14. Knowing The Imam Of Your Time & Jahiliyya? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

4 المشاهدات· 26/03/03

Sayed Ammar Nakshawani Official
مشتركين

في محاضرات

Truth. Dialogue. Courage. After two compelling and impactful seasons, The Divide & Dialogue returns for Season 3—at a moment when silence is no longer an option, but a risk. As sectarian narratives intensify and misinformation deepens divides, this series fearlessly challenges accusations, unpacks misunderstandings, and confronts the uncomfortable truths shaping today’s Muslim world. This Holy Month of Ramadan, join Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshawani on Imam Hussein TV 3 for bold conversations, sharp historical insight, and a dialogue that refuses to be silenced. ——————————— Subscribe to Sayed Ammar’s official online platform, consisting of bespoke courses, exclusive content, brand new podcasts & more! https://www.sayedammar.com

أظهر المزيد

Transcript

[0:00]Are you ready for the biggest monthly Shia raffle?

[0:04]Introducing the big Kerbala monthly raffle held live every month on Imm

[0:09]Hussein TV3.

[0:10]Every month, three winners receive blessed shrine flags.

[0:16]Five receive marble rings from inside the holy shrine and one lucky

[0:20]winner receives a Zara ticket to Carbala.

[0:22]But this is more than prizes.

[0:24]When you join the 14,000 subscribers campaign, you help Imm Hussein TV3

[0:29]protect the message of the Bai defend our faith and educate the

[0:37]next generation worldwide.

[0:37]Your support becomes ongoing and in return you receive exclusive carabala services

[0:44]every month.

[0:46]Zara is recited on your behalf and your inability is given in

[0:53]your name.

[0:54]You receive one free and an Islamic wallpaper and access to a

[0:58]live Islamic law Q&A.

[1:01]Stay committed and the rewards grow.

[1:03]After 3 months, your mome's name and a photo are placed inside

[1:06]the shrine.

[1:08]And after 1 year, you receive a blessed from Carbala.

[1:11]And when you visit Carabala, you can visit the rooftop of Imam

[1:15]Hussein TV and personally receive your exclusive Carabala gift bag.

[1:22]The raffle runs every month and the rewards last forever.

[1:25]Visit Imam Hussein3.tv/14,000 TV/14,000 or WhatsApp + 44203515199.

[1:46]Hey, in the name of God the most beneficent, the most merciful.

[2:14]All praise is due to the Lord, master of all the worlds.

[2:19]And peace and blessings be on all his prophets and especially the

[2:24]final prophet, the prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi.

[2:26]My respected brothers and sisters, who is the imam of your time?

[2:39]Who was the imam in the time of Fat?

[2:41]who was the imam in the time of after the holy prophet

[2:46]peace be upon him and his family had passed away.

[2:50]One of the most contentious issues affecting the Muslim um from that

[2:55]time until today is obedience or disobedience to the imam of their

[3:00]time to the amir of their time to the khalifa of their

[3:06]time.

[3:07]Do they pledge allegiance to anyone?

[3:10]Do they agree with anyone who's elected?

[3:13]Do they have to accept anyone who's elected?

[3:18]Or are they allowed to disapprove?

[3:21]Are they allowed to disagree?

[3:21]If, for example, a Khalifa was appointed from the Umayids or from

[3:27]the Abbasids, are you meant to obey them irrespective of how irreligious

[3:31]they are?

[3:32]What if they're a drunkard?

[3:34]What if they're corrupt?

[3:34]What if they're someone who's oppressive?

[3:37]Am I meant to obey him because he's ruling me?

[3:42]Or am I allowed to withdraw this piece of obedience or this

[3:46]moment of a pledge of allegiance?

[3:48]If I do, then do I die the death of somebody who

[3:55]is a jahil or somebody who is acting like those in the

[4:02]state of Jah.

[4:01]We know that period of jahalyah is a period that can be

[4:06]summarized with two words and misguidance deviated astray or polytheism.

[4:17]Many of the traditions concerning knowing the Imam of one's time and

[4:21]obeying the Imam of one's time and pledging allegiance to the Imam

[4:27]of one's time without a doubt are affecting the Muslims today as

[4:34]they affected the Sahabah at that time.

[4:35]Because we know very well that there were disagreements as we've seen

[4:40]in the last few episodes between the Sahaba even in relation to

[4:45]who they believed should be the califf.

[4:48]Not all Sahabah necessarily agreed as we saw on the appointment for

[4:52]example of man or on the appointment of Muawia or on the

[4:57]appointment of Yazid.

[4:59]But now what's the responsibility of a person living in that time?

[5:03]Are they meant to obey that ruler irrespective of whatever the behaviors

[5:06]were of that ruler or are they allowed to raise an objection?

[5:12]Until today, this affects the Gulf, affects the Middle East, affects the

[5:16]Islamic world.

[5:15]Because sometimes a person may live in these countries and may see

[5:21]a ruler who's a tyrant, a ruler who's oppressive, a ruler who

[5:25]has gone away from the path of Islamic law.

[5:28]And then you ask yourself the question, do I look at this

[5:31]ruler and do I remain silent about this ruler or not?

[5:35]Am I allowed to rise against this ruler or not?

[5:39]Some Muslims will tell you, you must obey the ruler irrespective of

[5:42]whether they are a farid, whether they are a fire, whether they

[5:46]are unjust, whether they are transgressors, whether they are oppressors.

[5:51]Other Muslims will say to you, "No, how could you remain silent

[5:55]when you see any form of oppression?" We know very well that

[6:02]the leader of society, any society is fundamental to the growth of

[6:06]that society, to the guidance of that society.

[6:09]And we know very well that Islamically our Lord continued to send

[6:15]us leader after leader to guide our community.

[6:16]Those leaders were known of course as prophets and of course as

[6:22]messengers in the Quran.

[6:23]Sometimes they are called enia and sometimes they are called and sometimes

[6:28]they are given the title of imam cuz sometimes people do always

[6:34]ask the question why do you guys believe in im.

[6:35]We see imams throughout the Quran.

[6:37]The idea of a leader is not just that he's called an

[6:41]ebi in the Quran.

[6:42]Sometimes he's called a rasool.

[6:43]Sometimes he's called an imam.

[6:47]And imams can of course guide you in two ways.

[6:53]You may have the of and kufur and you may have the

[6:55]of haya towards the path of god.

[6:58]If you look in the Quran, join me in the Quran over

[7:00]here.

[7:00]If you go to surah 32 of the holy Quran, you'll see

[7:06]my dear brothers and sisters in surah 32 of the Quran surah

[7:09]saga.

[7:10]Everybody come with me over here.

[7:11]Let's go to surah 32 verse number 24 in surah 32man all

[7:19]of you can see over here we see very clearly that the

[7:32]Quran says we appointed leaders from amongst them guiding people by our

[7:37]command when they were steadfast in their dean.

[7:40]Now what we have over here, you may have a leader who

[7:43]guides you on behalf of God.

[7:48]That's one you have to obey unconditionally.

[7:49]Anyone who is chosen by God, you must obey unconditionally.

[7:54]And them reaching a rank of imam of their people, a person

[8:02]cannot disobey.

[8:04]A person can't even raise an objection to the one who has

[8:08]been appointed by God.

[8:08]When God appoints this person for us, we cannot stand up and

[8:13]say, "You are unjust.

[8:13]I don't trust you.

[8:16]Are you sure you're a prophet?

[8:17]You are delirious." You cannot do any of that to one who

[8:21]was appointed by God.

[8:21]Why?

[8:22]Because they are the ones being guided by God.

[8:26]Therefore, we have to obey them unconditionally.

[8:28]We have to pledge our allegiance to them from the first of

[8:31]them until the last of them.

[8:32]I must pledge my allegiance to them unconditionally.

[8:34]And we know very well that the Quran says you may have

[8:37]imams who are guiding you towards good.

[8:39]But you may also have this other conundrum where the Quran tells

[8:46]you that there are imams am leadershifas who might guide you astray.

[8:52]If you look again in the Quran in surah 28 of the

[8:54]holy Quran go to about verse 41 of surah 28 you'll see

[9:02]here what does the Quran say over here it says we made

[9:11]them leaders in this world summoning to the fire by their shik

[9:15]there are leaders who I see in my life from the beginning

[9:21]of Islam until the end.

[9:21]Some of those leaders are leaders who are taking me towards heaven.

[9:27]Others might be leaders who take me towards hell.

[9:29]Now then I have another conundrum.

[9:32]Can I obey a leader even if he's a Muslim publicly saysahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahu

[9:37]rasoolah sallallahu alaihi but if I feel that this leader has been

[9:44]unjust or has usurped someone's right has confiscated someone's property has hurt

[9:50]somebody especially if they are close to the holy prophet peace be

[9:54]upon him's family must I pledge an allegiance to them or no

[9:59]in sunni tradition there is this hadith as we'll see in clip

[10:03]number one which is always famously narrated about the importance of making

[10:10]sure that you have given be to the leader irrespective of who

[10:15]that leader is.

[10:18]Let's play clip number one.

[11:18]Normally in Shia literature we'll hear the im everybody knows that hadith

[11:28]that everybody would have come across that whoever dies without knowing the

[11:33]imam of his time dies the death of aah that's in literature

[11:36]in Sunni literature as the respected sheh just mentioned you have a

[11:42]similar hadith not exactly the same we say and jahalyah.

[11:48]Whoever dies without knowing the imam of their time dies the death

[11:51]of jahalyah.

[11:52]You'll see in Sunni literature there is something somewhat similar that a

[11:58]person must have pledged and have the pledge on their neck to

[12:03]the leader of their time otherwise they fall into a state similar

[12:06]to that of the people of Jahalia.

[12:08]The people of Jahali as I mentioned earlier were either on Dalala

[12:11]or they were on kufur and therefore if a person has a

[12:16]leader in their time they must have pledged their allegiance.

[12:18]So that leader and that pledge of allegiance must be there otherwise

[12:22]they die like they are in a state of jah.

[12:25]The Quran gives you a conundrum which also causes an issue.

[12:28]The Quran says there are leaders who will take you to heaven.

[12:32]Quran says there are leaders who will take you to hell.

[12:33]The Quran also says you got to be careful not to obey

[12:39]one who is unjust or for example one who is astray an

[12:45]evil doer one who's not grateful to Allah subhana wa tala come

[12:48]with me over here in surah 76 of the Quran verse number

[12:54]24 you'll see the verse what does it say okay so the

[13:02]Quran over Here what does it say?

[13:04]It say therefore wait patiently for the judgment of your lord as

[13:09]to how he decides to convey his message.

[13:13]Do not obey any unbelieving evildoer or thankless man amongst them.

[13:20]Okay.

[13:21]A person has to be careful that they do not obey a

[13:24]person who's evil.

[13:26]But someone says well what if is a Muslim Khalifa and he's

[13:29]an evil Muslim Khalifa.

[13:29]This caused a conundrum for the Muslims because the Muslims now had

[13:35]an issue.

[13:37]Be you Sunni, Shia, whichever sect you had.

[13:37]The issue was firstly did the prophet leave behind a leader or

[13:43]not.

[13:44]The Shia said that the prophet announced Ali as the leader.

[13:46]Therefore, it was incumbent upon the Shia to pledge their allegiance to

[13:51]Ali.

[13:51]In the Sunni world, of course, there were many different ways in

[13:55]which the leader was to be chosen.

[13:57]And then it became a conundrum because it becomes subjective.

[13:59]A first leader may be chosen at a second leader may be

[14:05]chosen by the first leader.

[14:06]The third leader may be chosen by six and a fourth leader

[14:11]may be chosen by the whole community.

[14:13]The fifth leader may have been involved in a war that led

[14:16]to the sixth leader Muawia after the abdication of the fifth leader.

[14:19]Now the people had a conundrum.

[14:21]Am I meant to have full obedience to the leader even if

[14:29]I've seen the leader is a or a if the Quran is

[14:35]saying to me very clearly that that do not obey any of

[14:45]them who evil or transgressor.

[14:45]What if I see a Muslim ruler who's blatantly evil and a

[14:51]blatant transgressor?

[14:52]Now when we come to look at that hadith, let's see what

[14:57]that hadith say on this particular area.

[14:58]Let's go to Bkari.

[15:02]All of us over here, there's a whole section which brings the

[15:06]concept of governance and to the Muslim and knowing the imam of

[15:09]one's time and understanding the am of one's time and your responsibility

[15:13]with them.

[15:14]Come with me over here.

[15:17]My dear brothers and sisters, volume 9 a hadith 6561 to 7563

[15:21]translated by Dr.

[15:26]Muhammad Minhan you can all see here dam publishers printed July 1997

[15:32]printing supervised by who by Abd Melik Mujah let's all go to

[15:35]page 162 you've got this whole section as you can see chapter

[15:43]4 to listen to and obey one's imam Muslim ruler as long

[15:51]as his orders involve not one in disobedience to Allah.

[15:58]Okay, this as you can see here.

[16:03]Now the first we have here 7142 narrated and bin Malik Allah's

[16:11]messenger said you should listen to and obey your im even if

[16:16]he was an Ethiopian black slave whose head looks like a raisin.

[16:23]where in look over here it's very important when you must obey

[16:34]your IM you must listen to your im even if it's an

[16:40]Ethiopian you must obey them in everything that they do then the

[16:44]next hadith hadith number 7143 narrated Ib Abbas the prophet sallallahu alaihi

[16:51]wasall said, "If somebody sees his Muslim ruler doing something he disapproves

[16:58]of, he should be patient.

[17:00]For whoever disunite from the Muslim group, they become separate from the

[17:07]Muslim group even for a span and then dies.

[17:10]He will die as those who died in the pre-Islamic period of

[17:14]ignorance." Join me.

[17:16]Let's read the Arabic.

[17:37]Look how clear this is that if you see the Muslim ruler

[17:43]doing something that you disapprove of, believe you me, these hadiths are

[17:47]still applicable to 2026.

[17:49]There are Muslims who live under Muslim rulers and sometimes you wonder

[17:54]he can see that this Muslim ruler is oppressive is a tyrant

[17:57]is a dictator has killed people has imprisoned people and you'll see

[18:01]some of them will refer to Bkari and say that look the

[18:06]prophet sallallahu alaihi wasall said if you come back to it if

[18:09]you see the Muslim ruler doing something he disapproves of he should

[18:16]be patient for whoever disunites from the jama of the Muslims even

[18:20]for a span and then dies he will die as those who

[18:26]died in the period of so you see that very clearly here

[18:33]what do we have we have very clearly that if a person

[18:35]is living at the time of a khalifa that khalifa may do

[18:40]something that you may for example have an issue with that you

[18:44]may disapprove of for example you cannot separate from the jama of

[18:49]the Muslims.

[18:50]Yes, but what if the Khalifa has confiscated my property?

[18:52]What if the Khalifa has usurped my rights?

[18:55]No, YOU CANNOT SPEAK OUT.

[18:58]WHY NOT?

[18:59]Why can I not speak out?

[19:02]No one thing that all of these Bkari and Muslim and other

[19:04]works are written at the time of the you dare to speak

[19:09]out against the Khalifa, your tongue will go, your ears will go,

[19:12]your legs will be chopped and so on and so forth.

[19:17]But also what's interesting is that the person who does separate from

[19:20]a community even if there is something that the ruler disapproves of

[19:24]then they die as if they are a jah.

[19:26]Now a question also arises.

[19:30]So must I give to whoever is the ruler whether I agree

[19:32]with them or not?

[19:35]Come with me to Sah Muslim.

[19:36]My dear brothers and sisters when I come to Sah Muslim volume

[19:41]number five from hadith number 4519 to 5645.

[19:44]All of you can see a hadith edited and referenced by Abu

[19:49]Tah translated by Kam.

[19:54]Final review by Abu Khal first edition August 2007 supervised by Abd

[20:00]Malik Mujah volume number five D Salam publishers over here my dear

[20:05]brothers and sisters if we go to page 184 join me over

[20:09]here it's of course the book of leadership all of you know

[20:12]the book of leadership very well in Sah Muslim over here you'll

[20:18]see my dear brothers and sisters over here the book of leadership

[20:23]of course Come with me over here.

[20:30]4793.

[20:27]It was narrated that said Abdullahb Omar came to who?

[20:36]Came to Abdah when the incident of Al occurred.

[20:42]The incident of Al, as you all know, is when Mu and

[20:48]his soldiers absolutely pillaged Medina and then later Mecca.

[20:56]They pillaged Medina and there was rape of the ladies in Medina

[21:00]and dogs were urinating everywhere and people were butchered.

[21:03]And that's why those who try and say Yazid is not to

[21:09]blame for then just look at Har come back please.

[21:11]Abdullahb Omar came true when the incident of occurred at the time

[21:18]of Yazid bin Muawia and he said set out a pillow for

[21:24]Abu Abdman.

[21:24]Okay.

[21:25]He said I have not come to sit with you.

[21:28]I have come to narrate to you a hadith.

[21:31]I heard the messenger of Allah sall say whoever withdraws his hand

[21:41]from obedience or rebelss against the ruler will meet Allah on the

[21:45]day of resurrection with no justification for his action and whoever dies

[21:51]not having sworn an oath of allegiance has died a death of

[21:54]ignorance let's read the Arabic over here read with me my dear

[22:00]brothers and sisters he comes to him over here.

[22:28]Now, here's the important part.

[22:36]Whoever dies not having sworn an oath of allegiance has died a

[22:44]death of ignorance.

[22:46]Now forget the point about this hadith and the importance of giving

[22:54]to Yazidaw from the great Abdah Omar.

[22:59]Forget that.

[23:03]That means that if a person decides that they are not going

[23:07]to give a to any of the Abu Bakr, Omar, Oman, Ali,

[23:13]Zuber, any of the after Ali, Yazid, all of these if you

[23:21]do not give them your then you die either in a state

[23:27]ofal or kufur.

[23:29]If the rule applies to all of them, this puts us in

[23:33]such a mess in Islamic history.

[23:37]Because if the idea is that I have to know the lead

[23:42]on my time and I must pledge allegiance to the lead on

[23:47]my time and that if I do not then I die the

[23:49]death of Jah as you saw in those a hadith.

[23:54]Then there are a number of notable people in the first 4550

[24:01]years after the prophet died who are on their way to hellfire.

[24:07]And I don't know how many Muslims are willing to say this.

[24:13]Let's look at the first one gave Abu Bakr when he became

[24:22]Khalifa not a chance.

[24:24]No way.

[24:24]If I read, let me get the musmed of Im Ahmed.

[24:28]If you read in the musn of Im Ahmed, you'll see very

[24:33]clearly that Fat Zah died without a on her neck for the

[24:36]first Khalifa and disapproved of the first Khalifa.

[24:40]No.

[24:40]Was angry with the first Khalifa.

[24:42]Do you have the bravery to say that Fat Zah died in

[24:47]a state ofal or in a state of you have that bravery

[24:49]or no?

[24:51]Come with me over here.

[24:54]The Muslim of Ahmed.

[24:53]Hadith number 1 to1380 Muhammad bini volume one translated by Kab edited

[25:03]by Hudabam publishers.

[25:04]All of you can see my dear brothers and sisters 2012 Saudi

[25:13]Arabia.

[25:12]Come with me over here.

[25:16]Let's go to page 41.

[25:16]Look over here.

[25:18]Hadith number 25.

[25:19]Let's zoom in narrated that Aisha the wife of the prophet told

[25:25]him that Fath the daughter of the prophet sallallahu alaihi asked Abu

[25:28]Bakr after the death of the messenger of Allah to give her

[25:32]her share of inheritance from that which the messenger of Allah had

[25:35]left behind of the fate that Allah had bestowed upon him Abu

[25:38]Bak said to her the messenger of Allah said our prophet's property

[25:44]is not to be inherited and whatever we leave behind is charity

[25:49]got angry.

[25:51]She disapproved of the khalifa of her time.

[25:54]My dear brothers and sisters and remember what the hadith said.

[25:57]Whoever disapproves from the jama then they die in a state of

[26:04]jah come back.

[26:03]Fatma got angry and kept away from Abu Bakr and she continued

[26:09]to do so until she died.

[26:12]Fatama lived for 6 months after the messenger of Allah s and

[26:18]she used to ask Abu Bakr 6 months for her share of

[26:23]that which the messenger of Allah had left behind of and his

[26:27]charitable endowments in Medina.

[26:28]But Abu Bakr refused to give her that.

[26:31]He said, "I will not stop doing something that the messenger of

[26:37]Allah he used to do.

[26:41]Rather, I will continue to do it." Now, is there anyone in

[26:48]the Sunni world who's willing to say that Fat Zah died in

[26:51]the state of Jah?

[26:52]Is there anyone?

[26:56]Because Fatan Zahar doesn't pledge allegiance to him.

[26:59]She doesn't see him as the imam of her time, the khalif

[27:02]of her time.

[27:02]Not at all.

[27:03]She completely rejects him.

[27:04]It's quite clear.

[27:06]And as Ahmed Muhammad says, she got angry with him and she

[27:09]kept on asking for her right.

[27:10]Very clearly Fathan Zah rejects him.

[27:12]Does Fathma Z die the death of someone in Jah?

[27:16]Second question is if you're meant to know let's say according to

[27:20]Shia sources of imah say that's in Shia sources who's Fatma's IM

[27:26]does Fatama know the im of her time because in Shia sourc

[27:30]it says whoever dies without knowing the imam of their time dies

[27:33]the death of ignorance if Fatma rejects Abu Bakr she must have

[27:38]an imam of her time otherwise she dies in the state of

[27:41]Jah Fatama's im no doubt is Im Ali and that's something to

[27:47]remember that even though the government got into power, Salman's im and

[27:51]the im of his time of immani mahal salman's im was Ali.

[28:00]Abu Dar's im was Ali.

[28:02]Amar's im was Ali.

[28:01]Makdad's im was Ali.

[28:05]Their im was imam.

[28:07]Now in the Sunni world if you haven't given to the leader

[28:11]of the time then you die in the state of Jah didn't

[28:15]give.

[28:16]Are you willing to say that the mistress of the woman of

[28:18]paradise?

[28:19]You know those four women you always mention as Mariam Khadijah and

[28:22]Fatma.

[28:22]Are you willing to say that she died in a state of

[28:26]jah?

[28:24]Because then it doesn't add up further.

[28:27]Why wouldn't Fat Zah accept Abu Bakr's Khalifa?

[28:30]If Abu Bakr has got all of these attributes, why would Fat

[28:35]Zahar not accept him?

[28:36]For what reason would Fat Zahar not give him allegiance if he

[28:39]is such a great old statesman and such a great political figure

[28:44]and so spiritual and the last man to lead prayers behind her

[28:48]father what's her issue with him if she does have an issue

[28:52]we all know Fatma is a part of me whoever angers her

[28:54]angers me and whoever angers me angers Allah so therefore if this

[28:59]hadith says that Abu Bakr angered Fatma Zah come back to the

[29:02]hadith again the hadith very clearly says Fatma got angry and kept

[29:04]away from Abu Abu Bakr if Zah got angry and kept away

[29:09]from Abu Bakr my dear brothers and sisters then that means that

[29:11]her anger is the same as the anger of the messenger of

[29:16]Allah.

[29:17]Therefore for us if someone says then we say that that person

[29:22]has committed kufur.

[29:22]If someone says must have known the imam of her time it

[29:25]certainly isn't Abu Bakr.

[29:27]Then who is the imam of her time?

[29:29]very clearly for us.

[29:29]The Imam of her time as per the incident of amongst others

[29:35]was Imam.

[29:35]Now that's in the case of Fatma.

[29:41]She rejects the so-called Khalifa or of her time and no one

[29:44]has the audacity to say that she dies in the state of

[29:49]Jah.

[29:50]Now what if the Sahaba reject the Khalifa of their time?

[29:52]Because remember one thing the hadith said that you have to have

[29:55]the pledge of allegiance for the khalif of your time and that

[30:01]you cannot disapprove of the khalif of your time.

[30:03]Something interesting is that has three interesting volumes which are all available

[30:08]for you my dear brothers and sisters in English for all of

[30:13]you to read.

[30:12]These three volumes are all available the history of tabari.

[30:17]This is the first of them.

[30:18]If you want to zoom in on this one, my dear brothers

[30:22]and sisters, you'll see that this one over here, the history of

[30:26]Tabari, the crisis of the early.

[30:28]You know how in Sunni Islam, you'll always talk about the greatest

[30:33]generation being that of the Sahabah and the and the forget what

[30:37]happened in Kbal.

[30:39]Yes, this is the most glorious generation.

[30:41]Forget, forget the killings of the great grandchildren of the prophet.

[30:45]The most glorious generation, mashallah.

[30:47]Anyway, Tabari here has the history of Tabari.

[30:51]You all know you have over here volume 15, the crisis of

[30:55]the early this crisis of the early is where we have a

[30:59]major conundrum.

[31:01]Many Sahabah who disapprove of a Khalifa.

[31:03]Do they die the death of Jah or not?

[31:06]You can't say that they all go to Jenna.

[31:08]But what if they disapprove of the Khalifa?

[31:11]Volume 15, the history of Tabari over here, of course, translated by

[31:16]Robert Steven Humphre.

[31:16]You've got over here volume 15.

[31:18]Volume 16 of Look at the title of volume 16.

[31:22]Volume 16 of I'll place them all together so all of you

[31:27]can see if you zoom into these three.

[31:30]Look at these.

[31:29]All of you are able to get this online.

[31:32]You can order these three on Amazon just in case you thought

[31:36]the Sahaba were all approving of the califfs.

[31:40]Many were disapproving.

[31:40]Does that mean they die in a state of jahalia?

[31:44]Volume 15.

[31:46]The community, sorry.

[31:45]Volume 15, the crisis of the early caliphate.

[31:50]Volume 16, the community divided.

[31:57]VOLUME 17, the first civil war.

[32:00]First one translated by Steven Robert Steven Humphre.

[32:03]The second one Adrien Brockett.

[32:05]The third one Gerard Horting.

[32:08]Okay.

[32:09]All of you can see over here we've got volume 15, volume

[32:12]16, volume 17 of which text of now when we want to

[32:20]see what is tabari showing us.

[32:22]He shows us that this whole idea that you must know the

[32:26]imam of your time.

[32:27]These companions knew of the Imam of their time but they disapproved

[32:33]of him big time.

[32:33]If anyone has launched a narrative and an attack on how the

[32:37]companions were so outspoken against the leader of their time and how

[32:44]they disapproved him and his cousin after him, all you have to

[32:50]do is open volume 15, volume 16 and volume 17 and look

[32:55]at the narrations within.

[32:56]Let's open volume 15 to begin with over here.

[33:00]The history of all of you can see my dear brothers and

[33:01]sisters.

[33:02]The history of Tabari volume 15 the crisis of the early kalafa

[33:05]translated by Robert Steven Humphre all of you can see over here

[33:11]series and near eastern studies state university New York you've got over

[33:15]here state university of New York press all of you can see

[33:18]the history oful and of course the mul if you come with

[33:22]me to page 183 let's see what it says over here my

[33:28]dear brothers and sisters come with me over here to the bottom.

[33:34]It was related to me.

[33:34]This is the event of the year 35.

[33:35]So this is the year in which bin gets killed.

[33:39]It's that period.

[33:41]Come back over here.

[33:41]It was related to me by Abdui Muhammad binasari his paternal uncleas.

[33:51]When the people saw what Otman was doing, the companions of the

[33:58]prophet in Medina wrote to the companions who were scattered throughout the

[34:02]frontier provinces, "You have gone forth but to struggle in the path

[34:06]of Almighty God for the sake of Muhammad's religion.

[34:10]In your absence, the religion of Muhammad has been corrupted and forsaken.

[34:16]Come then and reestablish Muhammad's religion." Thus they came from every direction

[34:21]until they killed Osman.

[34:26]Who killed Osman?

[34:29]Companions of Sai.

[34:30]Wall Allah you lied to people for so many years.

[34:34]Why did you lie?

[34:36]You said all these companions loved the first three and all of

[34:40]them admired them and all of them were inspired by them and

[34:43]all of them would pledge allegiance to them in a hurry.

[34:47]Look at the companions telling other companions.

[34:50]Look what they say.

[34:50]When the people saw what was doing, what was doing?

[34:55]Nepotism.

[34:56]By um were all over the place.

[34:59]Marwan Hakim had complete control.

[35:00]W Abb was drinking as much as he wanted.

[35:04]Even in salah.

[35:05]You could do whatever you want underman as long as you are

[35:07]related to him.

[35:08]When the people saw what was doing, the companions of the prophet

[35:11]in Medina wrote to the companions who were scattered throughout the frontier

[35:14]provinces.

[35:14]I thought all the companions were best friends and they all loved

[35:17]each other and they were all pious.

[35:21]It's them who led to the death of certainly think so.

[35:23]Come back.

[35:24]You have gone forth but to struggle in the path of God

[35:26]for the sake of Muhammad's religion.

[35:28]In your absence, the religion of Muhammad has been corrupted and forsaken.

[35:33]Come then and reestablish Muhammad's religion.

[35:37]A sahabi writes to other Sahabah that Allah's religion has been corrupted.

[35:42]If it was a Shia today saying that in a lecture they'll

[35:47]say they do not respect the companions.

[35:49]Go and sort out if you don't mind go and sort out

[35:51]this issue that the Sahabah had with each other and so blatant

[35:56]who they were amongst others who were all outspoken against the of

[36:04]their time.

[36:05]But what happens if someone's outspoken against the khalif of their time?

[36:09]Please play clip number two.

[36:10]We'll see very clearly what the sheh thinks that if you're outspoken

[36:13]and you don't take the pledge and obey, this is what happens.

[36:19]Please play clip number two.

[36:37]forl.

[37:10]Everybody's meant to obey once that khalif is in.

[37:14]But they certainly didn't.

[37:14]And nor did they with Muawia because with Muawia you clearly saw

[37:20]the groups emerge one after another you began to see all of

[37:24]these groups emerge where they were outspoken and now you had people

[37:27]who sided with Otman's line, people who sided with Ali's line.

[37:33]Just on the point about Im Ali, if a person doesn't pledge

[37:38]allegiance to Ali, they die the death of Jah.

[37:42]Does Aisha fall into Jahyah?

[37:46]Aisha didn't pledge allegiance to Im Ali.

[37:50]So, does she fall into or no?

[37:55]Because the hadith said if you don't have the pledge on your

[38:01]neck you fall the death of the hadith also said if you

[38:03]show any disapproval you die the death of jah is dead the

[38:08]death of jahyah is that what she died.

[38:11]How about died the death of jah?

[38:13]How about died the death of jahyah?

[38:17]How about did he die the death of jahyah?

[38:20]And how about the rest of the companions who fought him at

[38:26]jal?

[38:27]If you're meant to obey the khalif of your time, they never

[38:32]obeyed the khalif of their time.

[38:33]They rose an army.

[38:36]They raised an army to fight Ali.

[38:38]Is there anyone in the Sunni world who is willing to say

[38:42]on the basis of knowing the imam of your time?

[38:44]And on the basis that if you don't give bay to the

[38:48]imam of your time, then you die the death of Jah.

[38:51]Does Aisha fall in the death of Jah when she did not

[38:57]give bay to Ali at all in her life?

[38:58]Because you said IM Ali became fourth rightly guided Khalifa.

[39:02]Thanks for the compliment.

[39:02]from the year 36 after hijra to the year 40 after hijra

[39:06]didn't give him bay mar didn't give him bay abdah didn't give

[39:12]him bay didn't give him bay zub didn't give him bay then

[39:15]there were those who absconded mashallah the hadith says you must know

[39:19]the leader of your time you must have you cannot disapprove where

[39:26]was or abdah's or ib's are you willing to say that your

[39:31]companions who You give a blanket statement of approval on the basis

[39:41]of on the basis of on the basis of if they did

[39:48]not give to the im of their time do they not fall

[39:51]in a state of jah which is either falling intoal or falling

[39:54]into kufur which one come back with me over here first you

[39:58]hadman and they disapproved then They disapproved of Ali.

[40:04]But those who disapproved of Ali still have next to their names.

[40:08]They're still admired.

[40:10]They're still adored.

[40:11]Even if they rose with armies to fight Ali, even if they

[40:15]held their swords off to fight Ali, they were admired and adored.

[40:18]So what if they wanted to kill Ali?

[40:21]So what?

[40:23]They're all Sahabah.

[40:25]And Sahaba can fight each other.

[40:27]There's no issue.

[40:26]God says in the Quran, groups will fight each other, try and

[40:31]find peace between them.

[40:33]But if one continues against the other, then one will overcome, one

[40:37]will fight the other.

[40:37]Look at the state of the Muslims.

[40:39]But Aisha is no way called in any way.

[40:43]Not at all.

[40:44]Even though she did not have the pledge of allegiance of the

[40:48]Khalifa of her time, who was called the rightly guided Khalifa.

[40:50]So if you fight the rightly guided, does that mean you're rightly

[40:52]guided?

[40:53]Then after him, come with me over here.

[40:58]The history of Tabari, volume 17, the first civil war, translated by

[41:03]Gerard Horting, State University of New York Press.

[41:08]My dear brothers and sisters, all of you can see over here

[41:13]1996, State University of New York.

[41:18]I want us to go towards page 185.

[41:21]If I remember rightly, this is taking me back to my PhD

[41:24]days.

[41:25]So, I'm I hope I've got the right pages.

[41:27]Uh, come over here with me.

[41:29]Let's see.

[41:31]Let's let's come over here to page 70.

[41:32]The first civil war.

[41:35]Okay?

[41:36]Cuz as you know, my PhD was on Muawa.

[41:38]So, these were sections I had to read a lot about.

[41:39]Okay?

[41:40]So if we look at the first um the first civil war

[41:45]okay my dear brothers and sisters if we look at the first

[41:48]civil war you'll see over here hashim binbah al and the night

[41:57]of howling of course that was the night one of the most

[42:01]difficult nights that anyone has ever faced in the battle between trying

[42:07]to kill and all of them will go to Jenna Come back.

[42:12]According to Abu Mnaf, Abu Salam, at evening Hashimb Zi summoned the

[42:17]men.

[42:17]Let anyone who seeks God and the next world come to me.

[42:21]Many came to him, and he attacked the Syrians with a band

[42:23]of followers several times.

[42:26]But everywhere he attacked them, they held firm against him, and the

[42:30]fighting was fierce.

[42:29]He said to his men, "Do not let this steadfastness of theirs

[42:33]that you see frighten you.

[42:34]By Allah, it is only the firm of the Arabs that you

[42:37]see and their steadfastness is beneath their banners and in their battle

[42:41]positions.

[42:40]But they are in error while you follow truth.

[42:43]Notice that the Sahabah at did not say we're both on truth.

[42:49]We're both going ja.

[42:48]They are on error.

[42:51]We are on truth.

[42:51]Simple.

[42:52]There's no such thing as fights fights.

[42:56]Give me a break.

[42:59]Come back.

[42:59]As you will see, but they are in error while you follow

[43:01]truth.

[43:02]Oh my people, be patient and firm and vi with them in

[43:03]steadfastness.

[43:04]Unite together and let us march against our enemy with deliberation and

[43:09]purpose.

[43:10]March against our enemy.

[43:11]Sahabi versus sahabi.

[43:14]But they say enemy.

[43:15]Then stand firm.

[43:17]Help one another.

[43:17]Remember Allah.

[43:18]Let no man ask his brother for anything.

[43:20]Do not keep turning around.

[43:20]Be valiant in face of their courage and make jihad against them

[43:23]in expectation of your divine reward until God decides between us and

[43:26]them.

[43:27]For he is the best of judges.

[43:31]Then he went forward with a band of the Quran and he

[43:32]and they fought fiercely at evening until they were content with what

[43:35]they had achieved.

[43:36]At that point a young warrior came out against them and said,

[43:38]"I am the son of the great kings of Asan and today

[43:42]I adhere to the dean of man." There has come a report

[43:49]that has caused much alarm that Ali killed the son of Afan.

[43:52]Notice he says I adhere to the dean of man.

[43:55]That means I'm not pledging allegiance to that khalifa.

[44:00]That means jahil jah come back.

[44:00]He rushed to the attack and did not turn away until they

[44:03]had struck with his sword.

[44:05]He then made free with abuse and curses and hashba said to

[44:08]him servant of God after such talk there is conflict and after

[44:13]such fighting there is reckoning.

[44:14]Fear Allah for you are returning to him and he will question

[44:16]you about this encounter and what you sought by it.

[44:19]He replied I am fighting because your master does not perform the

[44:22]prayer ritual as I have been told and neither do you.

[44:25]I am fighting you because your master killed our Khalifa and you

[44:27]urged him to do it.

[44:29]Hashim said to him, "What have you got to do with Iban

[44:33]Afan?" It was the companions of Muhammad and the sons of his

[44:36]companions and the Qur of the people who killed him when he

[44:41]introduced innovation and opposed the authority of the Quran.

[44:43]They were people of religion and more worthy of handling the affairs

[44:45]of the people than are you and your companions.

[44:47]I do not think that the affairs of this community and of

[44:52]this religion have been neglected for even an instant.

[44:54]You see over here my dear brothers and sisters notice over here

[44:59]that they continue in their narration attacking one another.

[45:06]This group doesn't recognize Imam Ali Ali rather they have recognized to

[45:12]kill Imam Ali and his people like Hashim and others very clearly

[45:16]very clearly who are the ones who are defending Im Ali.

[45:21]I ask you on that day who's the jah the one who's

[45:23]given to Ali or Muawi and his group who will not give

[45:28]to Ali.

[45:30]And if not giving you fall intoah disapproval of the Khalifa you

[45:35]fall into jahyah killing Sahabah you fall intoah.

[45:39]Imagine my dear brothers and sisters you see over here as you

[45:44]continue in page 73 according to Abu Mkhav and so on passed

[45:48]near a group of Syrians amongst them who was abusing him verbally.

[45:52]is so funny was abusing was abusing he was told about that

[46:01]and stopped with those of his men who were close to them

[46:02]and said attack them the presence of God the dignity the dignity

[46:06]of Islam and the signs of the righteous be with you by

[46:08]God those amongst them who are closest to ignorance are their leaders

[46:14]and the one who has mustered them together with of course As's

[46:20]mom's name just to remind of what his 's role was in

[46:25]life.

[46:26]Absolut the wine drinker who was flogged according to God's law in

[46:29]the time of Islam.

[46:29]They are just the ones who would stand and cause harm to

[46:33]me and find fault with me.

[46:34]For even before today, they have fought against me.

[46:36]At a time when I was calling them to Islam and they

[46:38]were calling me to the worship of idols.

[46:40]Look what I Ali says.

[46:42]He says, "Look, I'm fighting the people who I fought before.

[46:46]I used to bring call them to Islam.

[46:48]They used to call me to shik.

[46:49]What's they're all the kings of course Islam had to rehabilitate them

[46:58]the suddenly become angels on earth suddenly become the most aesthetic people

[47:02]in the world shows Im Ali they're abusing him at but if

[47:05]you die without the of a ruler even if that ruler you

[47:10]don't like then you're a jah please include more on that jah

[47:13]list arguably the worst one has to be Imam Hussein and Yazid

[47:20]Yazid Even amongst the majority of Sunni Muslims, Yazid was known as

[47:26]a transgressor, sinful, drunkard.

[47:26]And Imam Hussein says, "A man like me will not pledge allegiance

[47:31]to a man like him." That means Im Hussein didn't know who

[47:33]the imam of his time was.

[47:35]No, he is the imam of the time.

[47:36]Now, if he doesn't pledge allegiance to Yazid, COULD ANYONE DARE TO

[47:39]SAY that the master of the youth of paradise is going to

[47:43]go to hell because he didn't pledge allegiance to the khalif of

[47:48]Islam as Abdahb Omar wanted us to in the hadith in Muslim.

[47:51]Could anyone dare say that in the Salafi world?

[47:57]Nothing should surprise you.

[47:57]Please play clip number three.

[48:24]Omar trouble.

[48:33]for them.

[49:01]for I No.

[49:48]Sure.

[50:05]Islam.

[50:24]Hey I don't know.

[50:51]is exit isn't the case.

[51:07]Yeah.

[51:11]Okay.

[51:26]Shut up, you despicable liar.

[51:29]That's all it can end with.

[51:31]The guy is asking, "Hold on a minute.

[51:33]Yazid goes Yazid must be respected.

[51:36]Yazid Muawi is the Okay.

[51:36]Who killed then?

[51:39]If he's the khalif is not giving him.

[51:41]So what's your position on?

[51:42]No, no, no.

[51:44]Muawi is great.

[51:43]Muawi is great.

[51:45]But again, we ask the question.

[51:47]He's saying Yazid has to be respected.

[51:50]Imm Hussein didn't respect Yazid.

[51:52]Im Hussein didn't give him IM Hussein disapproved of him.

[51:58]Does IM Hussein die as a Jah?

[52:00]Play clip number four and you'll see a person saying maybe Im

[52:06]Hussein did Hussein.

[52:52]I don't know what else to say.

[52:57]An absolute mess of a first 50 years of Islamic history.

[52:59]This man has just disrespected the prophet's grandson and others fought the

[53:05]prophet's son-in-law and others angered the prophet's daughter.

[53:07]But all of them will be going to Jenna.

[53:15]Hey, hey, hey.

[53:50]Now, we've just broken down this amazing wall at the Zenibia complex.

[53:54]And the reason that I'm telling you this is because we want

[53:57]full transparency with all of you that this is going to be

[54:01]a media hub for all of you.

[54:02]The first ever global sheer media hub in not just the west,

[54:04]but in the east as well.

[54:07]There's never been a place for channel and charity to come together

[54:10]and represent Shia views on this scale.

[54:12]There are so many Husini.

[54:12]There are so many imam ba but their conversations stay restricted within

[54:16]their community.

[54:17]This is a global project, a global endeavor to support every single

[54:21]Shia and Muslim around the world and none other than the name

[54:25]of S.

[54:24]Zanib.

[54:25]And why do we choose SA Zanib?

[54:26]Say Zanib was the first one to give a public majalis for

[54:30]Muhammad Hussein.

[54:31]And we are the first ones to give a global majalis for

[54:33]immusin.

[54:34]We pray that every single one of you will support during this

[54:37]holy month of Ramadan to make sure that this dream becomes a

[54:43]reality.

[54:43]Visit www.im hussein3.tv/hq and support this Ramadan.

0 تعليقات

التالي

14. Knowing The Imam Of Your Time & Jahiliyya? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

Transcript

التالي

استكشاف المزيد

يرجى ملاحظة أنه إذا كان عمرك أقل من 18 عامًا ، فلن تتمكن من الوصول إلى هذا الموقع.

التالي

14. Knowing The Imam Of Your Time & Jahiliyya? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

Transcript

التالي

استكشاف المزيد

اختيار طريقة الدفع

لغة