12. Did The Sahaba Read The Qur’an? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

10 Bekeken· 26/03/01

Sayed Ammar Nakshawani Official
abonnees

Truth. Dialogue. Courage. After two compelling and impactful seasons, The Divide & Dialogue returns for Season 3—at a moment when silence is no longer an option, but a risk. As sectarian narratives intensify and misinformation deepens divides, this series fearlessly challenges accusations, unpacks misunderstandings, and confronts the uncomfortable truths shaping today’s Muslim world. This Holy Month of Ramadan, join Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshawani on Imam Hussein TV 3 for bold conversations, sharp historical insight, and a dialogue that refuses to be silenced. ——————————— Subscribe to Sayed Ammar’s official online platform, consisting of bespoke courses, exclusive content, brand new podcasts & more! https://www.sayedammar.com

Laat meer zien

Transcript

[0:00]I'm going no no no long no long glory oh glory Heat.

[0:31]Heat.

[0:53]Hey, hey, hey, hey.

[1:09]Hey, away.

[1:29]In the name of God, the most beneficent, the most merciful.

[1:33]All praise is due to the Lord, master of all the worlds.

[1:38]and peace and blessings be on all his prophets and especially the

[1:42]final prophet the prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi my respected brothers and sisters

[1:52]the title of tonight's discussion did the Sahabah read the Quran seems

[1:57]somewhat simplistic part of it is intriguing and virtually everyone would straight

[2:03]away say that all of the Sahaba of course read the Quran

[2:07]they are the ones who were living at the time of the

[2:08]Quran.

[2:09]They saw the revelation of the Quran.

[2:11]They are the protectors of the Quran and involved in the compilation

[2:18]of the Holy Quran.

[2:20]But there's something that continues to baffle me and that is did

[2:25]they when reading verses concerning them and verses that are claimed to

[2:32]be about them believe that all of these verses were related to

[2:37]them as a whole or to a few of them or to

[2:42]a number of them because when a person looks at this issue

[2:44]concerning the Sahabah of course in Sunni Islam it is the most

[2:50]sens sensitive issue that you could touch.

[2:51]In the same way that the Shia feel very sensitive about im

[2:57]likewise in Sunni Islam is really a tenant of faith.

[3:00]When the Sunni world says that the Shia believe in this concept

[3:06]of im and that this is not an Islamic concept.

[3:08]Likewise, the belief in the uprightness of all the companions of Allah

[3:14]is a tenant of faith in Sunni Islam that can be challenged

[3:19]and of course that's what theology is all about having these discussions

[3:22]back and forth.

[3:25]Hence why in some circles we call theology.

[3:28]But why I ask the question, did they read the Holy Quran

[3:33]is because whenever I ask anyone from the Sunni world about their

[3:37]reverence for the Sahabah, they always point me to a number of

[3:43]verses in the Holy Quran which rever or which praise or which

[3:49]show the highest respect to the Sahabah of the Holy Prophet peace

[3:53]be upon him and his family.

[3:55]Interestingly, of course, the word Sahabah is not mentioned in any of

[3:58]these verses.

[3:59]So, the verses that I'm going to quote tonight, be it from

[4:06]Alan or Toba or Fat, none of these verses actually mention the

[4:11]word.

[4:12]Normally, they talk about those who are with the holy prophet peace

[4:15]be upon him and his family.

[4:16]Now, who knows and understands those verses better?

[4:21]me living in 2026 or the Sahabah living at that time.

[4:26]I think you'll all agree that of course the Sahaba would understand

[4:30]the meaning of those verses better than I would.

[4:32]Today I will read a number of tapas about what took place

[4:38]1400 years ago.

[4:39]And that's the only way that I can gain some sort of

[4:43]contentment or some sort of certainty if I want to believe I've

[4:46]achieved certainty.

[4:48]that that is what this verse signifies.

[4:53]If there's a verse in Alan or in Toba or in fat,

[4:58]I will look at what mufun years later with their different theological

[5:04]leanings with their different political opinions, what they have used with their

[5:07]methodology and framework of what to accept from the hadith literature or

[5:14]the taps literature to bring it all together and then they will

[5:17]give it to me.

[5:20]And here I am in 2026 understanding this.

[5:20]But the actual Sahabi, we will all agree that the Sahabi who

[5:27]was living at the time of the holy prophet peace be upon

[5:32]him and his family, his behavior or his actions would show me

[5:38]that either he's never read verses which give complete praise to all

[5:45]the Sahabah or that he's understood there are verses that praise the

[5:51]Sahabah but not necessarily in the entirety or the generality that these

[5:57]verses and their taps is understood today.

[6:00]What do I mean by this?

[6:01]If for example I come across a verse in the holy Quran

[6:07]and that verse praises the Sahabah the Sahabi who was alive at

[6:11]that time whether he is from the muajiron or the ansar did

[6:17]he understand that that verse refers to praising every single sahabi that

[6:25]lived around him if that's what he understood then we have a

[6:34]dilemma If later on we realize that he fought some of the

[6:43]very people who those verses praise.

[6:45]So if I'm living in Medina and there's this amazing verse that's

[6:55]revealed about all of us in Medina about me about Ali about

[7:04]Zuber that all of us Sahabah is who this verse is revealed

[7:15]about and I'm living in Medina in the time of the holy

[7:17]prophet peace be upon him and his family and I see a

[7:24]verse come down saying that all of the Sahabah Allah has pleased

[7:29]with them these are people all going to heaven these are the

[7:37]best of people then surely I would not if that's the way

[7:46]I understood the verse.

[7:46]I would not come years later and abuse or curse or fight

[7:56]or kill somebody who I have read a verse in the Quran

[8:01]about that says he is from the people of Jenna.

[8:07]Because when I ask the question, did the Sahaba read the Quran?

[8:11]If you say yes, they read the Quran, then when they've read

[8:19]the verses that praise them and praise those around them, then surely

[8:26]their understanding of those verses, saying that for perpetuity forever, these companions

[8:35]who were praised in the year 6 after Hijra, whatever they do

[8:46]in the year 30, 36 or 37 or 38 or 40 or

[8:50]50 after hijra.

[8:51]It doesn't matter.

[8:53]I'll never raise a sword against them because I remember once upon

[8:57]a time that there was an ayah that was revealed about all

[9:02]of us going to Jenna.

[9:05]If there was an ayah revealed about all of us going to

[9:11]Jenna, I would not kill another person who I remember reading in

[9:16]the Quran that he's in Jenna.

[9:18]I would never do that.

[9:22]I would never fight a person who I remember an ayah in

[9:29]the Quran praising that person on that particular day or those people

[9:34]on that day.

[9:37]There is no way I would raise an army against that person.

[9:40]If I've read the Quran and you say to me today that

[9:44]in Almahba there is a blanket approval given to every Sahabi of

[9:56]the prophet I'm alive at that time if I understood those verses

[10:00]as blanket approval to every Sahabi then there is no way if

[10:08]that is the signification that of those verses unto my mind.

[10:11]There is no way 30 years later that I would raise an

[10:20]army or hurt or destroy or kill somebody who is praised in

[10:25]these verses.

[10:25]Someone say say you know what you mean.

[10:27]Come with me over here.

[10:30]Let's look at the three main verses that always are used to

[10:36]give a blanket approval of all the Sahabah.

[10:39]And if the Sahabah were alive when these verses were revealed and

[10:43]they felt that it means it's blanket approval then those same Sahaba

[10:47]there is no way that 30 years later they would raise swords

[10:50]against each other to kill each other.

[10:53]If the verses I'm about to quote which is used in Sunni

[10:59]Islam as a blanket approval for all of the Sahabah, there is

[11:02]no way the Sahabah could have understood those verses the way a

[11:07]Sunni understands those verses today.

[11:09]Which three verses?

[11:10]Come with me over here.

[11:10]The first verse which is always used to give the blanket approval

[11:17]to all the Sahabah and is always used to signify that the

[11:21]Sahabah would have also read it and understood the taps of it

[11:27]in the same way we do today.

[11:28]Surah 3 verse 110 is the first one.

[11:31]Look over here, my dear brothers and sisters.

[11:35]If you come over here to surah 3 verse 110 of the

[11:38]holy Quran, look over here.

[11:51]Okay, all of you can see this over here.

[11:53]What does the verse say?

[11:57]You of course being the nation of the prophets are the best

[12:00]nation in the knowledge of Allah ever to have been produced.

[12:03]Look at the translation because obviously the mufas adds his baharat as

[12:07]well.

[12:08]You the nation of Muhammad are the best nation in the knowledge

[12:10]of Allah to be produced to have appeared before mankind.

[12:14]You enjoin what is recognized as right.

[12:16]Forbid that is known to be wrong and believe in Allah.

[12:19]Okay.

[12:19]So now this is the first verse that's always used that Allah

[12:24]subhanahu wa ta'ala when he's saying then this is the sahaba forever

[12:35]all of them refers to the understanding of this ayah that's given

[12:43]today is that this is the blanket statement for all sahaba if

[12:49]shia dare to find an issue with that then that is why

[12:55]Shia are on the verge of kufur because this verse when you

[12:58]look at it they say that the meaning of it is that

[13:03]all of the Sahabah are the best of nations but did the

[13:08]Sahab who were living at that time believe that this verse was

[13:12]about all of them because if they did there is no way

[13:16]that they'll have fights or wars with each other later on because

[13:19]I will not raise an army or fight or kill somebody who

[13:26]the Quran years earlier when I was alive was saying that they

[13:28]are the best of the best.

[13:29]There's no way that I will raise an army to kill the

[13:32]best of the best.

[13:34]So that's the first verse that is normally used.

[13:35]The second one that's normally used is Surah 9 verse 110.

[13:40]Come with me.

[13:41]Surah 9 verse 110.

[13:43]My dear brothers and sisters, let's see what this verse says over

[13:48]here.

[13:48]And of course all of you uh surah 9 vers 100 sorry

[13:54]of course all of you have read this ayah can you all

[13:56]see over here look at the verse verse 100 the forerunners the

[14:19]first of the muahun and the ansar those who were present at

[14:25]bedr or all of the companions look how he includes this line

[14:29]mashallah mashallah look he includes this line or all of the com

[14:31]so it's those who are present at better or all of the

[14:34]companions and those who have followed them until the day of rising

[14:37]and doing good actions interesting in doing good actions in doing good

[14:41]actions Allah is pleased with them for obeying him and they are

[14:44]pleased with Allah with his reward.

[14:47]He has prepared gardens for them with rivers flowing under them, remaining

[14:51]in them timelessly forever and ever.

[14:54]That is the great victory.

[14:55]Normally a Sunni Muslim will say to you that this is the

[15:01]second ayah.

[15:03]The first one the second one is this one.

[15:05]Okay?

[15:05]They say that this is the second ayah that shows that the

[15:10]all of them blanket approval on all of them.

[15:15]You are not allowed to look for any fault or to find

[15:21]any fault even if the fault stares you in the eye.

[15:24]You have to suspend your in terms of what you see because

[15:27]the Quran has given blanket perpetuity forever because of this ayah the

[15:35]previous ayah and then there is another ayah which other ayah surah

[15:40]48 verse number 18.

[15:41]Okay.

[15:42]Okay.

[15:42]So if you go to surah fat verse number 18 cuz sometimes

[15:46]in the sh world people don't know why is it that the

[15:49]sunni world reveals all of the sahaba the way they do.

[15:53]You look over here my dear brothers and sisters.

[15:57]You see over here verse number 18 of surah 48.

[16:12]Okay.

[16:13]And at the end of verse number 29 ofah is the last

[16:20]part of why the sahaba are all revered.

[16:24]Come over here.

[16:48]Okay, you can all see over here.

[16:57]Come over here to the translation, my dear brothers and sisters.

[17:01]Again, this is the final ayah.

[17:03]Muhammad is the messenger of Allah and those who are with him.

[17:06]You see it says in the mufas put his companions amongst the

[17:13]believers are fierce to the unbelievers.

[17:14]Do not show mercy to them.

[17:16]Merciful to one another gentle with one another and showing mutual love

[17:20]as between parents and children.

[17:22]You see them bowing and prostrating seeking Allah's favor and his pleasure.

[17:26]Their mark is on their faces light and brightness by which they

[17:29]will be recognized.

[17:31]Yep.

[17:32]All of you can see this over here.

[17:35]And then you will see recognition of them in this world and

[17:40]the next since they prostrated themselves in this world.

[17:42]The traces of prostration that is their likeness and description in the

[17:46]Torah.

[17:46]And their likeness is in the gospel is that of a seed

[17:50]which puts up a chute and makes it strong so that it

[17:52]thickens and grows up straight upon its stalk filing the sers with

[17:58]delight.

[17:59]Now I've just quoted three ays of the holy Quran.

[18:02]Surah almata and surah fat the best of nations to mankind alm

[18:10]the foremost of the migrants and the helpers and the last one

[18:18]those who pledged in the those who are with the holy prophet

[18:25]are firm against the disbelievers and of course they're merciful amongst each

[18:27]other now I'm living in medina high When this verse is revealed,

[18:36]say my name is Abu Dari and say my name is bin

[18:44]A.

[18:45]If I understood those verses to mean that the are the best

[18:55]of people, no way would I quarrel or fight or raise an

[19:03]army or kill one another when GI has brought down a verse

[19:07]about how we are the best.

[19:08]I would always have to show you complete respect.

[19:14]Now if I don't show you complete respect it either means that

[19:18]I never read these verses of the Holy Quran impossible or that

[19:22]I did read them but they were never blanket approval of everybody

[19:26]rather they were signifying something at a particular context in the year

[19:35]2 ah you are the best or in the year 5 ah

[19:36]currently this lot is the best Or they were indicating like some

[19:46]of the verses, we know what's in the hearts of those who

[19:51]pledge allegiance or those who do good deeds must continue to do

[19:55]good deeds.

[19:56]This is a blanket statement.

[19:57]No, it's conditional that I continue or will you continue on good

[20:01]deeds.

[20:02]Or it's conditional that they are firm against disbelievers but they are

[20:07]merciful with each other.

[20:10]If I'm a sahabi and I've read these verses and I remember

[20:15]was there when this was revealed was there when this was revealed.

[20:20]I remember for example Jarb was there when this was revealed was

[20:25]there when this was revealed.

[20:29]I remember for example let's say Zuber was there when this was

[20:32]revealed.

[20:32]Abu Dar was there when this verse was revealed.

[20:34]Would I ever one day knowing this verse was revealed about that

[20:41]person, would I ever one day banish that person, kick him out,

[20:48]get him out of my way?

[20:49]How would I?

[20:50]If I've read this ayah and the Sunni Muslim today tells me

[20:54]that the Sahabah are all the best, is that what the Sahabi

[20:59]read of this ayah?

[20:59]Because if the Sahabi read and understood the dalal of this ayah

[21:05]or the taps of this ayah to signify that all of them

[21:06]are the best, then there's no way he'll fight someone who Allah

[21:10]has praised.

[21:11]The problem we find is that either we say the Sahabah never

[21:16]read these verses or that we say they read them but they

[21:22]must have had a different understanding of them because they were ready

[21:26]to fight each other and that there is no doubt about no

[21:31]one can deny the Sahabah reached a stage where they didn't just

[21:37]fight each other they were killing each other as well there is

[21:41]absolutely no one who can deny this at all in terms of

[21:47]their fighting of each other.

[21:48]As usual, I'm going to open Bkari Abu Daw and so on

[21:52]and so forth.

[21:53]In terms of their fighting each other, let's begin with a basic

[21:56]one over here.

[21:58]My dear brothers and sisters, okay?

[21:59]And I want you to remember one thing.

[22:03]The prophet has already warned them.

[22:06]Whatever you do, don't apostasize after I die.

[22:09]Meaning that those verses are not cart blanch for you to behave

[22:18]recklessly, abysmally, disgustingly or destructively with one another.

[22:21]Come with me over here my dear brothers and sisters.

[22:26]Sah bkari Arabic English volume 9 a hadith 6561 until 7563 translated

[22:33]by who?

[22:36]By Dr.

[22:38]Muhammad Msin Khan.

[22:38]Come with me over here.

[22:41]Volume 9 D Salam publishers and distributors Riyad Saudi Arabia.

[22:45]Okay, you come over here.

[22:47]Printed July 1997.

[22:52]Printing supervised by Abdul Malik Mujah.

[22:54]I want you to come with me over here and look at

[22:58]this very interesting hadith from the time of the holy prophet peace

[23:01]be upon him and his family.

[23:02]Come with me over here to hadith number 7079.

[23:07]This hadith is fundamental.

[23:10]If you look over here, you'll see that the hadith is narrated

[23:16]by Abbas.

[23:27]The prophet peace be upon him said, "Beware.

[23:30]Do not renegade as disbelievers, apostasize, revert to disbelief after me by

[23:37]striking, cutting the necks of one another.

[23:40]Again, let's read it again.

[23:42]We need to see the time.

[23:45]Please look over here.

[23:46]The prophet said, "Beware.

[23:50]Do not renegade as disbelievers after me." Allah.

[23:52]I am taught by Sunni Islam today, who cares about what happens

[23:58]after you?

[23:57]Who cares?

[23:59]The Quran has already in Almran in Toba and in fat has

[24:05]already given card blanch blanket approval for the Sahabah are in Jenna

[24:10]irrespective what they do after you.

[24:13]No the holy prophet peace be upon him's family in this hadith

[24:16]in Bkari makes it clear the prophet said beware do not renegade

[24:20]as disbelievers after me by striking the necks of one another.

[24:26]Why would Sahaba strike the necks of one another?

[24:27]For what reason?

[24:31]Everybody was there in Medina Abu Abdul Johanni.

[24:39]All of these were there.

[24:41]They were all there with one another.

[24:44]Aisha was there.

[24:47]Ali was there.

[24:46]Omar Yas was there.

[24:49]They all either read the verses that gave them blanket approval to

[24:54]do whatever they want to do or they had a tap of

[24:59]the verses in their own and each one differed.

[25:02]Some might have said this is about all of us.

[25:05]Some might have said that's about some of us.

[25:05]Some might have thought this is still testing us.

[25:08]The prophet peace be upon him's family and alkari warns them whatever

[25:12]you do not strike the necks of each other after me.

[25:17]I ask you Allah, if they're all going to Jenna, why would

[25:19]you be worried about what they'll do after you?

[25:22]What could worry you about them?

[25:23]They were there when these verses were revealed and all the so

[25:28]why are you so worried about what they would do after you?

[25:32]You know why?

[25:31]Because those verses were never blanket approval for all of them.

[25:37]There is no way those verses signify that there's a blanket approval

[25:40]for all of them.

[25:43]Those verses were always testing the hearts, seeing what their good deeds

[25:47]would be after.

[25:46]Allah knew what was in their hearts.

[25:48]Allah knew which portion of them were sincere and which turned out

[25:53]to be hypocrites, which turned out to quarrel with one another.

[25:56]The problem in Sunni theology that's evolved over the years, I must

[26:00]say, is that discussion of the Sahaba and their punchups and their

[26:04]fights and their quarrels with one another, you are not allowed to.

[26:09]Otherwise, you will be called a Shia dog.

[26:12]It's as simple as that.

[26:15]If you look on any website, you will find them saying, "Nobody

[26:18]is allowed to discuss these verses.

[26:20]This is cart blanch blanket approval." But the holy prophet is already

[26:24]giving a warning.

[26:26]Whatever you do, don't strike each other's necks after measool.

[26:28]These are all geni.

[26:31]Which geni will strike the neck of another geni?

[26:32]Oh no, no, no.

[26:35]They banished each other.

[26:36]They kicked each other out.

[26:39]No, no, no.

[26:39]They raised armies to kill each other.

[26:40]I give you the prime example from the beginning.

[26:43]I don't want to touch.

[26:45]I don't want to touch anything that happened straight after.

[26:47]You all know what's happened there.

[26:48]Let's go to the time of Otman.

[26:50]man.

[26:51]One of his biggest problems that he faced in his life was

[26:56]Abu Dar alar.

[26:58]Abu Dar Abu Dar we all know how truthful Abuar is.

[26:59]He's compared to Isa in terms of his truthful tongue to the

[27:04]extent Omar was envious when he said that.

[27:06]And so Omar when he heard that about Abuar he said yeah

[27:07]you believe that about the prophet as well.

[27:10]He said yes.

[27:13]So you find that Abu Dar and Muawi all have major problems

[27:16]with each other at the end of their life.

[27:19]man and Abu Dar some try to say this is just a

[27:23]shi thing come with me over here alkari Arabic English volume 2

[27:27]a hadith 876 to 17772 all of you can see over here

[27:34]my dear brothers and sisters let's go over here as you can

[27:37]see printed in July 1997 printing supervised by who by Abdelik Mujah

[27:42]come with me over here page 283 my dear brothers and sisters

[27:48]You'll see that the quarrel is already there.

[27:51]What's this quarrel my dear brothers and sisters?

[27:55]Look over here.

[27:55]Hadith is in the chapter the book of zakat.

[27:59]Clearly someone's misusing zakat over here.

[28:02]Hadith 1406 narrated my dear brothers and sisters from I passed by

[28:10]a place that was called and by chance I met Abuari and

[28:15]asked him what's brought you to this place.

[28:20]He said, "I was in sham and differed with on the meaning

[28:24]of the following verse of the Quran." Which verse of the Quran?

[28:32]Surah 9:34.

[28:34]Of course, Muawia said, "This verse is revealed regarding the people of

[28:38]the scriptures.

[28:39]I said it was revealed regarding us and also the people of

[28:44]the scriptures." There are those amongst us who also hoard gold and

[28:47]silver and they make sure that it is not spent in the

[28:51]way of Allah.

[28:52]So we had a quarrel Allah if all of them are geni

[29:00]why is there a quarrel between Abu Darman and Muawia about how

[29:03]money is being spent?

[29:06]If there was counge approval why is this happening?

[29:07]Come back over here when you come back over here.

[29:11]So we had a quarrel and Muawia sent a complaint against me

[29:13]to Oman.

[29:14]Oman wrote to me to come to Medina and I came to

[29:19]Medina.

[29:19]Many people came to me as if they had not seen me

[29:20]before.

[29:21]So I told this to man who said to me, you may

[29:24]depart and live nearby if you wish.

[29:26]This was the reason for me being here.

[29:28]For even if an Ethiopian had been nominated as my ruler, I

[29:33]would have obeyed him.

[29:34]Look over here.

[29:37]Clear problem between andy.

[29:37]If that verse was saying all of them Allah has pleased with

[29:41]them, why are they having quarrels with one another?

[29:44]What's their issue with one another?

[29:46]Who is it ultimately that's involved in the killing of man?

[29:49]Ultimately, who's involved?

[29:52]Sahabah are involved in the killing of man.

[29:56]If you want to see the killing of you'll see amongst others

[30:00]involved in the killing of you'll see that those who were outspoken

[30:04]against the most wahoo to the extent they reached a level my

[30:11]dear brothers and sisters they were ready to take him out they

[30:16]were ready to kill him and they were amongst the companions of

[30:18]the holy prophet peace be upon him and his family all of

[30:22]you can see for example If you look in this particular clip,

[30:26]you'll see that it's mentioned that man ultimately was killed by Sahab

[30:35]of Allah, which makes us wonder what did they understand from the

[30:41]verses that said they're all in Jenna when they're ready to be

[30:45]taken out.

[30:47]Please play clip number one.

[31:19]Amen.

[31:29]for mechan.

[32:09]foreignch.

[32:57]And that's why when you look over here in join me on

[33:02]over here compiled by Muhammad volume 6 hadith number 3291 to 3956

[33:10]translated by Abu Khalil.

[33:13]All of you come over here and you will see my dear

[33:15]brothers and sisters a hadith edited and referenced by Abuah Zuber Alai

[33:19]final review by Islamic research section Dar Salam first edition November 2007

[33:24]supervised by Abd Malik Mujah when we come to page 448 you'll

[33:31]see how blatantly they were all open in wanting to kill man

[33:35]and amongst these were companions of the prophets and look how blatantly

[33:38]these companions who all of them are meant to be going to

[33:44]Jenna whether it's Jarbas Abdah Mas amongst others Abu Dafi people outspoken

[33:51]against where the various Sahabah have given complete blank approval on chapter

[33:58]36 the virtues of Abdullahb okay you see over here what does

[34:05]he say Abdalikbar narrated from the nephew of Abdahbam who said when

[34:08]they were about to kill Abdullahbin Salam came and man said to

[34:12]him what did you come for?

[34:15]He said I came to assist you.

[34:16]He said go to the people to repel their advances against me

[34:19]for verily your going is better to me than your entering here.

[34:24]So Abdullah went to the people and said oh you people during

[34:26]jah I was named so and so.

[34:28]And the messenger of Allah named me Abdullah.

[34:31]And some ayas from the book of Allah who are revealed about

[34:34]me.

[34:35]The following was revealed about me.

[34:37]A witness from amongst the children of Israel had testified to something

[34:40]similar and believed while you rejected.

[34:43]Verily Allah does not guide the wrongdoing people.

[34:44]And the following was revealed about me.

[34:46]Sufficient as a witness between me and you is Allah and those

[34:48]two who have knowledge of the scripture.

[34:50]Allah has she the sword from you and the angels are your

[34:53]neighbors in the city of yours.

[34:54]The one in which the revelation came to the messenger of Allah.

[34:59]But by Allah, fear Allah regarding this man.

[35:02]If you kill him then by Allah if you kill him then

[35:03]you will cause the angels to remove your goodness from you and

[35:07]to raise Allah she's sword against you such that it will never

[35:10]be she's against until the day of resurrection they said what kill

[35:14]the Jew and killman okay clearly you had seen that amongst those

[35:20]who were companions you had quarrels amongst them you had amongst them

[35:27]those who ended up killing companions and then you have the case

[35:31]of another companion who is fought by other companions namely Yaser.

[35:35]Abu Dar had an issue with Muawia.

[35:38]Osman was in the middle of it.

[35:42]Osman himself was at the receiving end of companions who complained about

[35:45]him or rebelled against him or did not ultimately support him.

[35:48]In the case of Amarbinaser, Amarbinas, there is no one who denied

[35:52]the merits of Omar binasar.

[35:55]That there is no doubt about.

[35:56]If you come with me over here, my dear brothers and sisters,

[35:58]come to Bkari over here my dear brothers and sisters volume 4

[36:03]of Sah Bkari a hadith 2338 to 3848 translated by Dr.

[36:07]Muhammad Muin Khan printed July 1997.

[36:11]Printing supervised by who?

[36:15]By Abd Malik Mujahabad Salam 1997.

[36:18]King Fahad National Library Cataloging and Publication Data.

[36:22]All of you come with me over here my dear brothers and

[36:25]sisters to hadith number 2812.

[36:28]Amar bin Yaser definitely one of the earliest companions.

[36:33]Look how the prophet praises him.

[36:35]Someone like this.

[36:35]If the verses in the Quran were saying he's a jeti and

[36:39]the verses were saying Allah is pleased with him, the hadiths were

[36:42]certainly saying that Allah has pleased with him.

[36:45]Come to hadith number 281 two my dear brothers and sisters and

[36:48]you will see very clearly the discussion concerning.

[36:52]Come over here the book of jihad at the top all of

[36:57]you can see page 60 chapter 17 to remove the dust which

[36:59]falls on one's head while striving in Allah's cause.

[37:05]Now this hadith, my dear brothers and sisters, the Sahabah would have

[37:08]definitely heard it.

[37:10]If I heard this hadith, then I will definitely know that this

[37:13]hadith is something I'm never going to forget.

[37:16]Either I heard it or I decided to blatantly disregard it.

[37:23]Come with me.

[37:23]Hadith 2812 narrated from thatbold told him that Ali Abdah that Ib

[37:34]Abba sold him and Ali Abdah to go to Abu S and

[37:37]listen to some of his narrations.

[37:40]So they both went and saw Abu Sah.

[37:46]When they went to see Abu Sah and his brother irrigating a

[37:51]garden belonging to them, when he saw them, he came up to

[37:53]them and sat down with his legs drawn up and wrapped in

[37:56]his garment and said, "During the construction of the mosque of the

[37:59]prophet, we carried the adobe of the mosque, one brick at a

[38:01]time, while Amar used to carry two at a time.

[38:05]The prophet passed by Omar and removed the dust off his head

[38:12]and said, "May Allah be merciful to Amar.

[38:13]An aggressive group will kill him.

[38:20]Amar will be inviting them, his murderers, to obey Allah and they

[38:25]will invite him to the hellfire." Come with me over here.

[38:31]What does it say in the Arabic?

[38:52]There is a group over here, an aggressive group who will kill

[39:00]him.

[38:58]this group over here who will kill him.

[39:01]An aggressive group will kill him.

[39:07]We need to ask the leader of this group, is he a

[39:10]sahabi or not?

[39:11]He doesn't pick up the knife himself and kill Noah, but is

[39:15]he leading?

[39:17]Is he a sahhabi?

[39:16]Are there other Sahaba with him or not?

[39:23]If you tell me that the verses say the Sahab are all

[39:28]amazing and that's the way the Sahabah understood them that everyone is

[39:35]amazing then there's no way Sahaba would fight someone who Allah has

[39:38]revealed verses about they would never raise an army against such a

[39:44]person was killed fighting in the army of Im Ali Abalam against

[39:49]the army of the Sahabi And the Sahabah on the day of

[40:02]there were 50 bedies of the Sahaba and there is no doubt

[40:08]that the verses I quoted earlier involve the people of Badr and

[40:14]their sacrifices.

[40:13]If you kill those in Bedr, how do you say next to

[40:19]somebody?

[40:20]You claim that that person had heard those verses and was alive

[40:24]and fat.

[40:25]Then if he was alive and believed that those verses were praising

[40:29]all the Sahaba, would he raise an army to kill the people

[40:33]who those verses are praising?

[40:33]Play clip number two where we eventually reach a conclusion after someone

[40:40]has made a call asking this question that how are the Sahaba

[40:43]all killing each other?

[40:45]If those Sahaba know those verses aren't talking well of each other,

[40:48]how would you kill people who Allah's praise?

[40:52]Please play clip number two.

[41:11]was 15.

[42:36]foreign.

[42:50]No.

[42:57]No.

[43:06]No.

[43:27]No.

[43:30]for cut.

[43:48]Done.

[43:49]Thank you.

[43:55]He's right.

[43:56]Im Ali did not kill Tala.

[43:58]But I'll tell you what, Tal was part of an army that

[44:01]wanted to kill Ali and so was Zuber and so was Aisha

[44:06]and so was Abdah Zuber.

[44:06]All of these Sahabah who we said they've either read these verses

[44:12]in the Quran we quoted earlier about the best of about if

[44:16]they've read them and they knew they were about Ali and them

[44:21]and them Abuar and them and them and them.

[44:30]So if they knew that all of them, these verses from God

[44:34]gave a blanket statement of their infallibility till the day they die.

[44:38]Then how is it that they all raise their swords against one

[44:41]another and want to kill each other?

[44:43]How is it that we reach that stage where it was normal

[44:47]for somebody to come and fight?

[44:51]And what a fight there was on that day in Safi.

[44:52]If you come to the sunnah of Abu Daw, my dear brothers

[44:55]and sisters, it's a nasty fight.

[44:57]We're not exchanging flowers.

[44:58]We're not exchanging chocolates.

[45:01]We're not exchanging pleasuries on the day of Sahabah are massacring Sahabah

[45:08]is killed in the middle of Sahaba punching each other.

[45:13]But we in 2026 when we read when we read these verses

[45:23]we say that this says all the Sahabah are good.

[45:26]It didn't seem like the Sahabah had read them or they must

[45:28]have read them.

[45:29]So it didn't seem that they understood them the same way.

[45:31]How nasty was that day of Safen?

[45:32]Come with me over here to Sunna of Abu Daw.

[45:36]My dear brothers and sisters, the Sunnah of Abu Daw all of

[45:39]you can see over here in the Sunnah of Abu Daw volume

[45:44]number five from hadith number 4351 2274.

[45:50]Hadith edited and referenced by the Zubai translated by Katab.

[45:56]Final review by Abu Khal first edition July 2008 supervised by Abd

[46:00]Malik Mujah I want you to come with me actually you know

[46:05]what let's go to the narration of Sah Bkari there's a narration

[46:07]Sah Bkari on this which shows you how vicious it was on

[46:10]that day Bkari Sah Bkari volume number N hadith 6561 to 7563

[46:16]come with me here to this particular narration hadith number 7,38 and

[46:23]you'll see over here the description of how vicious was between Muawei's

[46:29]army going to Jenna Ali going to Jenna everyone killing each other

[46:33]but they're all going to Jenna mashallah now come over here 7308

[46:37]narrated Ahmed I asked Abu did you witness the battle of between

[46:43]Ali and Muawia come back if Surah 3 verse 110 and the

[47:04]if all of these the Sahaba thoughts signified each other how do

[47:10]we have a battle between Muawi and Ali can you say they

[47:15]haven't read those ayats that show how each other is praised by

[47:17]Allah has those who are pleased with Allah and Allah is pleased

[47:20]with them or is it that those ayats they even didn't understand

[47:26]them the way Sunni theology understands them as a blanket statement of

[47:31]approval today come back narrated I asked Abu did you witness the

[47:35]battle of between Ali and another question why is it that a

[47:40]lot of the Sunni world there's something I'd like to why a

[47:43]lot of the Sunni world still are not allowed to discuss what

[47:45]happened at Safen between the Sahaba or Jal how many in the

[47:51]Sunni world were not allowed allowed to discuss this.

[47:55]Shh, don't talk.

[47:54]Allah loves all of them.

[47:55]They didn't love each other.

[47:57]So, I don't know where you're getting this conclusion from.

[47:59]Come back.

[48:01]Did you witness the battle between Ali and Muawa?

[48:03]He said, "Yes." And added that I heard bin saying, "Oh, people

[48:09]blame your personal opinions in your religion.

[48:12]No doubt.

[48:13]I remember myself on the day of Abuja." Okay.

[48:15]On the day of, as you can see over here, my dear

[48:19]brothers and sisters, on the day of Abu Jal, if I had

[48:24]had the power to refuse the order of the messenger of Allah,

[48:27]I would have refused it.

[48:27]We have never put our swords on our shoulders to get involved

[48:31]in a situation that might have been horrible for us.

[48:32]But those swords brought us to victory and peace except this present

[48:40]situation.

[48:37]Abu said, I witnessed the battle of Safi and how nasty Safi

[48:44]was.

[48:44]Look at the bottom here.

[48:47]Safen were bit how vicious and nasty Safi was.

[48:54]And that's why Sahaba were blatantly open in their attacks on Muawa.

[48:57]They didn't care.

[48:57]I give you an example of clip number three where one of

[49:02]the Sahabah Moawa confronts him and the Sahabi is open in his

[49:05]reply back to Muawa that I don't find anything that praises you

[49:12]and I'll reply to you.

[49:13]Jarb is a sahabi.

[49:13]is a sahabi.

[49:15]Play clip number three.

[49:43]for Allah.

[50:22]open, outspoken will never remove the hate that we have of you.

[50:27]And of course between them there was that hate.

[50:30]So this whole idea of that they are merciful amongst each other

[50:33]that's a condition for them a condition that they must remain in

[50:36]this state and not have this hatred.

[50:38]But someone says, "Okay, with all of these quarrels and killing each

[50:41]other, surely they would have forgiven each other.

[50:45]It's just a fitna." And there is no word that's used more

[50:49]to cover all of this than the word fitna.

[50:49]You'll always hear this.

[50:51]It's a fitna.

[50:50]It's a fitna.

[50:52]We don't want to discuss the fitna.

[50:53]No, no, no.

[50:55]Openly the prophet come with me over here.

[50:58]You will see sah bkari Arabic English volume 8 a hadith number

[51:03]5970 to 6560.

[51:04]All of you can come over here to this particular volume and

[51:09]I want us to come to hadith 6596 and look what the

[51:14]prophet openly says that don't ever say a blanket approval.

[51:16]Don't say those verses say that there's blanket approval because after I

[51:22]died there was a major mess up and there was bloodshed and

[51:24]there was trial and there was tribulation.

[51:27]And look over here 65 96.

[51:29]My dear brothers and sisters, come over here and you will see

[51:35]very clearly how the holy prophet peace be upon him and his

[51:38]family tried to make clear to everybody around him, stay on the

[51:43]path, do not fight one another and so on and so forth.

[51:45]You'll see that the holy prophet would always remind his people of

[51:49]this.

[51:50]And inshallah we will continue with that very tradition as we have

[51:54]run out of time on this episode.

[51:56]But with that tradition, we will continue from tomorrow and we'll remember

[52:00]the hadith that says, "You do not know what they did after

[52:03]you." May Allah bless you all.

[52:05]Do not forget me, all the believers in your prayers in these

[52:10]difficult times.

[52:17]Hey, hey, hey.

[52:48]This Ramadan, Imam Hussein charity continues to make an impact on vulnerable

[52:53]lives pack by pack, family by family.

[52:55]Every box you see is a family's ifar.

[52:59]Essentials such as oil, milk, sugars, salt, meat, lentils, pasta, dates, so

[53:05]much more.

[53:07]These food packs are made possible with your donations.

[53:09]Donations become food.

[53:11]Food becomes relief.

[53:11]Relief becomes hope.

[53:13]And as long as there are families who cannot provide, this work

[53:17]does not stop.

[53:19]This is what collective effort looks like.

[53:20]Give what you can and invite others to join in this reward.

[53:25]Together we can make their Ramadan easier.

0 Comments

Volgende

12. Did The Sahaba Read The Qur’an? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

Transcript

Volgende

Ontdek meer

Houd er rekening mee dat als u jonger bent dan 18 jaar, u geen toegang kunt krijgen tot deze site.

Volgende

12. Did The Sahaba Read The Qur’an? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Ramadan 2026

Transcript

Volgende

Ontdek meer

Kies een betaal methode

Taal