in a manner that leaves no room for confusion or doubt

[53:01]or ambiguity none whatsoever F made a call to Arms in her

[53:06]fedia sermon and by the way fedya sermon is narrated in their

[53:15]sources before it was narrated and compiled in our sources by a

[53:23]a book called The eloquence of women the author included the sermon

[53:28]in there because he noticed how eloquent it was probably missed the

[53:32]point didn't get the memo as to what the sermon was actually

[53:38]about disrobing this illegitimate regime and in that sermon f z makes

[53:43]a call to Arms he says why are you dozing off when

[53:57]my my right has been usurped why are you sleeping and careless

[54:02]and indifferent when I have been oppressed she says to them you

[54:09]have the power you have the strength so get up do something

[54:13]about it they will try to manipulate they will try to distort

[54:16]the fact you know there is an entire discussion in the uh

[54:23]history books of our opponents about the number of gray hairs in

[54:31]the prophet's beard did you know that some have said it was

[54:35]17 others have argued intensely that no it was 18 that level

[54:41]of detail that level of nuance how many gray hairs another person

[54:45]then came along and said no no no no no you're all

[54:48]mistaken in fact there were 20 strands of hair that were gray

[54:54]in the prophet's beard and you might say Well I'm I mean

[54:56]that is relevant information that's good to know how many strands of

[55:02]gray hair the prophet had in his blessed beard sure I I

[55:05]would love to know that the problem isn't there the problem is

[55:10]when they discuss more important issues and you see how this attention

[55:16]to detail all of a sudden disappears completely I'll give you one

[55:22]example of that says that when uhan perceived Abu to be somewhat

[55:30]of a threat to his government and to his security and his

[55:34]legitimacy man was going around speaking out mentioning the merits and virtues

[55:40]of Amir the whole time speaking about corrupt rulers embezzling public funds

[55:47]and acting with favoritism and nepotism and stealing and lying and cheating

[55:54]and so he became a threat so what didan do he exiled

[56:02]him to Sham he sent him to jab the south of Lebanon

[56:05]and within I don't know how many days but the south of

[56:12]Lebanon was now beaming with the love of until this day thanks

[56:18]to and so they said no no no no he can't be

[56:22]in the south of Lebanon let's ship him to Damascus so he

[56:26]goes to Damascus as soon as he arrives into the city he

[56:28]notices mua on the mimar and so he picks up a few

[56:33]uh Pebbles and starts to throw them in the direction of muaah

[56:39]they say to him what are you doing this is mua is

[56:40]giving a sermon he said well I don't know I just heard

[56:45]say that if you see mu on my member whoever sees him

[56:55]should Pelt him with stones right by the way who's one of

[57:02]the uh most um authoritative most famous uh wahhabi leaders contemporary wahhabi

[57:09]leaders from Saudi Arabia he said no no no no you you

[57:12]misunderstood the Hadith didn't say he simply took one dot from the

[57:24]top of the word brought it down very simply and he changed

[57:29]if you see him on the member Embrace him accept him that's

[57:35]what the prophet actually said this is the soft war that we're

[57:38]up against this is what we have to deal with just like

[57:43]one of their Scholars Subhan Allah look at what they did to

[57:53]famously saysi he came and he said no you've misund understood the

[58:07]Hadith the prophet didn't say he said you are to me like

[58:18]was to M allahar this is what they do anyway so says

[58:24]that Abu became a kind of a nuisance in Damascus muaah sent

[58:31]a message back to his cousin in Medina saying take him back

[58:35]I can't have him here he's going to change public opinion about

[58:41]me he's a companion of everybody knows him so he was exiled

[58:45]back to Medina when he reaches this point listen to what he

[58:50]does he says when he came backman had no choice but to

[58:56]Exile him back to R which was his hometown that Abu never

[58:59]wanted to go back to because he was a polytheist he was

[59:03]a mushrik when he was there he had you know memories that

[59:05]he didn't want to live once again he didn't want to go

[59:10]back there butman was forced to send him back there because certain

[59:13]things were said between the two conversations happened Abu said things to

[59:18]which I don't want to get into so the number of gray

[59:25]strands of hair we need to get into that pages and pages

[59:29]of books have to be authored about this but what happened between

[59:34]the companions let's just put that you know Shelf at somewhere water

[59:39]under the bridge let's not get into those things those disputes I

[59:44]mean it's like your parents fighting would you get involved where your

[59:47]parents get into a fight you wouldn't do that somebody once said

[59:50]this to me would you get involved would you pick a side

[59:54]I mean it's your parents this is your mother this is your

[59:55]father and they're having problems they're having a fight it's like the

[59:58]early companions they're like our parents I said look maybe I wouldn't

[60:03]get involved if it was like a simple disagreement but if one

[60:06]of my parents killed the other you'd be sure as hell that

[60:11]I would get involved but F left no room for confusion after

[60:23]the passing ofo the Hadith says she had a headband on her

[60:43]forehead he spent those 95 days after the passing of crying nonstop

[61:33]her cries were louder than any other voice her cries spoke volumes

[61:47]about her oppression which is why they didn't want to hear FAA

[61:56]cry she was Ill the whole time can you imagine the pain

[62:10]the agony a rib that is broken an eye that is bruised

[62:24][Music] a back with a mark of the sheath of The Sword

[62:34]and the whip of and don't even ask me about the nail

[62:47]as one of our Scholars says don't ask me ask the nail

[62:55]itself what happened [Laughter] [Music] and she was Ill her health deteriorating

[63:34]day after day after day until the final day arrived that day

[63:47]fa Z was up early she looked healthy she brought her children

[63:58]she bathed them she probably brushed the hair of Lady Z for

[64:05]the last time such that the children when they saw that their

[64:14]mother had gotten up she was now doing all these things for

[64:20]them they said you look so much better alhamdulillah maybe you're recover

[64:31]you've recovered you've looked so much better than before you were in

[64:36]bed most of the time and now you're up Fatima must have

[64:44]been silently saying no rather this is my last day last night

[64:49]I saw my father in my dream and he said to me

[65:00]just as I promised you on my death bag that you will

[65:07]be the first person to join me my sweetheart fa I am

[65:18]eagerly waiting for you tomorrow you will be my guest so FAA

[65:24]somehow musters up the energy to get up and to look after

[65:32]the children as she did before when she was healthy then she

[65:38]sends Z andum to some woman's home to one of their relatives

[65:44]as for Hassan and Hussein she says to them go to the

[65:51]mid to your father she doesn't want the children around when the

[65:57]moment comes instead she says to Asma she says to her as

[66:01]I think this is my last day on this Earth finally I

[66:06]will get to go and complain to somebody I couldn't complain to

[66:13]because I didn't want to hurt him but I will get to

[66:20]complain to my father she says to her that I will go

[66:24]into my room in order to pray and recite the Quran if

[66:35]you see me go quiet call my name if I respond to

[66:42]you then so be it if I don't respond then you should

[66:46]know that I have left this D I don't know when it

[66:56]was that father left her instructions to was it before that or

[67:04]was it after she went into that room but that was a

[67:06]heartbreaking moment when she called her husband she said to [Applause] him

[67:18]have you ever known me to have hurt you to have disobeyed

[67:24]you to have mistreated Beed you burst into tears the IM [Applause]

[67:33]said you are nothing but the best wife for me the best

[67:41]mother to my children not once did you disobey me then the

[67:47]Hadith says he held her head and placed on his chest he

[67:54]cried and she cried then she said to him yeah Hassan I

[68:01]have some instructions to leave you if you can execute my instructions

[68:05]then so be it if you can't for any reason maybe you

[68:13]have received instructions fromo maybe there are things that you cannot do

[68:18]that's okay but I would love for you to do what I

[68:20]ask of you the IM said tell me anything so she tell

[68:31]told him when I die I want you to prepare my body

[68:41]at [Applause] night and when it's time to bury me do so

[68:58]at night and in secret why she said because I don't want

[69:07]them to attend my funeral I don't want them to come and

[69:11]witness my burial I don't want them to shed crocodile tears over

[69:19]my body I don't want them to be anywhere near me because

[69:22]I'm going to complain about them to my [Music] father cried and

[69:32]cried so now f zah is in her room she's reciting the

[69:40]Quran The Voice Fades and Fades and Fades until there is not

[69:44]a there is nothing coming out of the room says is worried

[69:53]F zah doesn't respond Asma calls out her name once again doesn't

[70:03]respond Asma rushes into the room only to find fa had departed

[70:08]this world Asma begins to scream suddenly Hassan and Hussein come into

[70:17]the house Asma tries to block them from coming into the room

[70:23]they say Asma where is is our mother Asma says that she's

[70:30]sleeping Imam Al Hassan says no this is not the time of

[70:32]her sleeping our mother wouldn't sleep right now where is she they

[70:39]sense something is wrong they Rush inside the room to find their

[70:45]mother had died listen to this IM Hassan rushes to his mother's

[70:50]headside Imam Hussein goes towards her feet he grabs the feet and

[71:00]starts kissing them saying my mother speak to me my mother say

[71:08]something allahar IM Hassan says the same thing at that moment they're

[71:18]crying as wants to distract them she says to them go and

[71:21]call your father they run while crying back to the Masid when

[71:28]they get to the Masid imagine these two orphans they run inside

[71:32]the Masid some of the companions Salman and others they see them

[71:38]what's happened to you why are you crying like this they say

[71:44]a our mother's dead our mother's dead they say got up he

[71:56]took his turban and threw it to the ground who plucked open

[72:08]the gate of from the Masid back to the home the Imam

[72:12]fell down multiple times the Imam went back to his home I'll

[72:32]mention this it's the last night of the mjus the Imam after

[72:39]he prepared the body of F at night there were things that

[72:47]happened the Imam burst into tears at one point the Imam placed

[72:50]his forehead against the wall and cried out loud he cried and

[72:57]cried as told him you're telling us to cry quietly but you're

[73:02]crying loudly what happened he said don't blame me you didn't see

[73:08]what I saw you didn't see what I saw FAA was trying

[73:15]to hide this from me the whole time 95 days of constant

[73:20]pain she hid the side of her face and I got to

[73:27]see it for the first time and she hid that dent in

[73:32]her chest and I touched it for the first time there are

[73:39]things that happened on that night prepared the body of fa he

[73:49]was about to wrap the Shroud he made a dreadful call he

[73:53]said yah Hass yah Hussein [Applause] say your final farewells for this

[74:12]is the final goodbye they came into the room IM says they

[74:17]came and they cried with such intensity that she sigh and she

[74:32]raised her hands and embraced her children such that a call was

[74:40]made a voice in the heavens remove them from their mother for

[74:47]the Angels cannot stop crying over this scene allahar Allah cried all

[75:00]the children cried and when the IM lowered her into her grave

[75:08]as soon as the Imam was separated from his beloved wife fa

[75:17]by the by the sand of the Grave the Imam suddenly lost

[75:21]it his emotions came pouring out what did the Imam do he

[75:28]looked in the direction of the grave of he said peace be

[75:44]upon you and your daughter who is your neighbor tonight she is

[75:51]your guest tonight it's as if was so shy of remembers when

[76:00]the prophet placed the hand of F into his hand while he

[76:07]was on his deathbed he said yah Ali this is my trust

[76:10]look after my daughter is almost ashamed and embarrassed not that he

[76:22]had not done what he had to do it's almost like when

[76:25]Abbas was ashamed to go back to the tent he had done

[76:31]everything he could everything in his power and yet he was still

[76:35]ashamed of going back said to the holy prophet he said I'm

[76:45]giving you the trust back but I am sad to say she's

[76:54]not the way you gave her to me she was snatched away

[76:56]from my hands then he said something he said I want you

[77:08]to ask her what happened between the wall and the door because

[77:12]she would never tell me this is what the used to do

[77:20]I'll wrap up with this and I do apologize May f z

[77:25]intercede for all of you may f z relieve us of these

[77:29]afflictions against our brothers and sisters against the school said insist on

[77:39]your daughter to tell you what they did to her spoke to

[77:45]this was a means of consolation for the every time they were

[77:49]Afflicted they would turn toool who picked up on this lesson A

[77:57]Little Orphan called Z which is why on the day of a

[78:09]z came instead of looking at the pile of arrows and Spears

[78:17]and addressing abah she looked in the direction of Medina she said

[78:27][Applause] do you remember who this is this is your Hussein look

[78:39]at [Applause] him his turban is taken off his AB is taken

[78:54]off y Allah look at him [Music]

0 Comments

Up next

Their Hatred Toward Ahlulbayt - Kitab Sulaym & Sahih Bukhari (Fatemiyah 2024)

Transcript

Up next

Explore more

Please note that if you are under 18, you won't be able to access this site.

Up next

Their Hatred Toward Ahlulbayt - Kitab Sulaym & Sahih Bukhari (Fatemiyah 2024)

Transcript

Up next

Explore more

Choose a payment method

Language