9. Three Rightly Guided Caliphs, or Four? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2025

7 المشاهدات· 25/03/09

Sayed Ammar Nakshawani Official
مشتركين

في محاضرات

9. Three Rightly Guided Caliphs, or Four? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2025 👉 http://bit.ly/AmmarNakshawani #AmmarNakshawani #Ramadan2025 Subscribe now to Sayed Ammar’s official online platform 👉 https://www.sayedammar.com - consisting of bespoke courses, exclusive content, brand new podcasts & more!

أظهر المزيد

Transcript

[0:04]Sal [Music] [Music] that's keep follow [Applause] hey hey he [Music] [Music]

[2:02]in the name of Allah the most beneficent the most merciful all

[2:06]praise is due to the Lord master of all the worlds and

[2:09]peace and blessings be on All His prophets and especially the final

[2:13]Prophet The Prophet Muhammad s my dear brothers and sisters for rightly

[2:24]guided cffs or is it three rightly guided cffs or is it

[2:30]five rightly guided cffs or are there more rightly guided cffs one

[2:34]of the most interesting discussions that you'll come across is the famous

[2:38]Sunni opinion that's spread in virtually the whole of the Sunni world

[2:44]that the four best people after the holy prophet peace be upon

[2:48]him and his family are Abu Bakr omaran and Ali and indeed

[2:54]this is often used as an argument against us that look we

[2:57]love Ali as well you are not the only ones who rever

[3:02]Ali Ali is our fourth khif Ali is the fourth person after

[3:07]the holy prophet peace be appointment's family to lead the Islamic State

[3:14]historically speaking of course that is the order of the cffs but

[3:18]alongside that order you have a couple of Notions that emerge the

[3:21]first is that these are all rightly guided and that you will

[3:28]find that these are the very representatives and embodiment of the path

[3:33]of the holy prophet peace be upon him and his family but

[3:36]the second one is that this was always the unanimous opinion of

[3:42]what we know today as that from the day died they never

[3:53]differed about abak being the first Khalifa No One raised an objection

[3:56]no one had a difference it's as if Abu Bakr was chosen

[4:02]by Allah when we know he was chosen at sakif and Omar

[4:04]was chosen by Allah when we know he was appointed by the

[4:08]first Khalif andman was chosen by Allah when we know the option

[4:12]was Ali first and thenan and then ultimately Imam Ali it's as

[4:19]if he was chosen by Allah for us yes he was at

[4:21]least 25 years before he assumed the innovation of the caliphate of

[4:28]sakif so you find therefore that if you ask anyone who's Sunni

[4:31]what is the order of the cffs after the prophet they'll say

[4:33]to you four as if that has become a tenant of Faith

[4:39]but when we open this discussion we'll see that the text themselves

[4:47]and the works of Hadith do not agree that there was four

[4:54]as the only cffs four as the rightly guided cffs and that's

[4:59]a variety of opinions even emerge as to who should be number

[5:04]four who should be number five and one may even argue that

[5:06]some will point us that there are even more than five that

[5:11]the holy prophet spoke about himself number of questions then also emerge

[5:15]if someone's rightly guided what happens if you fight them what happens

[5:20]if you raise an Army against them what happens if you don't

[5:25]obey them say for example the first Khalif is seen as a

[5:28]Khalifa who is guided in the path of the Prophet peace be

[5:33]upon his family what if for example you don't pay him zakat

[5:36]and you don't acknowledge his caliphate what would happen to you what

[5:39]would happen if you raised an Army against one of the four

[5:41]rightly guided KFA what I want to show you tonight is that

[5:48]this conception of the for rightly guided Cals was never an early

[5:51]agreed upon belief otherwise the question automatically is raised how do and

[5:57]muaah fight the rightly guided fourth Calif that all sunnis agree on

[6:02]and when we look therefore at this discussion three rightly guided KFA

[6:08]four rightly guided five rightly guided I will show you tonight that

[6:11]the Sunni world has never been unanimous on this opinion and also

[6:15]that it took them a long time to even acknowledge im as

[6:20]the fourth Khalifa today yes you meet anyone who sun say Ali

[6:23]is my fourth khif but when you look early as I'm going

[6:27]to look early at the earliest texts you'll see that on the

[6:33]contrary this idea idea of of one of the above the other

[6:36]was never agreed upon there are differences about even the order of

[6:40]and precedence and Excellence but also at the same time when you

[6:46]look in the it works and we said I don't know when

[6:51]I speak to a Sunni are you a are you an are

[6:53]you a are you a salafi are you are you are you

[6:58]and are you because there's so many subdivision of that you can't

[7:01]figure out who they are but when you actually open the works

[7:05]of you'll see that this whole idea that there are four rightly

[7:08]guided Cals is something that the Sunni world has never agreed on

[7:13]just because it's become generalized in the world today let's look at

[7:17]early Sunni Islam and let's see what they agreed on and what

[7:20]they differed on come with me here to this first text the

[7:26]foundation of the Sunnah authored by Imam Ahmed bhel all of you

[7:29]could see over here here the foundations of the Sunnah ahed died

[7:32]241 after hij so that's 230 years after died this particular work

[7:42]as we know is an work when you look at this particular

[7:44]text this text it is called the foundation of what the foundation

[7:52]of the Sunnah so when a text is called the foundation of

[7:54]the sunn it's giving me the of come with me to page

[8:00]25 over here all of you come and let's see what it

[8:05]says over here there's some very interesting points about early that if

[8:09]someone was to ask you what is early look what it says

[8:14]over here you'll see my dear brother sisters at number 39 and

[8:17]the best of this umah after its Prophet s is Abu Bak

[8:26]then meant to be Omar thenan bin afan we give precedence to

[8:40]those three just as the companions of the messenger of Allah Sall

[8:45]alai gave precedence to them they the companions never differed in that

[8:50]all of the companions of all of them agreed that the best

[8:55]three Companions of are abak Omar and notice here if we come

[9:05]back says the best of this um after the prophet is Abu

[9:10]where's where is often credited as the man who believed in four

[9:18]rightly guided K that before him there are different opinions as to

[9:22]whether someone before him or after him but Ahmed he has given

[9:28]a lot of credit to IM Ali in works like even in

[9:30]his mus and other works of his but here in the foundations

[9:36]of the Sunnah 200 years after has died I've got a text

[9:45]which says the best of this um after its Prophet is Abu

[9:51]bakik then then ban then it says we give precedence to those

[9:57]three not those four normally you hear that the Sunni World believes

[10:05]in four rightly guided K not three here it says ahed bhel

[10:08]foundations of the Sunnah we give precedence to those three just as

[10:12]the companions of the messageer of Allah gave precedence to them they

[10:17]the companions never differed in that then we go to the next

[10:23]page over here then after those three There is five who are

[10:29]on the same level Allah ah hold on hold on hold the

[10:31]back pages wait one second my dear brothers and sisters ahed saying

[10:39]does not number one is not number two is not number three

[10:47]no no IM after those three is on a level Champions League

[10:52]spots with another five who are they then after those three the

[10:56]five Companions of the sh the that elected each of them was

[11:09]fitting and appropriate for and in each of them was what was

[11:15]an IM in the Sunni world ahmedh is saying this is 230

[11:25]years after has died so if you were a Sunni living at

[11:30]that time the Creed you'd have to believe in was not that

[11:35]IM Ali's number four number one Abu Bak number two Omar number

[11:38]three and then the remaining European places or I should say Middle

[11:43]Eastern places go to go to Imam Ali ABD and I haven't

[11:51]stopped there wait wait wait wait wait wait wait relax you've had

[11:54]your AAR in some cases some of you will have soon I

[11:57]just want you to relax with me this whole idea we've been

[11:58]baited the picture we love Ali as well come and read what

[12:05]it says number 42 in this regard we take the Hadith of

[12:08]what is the Hadith we used to consider while the messenger of

[12:14]Allah was alive and his companions widespread Abu Bakr to be first

[12:19]then Omar thenan and then we remained quiet Imam Ali you're telling

[12:28]me in the early life of whatever Sunni world was after you're

[12:31]telling me people loved IM Ali then how do we have jaml

[12:34]and people fighting him if they believed he's the fourth rightly guided

[12:37]khif how did people fight him at Jam how did people fight

[12:41]him in if they believe that there's a concept that he's rightly

[12:44]guided so how would you fight him the rightly guided cannot fight

[12:47]rightly guided unless you are absurd as a human being in your

[12:53]intellect rightly and rightly do not fight each otherb was open did

[12:59]not hide his belief that I do not Place Ali no look

[13:08]what he says in this regard we take thei of we used

[13:10]to consider while the messenger of Allah s Al was alive and

[13:15]his companions widespread Abu Bak to be first then Omar then at

[13:17]least then say then just say say that you know what but

[13:22]IM Ali wasif because of course they know he was khif this

[13:24]book is written 200 years after Ras died which means it was

[13:28]written what It Was Written around 200 years after IM Ali died

[13:35]this particular work what is clear Ahmed knows that Imam Ali became

[13:39]the fourth Khalifa but Ahmed B doesn't go on to conclude number

[13:44]43 then after the five Companions of the sh are the people

[13:49]who fought in B from amongst the mun and then those who

[13:51]fought in B from amongst ANS from amongst the companions each one's

[13:55]rank is according to his migration and precedence in the religion then

[14:01]the most Superior of mankind after these are the companions of the

[14:05]generation which he was sent everyone who accompanied him whether for a

[14:09]year a month a day an hour or just saw him then

[14:12]he is amongst the companions what does that show me that shows

[14:17]me that even the Sunni World puts levels as to the sah

[14:20]so don't come and tell me the Shia why I adore Salman

[14:24]above Omar why I adore mikad above like you can have categories

[14:28]I have you have your categories I mine but there's something missing

[14:31]here IM aliam doesn't make the top three places for the Champions

[14:36]League IM misses out he has to go into the playoffs with

[14:44]who with and and that is the playoffs I thought hold on

[14:49]hold on the Sunni world says 1 2 3 4 but Ahmed

[14:54]bhel in this text is saying no however Ahmed bhel at the

[14:58]same time as him of Egypt as you see over here a

[15:05]commentary on the Creed of IM byan you'll see my dear brothers

[15:13]and sisters over here that when we come to this particular area

[15:16]what do we see we see that has a discussion on this

[15:24]area about who about the Companions and their order and in his

[15:28]discussion about the companions and the virtues of the Companions and the

[15:32]Order of the companions he seems to contradict Ahmed so they're both

[15:37]called Sunni today there are people who follow the Creed of follow

[15:40]the or or M or or maybe there might be some odd

[15:48]still alive no problem when you come to page 332 of the

[15:50]commentary on the Creed of IM of course right at the top

[15:54]he attacks the Shia straight away are the opposite aligning themselves with

[15:58]the family of the prophet they claim and they hate the companions

[16:00]moreover they curse them declare them to be disbelievers and vilify them

[16:05]I think yesterday we realized that um Samar was cursed um and

[16:09]um was also cursed by companions but we won't talk about cursing

[16:14]mu and and z and all of them but anyway come back

[16:16]here the companions vary in respect of their Excellence the most Superior

[16:24]of them are the four rightly guided can you please guys make

[16:28]up your mind and will the real please stand up I'm getting

[16:31]confused because and ahed are both living at the same time one

[16:39]of them saying that one two three and then no this one

[16:42]here is saying the companions vary the most Superior are Abu Bakr

[16:49]Omar and Ali and those who are concerning whom the prophet said

[16:51]ADH to my and of the four rightly guided C to come

[16:56]after me bite down on them with your Moler teeth I don't

[16:59]know are you on three or are you on four I'll prove

[17:04]to you my dear brothers and sisters that in Sunni Hadith literature

[17:07]they couldn't make up their mind is it just Abu bakar Omar

[17:14]who are rightly guided shall we include Ali come with me over

[17:18]here my dear brothers sisters to where come with me over here

[17:21]too if we look the prophet peace be upon him and his

[17:26]family he's clearly told us to hold on to his Sunnah and

[17:28]the sunah of the Cs because someone might say to me where

[17:31]does this idea of holding on to the sun of the Cs

[17:37]English translation of J compiled by IM hav mamad volume five over

[17:42]here from Hadith number 2606 to 3290 translated by who by Abu

[17:47]KH as we could see over here that this was the first

[17:54]edition November 2007 supervised by Abdul Malik muah all of you can

[17:58]see over here if we go to Hadith number 2676 you'll see

[18:04]that the prophet we agree the prophet told us hold on to

[18:08]my teachings and the teachings of who of the Cs you see

[18:12]over here my dear brother and sisters this Hadith over here if

[18:17]we go in it's from he narrates 2676 one day after the

[18:23]morning Salah the messenger of Allah exalted us to the extent that

[18:26]the eyes wept and the hearts shuddered with fear a man said

[18:31]indeed this is a farewell exhortation so what do you order us

[18:35]oh messenger of Allah he said I order you to have tawa

[18:37]of Allah and to listen and obey even in the case of

[18:42]an Ethiopian slave indeed whomever amongst you lives he will see much

[18:44]differences Beware of the newly invented matters for indeed they are astray

[18:48]whoever amongst you whoever among you sees that then he must stick

[18:54]to my Sunnah and the Sunnah of the rightly guided KFA cling

[18:57]to it with the MERS all of you could see that the

[19:14]prophet sallallah alai he told us hold on to my Sunnah and

[19:16]the Sunnah of the rightly guided question how many of them because

[19:20]ahed and are show a contradiction is it three rightly guided is

[19:27]it four rightly guided can you make up your mind let's see

[19:30]over here come with me to the Sunan of Abu da my

[19:34]dear brothers and sisters English translation of the Sunan of Abu da

[19:38]compiled by IM Abu volume Five from Hadith number 4351 to 5274

[19:48]if we come over here what do we see we see first

[19:54]edition July 2008 supervised by Abdul Malik mujah daram publishers come with

[19:59]me over here let's go over here my dear brothers and sisters

[20:03]let's see in the Sunni world who are the best people after

[20:09]and how it was normal to sideline IM come with me over

[20:16]here chapter 7 regarding preference at the bottom what does it say

[20:21]in the footnote meaning consider some of the companions more virtuous than

[20:26]others and in what rank the companions in the Sunni world you

[20:32]put them in ranks so don't come and tell me that they're

[20:36]all the same you have even put them in ranks and therefore

[20:41]if they are in ranks then there are mistakes if I discuss

[20:44]their mistakes don't slander me I have every right to discuss because

[20:46]you even said that there's ranks come with me 4627 it was

[20:50]narrated by who narrated from na from Omar who said at the

[20:55]time of the Prophet sallallahu alaih we used to say during the

[20:57]a of the Prophet we did not regard anyone as equal to

[21:02]Abu Bakr then Omar then and then after that we did not

[21:05]differentiate between the companions of the Prophet firstly I just proved to

[21:10]you from Ahmed that there is a differentiation between who was that

[21:12]better who wasn't that better who migrated who wasn't migrating that's there

[21:17]is a differentiation number two abak Omar where's Ali ifni Islam is

[21:27]not the rejection of Al from the day after died I'll cut

[21:31]my hands if Sun Islam is not the rejection of since the

[21:40]day died first incident we don't take if Islam is not the

[21:47]rejection of that anyone who fights him in war they will always

[21:51]say after their names if Islam I will prove to you that

[21:54]the Bedrock of it forget I've showed the God is different the

[21:58]prophet is different Quran is I've shown all of that if you

[22:01]get stuck in what happened after sakif you won't ever be able

[22:06]to be constructive with Islam so Islam you got to go to

[22:08]the Bedrock God has feet God has curly hair and a body

[22:12]and jogs and so on and the prophet is Bewitched delirious and

[22:14]so on and the Quran has God knows how many different copies

[22:17]which are missing and SAS and so on put that aside if

[22:21]we want to come to the basic Sun discussion which everybody in

[22:24]the Ley has or everybody generally has then look over here the

[22:31]idea when a Sunni tells you I love Ali Ali is very

[22:33]high W I'll tell you something someone had sent a message to

[22:36]us yesterday do you know what he said he said well if

[22:37]you're going to discuss the Companions and you're going to critique them

[22:42]so why don't you critique Ali he's not above criticism thank you

[22:45]so much that's all I wanted to hear that your love of

[22:50]Ali is by default it doesn't come naturally to you otherwise BK

[22:52]would only narrate a few from let's come back Hadith 4628 it

[23:01]is narrated from IB shab and then from Salim the son of

[23:06]who the son of Abdullah that I Omar said we used to

[23:08]say when the messenger of Allah was alive the best of the

[23:13]um of the prophets after him is Abu Bakr then Omar may

[23:15]Allah be pleased with [Laughter] them how many righty guided Cals normally

[23:25]when you ask son how many righty guided say four where's Ali

[23:30]in all of this there's this interesting next Hadith where it's narrated

[23:38]4629 it was narrated that mammed said I said to my Father

[23:43]which of the people is the best after so the father said

[23:49]IM Ali said AB Bakr and then he said Omar then I

[23:53]was afraid to ask then who lest he say mamed is baffled

[23:58]surely he's not going to say that's how people would be baffled

[24:03]with I ask abdah and about man's behavior they'll tell you so

[24:09]I said then you oh my father he said I'm just one

[24:17]of the Muslims come with me over here this Hadith is 4630

[24:32]narrated by who narrated my dear brothers and sisters by Muhammad of

[24:37]course known as alabi and then he heard from sufyan whoever claims

[24:42]that Ali was more deserving of being the khif than both Abu

[24:45]Bakr and Omar clearly people were claiming it huh clearly people were

[24:49]saying M Ali is more deserving of than Abu Bakr and Omar

[24:52]so it's not unanimously agreed upon as you make it out like

[24:55]everybody believed it and then some random Shia came no problem whoever

[24:58]claims that Ali was more deserving of being khif first than Abu

[25:03]Bakr and Omar then he has attributed error to Abu Bakr Omar

[25:05]and the muaj and the an and I do not think that

[25:10]with this belief any Deeds of his will rise to Heaven wait

[25:12]wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait come back here this

[25:18]is a this is a huge Hadith whoever says Ali deserves more

[25:20]than abak and Omar I don't think his deeds will reach heaven

[25:24]hold on a minute you said that Islam is Allah and the

[25:26]prophet have you got a new concept called sahab the way you

[25:30]accuse the Shia of making up IM I believe in and I

[25:35]believe in Muhammad I reject the authority of ab so what will

[25:38]I go to Janam because of it if you say I will

[25:41]that means you've made belief in theah and the Order of the

[25:45]one of the tenants of so why you attacking my 12 imams

[25:47]when you've made your own order who did he say was the

[25:56]best they say Abu Bakr Omar and they would continue with this

[25:59]as wellah alari come with me over here the translation and the

[26:03]meanings of sah alkari Arabic English volume 9th 6561 to 75 63

[26:10]translated by who by Dr M Khan as you could see my

[26:16]dear brothers and sisters printed in July 1997 printing supervised by who

[26:20]by Abdul Malik mujah come with me over here to 7262 let's

[26:26]see again my dear brothers and sisters narrated Abu mus 7262 the

[26:34]prophet Sall alai entered a garden and told me to guard its

[26:39]gate then a man came and asked permission to enter the prophet

[26:41]said permit him and give him the Glad Tidings that he will

[26:43]enter Paradise behold it was Abu Bakr then Omar came and the

[26:49]prophet said admit him and give him Paradise Glad Tidings thenan came

[26:53]and the prophet admit him and give him the Glad Tidings of

[26:59]watch that he will enter Paradise Abu Bak Omar and always conveniently

[27:05]have a Hadith where they enter the prophet's house sometimes it's when

[27:08]the prophet's in bed with a of the Hadith of the which

[27:12]we already discussed that the prophet is in bed with Abu Bakr

[27:15]comes in then Omar comes in and then the prophet tells cover

[27:17]yourself because man's coming and he might be shy and now again

[27:22]Abu Bakr Omar andman only rarely do you see a Hadith in

[27:25]Sunni literature Abu Bakr Omar and Ali all enter upon the prophet

[27:31]peace be upon his family and he gives all four of them

[27:32]Jenna at the same time if it's there show me Maybe I'm

[27:37]Wrong where 1 2 3 4 all enter or do the packages

[27:42]only come in three they don't come in four is there a

[27:46]problem with coming in four I don't know come with me over

[27:50]here my dear brothers and sisters the translation of the meanings of

[27:55]Arabic English volume Five Hadith 3849 to 4473 if you come here

[28:06]and you will see translated by Dr M Khan printed in July

[28:09]1997 printing supervised by who by Abdul Malik muah come with me

[28:18]here let's see what it says again we have this Hadith here

[28:22]come the merits of Abu Bakr as next to those of the

[28:26]Prophet narrated Omar we used to compare the people as to who

[28:34]was better during the lifetime of Allah's messenger we used to regard

[28:40]Abu Bakr as the best then Omar and then that's it that's

[28:47]it that's Islam Islam is the protection of Abu Bakr Omar's so

[28:53]someone says but my brother They're saying four I said Baba I'm

[28:56]seeing three oh all I see is the best is Abu bakar

[29:00]Omar and then I see after that the Champions League spots or

[29:05]the UEFA spots or the what are the other leagues called now

[29:07]the conference league and I don't know what European league and so

[29:12]on hey he's saying we used to regard Abu Bakr look at

[29:14]it we used to regard over here abrin and then who then

[29:20]Omar then that's it that is Sunni belief what's more amazing is

[29:26]if I show you my dear brothers and sisters what if I

[29:30]show you that in early Sunni belief there was also a belief

[29:37]that after Abu bakar the best person is Zu someone's going bro

[29:41]they're going to say to me bro wait wait wait wait wait

[29:43]wait we know that they believe that the best is Abu Bakr

[29:49]then Omar then and then IM Ali and we saw we did

[29:54]mention that but when you look deeper you'll actually see that on

[29:58]the one hand Imam Ali he's placed alongside I'm going to show

[30:07]you AI that you may not have come across where Zu is

[30:09]seen as the one most fitting to be the rightly guided Khalifa

[30:14]after come with me over here if we go toi my dear

[30:20]brothers and sisters should be somewhere here my volume Five hadiths 3849

[30:29]to 4473 if you come and zoom in over here you will

[30:35]see this particular edition of sahkari 3849 to 4473 if we go

[30:43]to Hadith number this bukari translated by who Dr M Khan July

[30:47]1997 Abdul Malik mujahid King Fahad National Library cataloging and publication data

[30:55]come with me to 371 seven let's see what it says over

[31:03]here my dear brothers and sisters let's see my dear brother sisters

[31:07]if after the best person is IM Ali or is it someone

[31:09]else the merits of Zu he of course Zu was one of

[31:19]theun and theun in this opinion were called this because of the

[31:26]whiteness of their clothes Hadith 3717 narrated by the ever glor ious

[31:31]the wonderful pure biggest Troublemaker Maran okay let's go here was afflicted

[31:36]with severe nose bleeding in the year when such illness was prevalent

[31:40]and that prevented him from performing Hajj and because of it he

[31:44]made his will okay man before he dies he's making his will

[31:51]let's see who is quite obviously going to be the best let's

[31:57]see let's go back a man from came to him and said

[31:58]appoint your successor man asked did the people name him the man

[32:05]said yesman asked who is that the man remains silent another man

[32:12]came to and I think it was he's also said appoint your

[32:18]successor man asked the people name him the man replied yesman said

[32:25]who is that the man remained silentman said perhaps they have mentioned

[32:32]a Zu the man said yesman said by him in whose hands

[32:38]my soul is he is the best of them as I know

[32:43]and the dearest of them to Allah's messenger abak Omar and then

[32:56]the best afterman says is who is Zu is the best I

[32:59]thought you love that IM forthrightly guided you didn't even have that

[33:04]conception in your early beliefs there's no way it could be there

[33:10]early it is a later you innovated within your theology but then

[33:13]theology by its nature things crystallize things change no problem who didan

[33:17]say is the best after him who look what he says man

[33:24]said perhaps they have mentioned who perhaps they have mentioned the Zu

[33:31]the man said yesman said by him in whose hands my soul

[33:37]is he is the best of them as I know and the

[33:40]dearest of them you see how the Sunni World it will tell

[33:51]you the stories and you look early in their teachings they haven't

[33:56]got a clue one minute Abu bakar Omar Ali next minute Abu

[34:02]Bak Omar next minute Abu Bak Omar Zu what if I show

[34:08]you even if you look over here in the mus of come

[34:12]with me over here the English translation of the mus of IM

[34:15]Ahmed Hadith number 1380 to number one to 1380 by of course

[34:24]translated by edited by who by as you could see over here

[34:33]2012 King fad National Library cataloging in publication data come with me

[34:39]over here read this Hadith my dear brother and sisters you'll see

[34:42]you'll see very clearly my dear brothers and sisters what does it

[34:46]say again the same Hadith it was narrated from from his father

[34:51]from Maran and we have no reason to suspect him Maran is

[34:53]a very good human being who saidman suffered a nose bed in

[34:57]the year of the nose bed which was so bad that he

[34:58]stayed behind from Hajj and gave his final instructions because he thought

[35:01]he's going to die soan knows he's going to die so what

[35:08]do you do in your last Hajj you appoint a leader after

[35:10]you you write a will at the very least to make it

[35:16]clear only forgot to tell people who the leader is after him

[35:20]let's go back a man of qur entered upon him and said

[35:23]appoint a successor Subhan Allah how rationally rationally everyone's first thought is

[35:28]if you're the leader you got a point someone you got make

[35:32]it clear for us don't leave us in a mess called s

[35:33]where an and M have a punch up come back he said

[35:38]are they suggesting that he said yes he said who are they

[35:40]suggesting the man kept quiet then another man entered upon him and

[35:43]said something similar to what the first man said and he gave

[35:47]the same response thenan said are they suggesting a Zu he said

[35:49]yes he said by the one in whose hands is my soul

[35:52]indeed he is the best amongst them as far as I know

[35:55]and the most beloved of them to the messenger of Allah is

[35:58]more beloved to Allah Islam you keep doing you keep you have

[36:04]the gift that keeps on giving you keep giving what if I

[36:11]show you my dear brothers and sisters that you know how sometime

[36:17]I just showed there's three and then someone said there's four rightly

[36:22]what if I show you five there some's like wait wait wait

[36:24]wait I thought there's four rightly guided K what if I show

[36:28]you five come with me over here English translation of the sun

[36:32]of Abu da compiled by volume 5 from Hadith number 4351 to

[36:38]57 5274 all of you could see over here that it's translated

[36:44]by final review by who by Abu first edition July 208 supervised

[36:55]by Abdul Malik muah if you come with me to which Hadith

[36:59]for 631 I used to say that in the Sunni World they

[37:02]say there's four rightly guided cips then I show today they mention

[37:05]three and then there's a Champions League fight now let's go to

[37:11]4631 what does it say you've got the Hadith over here from

[37:19]who the Hadith from I heard San say theas are many how

[37:29]many how many how many do we have now omdd who hold

[37:49]on a minute what's going on why you rejecting mu you've just

[37:54]done a whole series on NBC about him where is he gone

[37:58]hey what's going on here what's going on Abu Bak Omar Ali

[38:06]and Omar so what's happened to mua what's happened to the Glorious

[38:12]in sham the golden M that they're so proud about the golden

[38:19]Ami Masid where are they you had to skip how many years

[38:22]after IM Ali you skip 50 years now look at Sunni Islam's

[38:29]one minute it's three next minute it's four now it's how many

[38:32]how many is it now look what it says over here so

[38:49]Sunni Islam has an imamat but it's five imams so why you

[38:54]attack me when I have a choice of leaders after the prophet

[38:58]when you have five your saying these are five or you're saying

[38:59]four or you're saying well I'm confused I I've been so confused

[39:02]with your beliefs about God anthropomorphism or no whether you believe the

[39:06]prophet is Bewitched or Delirious whether your Quran is the same W

[39:09]you've confused me so much may Allah bless me inshallah if we

[39:13]go here my dear brothers and sisters let's go to the sun

[39:16]of Abu DA they even doubted whether Imam Ali was the fourth

[39:20]didn't I make that clear that they doubted that IM Ali was

[39:23]the fourth someone says where did they doubt it there's very interesting

[39:28]Hadith over here in the sun of ab da volume five of

[39:30]the Sunan come with me here the Sunan of Abu daud Volume

[39:34]5 from Hadith 4351 to 5 274 come with me to Hadith

[39:41]46 46 over here my dear brothers and sisters and you'll see

[39:46]very clearly this Hadith it's narrated over here that if you look

[39:54]over here Safina said to me S said Safina said to me

[39:58]calculate Abu bak's khif as two years Omar's as 10's as 12

[40:04]and Ali's as such and such s said I said to Safina

[40:10]they are saying that Ali was not aif Allah the Shia were

[40:14]saying he's the first IM is telling sa but there are people

[40:18]who are saying Ali is not aif thank you for admitting it

[40:22]thank you for admitting that in early Islam if and and Zu

[40:27]and Maran and mu andd if they all raised armies to fight

[40:35]IM imagine imagine W it hurts but I'll continue I'll calm myself

[40:50]down and continue inshallah let's see what it says s said I

[40:54]said to Safina we'll come back to theith Safina said to me

[40:59]C at abak is two years Omar's is 10's is 12 and

[41:01]Ali's is such and such s said I said to Safina they

[41:04]are saying that Ali was not aif listen to what he replies

[41:19]the buttocks of are lying meaning Banu Maran look how blatant he

[41:25]is with the language the buttocks of Ben are lying meaning Ben

[41:29]Maran meaning the Maran on them they are the ones who are

[41:36]lying against Imam Ali by saying Imam Ali was not a khif

[41:42]of course because their granddad fought IM Ali and they done abuse

[41:45]of IM Ali 24/7 and but you cannot abuse the sahab no

[41:50]when the om's abuse it's fine when the Shia say anything they

[41:54]are KU when you sayman for example is rightly guided man is

[42:06]rightly guided what if companions believe that he's got major issues and

[42:11]problems so if there's a companion who speaks out against a rightly

[42:16]guided khif is he therefore rightly guided logically Jal come with me

[42:22]over here Jal the history of theas who took the wrong way

[42:25]theas who took the right way come back here the history of

[42:31]theas who took the right way translated by ABD CL Taha Publishers

[42:38]limited you have over here 2021 Taha Publishers wins The Grove London

[42:46]se e279 you said to me that a Khalifa if he's rightly

[42:49]guided then you can't fight the rightly guided khif if you believe

[42:51]in the theory the innovation of four rightly guided then anyone who

[42:57]fights Theif is of the fold of the religion what happens to

[43:00]Companions who blatantly attack a Khalifa in public if they are going

[43:03]Jenna and he's going Jenna he's rightly guided but they don't believe

[43:06]he's rightly guided so what's their opinion then if you come over

[43:12]here my dear brothers and sisters you'll see that blatantly over here

[43:16]you'll see on page 168 the question is asked narrated by another

[43:22]rote that said I said to can you tell me how was

[43:26]the killing of what were people uh saying what were they up

[43:30]to and why did the companions of Muhammad sahu alai fail to

[43:35]help him saidman was killed unjustly whoever killed him was wrongdoing and

[43:39]whoever failed to help him is free of blame he said I

[43:40]said how was that he said whenman was appointed a group of

[43:44]the companions disliked his appointment hold on if the prophet said I'm

[43:48]leaving three calips who are rightly guided so how can the companions

[43:54]dislike whoever becomes the third Calif if the companions already know thatman

[43:57]is been chosen and by the prophet imagine here that here the

[44:03]companions what were they complaining he used to appoint people from B

[44:07]how could you be rightly guided when you give Maran and others

[44:13]all the best of the treasuries you don't think other companions are

[44:17]going to complain let's see which companions complain against the rightly guided

[44:21]come to the next page page 169 of come over here there

[44:28]been slight before from to Abdullah AB andarin y those three did

[44:33]not see him as a rightly guided Khalifa therefore the idea that

[44:38]the umah was unanimous about these cffs here you have three who

[44:41]have a major problem with that Khalif now there's another contradiction what's

[44:45]the contradiction what if there's a Hadith in the Sunni literature that

[44:50]talks about for example there being 12 what do we do you

[44:56]got one saying four you got one saying five you go what

[45:00]if you have one saying there's 12 who govern after me who

[45:04]are those 12 come with me here sah Muslim the English translation

[45:10]of sah Muslim compiled by Hussein Muslim volume Five from Hadith number

[45:15]4519 to where to 5645 a Hadith edited and referen by translated

[45:24]by final review by who by Abu first edition August 2007 supervised

[45:32]by ABD Malik mujah as you could see over here daram Publishers

[45:37]come with me let's go and see whether the prophet said more

[45:41]numbers if the prophet said three I follow three he said four

[45:43]I follow four said five I what if he says 12 come

[45:47]over here my dear brother and sisters let's go to this Hadith

[45:51]over here 4705 you will see the book of nice title as

[45:57]well the book of leadership page 145 Hadith 4705 narrated from who

[46:05]jab the son of samur said I entered upon the prophet with

[46:08]my father and I heard him say this matter will not end

[46:13]until there have been amongst them 12 khalifas 12 why the magic

[46:18]number of 12 here then he said something that I couldn't hear

[46:29]best time to forget anything and I said to my father what

[46:33]did he say he said all of them will be from the

[46:37]qu these 12 all of them will be from the qu no

[46:38]problem you can interpret it as you want the fact that he

[46:42]opened it to qur means he opens it to others I don't

[46:45]care all I'm seeing here is that if I read the Arabic

[46:46]what does it say over here that Hadith number 4706 it was

[47:12]narrated that ja samur said I heard the prophet Sall say the

[47:15]people's Affairs will go well the people Affairs will go well so

[47:28]long as they are governed by 12 men then the prophet said

[47:34]something that I did not hear and I asked my father what

[47:35]did the messenger of Allah say he said all of them will

[47:38]be from Hadith 4708 it was narrated from who narrated from Sak

[47:46]the son of har who heard Jab Sam say I heard the

[47:51]messenger of Allah say Islam will continue to Prevail through 12 khalifas

[47:56]not four then he said something that I did not understand and

[47:59]I said to my father what did he say he said all

[48:02]of them will be from where qu Hadith 4709 it was the

[48:04]that ja Sam said the prophet sallallahu alaih said this matter will

[48:11]continue to Prevail until there have been 12 khif then he said

[48:17]something that I did not understand and I said to my father

[48:21]when he said this I said to him what did he say

[48:31]naturally he's going to ask this question as to what did he

[48:38]say he said all of them will be from where all of

[48:42]them will be from come over here 4710 I went to the

[48:54]messenger of Allah my father was with me and I heard him

[48:57]say this religion will continue to Prevail and be strong until there

[48:59]have been 12 khalifas all of these I showed you 12 why

[49:03]when you look at me as a Shia and I follow 12

[49:05]don't say that I got this out of my pocket or random

[49:08]I don't mind what interpretation you give I don't mind what reading

[49:10]you have but in your own books there's 12 mentioned my 12

[49:17]I'm proud to mention who they are from IM to from the

[49:22]sons of and even if you want to give me a million

[49:24]interpretations about these 12 you can have your interpretations I even find

[49:29]that of the that were left behind from the time of IM

[49:35]you have that of and even he mentions 12 so it wasn't

[49:38]something that we made up after the IM went into or after

[49:44]go and read who's also the use him as a narrator and

[49:47]you'll see his discussion of the 12 but suffice for me to

[49:51]then say that in the Sunni world this whole idea that you

[49:53]always give that there's four rightly guided today I've shown number one

[49:57]that you believed in three and then it was Champions League spots

[50:00]and only a couple of your Creeds try to differ with that

[50:02]later number two that even those three there were companions who objected

[50:06]to them and there's no such thing as there wasn't difference as

[50:11]to their appointment number three even when it came to the fourth

[50:15]of them you didn't mind fighting him in Jamal and sa even

[50:17]though you admitted he was rightly guided further than that you don't

[50:22]mind saying there's five where Omar bin ABD aiz gets thrown in

[50:24]further than that if you don't believe in those three then you

[50:27]are according to that narration someone whose deeds will not even reach

[50:31]the heavens have you added another of the called sah the way

[50:35]you accuse us of IM further than that I decide to hold

[50:39]on to the 12 after and inshallah hedge my bets and meet

[50:42]you all quite confident of the 12 that I hold on to

[50:47]it's been an absolute pleasure hey hey [Music] it's brothers and sisters

[51:32]I here for a very urgent but very exciting new project from

[51:35]Imam Hussein TV as you are aware Imam Hussein TV is in

[51:39]Northwest London a very very small Studio very we're actually renting the

[51:42]area you know the offices and so forth but we have a

[51:44]brand new opportunity here in West London there's a brand new building

[51:49]up for sale and Imam Hussein TV needs your help to secure

[51:51]that building so for all those who help number one you're going

[51:53]to help in TV move to a brand new location number two

[51:57]you're going to help set up a brand new studio control room

[52:00]you're going to be part of our team to help bring brand

[52:04]new programs and broadcasting for you guys to spread the message of

[52:07]Imam Hussein TV anybody who watches these programs on Imam Hussein TV

[52:10]whether it is a program onr sh any program that you watch

[52:19]and You' donated towards TV you're going to get the every view

[52:22]you're going to get the thawab and the thing is our programs

[52:23]are watched every day by millions and millions of people loads of

[52:28]people watch our TV show and they are learning the message of

[52:30]IM Hussein the message and lessons of the and you guys are

[52:34]going to be behind that helping spread the message of the AC

[52:36]B by you know looking under lower third there below it will

[52:38]tell you how to get in contact with us whether it's his

[52:41]phone number email or even just sharing you guys need to get

[52:43]involved help us secure this brand new building so that we can

[52:47]continue to spread the message of Imam Hussein inshallah to all the

[52:50]corners of the earth and make sure that we have one massive

[52:52]Global sa year

0 تعليقات

التالي

9. Three Rightly Guided Caliphs, or Four? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2025

Transcript

التالي

استكشاف المزيد

يرجى ملاحظة أنه إذا كان عمرك أقل من 18 عامًا ، فلن تتمكن من الوصول إلى هذا الموقع.

التالي

9. Three Rightly Guided Caliphs, or Four? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2025

Transcript

التالي

استكشاف المزيد

اختيار طريقة الدفع

لغة