3. ‘Did Yazid regret Karbala?’ | Arbaeen 2023 | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani (Spiritual Journeys)

15 Bekeken· 24/03/24

Sayed Ammar Nakshawani Official
abonnees

Night Three | Arbaeen 2023/1445 | Karbala, Iraq

https://spiritualjourneys.co

Subscribe now to Sayed Ammar’s official online platform, consisting of bespoke courses, exclusive content, brand new podcasts & more!

https://www.sayedammar.com

Laat meer zien

Transcript

[0:00]foreign foreign foreign [Music] [Music] and forced him to fight when he

[1:44]was ready to leave or come to me or go to the

[1:54]borders and defend and God the borders of the Muslims until his

[2:00]soul was taken in death but when he did not allow this

[2:08]and he refused this for this to happen and he ended up

[2:13]killing him then the hate of the people both the righteous and

[2:19]the evil Doer came towards me an enmity was instilled in their

[2:27]hearts against me for the serious killing of al-hussein I wish I

[2:35]had never had anything to do with IBN marjana may God curse

[2:42]him and may God be angry with him the first of our

[2:49]Lord um a third with your loudest voices in honor of the

[3:11]Imam of our time Imam respected Scholars brothers and sisters regret what

[3:32]took place in karbala was he remorseful or even repentant over the

[3:39]actions of what took place on the 10th of Muharram this is

[3:44]a question that is being asked not only in non-shiite circles but

[3:50]also in Shiite circles that you see that in certain pieces of

[3:55]Islamic literature yazid admits that he is remorseful about the actions that

[3:59]took place in Carabella this particular passage that I quoted is an

[4:04]example of yazid seemingly remorseful and mentioned in some of the most

[4:08]famous books in the history of the religion of Islam when a

[4:14]person for example reads or a person reads or a person reads

[4:21]for example then there is a certain section or a certain aspect

[4:27]of when yazid meets the captives of the 10th of Muharram in

[4:34]Shan that there is a back and forth that takes place between

[4:36]him and said and that's in that back and forth we see

[4:44]a passage like this showing a regretful yazid a yazid who is

[4:52]angry with the actions which he lays blame on IBN marjana because

[4:56]of this you found that's in the spectrum of the opinions on

[5:01]yazid within the schools of Islam you go to one extreme and

[5:08]that is for example the Shia twelvers who do Lana on yazid

[5:12]and then you go to a middle ground of Shia who may

[5:17]not like yazid or despise him but prefer not to do Lana

[5:21]and then you go to a ground of Allah who reviled yazid

[5:26]and then you go to a ground of Sunnah who say that

[5:32]we neither love him nor we revile him and then you may

[5:34]find some of Allahu come to a conclusion that ultimately as Eid

[5:41]was not at Carabella because he was not at karbala he could

[5:44]not be wholeheartedly blamed that's on the one level which we dissected

[5:48]in last years but on the other level there is a movement

[5:55]that has existed since after karbala until today that says that there

[5:59]are those who love yazid because they say the man himself was

[6:02]regretful at the end of the day the babies and the granddaughters

[6:09]came back from sham to Medina if yazid was so bad then

[6:15]yazid would have killed them at the end of the day said

[6:22]a lot of them who were there present in sham were very

[6:26]open in their language against yazid in some cases their language was

[6:31]very harsh was very strong if yazid was as tyrannical as the

[6:36]Shia say he is it could have easily at that moment said

[6:40]kill this person right now don't let this person live but yes

[6:47]he does not do this on a night like tomorrow night we

[6:52]are of the belief that they return back to Carabella and then

[6:55]eventually from karbala returned back to Medina if yazid was so evil

[7:02]then how could yazid let them go yazid could have easily made

[7:05]sure that that period imprisonment was a very short period and he

[7:10]could have made sure then after that that he could have kept

[7:15]them even longer and longer to torture them and make them have

[7:17]the worst of lives further than that some people said that if

[7:22]Allah's door of Toba is always open therefore in that door of

[7:29]Joba where it's always open why would Allah not open the door

[7:33]of Toba for someone like yazid Allah says in the Quran Bismillah

[7:49]say to my servants who have been extravagant against themselves never be

[7:57]despondent of the mercy of Allah for Allah forgives all sins if

[8:05]the Quran says Allah forgives all sins we all believe that there

[8:09]is only one sin that if you die on it on the

[8:13]day of judgment you could not be forgiven and that is if

[8:16]other sins are committed killing people harassing people torturing people lying against

[8:22]people and so on and so forth so then why would yazid

[8:27]not be open to these as well especially if the man himself

[8:30]makes an effort for these at the end of the day I

[8:35]cannot apply a scale on some and I move on with a

[8:39]scale on others I cannot tell the whole community that Allah's daughter

[8:42]of job has on all of you except yazid at the end

[8:47]of the day if God says then sometimes it takes one moment

[8:53]for a person who's blocking water from the children of adelbait like

[8:58]horror to begin to become a person under the mercy of Allah

[9:03]blocks the water from the children of the Prophet peace be upon

[9:09]him in his family and yet God Is Forgiven in a moment

[9:11]when he turns his heart towards the family of the Prophet so

[9:17]if can be forgiven and we always say that everybody can be

[9:21]forgiven by Allah so why could he has Eid not be forgiven

[9:25]if he has he turned around say with us Allah turned around

[9:33]and said that look I'm gonna send you back to Medina in

[9:38]a state of Peace in a state of security is that not

[9:40]enough for Allah to forgive does Allah not say we love those

[9:45]who are repentant Allah loves his creation Allah is merciful with his

[9:52]creation Allah leaves the door of Toba open to all his creation

[9:55]therefore when you add all of these what conclusion was reached the

[9:59]conclusion was reached by some non-shia that yazid can neither be loved

[10:09]nor can he be reviled on the basis of what on the

[10:11]basis of passages like this how do we reply because for us

[10:17]a Shia we obviously are of those who completely revile yazid but

[10:21]if I see a Hadith attacks as you all know is IBN

[10:27]Ziad if yazid attacks him in Ziad then maybe the blame should

[10:34]be on ibn's yard not only as it because at the end

[10:39]of the day IBN Ziad had more of a role in karbala

[10:41]than yazid according to mostly was the one who made sure that

[10:48]um was being watched closely by Sherman bindal Joshua was the one

[10:52]who was involved in all the preparations one may argue that maybe

[10:59]IBN Ziad is more to blame let us tonight examine this key

[11:03]area in depth as to whether yazid was truly according to the

[11:07]sources regretful was the door of Toba open for him or not

[11:16]was yazid someone who the armies that he had taken part in

[11:22]meant that he was forgiven by Allah or not did yazid himself

[11:25]look for forgiveness or not and how do his actions and the

[11:32]words of say to zainab and the words of Imam Zain and

[11:33]abedin and his actions after sham indicate that the man was never

[11:41]close to Toba whatsoever let's examine this and dissect the topic in

[11:46]complete depth let's look at that passage again the passage says that

[11:51]yazid said may God curse even marjana interesting line may God curse

[12:00]even marjana why because he attacked Imam al-hussein and he forced Imam

[12:07]al-hussein to fight or come to me as it says or ready

[12:18]to go to the borders of the Muslims and protect them but

[12:21]because of IBN ziyad Eben Ziad did not give him these options

[12:25]and therefore Eben Ziad is responsible for the killing of Imam Al

[12:32]Hussain and responsible for the enmity in the hearts of the people

[12:35]towards me how do I look at that passage first and foremost

[12:41]yes you are the one who appointed Eben Ziad in kufa yes

[12:44]you find that when I look at this passage I remember that

[12:50]yazid was in trouble months before katabella why when Imam Al Hussain

[12:54]was ready to stand up against yazid yazid himself found himself in

[13:02]trouble that there were people who were ready to support Imam al-hussein

[13:05]yes sir John the Roman who was his advice and the advice

[13:12]of his father he said to him what would my father do

[13:14]if he was alive today Sir John the Roman Christian Masha Allah

[13:19]the Roman Christians become the adviser of the Muslim Khalifa of Allah

[13:26]on Earth Sir John the Roman Christian said to yazid if your

[13:30]father was alive then he would put Eben Ziad in power in

[13:37]kufa yes was similar rank similar positions similar lineage to one another

[13:41]so yazid decided that he'll put IBN Ziad in kufa therefore when

[13:47]yazid says may God curse first and foremost you are the one

[13:54]who appointed Eben marjana even marjana would never have come to kufa

[13:59]were it not for your appointment you are the one who made

[14:01]sure he got to Cuba number two not only did you tell

[14:05]him to be in kufa you also asked him to Massacre anyone

[14:11]who was the supporter of Jose benali if you look at Eben

[14:15]marjana's decisions in kufa they were all decisions that were based on

[14:22]who that were based on the rulings and the guidelines of yazid

[14:26]killing Muslim killing haniban Ottawa not just them these are the names

[14:31]that everyone always mentions as if there were only two or three

[14:34]Shia and kufa who died nearly three four thousand maybe even up

[14:40]to ten thousand Shia of salaam and kuffa were killed by IBN

[14:46]Ziad when you curse him because he's the one you say killed

[15:05]Hussain ebenciad is the one who firstly killed the people of kufa

[15:08]secondly IBN Ziad on your orders was the one who said that

[15:16]make sure Hussain is blocked from coming to kufa unless Hussein pledges

[15:21]allegiance to me I ask you all a question originally Imam Islam

[15:26]why did he even head towards kufa why did he add even

[15:31]to mecca for what reason because yazid ultimately before Eben Ziad was

[15:36]in the picture yes it was the one who had said that

[15:40]behead Hussain in Medina therefore those who said that he hasid was

[15:45]not guilty for what took place at karbala yesid was the one

[15:50]who had ordered that Imam is killed in Medina then ordered that

[15:54]Imam is killed where in Mecca by the Kaaba then ordered that

[15:58]Eben marjana irrespective of whether Imam has woman with him whether he

[16:08]has children with him that Imam Hussain is to be blocked from

[16:11]coming towards kufa these were all orders from the central headquarters where

[16:16]and Sham say for example in this country Saddam Hussein when he

[16:22]was alive in this country someone could say is not to blame

[16:25]for everyone who's died in Iraq at the end of the day

[16:29]he appoints governors he appoints generals and those generals undertake whatever the

[16:34]appointment is from the head Authority therefore when Eben marijuana blocks that

[16:41]is a guideline that has come from where that is the guideline

[16:47]that has come all the way from sham yes it continues in

[16:51]this particular passage what does he say he says that Hussein was

[16:55]ready to leave Carabella yes it's true he was ready to leave

[17:01]karbala Imam Hussain as I discussed in my Muharram majalis up until

[17:06]the morning of ashora was ready to leave karbala and go home

[17:12]was not a bloodthirsty individual who looked for war and killing up

[17:20]until 9 A.M on the 10th of Muharram Imam al-hussein was ready

[17:24]to go back allow me to go as it says let my

[17:30]master go to Rome or let him go to India and you

[17:36]can keep hijaz and you can keep the land of Iraq Imam

[17:39]Hussain yes he was ready to leave to go back but he

[17:44]was forced by um which had come from yazid that Hussein men

[17:53]Ali can neither leave one way or leave the other unless what

[18:01]happens unless he pledges allegiance to Yes it and that's why you

[18:05]find that that blame on IBN Ziad All of It ultimately comes

[18:08]back to to the man who appointed a to carry out all

[18:13]of this yes he then goes on to say what he says

[18:18]people hate me because of ibn's yard we don't hate you because

[18:21]of IBN we hate you and debenciad we don't hate you we

[18:29]don't hate you because of Eben Ziad in that passage which is

[18:35]narrated in as I said yazid says because of IBN Ziad the

[18:41]people now hate me the people don't hate you because of IBN

[18:46]Ziad rather the people hate you for a number of other reasons

[18:49]I will come to shortly so therefore the first opinion that they

[18:52]gave was that yazid himself said it's not me it's IBN Ziad

[18:58]I have no issue with the Imam al-hussein that was the first

[19:04]argument they gave we break that argument down second argument for yazid

[19:08]regretting Carabella and doing Toba was that they said yazid how can

[19:14]I be forgiven for what happened that karbala how many times have

[19:21]you heard this in magalis he says to him how can I

[19:28]be forgiven for what I have done to all of you Imam

[19:31]supposedly replies to yazid by saying for whatever number of days in

[19:41]a row let's say for 40 days in a row and Allah

[19:43]will forgive you for killing Imam al-hussein you all know which a

[19:53]person normally prays between of course you can pray it after Asha

[19:59]as well but mainly you pray it between Maghrib and Asha the

[20:02]rewards for it Jannah you are the inheritor of Jannah if you

[20:09]praise and that Allah instantly answers all of your desires so they

[20:16]say that's Imam is the one who told yazid pray this prayer

[20:20]for 40 days in a row Allah will forgive you for killing

[20:25]him Allah I wish forgiveness was that easy in all honesty that

[20:28]a person just needs to pray 40 prayers it's like that Salah

[20:32]people will come to me they say there's this one Salah if

[20:34]you pray it 100 Years of kava is wiped out a wonderful

[20:39]Salah it sounds great but it's an absolute fakie if ever there

[20:44]was one yes there's no such thing as a Salah which is

[20:46]a pass for my prayers to all be deleted I have to

[20:51]try and make up as many of those kavas as possible and

[20:55]then if I die I might write in my will Salah someone

[20:58]comes in makes up the rest for me yazid no way this

[21:05]is absolute nonsense this Rafaela story it's absolutely ridiculous a knows that

[21:12]this person will never pray these prayers if he's ever prayed prayers

[21:17]that's another story number two no such thing as Imam offering him

[21:22]because he has he's saying look I'm really sorry I made a

[21:26]big mistake is there a way out for me yes these two

[21:28]arrogant to look for a way out and he is someone who

[21:34]is referred to already when he looked at the army of yazid

[21:39]and he said to them shaytan has overtaken you and once shaytan

[21:43]has overtaken you there is no way back because the remembrance of

[21:46]Allah has complete over taken contrast shaytan hadn't overtaken him how do

[21:56]you prove it because when it came to Leading Salah Imam Al

[22:01]Hussain what did her say you are the son of Father grandson

[22:07]of rasulullah you are the one who leads us in Salah you

[22:16]all know the lines may your mom have never given birth to

[22:21]you or replied if your mother was any other mother then I

[22:24]would have attacked you but you are the son of Fatima shaytan

[22:28]had not overtaken him whereas with yazid shaytan had overtaken him completely

[22:34]how do you prove it with the fact that yazid had wanted

[22:39]to behead Imam al-hussein and ordered for his beheading whether it was

[22:43]in Medina or in Mecca how much shaytan has overtaken you that

[22:46]even next to the Kaaba you don't mind seeing blood the Kaaba

[22:52]where a grasshopper or mosquito if it comes on you you're not

[22:55]meant to kill it he says behead the grandson of rasulullah therefore

[23:01]the Salat and Rafaela Story number two absolute nonsense number three there

[23:06]are those who say that you have to leave him alone why

[23:09]because he's the son of a sahabi of rasulullah so what but

[23:15]you know he's one of the sons of the sahaba and if

[23:19]you are the son of a sahabi then we must have not

[23:26]love for him but we must not revile him because you should

[23:31]not revive Allah somebody who's the son of a sahabi firstly in

[23:35]the Quran prophets of Allah may Allah bless them their sons come

[23:41]out as their enemies yes those sons who come out as enemies

[23:44]became an enemy of Nabi Adam when khabil is an enemy can

[23:52]I say that look the door of Toba regret no God is

[23:55]himself Adam is himself his sons they turned out to be enemies

[24:02]of their father so just because someone is the son of a

[24:08]sahabi or the son of someone respected we should not even I

[24:12]remember they used to say that if someone is the son of

[24:18]a mushrik you shouldn't attack his Muslim father this is one of

[24:22]the arguments because they said that the sahabi son would be sad

[24:28]if you attacked his father especially because a major enemy of rasulullah

[24:37]in this early years in his life and so they said that

[24:40]don't attack Wali too much because it's his son there's a rule

[24:47]for Khalid but not a rule for Ali for Khalid you cannot

[24:52]attack his father too much but for Ali it's open game on

[24:56]Abu Talib in some circles when I come therefore on the third

[25:02]level they say that look yazid is the son of and therefore

[25:05]you shouldn't then have reviled him because you should still have that

[25:09]level of respect that was the third argument fourth argument said that

[25:13]yazid would have some regrets and some told by why because there's

[25:19]a Hadith that says whoever participated in the siege of Constantinople then

[25:25]that person is forgiven by Allah they said yazid was seen in

[25:30]the siege of Constantinople and therefore yes it is forgiven by Allah

[25:36]automatically again the first Siege of Constantinople yazid was around five years

[25:40]old at that time I don't think he's gonna be there in

[25:44]the battlefield necessarily but even the siege of Constantinople that came later

[25:49]in yazid's time yes he turned up saw the battle he was

[25:55]on the outskirts he hung around with his Mrs um and he

[25:58]was reading poetry while watching the battle take place yes it had

[26:05]nothing to do with any of those sieges whether literally or metaphorically

[26:09]another argument they said is look yes he sent the family of

[26:13]the Prophet back with respect to Medina and it's true let's be

[26:20]very real here that yazid did send the family of rasulullah when

[26:24]he was asked by them when he said to them what is

[26:29]it that you want and Imam replied what you took with from

[26:35]us you can never give back to us and then he asked

[26:37]again and the Imam replied back by saying allow us to return

[26:43]to Medina via carabala what do they say they said yazid allowed

[26:47]them to return therefore that is choba from yazid that is Regret

[26:51]from yazid because if he hasid had no job he would not

[26:57]have allowed them to return We reply by saying what we reply

[27:00]by saying look at the words and the behavior of yazid leading

[27:06]up to this moment you'll see that the man had no regrets

[27:09]whatsoever for what took place in karabella how do we prove it

[27:15]number one his poetry shows he had no regret for what took

[27:21]place in Carabella what did he say in his poetry later in

[27:27]foreign 's fault if it's all ibin ziad's fault what does he

[27:55]say in his poem I wish my ancestors from better were here

[28:02]today who's yazid's ancestors from better let's see how regretfully azid is

[28:08]his ancestors from Bader were of course who his grandmother was of

[28:16]course hint hint who's her father was the head of the Army

[28:22]on the day of better killed by Imam and his uncles were

[28:27]killed by Imam Ali alaihissalam so when they were all killed by

[28:34]Imam then what's yazid saying now he's saying I wish those ancestors

[28:49]who fought the grandson or for the grandfather of Imam al-hussein on

[28:56]the plains of and so on and so forth when you say

[29:02]later in what are you saying I hope you know better you

[29:04]know the way that his father this one whose head is next

[29:09]to me the way that his father killed my grandfathers I wish

[29:13]those grandfathers were here today I wish so they could see what

[29:18]I've done to his head the way that I play with what

[29:23]I play yes when you say that is there any told by

[29:25]the any at all I ask you the person number two who

[29:31]pokes the lips of the grandson of rasulullah when a person pokes

[29:39]the lips of the grandson of rasulullah is that what regret is

[29:44]that you say may Allah for what because you weren't the ones

[29:54]who directly killed Imam Hussain you're poking the lips of Imam Al

[30:01]Hussain I love I love how even the historians try and turn

[30:04]the issue onto IBN ziyad not Imam al-hussein what do I mean

[30:08]online there's a website even on Google if you type yazid killing

[30:13]Imam al-hussein a new type Islam QA Islam QA is a famous

[30:22]website which answers all sorts of questions in the world the predominantly

[30:27]salafi website on that website every argument against yazid they've written weak

[30:35]weak Shia weak Shia roughly weak okay but they say but we

[30:38]don't like him bubble you've given a better defense that you give

[30:42]of your mom and dad who as they used to say is

[30:50]it love of more AWA or hate of Ali I don't think

[30:54]anyone loves Moana it's just that I hate true sometimes when you

[31:00]read through the lines of History it's not hate it's not loveable

[31:02]some of these historians I don't think they could care less about

[31:06]but the hate of Ali likewise Wallah sometimes I think it's not

[31:14]love of yazid it's hate of Hussain really because when you look

[31:17]at some of the points that I mentioned for example the second

[31:22]point about poking the lips was a companion of rasulullah he is

[31:30]the one who saw the poking of the lips in bukhari mentions

[31:35]that IBN Ziad was the one poking the lips other texts mention

[31:40]yazid poking the lips how dare you poke the lips I seen

[31:55]these lips kissed by rasulullah yeah what do they say on this

[32:03]website the ones on their seeds no authenticity just on IBN why

[32:06]why it's not the love of yazid the problem is Domino Falls

[32:12]the next one Falls and if the next one Falls the one

[32:21]who appointed him the biggest pillar falls true those who know no

[32:25]I don't know you know you don't know those who know I

[32:33]can't go any further because then become YouTube clip if you admit

[32:51]that yes the person will say to I don't like yazid but

[32:55]Wallah if you attack him I'll say everything you attack him is

[32:58]life okay but you don't like him no I don't like him

[33:02]but if Ashia doesn't like him I like him and I'm gonna

[33:09]prove this to you in a second so when it comes to

[33:14]yazid poking the lips it's there babari says but one papari says

[33:17]this now it's weak tabari says other things good that body Praises

[33:23]Ali he's just a historian babari praises anyway so the poking of

[33:30]the lips and the teeth before I see the Red Mist descend

[33:36]upon me it's better that I move on to other points the

[33:38]poking on the lips of Imam al-hussein that number two doesn't show

[33:46]regret at all yes so firstly I want my ancestors from better

[33:50]back no regret poking the lips no regret even worse than that

[33:56]his last lines in the poem played with a kingdom that means

[34:02]he doesn't believe in nobua at all ah no news came and

[34:13]there was no why if you don't believe in wahi are you

[34:18]Muslim that's why I've always believed that yes was a Christian at

[34:24]most Christian his mom is Christian so I believe that's a Christian

[34:28]Syrian you see that most is Christian he is not Muslim at

[34:33]all his dad married a Christian and that's why sometimes people ask

[34:37]can we marry from other religions say yes some may not allow

[34:44]but even those say yes you have to think about the children

[34:47]which direction are they gonna head you believe in one he believes

[34:50]in three really as in at the end if I'm gonna say

[34:56]that God is one and then God Is In the Flesh and

[34:59]then God's on a cross and then God's talking to God but

[35:02]one God's in heaven the others on Earth even the child will

[35:05]say you know atheism sounds all right now so we have to

[35:10]make sure you see more AWA marry the Christian lady May soon

[35:13]yazid and his childhood you spend a lot of time with his

[35:17]mom's tribe and it has the effects of the end live at

[35:19]if a Christian does not believe that rasulullah was a prophet and

[35:24]a Christian doesn't believe that Gabriel descended on the prophet he might

[35:28]even say Prophet is the Antichrist in certain times why because he

[35:34]doesn't even believe in the religion of Toba the religion of Toba

[35:39]yes he does not believe in it therefore that's on the third

[35:43]level on the fourth level destroys the argument that yazid was regretful

[35:51]in which way the first way in her when says how ironic

[35:57]it is that the members of the party of Allah are killed

[36:03]by the members of the party of shaytan if you're called the

[36:08]party of shaitaan there's little Toba coming your way yes hezbo shaytan

[36:12]versus Allah there's a difference between the two of Allah are those

[36:19]on the path of Muhammad Muhammad shaytan are those people who shaytan

[36:34]has overtaken Every Act of this is a transgression against Allah subhanahu

[36:40]so therefore approves it in another way one of the most intense

[36:47]dialogues that happens in sham highlights the cupboard of this FASA of

[36:56]this Allah this dialogue that happens between who between Sayed there was

[37:04]as the maktal says word for word a ruddy looking Syrian who

[37:09]was sitting next to yazid and who saw the daughter of Imam

[37:15]al-hussein the young one and said to yazid I want her for

[37:18]me saw this Syrian sitting next to yazid a zainab looked at

[37:29]them she said you Liars you are delusional neither of you has

[37:33]the authority to decide where she goes yazid said to her by

[37:38]Allah you are the liar number one there's no toll but they're

[37:42]calling the granddaughter of rasulullah by Allah you are the liar I

[37:50]am the one God has given me authority to decide whether she

[37:54]comes here or she doesn't say the zainab says God has never

[37:59]given you any Authority but if you leave this religion you may

[38:02]find some Authority waiting for you get out of Islam someone might

[38:09]give you Authority in Islam God has never given you Authority he

[38:12]said how dare you talk like that to me rather it is

[38:18]your father and your brother who have left the religion imagine where

[38:22]is the talba there to which she replies listen to this reply

[38:28]of listen to this reply this is a reply of all replies

[38:31]she says if your father or your grandfather or you have even

[38:40]become Muslims at home it was because of my grandfather and my

[38:43]father and my brother there's a huge line if your father or

[38:51]your grandfather all you have even become Muslims which means she has

[38:55]a Shack on whether he is a Muslim or his father is

[38:59]a Muslim or his grandfather is a Muslim might be non-share listening

[39:03]to the saying how could you have shek and Amir being a

[39:08]Believer Habibi you can if you want you can believe in him

[39:12]but you cannot impose your history on me you have yours at

[39:17]the end of the day I believe is a Muslim you may

[39:21]believe it's a cafe that's up to you but you could not

[39:22]impose on me who I believe is a Muslim at the end

[39:27]of the day when the granddaughter of rasulullah if you are father

[39:33]if your father or your grandfather or you have even become Muslims

[39:37]then it was only because of my father and my grandfather and

[39:43]my brother why does she say this firstly her grandfather is the

[39:46]one who released them on the day of Mecca all of these

[39:49]foreign because one is released from a contract they are in are

[39:58]those who were released on the day of Macau and they should

[40:03]have been beheaded but our Prophet is a man of Mercy otherwise

[40:06]all these people should have been beheaded on that day that's on

[40:11]the one level she says because of my father if they were

[40:15]Muslims it was because of my Father Allah if it wasn't her

[40:19]father's sword Islam would never have survived and if it wasn't for

[40:23]her father's bravery and her father's Valor Wallah Islam would not have

[40:27]reached where it reached one runs away as the poet says one

[40:30]runs away in and another runs away in hone and Abu turab

[40:36]remains firm in the middle of all of them imagine and one

[40:46]so what do I have here I have that say the zainab

[40:50]he says she says to him if you're even if you're even

[40:53]if you're even it is because of my grandfather and because of

[40:59]my father and because and because and because he said by Allah

[41:05]you are a liar with what you say to me she said

[41:07]all you have against me is a barrage of insults and nothing

[41:11]else in which in this back and forth likewise the very fact

[41:21]that when he is saying how did you find how we dealt

[41:26]with your father that's no trauma no it's over there if you

[41:29]say forgive me for what I did to your father I was

[41:33]wrong with why the true father how did you find Allah already

[41:36]knew of these events and how they would transpire a little bait

[41:40]have always this calm method that when they answer they answer with

[41:45]the broader perspective God already knew what would happen and then yazid

[41:49]consults those around him what do you think we should do to

[41:52]him and listen to what one of them says to him what

[41:54]do we do with a puppy that is the son of a

[41:59]Raby dog he calls imams a puppy son of a dog with

[42:06]rabies now what is the torba there which Toba where he is

[42:14]insulting and insulting Imam as you all know is respected by all

[42:18]schools in Islam and he shows the insults towards them as well

[42:22]further than that how else do we prove that there was no

[42:26]Toba what else can we shower so he would know whether someone

[42:43]has done Toba or not when he comes to the line could

[42:51]be here this is the day in which celebrated and who of

[42:59]them in particular to be here web no Allah notice does number

[43:14]one this is a day that was celebrated by Benny umayya not

[43:19]Eben Ziad not um meaning all the responsibility is on yazid the

[43:30]son of who the son of the cannibal that's not even number

[43:40]three he says the cursed son of cursed imagine why are you

[43:53]showing hate Imam we Shia people of rahma where love Mercy Wallah

[43:57]someone once came to me said to me does Allah love all

[44:02]this creation you know when it gets into this murky world of

[44:04]mysticism and arfani this and that and I don't know where it

[44:08]goes into sometimes even within our own shihas anyway so step to

[44:13]me does Allah love all his creation I said yes all his

[44:18]creation I said yes Allah loves all this creation so that means

[44:20]Allah you know you play with these games of wordings and so

[44:25]on yes but in the Quran Allah also says Allah does not

[44:31]like as well those who mock the message of Allah not don't

[44:36]believe in the message not believing in the message is okay you

[44:40]have free will but to mock the message means you are out

[44:44]of the realm of love when he does people say why are

[44:49]you doing and I've said this before and I'll continue to say

[44:54]it wherever we are that when a person tells you don't do

[44:59]yes a time and place in every case there has to be

[45:01]wisdom with what we do where we do it but with yazid

[45:05]when someone says and the poet replies they tell me do not

[45:09]do Allah for Allah May forgive him therefore I do double the

[45:16]line for if Allah is willing to forgive yazid for killing Imam

[45:21]al-hussein he'll forgive my Lana on him as well yes when Imam

[45:26]al-baq says Imam is saying on him and those who also were

[45:31]involved in what and the appointment of such a person into the

[45:36]realm and where he got to therefore another point about Toba Toba

[45:41]you regret what you've done true and that you never do it

[45:46]again historians sitting in this crowd in Masha Allah online all of

[45:51]you I'm sure have read about which occurred within the couple of

[45:59]years after karbala when yazid ordered his General to go to Medina

[46:10]and rape the woman of Medina and kill whoever's there then I

[46:17]look on YouTube Allah it's so interesting sometimes when you do research

[46:20]for these Majoris you're trying to look for the the one who's

[46:23]like the complete opposite to you in your opinion I saw one

[46:27]he said yes yes they went in and you know they they

[46:30]obviously um drag people out their houses and so on and that

[46:34]was it that was it that's what you do as the Khalifa

[46:37]Muslims and the general they rape the woman all these ladies were

[46:43]pregnant from men they didn't know why because there was an uprising

[46:47]against yazid in Medina by Abdullah Abdullah by the way is the

[46:52]son of a sahabi when a son of a sahabi arises against

[46:55]the Khalifa what does that tell you about that Khalifa is recites

[47:01]people in their thousands were killed in Medina dogs were urinating all

[47:09]over Medina women were raped and then after that they went to

[47:13]the Kaaba and they attacked the Kaaba if you had Toba with

[47:16]what happened in karbala then explain to me what happened within a

[47:22]couple of years just before yazid died they went they pillaged Mecca

[47:27]and Medina if you don't have respect for said you don't have

[47:33]respect for mechan Medina will you tell me and this person went

[47:44]and pillaged notice therefore that what's interesting is asks him He says

[47:51]Dad there are those who love yazid listen to this line This

[47:58]is interesting you all know Ahmed binham says there are people who

[48:06]love yazid what's your opinion and he said to him our opinion

[48:13]is that how could anyone love yazid who believes in Allah and

[48:18]believes in the day of judgment so then he said to him

[48:22]then Dad why don't you curse him and the Dad gives an

[48:27]interesting reply when have you known me to curse anyone why not

[48:30]why Imam Ahmed why don't you curse what's the issue should be

[48:36]open in your cursing of him the man who defiled the religion

[48:41]the man who defiled the Quran so when they give the answer

[48:45]what do they say yes most of the worst that he done

[48:47]was just some drinking that's it drinking nothing more drinking and the

[48:54]grandson of rasulullah and his head is paraded says I will not

[49:00]curse anyone why you won't curse anyone one lie it's not love

[49:03]of yazid as not to the love of yazid it's the problem

[49:07]of The Dominoes falling because if the door of cursing is open

[49:11]against those who hurt Allah and his Prophet then other doors began

[49:17]to be open why everyone please listen to this point before I

[49:21]conclude yazid what's his crime ultimately what's his crime is that he

[49:26]killed one of the signs of Allah on Earth true he killed

[49:35]one of the signs of Allah no recording please I I beg

[49:39]of you these are he killed one of the signs of Allah

[49:43]on Earth a so we do learn on him he killed also

[49:48]one of the family of rasulullah he ordered for burning years all

[49:56]of these therefore why would Ahmad not curse him because if the

[50:01]same criteria is applied to others then the door of Lana has

[50:04]to open before Carabella as there are some who will say to

[50:13]you that yes but others look the trouble began with Benny umayya

[50:17]foreign but at the end of the day if your criteria for

[50:21]why you do Lana on yazid is that he threatened the children

[50:27]of rasulullah and was ready to burn where they stayed and was

[50:32]ready to have henchmen go and attack them than if that criteria

[50:39]is taken and is applied somewhere else then Lana becomes simple for

[50:43]others is that true or no because sometimes if our youth ask

[50:51]us that we shouldn't what how why would you then hate your

[50:53]seed and then have issues with others when that hatred of yazid

[50:59]is because he done this to a family member of the prophet

[51:02]and he hurt them and he defiled their honor and their sanctions

[51:08]see the same would apply to others but but we follow the

[51:10]Sunnah of our imams at the end sometimes names are mentioned sometimes

[51:20]no out of recognition that there may be others for example out

[51:26]there who may have a reverence for people who fit that criteria

[51:30]for us finally therefore what was the biggest sign of no regret

[51:36]for yazid is his treatment of the daughters of rasulullah while in

[51:41]sham these daughters were young and some were older yes and the

[51:46]worst of the treatment which showed he had no regret was that

[51:49]even the tears of a young daughter had no effect on him

[51:53]whatsoever if you were to hear a child crying irrespective of your

[51:59]history irrespective of your position even now if I walk in the

[52:04]streets in Carabella and I see a child crying it breaks your

[52:06]heart Wallah why because on the one hand you cannot bear to

[52:11]see a baby cry or a child cry on the other hand

[52:15]you wonder that there was a time one day a thousand four

[52:17]hundred years ago that maybe maybe where she is crying a daughter

[52:25]of Hussain cried you know even myself personally I tell you something

[52:31]sometimes when I walk in karbala even even Wallah when I see

[52:36]Lady is all covered and abay and everything and you you can't

[52:39]see their face as such well sometimes I think to myself you

[52:42]know what there was a night where these ladies were like this

[52:49]walking and but wondering what's happened in Carabella and so the tears

[52:55]of a young girl will break your heart the sign that this

[53:01]man had zero Tolbert in him was that even the tears and

[53:06]the cries of Anguish from a girl so young when it woke

[53:11]him up he was more interested in shutting her up all of

[53:17]you know where I'm heading take your hearts on a night like

[53:22]this to charm those of you who've been you've seen that beautiful

[53:25]small barrier haven't you and those of you who haven't been may

[53:29]Allah bless you that you go and visit you go there in

[53:37]that small that exists and you remember a night like this and

[53:40]you remember a daughter of Imam al-hussein what did she see she

[53:54]saw horses hooves she saw burning tents she saw whips on her

[54:00]back she saw so many things Wallah may Allah never show a

[54:06]child any of these things a criminal however much he has done

[54:12]if he sees another one molesting children even for him he sees

[54:15]that as the worst act true a criminal if he sees someone

[54:20]in their prison who has molested a child even the criminal will

[54:22]say how could you do that to a child these people what

[54:26]did they do to those children whip them and hit them and

[54:29]kicked them and yet still those children would wake up every morning

[54:34]and each one of them would look in the eyes of their

[54:39]auntie zainab and say where's my father show me my father I

[54:42]want to see my father and in the ruins of Shams subhanallah

[54:48]and those ruins one night one of them woke up and said

[54:56]I want to see my father about I tell her we haven't

[55:03]even we all of us here on ziara were not even the

[55:05]children of delighted we earned to see him how about you who

[55:10]has been cuddled by him how about you who has been hugged

[55:15]by him how about you who have smelt his fragrance I can

[55:20]understand that you miss him I haven't even smelled him and I

[55:27]yearn for him she woke up she said to Auntie zainab I

[55:30]want to see my father her auntie may Allah bless her every

[55:39]day would say to her your your father's on her journey and

[55:43]he'll come back and your father's on a journey your father's on

[55:48]her journey you'll meet him your father's on the journey but this

[55:51]time she noticed her crying more than ever before and she noticed

[55:57]her scream was the loudest scream yes eat when he woke up

[56:02]when he woke up he said what was that scream they said

[56:06]to him hussain's daughter wants to see her father he said so

[56:08]let her see her father in a box they took the box

[56:20]into the room where they were staying she looks she said to

[56:23]her auntie auntie I'm not hungry why do they bring me food

[56:29]when she lifted the cover of the book she saw the holy

[56:35]head of the line from what does the daughter do except say

[56:41]father father father who drenched your beard with all that blood father

[56:51]father father who severed your head from your name to you all

[57:04]of a sudden image how many times did zainab have to hear

[57:17]what someone did saying about but how about the mothers another of

[57:28]the children of Al Muhammad died in front of them they gave

[57:33]the body to a nurse they said go and do Russell for

[57:38]her please the nurse took the body she went to go and

[57:40]perform the Russell but she came back quickly there's no way a

[57:45]good Soul could be performed the nurse said I apologize I couldn't

[57:54]do the Russell they said to her why she said to them

[57:57]was the young girl ill when she died they said to her

[58:04]no she was not she was feeling well she asked and what

[58:08]are all those bruises on her body what are the blue marks

[58:11]on her body Allah may your daughters never see this those of

[58:17]you who have daughters and can you imagine a bruises all over

[58:20]the body of your daughter to which the Imam said those aren't

[58:28]blue marks those are the bruises from shimmerman I'll leave you with

[58:36]this line when they reach carabala on nights like this you can

[58:40]imagine all of them running to their children to her child when

[58:53]she came towards her Imam she came by his body she had

[58:59]a message to give him what was it you told me to

[59:03]look after all of them as an Amana all of them I

[59:09]brought back with me except I love it

0 Comments

Volgende

3. ‘Did Yazid regret Karbala?’ | Arbaeen 2023 | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani (Spiritual Journeys)

Transcript

Volgende

Ontdek meer

Houd er rekening mee dat als u jonger bent dan 18 jaar, u geen toegang kunt krijgen tot deze site.

Volgende

3. ‘Did Yazid regret Karbala?’ | Arbaeen 2023 | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani (Spiritual Journeys)

Transcript

Volgende

Ontdek meer

Kies een betaal methode

Taal