25. Holy Month of Ramadan Q&A (Part 1) | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

8 المشاهدات· 26/03/14

Sayed Ammar Nakshawani Official
مشتركين

في محاضرات

Please like, share, and subscribe: http://youtube.com/SayedAmmarNakshawaniOfficial?sub_confirmation=1 - Visit Sayed Ammar’s official website: https://www.sayedammar.com - Shop The SAN Collection: https://www.thesancollection.com Follow the official accounts: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/sayedammarofficial/?hl=en Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/share/1QBzyjU6rE/?mibextid=wwXIfr TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@sayedammarofficial?_r=1&_t=ZN-94ZbpdBDG0k

أظهر المزيد

Transcript

[0:09]son has wanted an SUV and thanks to your donations, we made

[0:13]his dua come true with Imam Hussein charity.

[0:17]Look how happy he is.

[0:17]A smile like that cost nothing.

[0:19]And for these guys, it's priceless.

[0:24]Let's make sure no orphan feels left out this Eid.

[0:29]Donate to our campaign and help us bring a smile to their

[0:34]faces.

[0:42]We all subscribe to many things without thinking.

[0:45]Movies, streaming, entertainment.

[0:47]But what about a subscription that carries meaning?

[0:51]Imm Hussein TV broadcasts the message of Kbala across five global TV

[0:56]channels in five languages every single day.

[1:00]When 14,000 people give just 10 USD or seven British pounds a

[1:03]month, these channels stay on air sharing the teachings of the Bates

[1:06]with the world.

[1:08]This isn't just a donation, it's a subscription with purpose.

[1:11]Join us today.

[1:15]Visit www.am husseinfree.tv/donate.

[1:18]Become a partner today.

[1:21]Imam Hussein TV, your gateway to Kbala.

[1:25]Hey, hey, hey.

[2:05]and welcome to the first of four scintillating nights with Smar.

[2:09]In these four nights, we're going to delve into topics that he's

[2:13]discussed throughout this holy month of Ramadan.

[2:15]We've had an excellent 24-part series on the Shia and Sunni discourse.

[2:18]But you see, these four parts are very special because it'll be

[2:21]the last four that will be filmed at this set.

[2:24]We're soon to be moving to our new AWA complex and it's

[2:28]been a very special Ramadan because it's our last one here at

[2:31]our old studio.

[2:33]Not just that, the nights of have just passed.

[2:36]We pray that you've all kept us in duas.

[2:36]You've kept say in your duas.

[2:39]We know he's kept you all in your his duas.

[2:41]And we pray most of all that you've prayed for all those

[2:43]who are suffering around the world because this Ramadan has been a

[2:46]difficult one for all the Muslim.

[2:49]It's not a Ramadan that's been happy.

[2:51]It's been a Ramadan where the world is praying for one another.

[2:55]And with that, I welcome our guest of honor.

[2:59]Saywani Ali.

[2:59]How are you?

[3:00]>> I haven't seen you.

[3:01]I think we saw each other >> once this month.

[3:03]>> Once this holy month.

[3:04]Yeah.

[3:05]You came with dad.

[3:05]>> Correct.

[3:07]Great.

[3:06]>> Yeah.

[3:07]For one of the sessions.

[3:10]But it's uh it's great to be here.

[3:11]This familiar set.

[3:12]>> Alhamdulillah.

[3:13]um maybe relaxing a bit now and cooling off for the last

[3:16]>> four nights.

[3:18]So, alhamdulillah, you know, I'm I'm ever so grateful for the team

[3:21]behind the scenes.

[3:22]>> Everyone's been amazing.

[3:25]Um feedback's been amazing and you know, I know lots of people

[3:27]who are telling us they're catching up >> with the episodes, you

[3:31]know, some people are still even on night five, night eight, you

[3:33]know, and there are people still playing catch obviously mosque >> naturally.

[3:37]Yes.

[3:36]>> And the programs that are happening and so on and so

[3:40]forth.

[3:40]So, alhamdulillah, really good to see you and I'm I'm happy to

[3:42]have you back here again.

[3:43]>> I'm I'm honored to be sitting alongside yourself.

[3:45]So, I want to put a little disclosure out for all those

[3:48]viewing at home that we have more than 200 questions and it's

[3:50]not all going to get done tonight.

[3:52]So, I want it to be an aspect that people understand that

[3:54]inshallah we'll try to get through as many as we can.

[3:57]But if tonight then inshallah tomorrow, if not tomorrow, then by the

[4:00]four nights we'll try to get through as many of the questions

[4:03]in.

[4:04]So, to start off with saying that this topic of Shia Sunni

[4:06]discourse, it's been now the third Ramadan.

[4:08]any particular reason as to why we chose to go back to

[4:11]this topic?

[4:12]>> Well, I suppose there was um a few topics which I

[4:16]had thought about uh taking on this holy month of Ramadan, but

[4:21]this particular topic was one where I was receiving the most questions.

[4:25]>> Mhm.

[4:25]>> So, we had done two seasons already um as you know

[4:29]and and to go into a third season, you know, means you've

[4:33]got to always come up with, you know, new material, new angles.

[4:38]And >> I think um if I were just to give an

[4:39]example, you know, something like discussion on and um that that would

[4:47]have been an angle that hither to this point is very rarely

[4:50]uh discussed >> for sure.

[4:51]>> And I felt that hold on a minute, I've got something

[4:54]to build on here.

[4:56]If I can take the of the issue concerning the Quran and

[4:59]the Shia have been attacked on the Quran for so many years

[5:02]>> and then alongside that there's other areas which keep popping up.

[5:08]Um alongside that there's always you know the unbelievable number of of

[5:16]the in this great literature that's behind me honestly and there are

[5:22]so many hadiths that people only until today when they read them

[5:25]um they would maybe have never even have heard about that source

[5:31]like yesterday when we discussed Im Ali naming his son >> afterman

[5:33]and showing many people would not opened, you know.

[5:38]>> Yeah.

[5:39]>> Um and as you could see with the Im Hussein TV

[5:42]team and especially said Mada behind the scenes, I'd be in touch

[5:48]with him and and um and you know before we'd have this

[5:50]this um few weeks of lectures, I'd be telling him, "Listen, I

[5:54]need this book.

[5:54]I need that book.

[5:55]I need this book.

[5:55]I need that book.

[5:57]Make sure you get me this one.

[5:58]Make sure you don't miss this one." And we were just ordering

[6:00]books non-stop for sure.

[6:02]Um and and the more books we were ordering, the more topics

[6:04]I realized still hadn't been touched.

[6:07]>> Yeah.

[6:07]>> The more topics I realized, wow, I can have a good

[6:12]number of discussions on this particular area, >> you know.

[6:16]And um alhamdulillah, it's unbelievable.

[6:18]I still feel I could have done another five, six, seven, if

[6:23]God grants us long life to the next holy month.

[6:26]>> Say that the library is almost doubled this year.

[6:28]>> Yeah.

[6:29]And you were mentioning you've been ordering so many new books.

[6:32]So, first and foremost, what were the books that you were looking

[6:34]for maybe that you weren't able to find last year that you've

[6:36]actually been able to access this year?

[6:38]>> Yeah.

[6:39]So, for example, if you look behind, you've got the the musn.

[6:42]>> Yeah.

[6:43]>> Of IM Ahmed bin Hal.

[6:45]>> Mhm.

[6:45]>> And we've got it here in the whole 52 volume.

[6:48]You see the middle one there?

[6:50]>> Yeah.

[6:50]>> Okay.

[6:51]Just there.

[6:51]>> This Yeah.

[6:52]>> Yeah.

[6:53]Yeah.

[6:54]That's the whole 52 volume.

[6:54]Now something very interesting is that if you look here, >> if

[7:00]you look here, >> it's the abridged >> uh so look how

[7:02]many volumes is that?

[7:03]Five.

[7:04]>> Oh, five.

[7:05]Okay.

[7:04]>> Correct.

[7:05]Because I think one of the volume is probably just sitting somewhere

[7:07]else.

[7:07]>> Sure.

[7:08]>> Um so you've got mad of Ahmed over there >> and

[7:12]you've got the whole Musn 52 volumes there.

[7:15]>> So when I contacted said Mr.

[7:17]I was like listen >> I need the whole of the Musn.

[7:21]And obviously he's like to me didn't we order Musn.

[7:23]So I was like, "Yeah, but we ordered the a bridged version.

[7:27]I want the whole 52 volume version." So we managed to managed

[7:31]to get that.

[7:33]Okay.

[7:34]Then we've got as well over here as you could see um

[7:36]other works such as for example um if you look over here

[7:42]right behind me is >> Yeah.

[7:44]>> Okay.

[7:45]So you've got the whole of that.

[7:46]You've got Okay.

[7:49]Which I was always struggling to get hold of.

[7:52]>> Wow.

[7:52]So you've got some of the rarer books now in the collection

[7:55]as well.

[7:54]>> Yes.

[7:55]Yes.

[7:56]And I've got like for example um which wasn't hard to get

[8:01]hold of but we needed to use it uh this year in

[8:04]our discussions.

[8:04]Um what else do we have over here?

[8:09]Of course is one that we've had from before.

[8:11]This year I also managed to get it somewhere over there.

[8:14]Um I managed to get of kafir.

[8:18]Okay.

[8:18]Now you're asking me about which ones I >> that's where the

[8:23]is more historical.

[8:24]>> Oh, okay.

[8:25]>> This one is and then >> you got to remember like

[8:29]when you're dealing with Ib Kir or you're dealing with um people

[8:33]like um you're dealing with people who have historical works and they

[8:37]have Quran.

[8:37]>> I see.

[8:39]Okay.

[8:38]>> You know, so >> they've got so many books between them.

[8:42]>> Um so question would be then are there any books that

[8:45]you wanted that you could not get a hold of?

[8:46]>> Yeah.

[8:47]So, like for example, let's see which ones did I want.

[8:51]I couldn't get hold of.

[8:52]That is a really good question.

[8:53]Um, I I wanted to get I wanted to get uh >>

[9:02]Okay.

[9:01]>> I couldn't get hold of it.

[9:04]>> So, Ashar is this really classic work.

[9:08]um you're talking you know well over a thousand years um old

[9:15]and >> and it's a it's a phenomenal book but it's available

[9:17]in the soass library for example but it'd be available as a

[9:19]reference text only >> and if you want to buy it online

[9:25]I think like five volumes is like £560 or something and I

[9:28]think Hussein TV was about to kill me with the amount of

[9:30]orders we were making um so if I was to say yeah

[9:37]and a balad and then there are always these books you know

[9:43]sometimes you don't you can't necessarily have them there and then um

[9:48]you know >> a lot of these are available >> but sometimes

[9:53]when you need them at that moment it takes like 16 weeks

[9:57]to order and unfortunately I'm giving these guys like only five weeks

[10:01]to order everything >> uh but yeah we've we've amassed quite a

[10:04]library as I described it >> u I I managed to get

[10:10]this here which I was really happy about of Ahmed Hal that

[10:12]so a lot of these books are books you may see referenced

[10:17]um in in many in many books but you just don't know

[10:20]where they are.

[10:21]So you know sometimes when you see like a then I was

[10:22]guided over a tan at the bottom he's writing this book and

[10:25]you're like I don't even know what that book is but it's

[10:26]a sunni book you know what I mean so we've tried to

[10:30]amass this um >> would you say there are particular bookshops which

[10:33]really you have to thank for the >> yes for sure for

[10:39]sure like >> in the in the Sunni bookstores Mecca in Birmingham

[10:42]of Coventry Road.

[10:45]Okay.

[10:47]Nice.

[10:45]>> Yeah.

[10:46]Uh Coventry Road off Coventry Road in Birmingham.

[10:49]There's a store called Mecca bookstore.

[10:51]>> Mhm.

[10:52]>> And that's a great bookstore.

[10:56]That's just like honestly when you go in there, there's no limit

[10:58]to, you know, how many books are there and >> it's a

[11:02]that's a great one.

[11:04]In terms of um in our community, Hudj Stanmore, >> yeah, >>

[11:07]the Hudj book store, I must uh thank um Jaraj for his

[11:14]kindness.

[11:14]>> Yeah.

[11:14]>> Yes.

[11:16]uh because you know seno has been amazing in the sense that

[11:20]he's made sure uh that all the books are available and you

[11:22]know what I always give him a headache cuz there'll be in

[11:26]the last minute before the episode I would have messaged him like

[11:28]a couple of hours before I'll be like can you find me

[11:32]this one I can't find it right now and then he'll be

[11:33]like oh but it's it's a bit difficult cuz I'm going home

[11:37]and then somehow miraculously >> he'll find a way and I've got

[11:41]to thank you know Abu Amir would call Abu Amir Abu Amir

[11:43]would go to he'd pick it up from Dan Moy pick it

[11:45]up from his house.

[11:46]>> So your volume for Kafi for this year that you were

[11:50]using actually was delivered like 2 hours before you were saying to

[11:53]pick it up from I have to thank um our young brother

[11:57]Mahash.

[11:57]>> Alhamdulillah.

[11:58]>> You know what I mean?

[12:00]And it was amazing because he he collected for me.

[12:04]So if you look over there you'll see >> one two three

[12:09]and then what's after three?

[12:11]Five >> and six.

[12:12]Yeah.

[12:12]>> Okay.

[12:13]So we don't have four.

[12:13]>> Four.

[12:14]Okay.

[12:14]So I made him go and he delivered four with like I

[12:19]don't know 5 minutes of the show left.

[12:21]>> And someone might say to me, well why would you leave

[12:25]it so late?

[12:26]Cuz you're so confident going into these episodes that Tmidi is there

[12:29]volume four.

[12:30]So in my notes it's written volume 4.

[12:32]I'm going to be able to you know bring you access it

[12:33]and then all of a sudden you're like ah >> emergency.

[12:36]There's no TMI volume 4.

[12:38]I see >> you know.

[12:39]>> Um so it's teamwork brother.

[12:41]>> Of course.

[12:43]Of course >> it's teamwork.

[12:43]When I mention and I mention and I mention said Mortal and

[12:48]I mention Abu Amir and I mention the guys behind the scenes

[12:50]who have to you know deal with my happiest moments and sometimes

[12:54]the odd moment where I might be like what are you guys

[12:58]doing?

[12:59]Zoom into the page >> and you know everybody's fasting everybody's just

[13:03]about keeping their eyes awake and they've got said ham going on

[13:06]and they're just like hanging in the conversation.

[13:08]>> So it's a great great team over here and I'm indebted

[13:12]to everybody.

[13:13]I say this every year but I'm indebted to everybody for their

[13:15]duas and I'm indebted to the Imam Hussein TV team and the

[13:20]backroom staff for their hard work.

[13:20]SA I have a question which is a bit unique in the

[13:22]sense that do you feel as a community the Shabbab the people

[13:25]who actually you know are elders as well are reliant more on

[13:28]lectures to actually get their sources of knowledge than reading and do

[13:31]you feel that that's one of the reasons you've bought this collection

[13:33]of books to say to people look when you're reading you're getting

[13:35]things from the source you're learning in a better way >> your

[13:37]your granddad may Allah bless him is still alive and I'm sure

[13:40]when you were growing up you would have seen a few books

[13:42]in his house there would have been one shelf in particular still

[13:46]there still there and you know obviously in my granddad's case it

[13:48]was you know obviously there because of you know being in Naj

[13:51]and then the houseer I I believe that every household must have

[13:56]a section for books now someone might say do you know how

[13:59]many books we've got up there no one's even picked them up

[14:01]doesn't matter might be one day >> you your sibling your cousin

[14:05]might come and oh my god I need to read this book

[14:06]for example you know what I mean >> naturally >> lectures can

[14:10]only give you about 20% of your learning >> Hussein are big

[14:14]baraka in our life they gather our communities together >> as IM

[14:20]would Do you sit and discuss?

[14:22]And when the person said to him, yes, he said Allah subhanahu

[14:26]wa ta'ala has showered mercy on the one who revives our >>

[14:32]teachings >> teachings.

[14:33]Malis will give you 20% of your in life.

[14:37]The rest of your learning will either come through structured learning under

[14:41]scholars or reading.

[14:44]Now if if you were to ask your regular Muslim where's the

[14:49]most of your lectures from whether you're Sunni or your Shia they'll

[14:54]name a lecturer where most of their is from.

[14:56]Sorry.

[14:56]>> Naturally.

[14:57]Yeah.

[14:56]>> If you ask them what was the last book you've read

[14:59]or what was the last course you took so that you became

[15:04]an expert in a certain area you wanted to know all the

[15:06]dynamics of you'll see that unfortunately a lot of people are a

[15:11]bit far from that type of development in their learning.

[15:13]And the thing about only relying on me with all respect to

[15:19]all of our reciters is that the reciter only has 40 45

[15:22]minutes to get to the point about a huge topic >> before

[15:26]doing mas and before a is going to begin and before food

[15:30]is served.

[15:32]So even if you're listening to somebody for five, six, seven nights

[15:35]on the one level there's only so much they can talk about

[15:38]on the second level you can't really have a Q&A with them

[15:40]after.

[15:41]That should be >> the reason we hold these Q&As's um at

[15:44]the end of the holy month of Ramadan is that our viewers

[15:47]are able to send in their questions about some of the things

[15:49]that I may have tried to dissect in 50 minutes to 1

[15:53]hour but where they wanted more on that for example you know

[15:55]>> yeah naturally >> so when when I'm when we've put this

[15:58]library behind us it's not just for display um you know you

[16:05]mentioned to me about like for example fitan over there fit of

[16:09]you know it's a very very important important work next to it

[16:14]takes you back to very early works.

[16:16]Now one thing I do believe is that the scholars or the

[16:19]resident alims have to ensure that there's a library in the mosque

[16:24]or a bookshop in the mosque and have to take the community

[16:27]on small tours showing them each of the books when they were

[16:30]written why they were written.

[16:32]>> Nice.

[16:33]So for example right now I could do this.

[16:36]I can show you why exactly the was written.

[16:41]Why is written why is written why Islam of is written why

[16:47]Abu D is written why all these works are written.

[16:54]I could show you all of these and I want to show

[16:55]the development of them.

[16:56]And I think that's missing in our communities.

[16:58]You hear these names and you're like when was that written?

[17:00]Was it like Mafia Jan was the classic example?

[17:03]You ask anyone Mafati when was it written?

[17:06]Many of people be like he must be some really and you

[17:07]only wrote it about 90 years ago.

[17:09]Yeah.

[17:10]100 years.

[17:09]>> 100 years ago.

[17:11]So you know this is what we're trying to inculcate in our

[17:13]cultures inshallah.

[17:14]>> So say before we move away from the library I want

[17:17]to ask you is there a book in particular that surprised you

[17:18]this Ramadan and one that's your personal favorite from the collection.

[17:24]a book that of Ahmed okay of Ahmed H could have been

[17:32]the turning point of when I im Ali becomes the forthrightly guided

[17:34]Khalifa because up until Ahmed Im Ali was not the forthrightly guided

[17:38]Khalifa there was only three rightly guided Khalif I see okay >>

[17:41]Sahabah has got some phenomenal of IM Ali Alam I'm telling you

[17:46]I'm telling you the description of Im Ali and Fah of Ahmed

[17:49]Hal if you didn't know better you' think it's a Shia book

[17:52]>> you said that in your lecture character when you mentioned this

[17:54]book.

[17:54]>> Yeah.

[17:55]>> So is one that surprised me.

[17:58]And the other one did you say personal favorite?

[17:59]>> Personal favorite from this collection.

[18:00]>> Personal favorite.

[18:02]Where do you begin?

[18:03]There's there's so many good ones.

[18:06]Um what could I say is personal favorite?

[18:09]I always kafi always there's always a hadith that pops up in

[18:13]al kafi which even if you think you've read through the whole

[18:16]of al kafi there always every month or so of reading al

[18:20]kafi there's always one hadith that pops up whether whether theology whether

[18:24]historical whether which pops up and I I think it that it

[18:28]still remains >> um it still remains a treasure >> sense now

[18:32]say we've delved into the library quite extensively and I think alhamdulillah

[18:35]you've spoken for quite a bit we give a little bit of

[18:38]a break in when once we return we can go now more

[18:39]into the viewers questions if that's okay.

[18:41]So for all of our viewers in we'll take just a short

[18:44]break and when we return we'll be going over your questions with

[18:46]the say it.

[18:48]Thank you.

[18:47]>> Just a short while ago we came to you with a

[18:51]dream.

[18:51]Imam Hussein TV finally has a new home thanks to your generosity.

[18:55]This chapter is something special.

[18:57]We're finally bringing everything to life.

[19:04]Phase one of the Zenobia complex starts here on the ground floor.

[19:10]The studios are being developed.

[19:11]Shortly you'll hear the voices you love to hear and the stories

[19:13]about the B.

[19:16]Also on this floor is something special Hussein dedicated to Imam Sadam.

[19:22]Phase 2 brings this floor to life.

[19:27]All the background work be editing development for all of your favorite

[19:29]shows happens on this floor.

[19:32]The stuff you don't get to see, the magic behind the camera

[19:35]is all here.

[19:36]Phase three is all about sustainability with offices being created to allow

[19:43]the channel to generate rental income.

[19:46]This phase is all about the long-term vision of the channel, have

[19:50]the opportunity to rent an office in our new home.

[19:54]You helped us secure a foundation.

[19:58]This Ramadan helped us build it.

[20:00]Every single donation leaves a legacy.

[20:02]This is a place for community, family, and most importantly, every single

[20:08]one of you.

[20:08]Donate this month.

[20:11]Build with us.

[20:32]I'm going home.

[21:02]Heat.

[21:04]Heat.

[21:25]amlaykum and welcome back and thank you so much for joining us

[21:30]after the break.

[21:29]Now, alhamdulillah, we've so far been discussing this extensive library which we

[21:34]have behind us.

[21:35]But many of you have asked how can I send in my

[21:39]questions.

[21:39]So if you send a WhatsApp message to plus447939917163 with all your

[21:47]questions and inshallah across the rest of the three nights they'll be

[21:49]answered.

[21:50]Now one thing so far that we've seen is that sed is

[21:52]really passionate about reading and I pray that inspires your children and

[21:56]yourselves to get into reading about Islam.

[21:57]As he said you can only get 20% of the actual knowledge

[22:02]from the scholars of nimba.

[22:03]So when you're reading from the sources you learn a lot more.

[22:05]Now say as we return this year you quoted al kuri and

[22:09]was a a lot more and a lot more of the shia

[22:13]books last year it was more of an aspect where a lot

[22:16]of our didn't even know these books existed so why has it

[22:18]taken so long for us to finally open these books >> yeah

[22:22]these books were normally the remit of of the seminaries in all

[22:27]honesty >> and by the way until today they're not easy to

[22:29]uh to read unless you have a mentor or a teacher okay

[22:34]so even sometimes When people do hear me say go and study

[22:37]al kafi when I say that I put the um you know

[22:41]I I must put the uh disclaimer that it needs a mentor.

[22:46]It needs a teacher.

[22:46]>> True.

[22:47]>> Um so that they're able to unpack these hadiths for you.

[22:53]uh but alhamdulillah you know recently seeing and the translations are getting

[22:58]better and more volumes are you know uh emerging and being a

[23:03]made available and recently I've also seen I think is somewhere here

[23:09]I'm sure we've got a couple of the volumes I think over

[23:11]there you seen yeah so we got here and still are haven't

[23:21]been translated is here and I think that you know the onus

[23:24]again I keep repeating should be on the resale that the resale

[23:28]should be the one who keep opening up these books encouraging for

[23:31]more people um to read inshallah um because I've seen this in

[23:38]other schools in Islam you know sometimes you go to a jama

[23:41]in a mosque somewhere >> of you know other sects in Islam

[23:44]and you'll see them sitting in a circle afterwards and reading hadiths

[23:47]and you know discussing hadiths >> it's much more common in them

[23:50]it's much more natural for them as well especially after I know

[23:52]it sounds silly to say that I've seen a lot of my

[23:54]Sunni friends that say afterawi they've learned more hadith than they do

[23:57]anytime because after they sit together and they talk which we don't

[24:00]really have in our communities.

[24:01]>> Yeah.

[24:01]like we do in in one way for example in Muharam you

[24:05]know there's there is a lot more you know after the melus

[24:07]people hang out and discuss the lecture of course >> you know

[24:11]and remember we have we have lectures in muharam as well >>

[24:14]um so you got already one hour of a discussion on something

[24:17]but I do I do believe that sometimes there has been neglect

[24:19]and that's why I felt this year unlike the previous two years

[24:23]where it was mainly only the literature of non-shia uh this year

[24:26]I wanted to bring in more evidence from Shia literature say you're

[24:30]the head of the prophet Muhammad institute.

[24:32]I know the institute is a massive thing in your life.

[24:35]Can you tell us a little bit more about the institute and

[24:37]the main goals that you have with the institute for the coming

[24:39]year in?

[24:40]>> Yeah.

[24:41]The the Prophet Muhammad Institute is um is is founded upon a

[24:50]personal aspiration of mine and that was to teach the subjects that

[24:54]I had studied years ago at the seminary or academically.

[24:56]>> Okay?

[24:58]you know um many of my discussions were on me but I

[25:03]felt that I needed to have also courses that I teach.

[25:06]>> Sure.

[25:06]>> You know so while a lot of people may hear you

[25:09]speak for 10 nights in muharam or in the holy month of

[25:13]Ramadan they they want to maybe take part in a course that

[25:15]you supervise or that you teach for 6 weeks for eight weeks

[25:19]for 10 weeks.

[25:19]And so we we done for example Shia history.

[25:21]I think you know your dad was there in the Shia history

[25:25]course which was 15 um 15 weeks um and we had a

[25:32]great uh core group of students who took the Shia history course.

[25:35]We also had introduction to alafi >> that was a course.

[25:41]We also had introduction to Shia hadith studies you know that was

[25:45]another course that we had.

[25:46]And if people go you know if you if you look online

[25:50]I on my Instagram page of course um and you'll find you

[25:56]know the prophet Muhammad Institute um as one of the pages that

[25:59]I follow you'll see all the courses that are going to be

[26:01]available starting from after shah Ramadan we have a surah jin coming

[26:07]up >> uh we're going to have um public speaking of course

[26:10]>> we're going to have connection with god and spirituality another course

[26:15]coming up we have a great course by sammed on introduction to

[26:18]Islamic philosophy.

[26:20]So that's the aim.

[26:19]The aim was to have uh those courses being made available to

[26:22]people outside of Muharam and Shah Ramadan where they were able to

[26:27]continue their learning and be under someone who could be a mentor

[26:30]for their learning.

[26:30]>> Say now this uh question comes from one of our Sunni

[26:34]brothers.

[26:35]He was asking, "Have you seen any of the Sunni scholarship?

[26:37]And who would you say is the most prolific Sunni scholar of

[26:42]all time?

[26:40]Could you name your top three?" Well, I think I've seen the

[26:46]Sunni scholarship for sure.

[26:47]In terms of the most prolific Sunni scholar of the three top

[26:51]three >> top three they've given.

[26:52]>> Top three would be in terms of the most prolific it

[26:59]would be.

[27:09]Yeah.

[27:13]and probably Iben Haj probably is the most prolific.

[27:18]>> Okay.

[27:19]>> Three Sunni scholars um of all time.

[27:21]>> If I've asked about Sunni, it's only fair if I ask

[27:24]about our Shia scholars.

[27:24]Who would you say your favorite three or the top three most

[27:28]prolific Shia scholars that you feel that you've read from?

[27:30]>> Shia most prolific scholars in terms of how much they've written

[27:35]would have to beh.

[27:39]>> Yeah.

[27:39]>> Very nice.

[27:41]Now there's another question here about sociology and anthropology.

[27:44]You know in these times many people say that we don't need

[27:48]unity and we don't sorry we don't need to be disunited.

[27:52]We need to discuss unity and not discuss these differences.

[27:54]Why do you choose a topic like Shia Sunni when it can

[27:58]cause more problems at a time like this?

[27:59]>> Yeah.

[28:00]I think everyone's got their theory about what should be uh done

[28:04]in this period and I I you know and and then they

[28:06]you can still work for uniting the um >> Mhm.

[28:10]Um, I don't think, you know, it's mutually exclusive.

[28:13]If a person does a show looking at the of the Sunnia

[28:17]world and the of the Shia world or the history of the

[28:19]Sunnia world and the history of the Shia world or the laws

[28:23]of the Sunnia world and the laws of the Shia world, that

[28:25]doesn't mean that that person is not going to walk outside of

[28:29]this studio and promote for Muslims to socially come together for a

[28:32]common cause or a common goal.

[28:34]Um, I also have a theory that you can't claim to want

[28:43]to build a world where people come together unless you appreciate what

[28:46]another school believes in.

[28:49]We think Sunni Islam believes in A B C D E F

[28:55]G.

[28:55]Have you read the books of Sunni Islam?

[28:57]Because we're um bringing these books and we're putting them on the

[29:01]table.

[29:04]A person cannot say I know Islam and they don't know they

[29:11]don't know they don't know they don't know then how could you

[29:15]say I want to unite with a group of people I don't

[29:17]even know what's in their literature >> naturally of course >> I

[29:21]can only unite with a group of people of course I have

[29:27]to see which tangent of unity am I talking am I talking

[29:31]unity In terms of theological unity or social unity, there's two different

[29:37]things.

[29:37]>> Very different things naturally.

[29:39]Yeah.

[29:38]>> Theological unity.

[29:39]The idea that Muslims should come together because theologically they have a

[29:44]lot in common.

[29:44]Yes, that could be a good slogan in terms of we all

[29:48]believe in.

[29:50]But the way we view the world even when it comes to

[29:57]these is different.

[29:56]>> Very different.

[30:00]Socially there is absolutely nothing stopping people if you are now at

[30:06]work and you are working with some of our Sunni brothers and

[30:09]sisters me discussing what's in Bkari and what's in Muslim and what's

[30:13]in what's in for example the works of I'm discussing creed I'm

[30:19]not discussing the people the people are our brethren >> naturally >>

[30:22]the people are our brethren we can break bread visit each other

[30:27]we do Hajj with each other we're not discussing the people who

[30:31]follow the madhab.

[30:34]We are discussing the theological texts of the madhab.

[30:38]Why?

[30:38]Firstly, because until today, would you agree with me that on Twitter

[30:48]or on Insta, >> you still have page after page after page

[30:51]after page debating what do the believe in?

[30:54]>> Naturally.

[30:54]>> True.

[30:55]Of course.

[30:57]And you'll still get someone taking a a page from Alfi or

[31:00]from Bihar alsan or fan and saying look what these Shia believe.

[31:07]I don't look at that person say oh you're causing disunityity.

[31:11]No the person has every right to say look the Shia don't

[31:14]realize that even in their books they have this.

[31:17]Okay.

[31:18]Likewise I want to show you that even in your books >>

[31:19]some of the things that I believe in are in your books

[31:21]>> naturally.

[31:22]So don't tell me it's absurd that I believe that Imam Ali

[31:26]was the greatest person after the prophet peace be upon him his

[31:31]family and should have been the first khalif of the Islamic state

[31:35]because here is fah abcde efg here is bkari abcdfg here is

[31:42]I see secondly also we are discussing our because 95% of the

[31:48]shia world stops discussing their when they're 16 years old and they've

[31:54]left their local medasa.

[31:54]>> 100%.

[31:55]>> Would you agree?

[31:56]>> 100 100%.

[31:58]>> Your last days in Madrasa were when?

[32:01]>> 2016 2017.

[32:02]>> How old were you?

[32:03]>> 16.

[32:04]>> 16.

[32:04]>> Yeah.

[32:06]>> When you needed to dissect your theology the most is when

[32:11]you >> started leaving.

[32:11]>> Started leaving >> naturally.

[32:13]As a 16-year-old, it's when you want to know more depth about

[32:15]understanding ima ma understanding how Islamic history evolved, how Islamic law was

[32:29]crystallized and the different schools evolved.

[32:31]But most of us stop learning at 16.

[32:35]>> Yeah.

[32:38]>> In our local communities, don't we?

[32:40]>> Yeah.

[32:41]So when we stop learning at 16 in our local communities, there

[32:46]is a need for then someone to step up and say, "Let

[32:49]me take you back to understandinghed in our school and its comparison

[32:54]with others.

[32:55]Let me take you back to understanding uh Noua and our school

[32:59]and how we don't believe our prophet is bewitched, affected by shan,

[33:03]someone who wants to jump off a cliff >> and so on

[33:08]and so forth.

[33:09]And so when we discuss these things in the holy month of

[33:13]Ramadan, we it doesn't come in the way of us hoping that

[33:17]all Muslims are safe and secure.

[33:18]Doesn't come in the way of us hoping that all Muslims are

[33:20]happy in life.

[33:22]doesn't stop us in the way that if a Muslim brother is

[33:23]in need I don't look at his mab rather I look at

[33:27]the fact that they are a fellow believer in the religion so

[33:31]these types of things when people say it's not the time to

[33:35]discuss these things we're discussing our theology and everybody needs to make

[33:38]sure that they protect the of them and their children inshallah >>

[33:40]so say that having said that do you feel that there's a

[33:43]lot of our youth who lack the knowledge about our own sect

[33:46]let alone looking at the sunni sect and is that why you

[33:47]looked more at Shia books this year >> yeah yeah as a

[33:51]lot of would not have picked up say sometimes I would quote

[33:54]from or fromh or from for example you know other creed works

[34:02]a lot of people wouldn't have opened these creed works >> naturally

[34:05]>> so sometimes you know when you're like when someone says something

[34:08]I say oh I don't really believe in that and you're like

[34:10]ah that means you're not Shia because you got to believe in

[34:13]that well is that what the creed books say that we have

[34:14]to believe in >> but if you haven't opened those creed books

[34:16]>> you won't even know >> then you won't know so you

[34:19]start adding your own things that should be in Shiaism and that's

[34:22]why yeah sometimes we haven't read our creed books there might be

[34:25]Shia who are watching the show right now if you ask them

[34:29]name three four five of the most important theological creed works in

[34:32]Shiaism they wouldn't be able to because they've in one way inherited

[34:34]Shiam from their parents or I'm Shia because my dad Shia I

[34:40]really don't know the ins and outs of it and and you

[34:43]know there are others who want to learn more and if our

[34:45]lectures cater for those who who you know who want to listen

[34:49]to these things then alhamdulillah alhamdulillah So this question has actually come

[34:52]from Canada.

[34:51]I want to learn about the 14,000400 year old journey of Shia

[34:57]Islam as a Sunni.

[34:57]What is the book that you would recommend for me to start

[35:06]with?

[35:01]1,400y old journey of Shia Islam.

[35:08]So it's a a book that probably is looking at the whole

[35:13]development of Shiaism.

[35:13]>> Inshallah.

[35:16]Hopefully.

[35:18]So >> yeah.

[35:16]Um, I think there's two books I may refer to.

[35:22]One is by Andrew Newman.

[35:24]Oh, >> okay.

[35:24]>> Andrew Newman looks at the development of Shiaism at least for

[35:29]the last thousand years.

[35:30]>> Um, and the development of Shia literature.

[35:33]I think he's a professor at Edinburgh University if I'm not mistaken.

[35:37]Andrew Newman.

[35:38]And the book is available on Amazon.

[35:41]The second one I think is a book called History of Islam.

[35:44]uh I think it's by Mar said Akar Risby father of said

[35:48]Muhammad and I'm I'm sure said Muhammad Risby was involved in the

[35:50]finishing of that book.

[35:51]>> Yeah.

[35:51]>> Um and that will give you an overview of the development

[35:55]of Islamic history.

[35:58]Um and so on and so forth.

[35:59]Um so those those would be two books >> two different approaches

[36:02]as well.

[36:03]One from a our theology perspective, one from a non Shia theology

[36:06]perspective.

[36:06]So quite nice.

[36:07]>> Very true.

[36:08]>> Um now something that's quite a hot topic right now.

[36:11]It's come from one of our viewers in America.

[36:14]He's saying that Shia politics in the Middle East is quite a

[36:16]hot topic right now.

[36:18]Say, what book would you recommend that I read to get a

[36:21]better understanding of Shia politics within the Middle East?

[36:24]>> Yeah.

[36:26]Which book uh to understand Shia politics in the Middle East?

[36:32]Uh Lawrence Luer.

[36:30]I think it's pronounced Lu or it's a French >> surname and

[36:36]it's L O U E R.

[36:38]>> Okay.

[36:39]>> All right.

[36:40]He has a book called Sunni and Shia.

[36:42]a political history something like this.

[36:45]>> Yes.

[36:46]>> And that gives you an understanding of the politics of Shiaism

[36:52]especially in the Middle East.

[36:54]That's a very good book to read.

[36:56]Sunni and Shia Sunni and Shia political history.

[36:59]I think it's called by Lawrence Ler.

[37:00]>> Okay.

[37:01]A question from New Jersey.

[37:04]I want to learn about the hadith which showed bias against Imam

[37:08]Ali from early works all the way until Ibia.

[37:12]Yeah, that you the best person to who discusses that in my

[37:17]opinion would be Professor Nabil Hussein.

[37:19]>> Nabil Hussein.

[37:19]>> Yeah, Professor Nabil Hussein um in the University of Miami.

[37:25]>> Oh wow.

[37:27]Okay.

[37:26]>> He has um extensive work on the legacy of the Nawas.

[37:34]>> Okay.

[37:35]So he discusses how that nasp you know the nas of IM

[37:40]Ali how it develops within Sunni Islam >> and the different layers

[37:45]of it within Sunni Islam from the most diluted those who give

[37:47]to Mah to how it becomes extreme those who show hatred to

[37:52]mah to those who don't know that they're showing hatred to those

[37:55]who are state sponsored hatred it's a really excellent analysis professor Nabir

[37:59]Hussein is definitely the expert in that area of looking at hate

[38:02]towards Imam Ali Alisam so he has a which is available called

[38:05]the legacy of the nawas.

[38:07]>> Very nice >> and it's definitely a super read on my

[38:11]on my um >> on my website on samar.com I have a

[38:16]podcast >> with professor Nabil Hussein and so we discussed the book

[38:21]and how he wrote the book.

[38:21]It's it's really really interesting.

[38:23]>> Alhamdulillah.

[38:24]Um say that a question from New York a Q&A about last

[38:29]night's episode.

[38:31]Didn't I imic have a daughter named Isha?

[38:34]You explained about the khalifs named with imams.

[38:35]But how do we explain Imam Sadi in the times of no

[38:41]having a daughter called Imak and the list of the names of

[38:51]his children.

[38:49]Sheh Mufi does not name an as a daughter of Imam.

[38:57]As you know she mued we have over there.

[38:59]And yesterday I had listed I had said the books that she

[39:06]mued list or the names of the of the sons of Imam

[39:10]in the book of Mui Kab in the list of the children

[39:15]of Saddak he names 10 children that Im had and none of

[39:17]them is called Aisha.

[39:18]>> I see.

[39:21]So where would >> other works?

[39:23]Other works mention was a lady who went with after the incident

[39:31]of to Egypt the incident of when the Shia were beheaded.

[39:34]Yeah, this this reference says daughter of Im went with to Egypt

[39:45]after the incident of incident of takes place about 170 after supposedly

[39:54]dies 145 after that means who's this daughter.

[39:59]So we um according to a number of scholars we reject this

[40:05]particular um attribution to Imam.

[40:08]>> And I'd like to make this point when people are saying

[40:13]if I im Ali named his sons Abu Bakr Omar and I

[40:16]you know I discussed this last night that means that that's a

[40:19]show that he loves them.

[40:19]>> Did Abu Bakr name his son Ali or did Omar name

[40:23]his son Ali or didman name his son Ali?

[40:26]Did Abu Bakr name his son Hassan?

[40:28]Or did Omar name his son Hassan?

[40:30]Or did name his son Hassan?

[40:32]>> Did Abu Bakr name his son Hussein?

[40:38]Did Oman name his son Hussein?

[40:39]Did Oman name his son Hussein?

[40:41]None of them named their children after Ali or Hassan or Hussein.

[40:44]So therefore, I ask a question.

[40:45]Does that mean Abu Bakr hated Im Ali and Im Hassan and

[40:49]Im Hussein?

[40:50]Because if you're saying that the fact that Imam Ali names his

[40:53]sons after Abu Bakr means that he's so happy with them and

[40:57]pleased with them and loves them the opposite.

[40:58]If they don't name Ali Hassan and Hussein knowing >> that he's

[41:04]done this >> knowing Ali's knowing and you paradise why wouldn't you

[41:08]name your children after these very >> something to reflect on actually

[41:15]um say this Ramadan it was quite an interesting Ramadan naturally we

[41:18]saw some of the most famous kick streamers starting their streams with

[41:22]chess beating some of them taking their tops off to show off

[41:27]their latmia scars and you know Oh, look.

[41:28]I've got marks on my chest.

[41:29]And one of them was famously Sneo.

[41:30]And then Sneo talked about Imam Sab bless you as a man.

[41:35]And you did an episode discussing that.

[41:36]Has he invited you to do a collaboration?

[41:39]One of our views is asking, "No, no.

[41:43]Um, there's been a number of people who've reached out and if

[41:46]I give benefit of the doubt to him, >> Mhm.

[41:48]>> he seems to be positive about something, but it's something that

[41:52]he keeps saying, I'll discuss later or I'll look at later." Mhm.

[41:54]He has spoken with a couple of our brothers Hassan and somebody

[42:00]else discussing Shiaism.

[42:01]>> Yeah.

[42:01]>> Um but it doesn't seem like Sneo will bring on somebody

[42:06]who's uh you know seen as a Shia scholar.

[42:08]He'll only bring people who are working hard on YouTube or social

[42:11]media and so on.

[42:12]>> Even we had a friend of ours Ahmed who reached out

[42:15]to him and again there was a positivity and then he doesn't

[42:18]reply after that.

[42:19]I see >> who knows and then they listen.

[42:22]It's up to him.

[42:22]Why why are people so adamant that you know what he has

[42:26]to talk to a if he wants to talk to a Shia

[42:29]he will and if he's made up his mind that he knows

[42:31]enough about Shiaism it's up to him it's not going to make

[42:35]a difference to Shiaism whether you know he he joins Shiam he

[42:37]doesn't join it's up to him what haya he wants what worldview

[42:42]he takes and inshallah he's guided towards whatever he finds truth >>

[42:45]do you feel that that this Ramadan has been quite special in

[42:49]the sense that someone like him who had a very hardcore viewership

[42:52]against Shiaism when he first came to Islam because of the way

[42:56]he was taught by Islam has suddenly started softening his views and

[42:59]suddenly started changing his perspective.

[43:00]Do you think it's been a unique Ramadan in that sense?

[43:02]>> Yeah, look there Shiaism at the moment.

[43:04]Even non Shia are just looking and saying she are the only

[43:08]ones who are you know speaking out against injustice.

[43:10]Shia are the only ones who are even voicing against arrogance and

[43:13]oppressors.

[43:14]Sh the only one you see whose men turn out to be

[43:20]real men with their chests out and even you know the friends

[43:22]that he hangs around with who would have imagined a year two

[43:26]years 5 years ago they would be praying for Iran dua um

[43:28]and you know you you see now that all the prayers have

[43:33]begun we pray for everybody inshallah our duas are for everybody >>

[43:37]in these times inshallah >> say you've quoted often sunni hadith and

[43:42]under it it says it's so why use it on the show

[43:45]when it's not a reliable source.

[43:47]>> Yeah.

[43:48]Doesn't mean something can't be used.

[43:49]I think sometimes people have this impression that if something's it means

[43:52]that it's like fake.

[43:54]>> Yeah.

[43:54]>> No.

[43:55]Then they um firstly you could get a number of hadiths and

[44:00]you might end up getting a strong piece of evidence.

[44:02]>> Anyone who studies hadith will know this.

[44:04]Um you're building an argument together and you might have a mass

[44:08]number and that comes to strengthen your argument.

[44:11]I think number two what's very important is Sunni books of hadith

[44:16]are not my barometer for >> h >> I am only using

[44:20]them to show that once upon a time this was mentioned somewhere

[44:23]there by a big Sunni scholar >> now if someone comes later

[44:27]on says this is hadith because of X it's weak because of

[44:30]Y it's >> that I'm going back a thousand years ago to

[44:33]that book and that book is showing me whether you like it

[44:37]or you don't somebody somewhere had mentioned this and that scholar decided

[44:42]to include But anyone who imagines that I'm relying on Sunni literature

[44:46]to find h.

[44:49]No, >> I'm only showing those who say to us where did

[44:50]you guys get these beliefs or these thoughts from that it's from

[44:54]your books.

[44:55]>> Um say we only have about four or five minutes left

[44:57]and for all of our viewers at home many of you have

[45:00]been asking how do I send in questions again please send WhatsApp

[45:02]messages to plus447939917163.

[45:07]Inshallah we have three more nights.

[45:08]We're blessed to have said for three more nights for this impeccable

[45:13]Q&A where he's actually been going in quite deep into some of

[45:16]the questions which you guys have.

[45:17]Now a final question for tonight would be why is there mixed

[45:20]opinions in the Sunni world about helping our brothers within the Middle

[45:24]East?

[45:24]And I think that's quite a heavy topic for today.

[45:30]So >> if I can give some time on that.

[45:31]>> Yeah, I think it's one that we need to talk about

[45:34]maybe even tomorrow and go, you know, go a bit further.

[45:38]Look in the Sunni world at the end of the day you've

[45:40]got different scholarships and different schools when it comes to their opinions.

[45:45]If you look in the Salafi world for example, there is an

[45:49]extreme between the Salafi who obeys the king of a country versus

[45:52]the Salafi who's a jihadi who is ready to rebel against an

[45:57]you know an unjust ruler.

[45:57]And and so therefore in the Sunni world there's always been this

[46:00]theological issue.

[46:02]Is it complete obedience to the king or a royal family because

[46:05]there is a Muslim in power and that you shouldn't cause disunityity

[46:10]or do you actually speak out when you see an authority figure

[46:12]who's oppressing the people?

[46:14]>> Of course.

[46:16]And of course now when you know people see what's happening um

[46:22]with the children um in Palestine um and the and all of

[46:24]the oppressed and when they see what's happening as I as you

[46:27]mentioned earlier people look at Lebanon and what's happening people see what's

[46:31]happening in Iran people are seeing what's happening all over the Middle

[46:34]East people are seeing what's happening in different parts and are you

[46:39]know are are getting agitated um you know it's not nice when

[46:44]you hear 1500 people have been uh killed here, 800 people here,

[46:47]a million displaced in Lebanon, for example.

[46:49]And so in the Sunni world, you'll have some people who will

[46:52]be like, "You've got to say something.

[46:54]This not right." At the end day, these are Muslim brethren.

[46:57]Then you'll have others who will say, "No, Shia are our enemies."

[47:03]And whoever's fighting them, they're also our enemies.

[47:07]So let the enemies fight each other and let the oppressors fight

[47:10]each other.

[47:11]And so that's where the whole debate now is raging >> because

[47:14]you'll have some in the Sunni world who will be like put

[47:19]all these titles aside.

[47:19]We're all Muslims.

[47:21]We see a Muslim.

[47:22]Others will say, "No, I will never forget that that Shia 16

[47:27]years ago in Sham.

[47:27]He done this and I'm never going to let go of what

[47:31]happened in Syria and so on." Others will say, "Look, if this

[47:33]group in Syria did this, but what have these got to do?"

[47:36]No, they've got to do with and that's where it's going back

[47:39]and forth.

[47:40]And that's why you've got to when you you mentioned Sneo earlier,

[47:43]Sneo doesn't come from a world where this Salafi imam is telling

[47:46]him this or this preacher is telling him this or this speaker

[47:49]is telling who's coming into a world where he's a convert and

[47:52]he's objective to a certain extent.

[47:53]He's just like listen these are the only guys who are doing

[47:56]anything about this.

[47:57]Exactly.

[47:57]>> Everybody else you guys are all talking about salawi and always

[48:03]remember something as well.

[48:03]The Sunni world for a long time their scholars would say what

[48:08]if the Shia contributed to Islam you see these clips on YouTube

[48:10]you Shia what have you ever given to Islam which battle did

[48:16]you fight you weren't salah you weren't the you weren't the this

[48:19]you weren't that >> if that was your criteria so what happens

[48:21]now you know now it's a it's an absolute mess for some

[48:26]people of the world because it's like the so-called minority of the

[48:31]mushiks are the ones who are with their chests out and everybody

[48:35]else >> y >> is looking at each other worried about whether

[48:40]they could go to McDonald's or Burger King on a Friday night.

[48:45]And so that whole statement that used to always be used that

[48:48]what have the Shia done for Islam name one thing they've done

[48:53]now everybody is like oh my god and the worst thing is

[48:55]that it's in a period of social media.

[48:57]>> Exactly.

[48:58]Exactly.

[48:58]So now the whole world has begun to ask hold on a

[49:01]minute and if you see online the number of people who've written

[49:03]to us you know when people say why do you guys discuss

[49:07]this in holy month of Ramadan look how it's fallen perfectly we're

[49:10]discussing these things at a time where a lot of people are

[49:12]asking what is shi we want to hear about shiaism what are

[49:16]the beliefs of shiam why is it the shia have got this

[49:18]passion and why is it that the shia enjoying the good and

[49:23]forbid the evil and so on and so forth and so many

[49:24]people want to learn about u >> I'm not sure if you

[49:29]saw um earlier on this month.

[49:30]I think both Adnan Rashid and Muy were called out to the

[49:34]extent that you guys are cowards, you guys are staying silent, this

[49:36]and that.

[49:37]And then they tried to ignore it, but there was so much

[49:39]backlash that you guys always say this about the cheaters, this about

[49:42]the cheaters and stuff.

[49:44]And somebody put one of our links and a link of your

[49:45]lecture where you were discussing the importance of speaking out against injustice

[49:48]and then he stayed quiet and then suddenly he put something on

[49:53]his story like an hour later and it's gone crazy everywhere.

[49:54]>> Yeah.

[49:55]Look, I think they we don't want to like backbite individuals in

[49:59]particular and say that this guy or this guy, I think they

[50:02]these people must have their reasons.

[50:03]And look, even if I disagree with someone's worldview, they must have

[50:07]their reasons for why they're doing that.

[50:08]>> Um, I cannot force my worldview on anyone, nor can they

[50:12]force their worldview on me.

[50:13]>> All I'm answering is why there's a schism in the Sunni

[50:16]world.

[50:17]Some in the Sunni world, their orders might come from a certain

[50:19]country or their funding might come from a certain country.

[50:22]>> Not true.

[50:23]And even in the Shia world, your funding might come from a

[50:26]certain country that dictates what you say or what you don't say.

[50:28]And this is the reality that happens in in in Muslim scholarship.

[50:31]In Muslim scholarship to be an independent molana or an independent is

[50:36]not easy because most people are working for someone who works for

[50:40]someone who works for someone.

[50:42]So therefore, whatever they're going to discuss, they have to think of

[50:46]the high Iraqi.

[50:45]Okay, excuse the pun.

[50:47]You have to think of the hierarchy.

[50:51]Yeah.

[50:52]in terms of who is funding me, who pays my bills, that

[50:54]will be the determinant factors in some cases of who speaks out

[50:59]and who doesn't.

[51:00]If I also was to give a benefit of the doubt, some

[51:03]people you know you know might find themselves in situations where in

[51:07]their mosques in that particular area the whole mosque will be shut

[51:11]down by a commission for example because you're now delving into politics

[51:15]and and and you know when when this mosque planning application was

[51:20]given it wasn't meant to be a charity that talks about politics

[51:22]you know what I mean or nonprofit that talks about >> but

[51:25]in the Sunni world as I said it's a major dilemma that

[51:28]they face but it's not the first time they face this dilemma.

[51:30]In the Sunni world, even if you go back to when Sunni,

[51:34]for example, when members of the Sunni community were being killed, there

[51:40]were still Sunni scholars who were silent about it.

[51:42]>> So now when some Shia are saying, where are all the

[51:45]Sunnis to speak up for us?

[51:46]There were times when the Sunni uh people were being killed in

[51:51]certain places and there were Sunni scholars who didn't speak up.

[51:53]>> Now am I going to pinpoint every one of those scholars?

[51:56]No.

[51:56]then that person knows um his relationship with Allah subhana wa tala

[52:00]and why he's not speaking up as women how do I not

[52:03]know that maybe at home that person is speaking up maybe he's

[52:06]teaching people individually without telling everybody publicly so that there isn't an

[52:10]eye on him that tries to ban him or tries to finish

[52:11]him and someone will say who cares if you get if you

[52:15]get banned well at day everybody has their own decision to make

[52:18]about their position in life like may have had a decision to

[52:24]make working with Harash do I do I leave is there a

[52:26]compromise for the Shia can we help our Shia out so there's

[52:31]a number of factors in this um and and like I said

[52:33]we can't generalize and say every Sunni there are some who are

[52:38]posting online kudos to the Shia the Shia are amazing learning from

[52:41]the Shia the Shia's bravery Hussein amazing their passion amazing so there

[52:45]are many out there who are saying I don't care if someone

[52:50]else is not saying anything I objectively can look at something I

[52:53]can remove the years of hatred that I've been indoctr ated with

[52:55]in my somewhere.

[52:58]I can remove all of those negative stereotypes that were given to

[53:02]me about believing Ali is God or that Jira made a mistake

[53:06]or that the Shia commit zena and their dark muharam malis and

[53:10]I can actually look in front of me and here's evidence here's

[53:13]literature all of it is in front of me and that's enough

[53:17]for me to make a decision in my life.

[53:20]Thank you so much, SA.

[53:22]We've taken quite a bit of your time.

[53:23]Appreciate it a lot.

[53:24]Alhamdulillah, we are blessed that we have you for these three more

[53:28]nights of Q&A, inshallah.

[53:28]And is there anything you'd like to say to the viewers before

[53:30]we end?

[53:30]>> No, keep sending in your questions.

[53:32]>> And I know I know there's so many coming in and

[53:34]we look forward to answering them in >> Thank you so much,

[53:38]S.

[53:38]God bless.

[53:37]>> And to all of our viewers, we want to thank you

[53:40]all for joining us.

[53:41]As I mentioned earlier on, this is our final Ramadan in this

[53:44]studio.

[53:45]Inshallah, we're moving to our new home, the Zenibia Complex.

[53:46]as you've been seeing the ads before say lectures and we look

[53:51]forward to hosting say next year at the Zenia complex as much

[53:54]as we can and with that was Hey, I am saying TV

[54:34]is more than just a TV channel.

[54:35]It's a university, a hosera for us to learn the lessons of

[54:40]the B.

[54:39]>> It's not just a house.

[54:43]It's a home.

[54:44]It's a school.

[54:43]It's a really big im where we find out about the important

[54:47]message of Alam.

[54:48]>> Imm Hussein TV3 relies on your contribution and your support.

[54:53]We are a crowdfunded project and we are starting a 14,000 subscriber

[54:57]campaign.

[54:58]Brothers and sisters, this is a true opportunity of a where you

[55:03]can donate remember and have a daily leaving your account.

[55:10]Abdah Hussein on the plains of Kbalah said, "Is there anyone to

[55:13]aid me?" Now you brothers and sisters can answer that call and

[55:16]carry on waving the banner of Abdah Hussein.

[55:19]>> Let's also speak about the incentives that you'll be receiving.

[55:24]Indeed, every month you subscribers and supporters will be put into a

[55:28]raffle draw where one person every month will be going to Kadbala.

[55:30]Three people will be receiving the flag of Abd Hussein from the

[55:35]holy shrines and five of you will be receiving rings from the

[55:37]holy shrine.

[55:37]>> Brothers and sisters, there are many more other incentives inshallah which

[55:41]we'll be speaking more about.

[55:46]Yes, there incentives like um you know um you can call in

[55:50]for a for question and answers for um some of them if

[55:55]you're lucky enough will be able to go to Imam Hussein TV

[55:57]and visit the roof where you can get a great view of

[56:01]the shrines.

[56:00]>> Let us take this opportunity to become subscribers of the 14,000

[56:04]subscribers that are needed.

[56:05]>> Join the 14,000 subscribers campaign today.

[56:08]Keep the message of the B alive.

[56:10]Receive 10 Carbella services and enter the big Carbella monthly raffle.

[56:17]Visit www.imhusainfree.tv/14,000.

[56:20]Alternatively, WhatsApp us on plus 442035150199.

[56:31]Oh yes.

[56:34]Let's find lecture.

[56:35]There it is.

[56:37]No, wait.

[56:38]Wish it were easy to watch the programs you love.

[56:42]>> Come on, let's watch Carbal live lecture.

[56:54]Wait, episode.

[56:57]Okay.

[56:58]Is it the sixth, the seventh?

[57:05]Why?

[57:06]>> The Imam Hussein Media Group Smart TV app has live programs,

[57:13]lectures, and recitations all in one place so you can easily watch

[57:17]what matters to you.

[57:20]Search Imam Hussein Media Group on your TV app store and download

[57:23]our app now.

0 تعليقات

التالي

25. Holy Month of Ramadan Q&A (Part 1) | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

Transcript

التالي

استكشاف المزيد

يرجى ملاحظة أنه إذا كان عمرك أقل من 18 عامًا ، فلن تتمكن من الوصول إلى هذا الموقع.

التالي

25. Holy Month of Ramadan Q&A (Part 1) | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

Transcript

التالي

استكشاف المزيد

اختيار طريقة الدفع

لغة